I do find the rationale very interesting and possibly plausible and do honestly have an open mind but one thing I get stuck on with ghosts is clothing and accessories. Why are they in traditional dress, with weapons or items of the time when those items are actually buried/in museums/destroyed/disintegrated?
There is a rational answer to that if you go with the principle that ghosts can be a natural reproduction either visually or aurally of a past event. If nature can capture a soldier carrying a rifle at noon on 12 July 1913, that is the image that is played back under a strict set of conditions (unknown and theoretical, let's be clear). The soldier is not real and has no agency, so they have not unbuckled their ammo belt and laid down their rifle to come and see you. You are seeing nature's capture at that time replayed now.
Maybe an imprint of the person/animal or a full 'scene' (anyone remember that one of a nurse getting the lift and it opening onto a WW1 hospital scene?) but just the soldiers in their uniforms strutting past an Ikea sofa obscuring David Dickinson on the telly is very hard to rationalise.
Again, if you are open to exploring the theory you would have to accept this is possible. The lost 9th legion have yet to appear next to David Dickinson, but that is because a unique set of circumstances would have to have occurred naturally to capture that precise image in the first place. To then appear next to David Dickinson as against another person multiplies that probability by 8 billion. To do so while he is filming probably increases that statistic by another 4,000 (filming hours x career x total life hours). So the probability is going to be much less than you winning the Euromillions jackpot. How many people are on record as saying they witnessed a Roman soldier. It is not zero, but it is not 5,000. Possibly a few tens, out of billions of people and millions of hours.
The bell shaped curve principle has a line that at its outer edges gets closer to but never quite touches the X access unless all possible known outcomes can be established. If you say nature can never reproduce sound and vision in the way I have described in my post last night, then this particular graph does not exist for you. You may accept instead that only humans have powers over that part of nature as inventors of cathodes, digital media and photographic papers. Yet we are just a form of nature ourselves. If nature is behind our complex creation then why can't it be behind other things?
And are there ghosts of other kingdoms/phyla/classes - like mushrooms, viruses, bacteria, insects etc and if not, why not.
Again, going with the theory, there is no reason why not. What are we likely to see though? If I am sitting on a hill and see a farmer walk behind a hedge and never come out the other side I would think that is unusual. I might remember that for something to remark at a future supper. However, If the farmer came out the other side I might never raise the matter, unless they were dressed as a ploughman from the 18th Century then its back on the agenda. Same too with a black cat that just seemed to continue walking into a wall. That is odd, I might mention that. Driving down a high street I might not notice the ginger cat walking up the pavement. I might not even notice the two neighbours talking or hear one say to another "Look at that cat, I have never seen that here before".
But would I notice a swath of daffodils in October growing along a bank? Possibly and my rationalisation would be it must be mild this Autumn. The insect I am not going to give a second thought. The theory has some 'unknowns' such as what level of energy is required in nature to capture the past event in the first place? Maybe the energy from a human body under some stress might cut it, but a virus or a leaf perhaps not.
Honestly, honestly, not taking the piss or being close minded but twenty questions for every one answered. I want my animals that have passed to visit me. Why do some do and some don't?
Again, what do you believe? If you believe animals (including humans) only have agency when they are alive and yours have died, 'they' are not coming to visit you. You may be experiencing 'them' and you may be seeing a reproduction of a past event. You may see them due to conditions existing both past and present (ie in you today). You are experiencing them in a different form and through different forms of connection.
Humans have great abilities to solve complex problems. Necessity is the mother of invention, but we are overwhelmingly driven to solve future problems not past ones. Medicines, satellites, cars and weapons are produced through need. This is where the money is and so this is where science is focused and funded. Humans provide scant resources to find the final resting place of Richard the Third or to what extent settlements existed on Dogger Bank.
Humans are driven to exploit economic gains and generally have more interest in promoting ghosts and monsters with agency; Dracula, Godzilla, Predator etc. Woo plays into that and promotes Hollywood, Netflix etc, so it is very convenient to continue not to prove anything at all.