Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Natural birth

294 replies

Weirdbigtoe · 02/10/2023 21:47

What is classed as a natural birth-is it vaginal birth with no pain relief at all?
I had a vaginal birth, but requested epidural. My mum to this day still asks why, I can’t remember being massively informed at the time, but just basically not wanting any pain, is this weird? It seems incredulous to my mum. It wouldn’t have affected my Dd would it?
Where I am they don’t have gas & air, the only option was epidural or not, hence why I went for it, if they had gas and air I would have had that

OP posts:
Creepyrosemary · 03/10/2023 15:21

I don't know why people think that they should have an opinion on someone using pain relief. They never ask if it's ok to get pain relief for their own root canal treatment. Why would someones choice about delivery be more open to judgement? People should stop having so much opinion on other peoples deliveries. There is no comparison, no two births feel the same. Just because one person could do without pain relief for days on end, doesn't mean that they had it more difficult than someone who needed an epidural.

And even if it was easy, there is no purpose for pain. It's just there. You don't have to be in pain if you don't want to. Women don't get a healthier child because they had pain, in school they can't tell who was born with or without pain relief. There is no use to it. You're not a better or worse person for your choice in pain relief.

therealcookiemonster · 03/10/2023 15:03

@PuggyInTheMuddle please where can I sign up for the unicorn assisted magical births?

and my oncall shifts would be spent with my feet up eating cakes stolen from the midwives office not sweating into a scrub gown while trying to locate a tiny space with a tiny needle on a moving, very distressed person. although all worth it when the drugs kick in and I see the pure relief on the mum's face.

TheGoogleMum · 03/10/2023 15:01

There are some risks with epidural but they are more to you than baby I believe. The risk is fairly low, low enough that epidurals are widely used. If she was delivered OK and you have no lasting nerve pain then its all good!
It isn't unreasonable to have whatever pain relief you need during birth

PureAmazonian · 03/10/2023 14:58

@Weirdbigtoe

No one, and I mean NO ONE (especially people on MN). Can tell you how you should or shouldn't labour. Each labour is entirely unique and you need to do what you feel is right for you and your baby, at the time. Figure out what aspects are important to you, and make sure your birth partner (if you have one) is aware of your wishes so they can advocate for you if needs be. Other than that never has 'you do you' ever been so relevant, than in regards to a women giving birth.

My experience was entirely different to what I envisioned, I wanted to go in a birth pool, on all fours (let gravity do the work). When it got to the day, I wasn't allowed in the midwife rooms because baby had to be closely monitored. But honestly I couldn't think of anything worse than being surrounded by water, I didn't want anything touching me. And being on all fours or stood up heightened my labour pains significantly so I laboured on my back on the hospital bed. Which by all accounts is not what the 'natural birth' advocates would suggest. I didn't have medication, although I did have gas and air, which is suppose is medication. And I had an episiotomy, otherwise would've torn significantly.
This is what I mean by you have to decide at the time. Quite honestly your body will tell you what you want/need. I think that is the most natural way to give birth, being in tune and listening to your body. If it's telling you to have the epidural then bloody do it!

Katy123456 · 03/10/2023 14:53

What in the world is an "unnatural birth then." What a ridiculous term. Its either a vaginal birth or a c-section. If the first it was either with or without pain relief. None of these options are better or worse than others and none are more natural or unnatural than others.

CurlewKate · 03/10/2023 14:53

@Jellycats4life "They seem to think that because they suffered without pain relief, the women who had epidurals/c sections were cheating."

What a completely ridiculous and offensive thing to say!

Cowlover89 · 03/10/2023 14:50

RedRobyn2021 · 03/10/2023 07:32

Everything is a choice, it is your body. Nobody has a right to do anything to it without your say so.

I assume your mum hasn't been induced, if she had she would know it can be very painful so it is quite common to opt for an epidural. There are risk factors with this, like there are with any intervention, your baby would have been born drugged, I don't know the risk factors for this in regard to the baby but I do know it can effect the golden hour and breastfeeding relationship.

Didn't effect my breastfeeding relationship

Jellycats4life · 03/10/2023 14:47

When it comes to childbirth, I think misery loves company when it comes to some women. They seem to think that because they suffered without pain relief, the women who had epidurals/c sections were cheating.

PuggyInTheMuddle · 03/10/2023 14:45

When pregnant it is natural to give birth. With the most appropriate support and intervention available and necessary at the time.

What’s ‘unnatural birth’? Baby magically and painlessly manifests itself through your belly button , assisted by angelic unicorns?

Congratulations on the birth of your baby, OP.

jgjgjgjgjg · 03/10/2023 14:43

The main impact of epidural on baby is in terms of potentially prolonging the 2nd stage and the higher rate of assisted birth (although that is less of an issue with so-called 'low dose' epidurals).

MargotBamborough · 03/10/2023 14:38

therealcookiemonster · 03/10/2023 14:32

@SouthLondonMum22 @MargotBamborough there is like a permanent turf war between anaesthetists/doctors and midwives in the labour ward. traditionally midwives have been taught that doctors (especially anaesthetists) will mess up their lovely natural births. this is probably from a time when we used to give high dose epidurals. now with low dose epidurals there is no evidence that it increases the risk of c sections etc. also more recently qualified midwives haven't been through nursing training and this affects their approach/ability to recognise medical issues. I am not saying all units or all midwives are like this, but there is definitely a general anti epidural sentiment. some reports recently came out on units where mums and babies have been dying such as Shrewsbury hospital that have underlined these issues. hopefully things will change but given the current state of the NHS and limited number of anaesthetists around... it will take a while.

I didn't give birth in the UK, I gave birth in France, where epidurals are pretty much standard. But even here the midwives are much more pro physiological labour than the doctors are. In a way that worked well for me because I had fairly hands off care from midwives during early labour and only saw a doctor once things were really ramping up. But in both my labours the anaesthetists were fantastic, so reassuring, and the epidural was perfect both times. The first time it took away the sensation of the contractions completely but I could still stand up; the second time I had a lower dose because that was what I asked for and I could still feel the contractions but only very mildly and I still got the urge to push. Weirdly, the anaesthetist who did my epidural the second time was married to the anaesthetist who did my epidural the first time. I have very fond memories of them both!

Cowlover89 · 03/10/2023 14:38

Birth your baba how ever you want. It doesn't matter how as long as you and baba are healthy. Ignore ya mam. X

therealcookiemonster · 03/10/2023 14:32

@SouthLondonMum22 @MargotBamborough there is like a permanent turf war between anaesthetists/doctors and midwives in the labour ward. traditionally midwives have been taught that doctors (especially anaesthetists) will mess up their lovely natural births. this is probably from a time when we used to give high dose epidurals. now with low dose epidurals there is no evidence that it increases the risk of c sections etc. also more recently qualified midwives haven't been through nursing training and this affects their approach/ability to recognise medical issues. I am not saying all units or all midwives are like this, but there is definitely a general anti epidural sentiment. some reports recently came out on units where mums and babies have been dying such as Shrewsbury hospital that have underlined these issues. hopefully things will change but given the current state of the NHS and limited number of anaesthetists around... it will take a while.

Turfwars · 03/10/2023 14:30

Meh, I was drugged up to the eyeballs and I'd do it again in a heartbeat. It saved my life and my DS's life.

DM prides herself on the natural births she had but take it from me, it's not a yardstick of excellent mothering by any stretch.

WeWereInParis · 03/10/2023 14:27

I hate when people say "there are no prizes for not having an epidural".
Does anyone do it for prizes? No one in my life, except DH who was there, knows what pain relief I did or didn't have while giving birth. It's not a secret, it's just literally never come up, and I can't imagine asking anyone else either.
"There are no prizes" is quite a patronising thing to say because it implies that someone's choice is purely for the recognition of others, rather than something they chose for whatever other reason. With DD1, I didn't have an epidural because I had a home birth and you can't have an epidural at home. Now you may think that a home birth is batshit, I know it's not for everyone, but a consequence of that choice is a restriction on pain relief. I chose a home birth for various reasons including logistics, plus a pretty severe mental breakdown I had during pregnancy that led to extreme agoraphobia. It certainly wasn't for a prize. I wasn't being competitive, or a martyr, and I don't think my birth was better than anyone else's. Nor do I think that that birth was better than DD2's where I was induced due to PPROM (I mean, it was better in the sense that home was a nicer environment, and my waters breaking at 34 weeks meant I'd had a few stressful weeks leading up to the induction, but I don't think it was a superior birth).

therealcookiemonster · 03/10/2023 14:25

@RedRobyn2021 your comment is a prime example of why seeking medical advice on the Internet is dangerous.

no one is given an induction for fun. and the drugs given through the epidural do not have any chance of 'drugging' the baby.

@Weirdbigtoe please ignore this baby being drugged by epidural comment. we don't offer inductions without good reason. we always try to avoid induction where we can. and I always reccommend patients undergoing induction, especially if it's a first baby to have an epidural. it is ridiculously painful. also a working epidural allows us to take action faster if there are complications

CurlewKate · 03/10/2023 14:17

@Hufflepods "Some women get weirdly competitive over this, it stems from the idea that a non medicated birth is better. "

I haven't seen this-but I have seen that it's MUCH easier to talk about a birth with lots of interventions than one with none. And there are women who genuinely want a birth with no interventions. No competitiveness or martyrdom. Just what they want.

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/10/2023 14:16

MargotBamborough · 03/10/2023 14:03

It is true though!

And yet, I think the idea that an unmedicated birth is somehow better, which is completely cultural, is still very difficult to resist.

When I had my second child I was trying for a VBAC and I spent most of the night in a bath tub infused with lavender oil, listening to relaxing music and breathing through the contractions, but after more than 12 hours of regular contractions I was still only at 2.5cm.

An epidural was part of my birth plan because I was at increased risk of needing an emergency C-section due to my uterine scar, but I was under no pressure to get an epidural at that time because the midwives on duty overnight said I'd have a better chance of a successful VBAC if I could get to 5cm or so before having the epidural.

As it happened, I asked for the epidural at only 2.5cm because I was getting pretty knackered, thought I was probably in for the long haul, and the contractions had suddenly got much more painful. In retrospect, that was clearly the transition from early to active labour. Completely unexpectedly, I then went from hardly dilated at all to fully dilated and ready to push in about an hour and a half.

It was an absolutely lovely birth and the last hour and a half of it was completely pain free, but I still found myself wondering whether I could have managed to have a completely "natural" birth if I hadn't asked for the epidural when I did, because they probably would have left me alone during that time, and it might have been even quicker without the epidural. If someone had told me at the point I got the epidural that I was less than two hours from the finish line I might well have tried to manage without.

Why?

I honestly don't know.

I have to keep reminding myself that it was a great, largely painless experience, and that that last hour and a half might have been horrifically painful and traumatising without the epidural.

I'm super pro epidural now, and yet the idea that an unmedicated birth is somehow "better" is still really hard to shake off. I think it's because I grew up in the UK and got most of my information about childbirth from UK based sources and that is the prevailing attitude.

I just think it's interesting.

It really is that kind of attitude here. I was met with shock when I asked for an epidural straight away and I arrived at the hospital 6cm dilated so it wasn't like I was in very early labour either.

If it is safe, effective and available, why on earth would you try and fob someone off who wants one with fucking paracetamol? Not to mention how patronising they were because it was my first. They soon shut up when they saw I was 6cm. 😂

Chickenkeev · 03/10/2023 14:14

Margot i wanted an unmedicated birth but there was no common sense behind it whatsoever. I don't embrace unmedicated headaches like! End of the day, it should 100% be a personal choice, free of judgement either way. The important thing is that mum and baby are healthy and happy and that's it imo.

Gettingbysomehow · 03/10/2023 14:14

CurlewKate · 03/10/2023 13:34

@Gettingbysomehow "I can't stand all this "natural" childbirth stuff. I wouldn't dream of it. I insisted on having an epidural." Absolutely fine for you-but why are you not able to stand anyone who wants something different?

I couldn't care less what other people do it doesn't affect me. What I can't stand is having natural childbirth is best rammed down your throat by all and sundry including medical staff when you know that's not want you want.
I knew I wanted an epidural and I got sick to death of everybody telling me I shouldn't have one. I know my own mind.
Its a good thing I did because my baby got stuck and the interventions needed to get him out would have traumatised me for life had I not had an epidural. I won't go into the gory details here but I was left with a uterine prolapse aged 21, I was pretty much turned inside out, and couldn't sit down for 6 weeks.

MargotBamborough · 03/10/2023 14:03

Chickenkeev · 03/10/2023 13:47

I remember the 'no prizes' argument alright!

It is true though!

And yet, I think the idea that an unmedicated birth is somehow better, which is completely cultural, is still very difficult to resist.

When I had my second child I was trying for a VBAC and I spent most of the night in a bath tub infused with lavender oil, listening to relaxing music and breathing through the contractions, but after more than 12 hours of regular contractions I was still only at 2.5cm.

An epidural was part of my birth plan because I was at increased risk of needing an emergency C-section due to my uterine scar, but I was under no pressure to get an epidural at that time because the midwives on duty overnight said I'd have a better chance of a successful VBAC if I could get to 5cm or so before having the epidural.

As it happened, I asked for the epidural at only 2.5cm because I was getting pretty knackered, thought I was probably in for the long haul, and the contractions had suddenly got much more painful. In retrospect, that was clearly the transition from early to active labour. Completely unexpectedly, I then went from hardly dilated at all to fully dilated and ready to push in about an hour and a half.

It was an absolutely lovely birth and the last hour and a half of it was completely pain free, but I still found myself wondering whether I could have managed to have a completely "natural" birth if I hadn't asked for the epidural when I did, because they probably would have left me alone during that time, and it might have been even quicker without the epidural. If someone had told me at the point I got the epidural that I was less than two hours from the finish line I might well have tried to manage without.

Why?

I honestly don't know.

I have to keep reminding myself that it was a great, largely painless experience, and that that last hour and a half might have been horrifically painful and traumatising without the epidural.

I'm super pro epidural now, and yet the idea that an unmedicated birth is somehow "better" is still really hard to shake off. I think it's because I grew up in the UK and got most of my information about childbirth from UK based sources and that is the prevailing attitude.

I just think it's interesting.

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/10/2023 14:00

CurlewKate · 03/10/2023 13:57

@SouthLondonMum22 "Or any other things that absolutely can't be controlled."
Obviously many things can't be. But some things definitely can.

The vast, vast majority of things can't be controlled.

and the teeny tiny things that can? Don't make much difference.

Again, you can remain calm, practice hypnobirthing etc all you like but that isn't going to prevent an emergency c-section.

CurlewKate · 03/10/2023 13:57

@SouthLondonMum22 "Or any other things that absolutely can't be controlled."
Obviously many things can't be. But some things definitely can.

Hufflepods · 03/10/2023 13:57

Some women get weirdly competitive over this, it stems from the idea that a non medicated birth is better.
Imo all that does is lay the foundations for a motherhood of martyrdom.

Who the F cares what pain relief you used or didn't? Why is this information anyone needs?
When was the last time you discussed pain relief for a headache or muscle injury?

crumblylancs · 03/10/2023 13:54

CurlewKate · 03/10/2023 13:38

@crumblylancs "There is definitely the feeling of judgement over making pain relief choices."

Yes. Among other things, those of us who choose to go unmedicated are "crazy people"!

I don't think it's crazy at all if that's the woman's choice and she's made it without any pressure or feeling of judgment, on the flip side, think if the reason for choosing no pain relief is because of feeling like they "shouldn't" then that's the problem