Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Natural birth

294 replies

Weirdbigtoe · 02/10/2023 21:47

What is classed as a natural birth-is it vaginal birth with no pain relief at all?
I had a vaginal birth, but requested epidural. My mum to this day still asks why, I can’t remember being massively informed at the time, but just basically not wanting any pain, is this weird? It seems incredulous to my mum. It wouldn’t have affected my Dd would it?
Where I am they don’t have gas & air, the only option was epidural or not, hence why I went for it, if they had gas and air I would have had that

OP posts:
Ididivfama · 03/10/2023 22:00

Mummy08m · 03/10/2023 21:05

This I agree with.

I think if we could all agree - healthy baby and untraumatised mum are the targets - it's a short step to acknowledge that that looks different for everyone.

I'm going for ELCS for my second. And yes, the main reason is because I'm utterly traumatised by my failed induction and never want to risk that again. The medical team all agree that it's a perfectly ok option in terms of medical risk, including my anaesthesia plan. But for me my no1 goal is preventing further trauma.

I've heard of other mums opting for VBAC for similar reasons, eg they hated the c-section recovery period.

So reducing trauma, as a goal in birth choices, I'm fully signed up for, regardless of the means.

I'm dead against any argument about birth choices affecting breastfeeding though (which is one of the pro-natural-birth arguments I hear a lot).

On the small sample size of the mums I know, it's almost an inverse correlation between smoothness of birth and duration of BF.

Don't get me wrong, formula is a miracle and is a great option. But it's just threat of BF failing seems to be used to scare mums into declining birth interventions that would make their births easier

It’s also not true! so much more than that affects breastfeeding. I’m just glad they’ve stopped limited c sections purely for the numbers.

Ididivfama · 03/10/2023 21:58

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/10/2023 19:39

Of course, non traumatised mum too.

Again, it goes back to personal preference and previous experience. One of the reasons why I wanted an epidural is because giving birth unmedicated sounds traumatic to me and my epidural birth was lovely and not at all traumatic.

Others will obviously have a different experience.

Of course! Personally epidural terrifies me as does the idea of forceps and interventions (way more common with epidural) so that’s why it’s not for me. But totally get that for others it helps.

Mummy08m · 03/10/2023 21:05

Ididivfama · 03/10/2023 19:34

Healthy baby but also non traumatised mum, which is hard as one in three women experience birth trauma. A lot of women wanting natural are doing it to avoid trauma.

This I agree with.

I think if we could all agree - healthy baby and untraumatised mum are the targets - it's a short step to acknowledge that that looks different for everyone.

I'm going for ELCS for my second. And yes, the main reason is because I'm utterly traumatised by my failed induction and never want to risk that again. The medical team all agree that it's a perfectly ok option in terms of medical risk, including my anaesthesia plan. But for me my no1 goal is preventing further trauma.

I've heard of other mums opting for VBAC for similar reasons, eg they hated the c-section recovery period.

So reducing trauma, as a goal in birth choices, I'm fully signed up for, regardless of the means.

I'm dead against any argument about birth choices affecting breastfeeding though (which is one of the pro-natural-birth arguments I hear a lot).

On the small sample size of the mums I know, it's almost an inverse correlation between smoothness of birth and duration of BF.

Don't get me wrong, formula is a miracle and is a great option. But it's just threat of BF failing seems to be used to scare mums into declining birth interventions that would make their births easier

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/10/2023 19:39

Ididivfama · 03/10/2023 19:34

Healthy baby but also non traumatised mum, which is hard as one in three women experience birth trauma. A lot of women wanting natural are doing it to avoid trauma.

Of course, non traumatised mum too.

Again, it goes back to personal preference and previous experience. One of the reasons why I wanted an epidural is because giving birth unmedicated sounds traumatic to me and my epidural birth was lovely and not at all traumatic.

Others will obviously have a different experience.

Ididivfama · 03/10/2023 19:34

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/10/2023 17:01

Individually, absolutely.

That also needs to be the case with healthcare professionals, hospitals, birthing classes etc as opposed to the current attitude of unmedicated is best and epidural is a last resort, it's 'giving in'.

A healthy baby is ideal. That's it.

Healthy baby but also non traumatised mum, which is hard as one in three women experience birth trauma. A lot of women wanting natural are doing it to avoid trauma.

cestlavielife · 03/10/2023 17:04

No one cares how you or your baby came into the world. No one puts it on their c v .
You dont get extra anything whichever way.

junbean · 03/10/2023 17:03

We don't have gas & air where I live either. I tried for natural birth but things went wrong. I had fentanyl injections at first, then it went to epidural and then to emergency c-section. I've only had 1 natural out of my 4. I do prefer it but things usually don't go as planned. No one can have an opinion on your birth. Only you knew what it was like and what you needed. We're lucky to live in a time and place where we have options.

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/10/2023 17:01

Chickenkeev · 03/10/2023 16:58

Can we all just agree to agree that whatever birth suits us is fine?

Individually, absolutely.

That also needs to be the case with healthcare professionals, hospitals, birthing classes etc as opposed to the current attitude of unmedicated is best and epidural is a last resort, it's 'giving in'.

A healthy baby is ideal. That's it.

CurlewKate · 03/10/2023 16:59

@MargotBamborough "I think you're adding a few words there for dramatic effect."

I'm not, you know. Both martyr and competitive have been used several times. I half withdraw "crazy woman" now you've added context. But all the "why would you DO that??" posts do kind of suggest that it is a bit of a theme!

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/10/2023 16:58

SamAndEIIa · 03/10/2023 16:54

They gave me two paracetamol and begrudgingly sent a student in to see if I was contracting or just having “period pains” when I’d buzzed about 8 times and was rolling around in pain after being induced.

Turns out I was having 7 moderate to strong contractions lasting between 30 seconds and 2 minutes within a 10 minute period. So basically non stop agony for six hours, and they thought I needed two paracetamols. They eventually gave me gas and air and removed my pessary

It's infuriating.

I bet if men had to give birth, they'd be offered more than paracetamol!

Chickenkeev · 03/10/2023 16:58

Can we all just agree to agree that whatever birth suits us is fine?

SamAndEIIa · 03/10/2023 16:54

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/10/2023 14:16

It really is that kind of attitude here. I was met with shock when I asked for an epidural straight away and I arrived at the hospital 6cm dilated so it wasn't like I was in very early labour either.

If it is safe, effective and available, why on earth would you try and fob someone off who wants one with fucking paracetamol? Not to mention how patronising they were because it was my first. They soon shut up when they saw I was 6cm. 😂

They gave me two paracetamol and begrudgingly sent a student in to see if I was contracting or just having “period pains” when I’d buzzed about 8 times and was rolling around in pain after being induced.

Turns out I was having 7 moderate to strong contractions lasting between 30 seconds and 2 minutes within a 10 minute period. So basically non stop agony for six hours, and they thought I needed two paracetamols. They eventually gave me gas and air and removed my pessary

MargotBamborough · 03/10/2023 16:53

CurlewKate · 03/10/2023 16:40

@Chickenkeev "But people are being defensive here because they're getting judged for the interventions!"

Not by anyone on the actual thread, though. The only judging going on is of the people who want unmedicated. We're martyrs, competitive, crazy women.....I feel simultaneously judged and invisible. Which is a very odd feeling to have!

I think you're adding a few words there for dramatic effect.

I did use the word crazy, but as I explained a couple of times, I was describing the attitude where I live towards women who decline pain relief in labour.

I don't think women who want an unmedicated birth are crazy. But I am curious about why. If it's because you want a home birth, that's a very good reason. If it's because you think your baby will be born drugged, that's fake news and you are suffering for no reason.

Myneighboursarewankers · 03/10/2023 16:51

IkeandKyle · 02/10/2023 22:00

As a PP said, “natural” birth has no definition in medical terms. Normal vaginal delivery (NVD) is probably closest, but there’s been a ridiculous drive in the past decade towards a totally drug-free birth without pain relief. Believe me they don’t give out any medals for this and there’s no evidence it’s better for baby.

Glad someone said it.

there is so much pressure on women to have a “drug free” birth, if you like. People that do it without pain meds seem to feel they are above others I have found (Ofcourse this doesn’t apply to all). I had epidurals with both of mine and have requested it for my third. You wouldn’t brag about not needing pain relief if you broke your leg - why? Because it’s an insane amount of pain and should be medicated.
birth is the same imo.

still have no idea what people mean when they say natural birth. I assume they meant to medical intervention so C sec.

1stTimeMama · 03/10/2023 16:50

I would say a natural birth would be defined by spontaneously going in to labour, no pain relief and no medical assistance. Otherwise, I would say vaginal birth or c section.

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/10/2023 16:50

CurlewKate · 03/10/2023 16:40

@Chickenkeev "But people are being defensive here because they're getting judged for the interventions!"

Not by anyone on the actual thread, though. The only judging going on is of the people who want unmedicated. We're martyrs, competitive, crazy women.....I feel simultaneously judged and invisible. Which is a very odd feeling to have!

Most people were simply talking about their experiences that some (not all) of those who go unmedicated can be judgemental and assume it's simply because someone didn't try 'hard enough'.

OP even started this thread to begin with because her own mother judged her.

I had midwives trying to shame me for wanting an epidural and having no interest in gas & air and they are supposed to be professionals.

SamAndEIIa · 03/10/2023 16:48

CattingAbout · 02/10/2023 22:06

I think some peope just say 'natural birth' because they don't want to say the word 'vaginal' tbh.

Exactly. It’s fucking embarrassing for a grown adult tbh.

Ididivfama · 03/10/2023 16:45

What annoys me about this is that every birth is different. An induction/back to back baby can be more painful than a reasonably speedy birth, but again it depends doesn’t it. Positioning, environment, baby size, psychological state. There’s so much to it. You do what you need to do for each unique birth. It doesn’t define you overall.

Chickenkeev · 03/10/2023 16:44

CurlewKate · 03/10/2023 16:40

@Chickenkeev "But people are being defensive here because they're getting judged for the interventions!"

Not by anyone on the actual thread, though. The only judging going on is of the people who want unmedicated. We're martyrs, competitive, crazy women.....I feel simultaneously judged and invisible. Which is a very odd feeling to have!

The judgement is a real thing though. And i suppose hackles get raised betimes. Imho, mum safe, baby safe, job well done. And it's nobody elses business.

CurlewKate · 03/10/2023 16:40

*went, not want.

CurlewKate · 03/10/2023 16:40

@Chickenkeev "But people are being defensive here because they're getting judged for the interventions!"

Not by anyone on the actual thread, though. The only judging going on is of the people who want unmedicated. We're martyrs, competitive, crazy women.....I feel simultaneously judged and invisible. Which is a very odd feeling to have!

MargotBamborough · 03/10/2023 16:24

Chickenkeev · 03/10/2023 16:15

But people are being defensive here because they're getting judged for the interventions! Of course people will be defensive in that case. 'Intervention' mothers have done nothing wrong (people talking about drugged babies ffs). There is no right or wrong way to give birth as long as it's safe for mother and baby. And people should stick their beaks out of everyone elses choice.

I actually didn't feel judged by the comment about "drugged babies".

I felt sorry for that person because I think they actually believed what they were saying. It's actually terrible that a woman who is in pain might choose not to have pain relief because she has been led to believe that it is bad for her baby or that her baby will be born drugged.

I think it's really important to combat this kind of misinformation.

When I moved to France I was desperately worried about the fact that the only pain relief likely to be available to me was an epidural and very hung up about the fact that there would be no gas and air or anything else. I was absolutely convinced that the key to avoiding every intervention under the sun was to not have an epidural, and terrified when I ended up having to be induced. The reason I thought that having an epidural would make forceps, ventouse, episiotomy or a C-section much more likely is because all the English language resources I had access to, including books about hypnobirthing and thousands of women on Mumsnet repeating what they have been told, says that this is true.

It took giving birth to two babies in France, having two epidurals myself (and two incredibly different births), and looking up some of the statistics about the frequency of these interventions in France and the UK, to make me conclude that a lot of what we are told about the "risks" of epidurals appears to be total bullshit.

So no, I don't feel judged for those kinds of comments. I feel sorry for the women who believe them.

Chickenkeev · 03/10/2023 16:15

OhmygodDont · 03/10/2023 15:46

Honestly most of the bitchy comments I’ve ever had are because I had easy births. I’ve never once heard in real life anyone being bitchy or sarky to those who had csections or epidurals.

however us who did no drugs, water births and home births where mental and crazy and wanting to risk our babies lives 🥱 or we where smug hippies or whatever else people wanted to call us.

But people are being defensive here because they're getting judged for the interventions! Of course people will be defensive in that case. 'Intervention' mothers have done nothing wrong (people talking about drugged babies ffs). There is no right or wrong way to give birth as long as it's safe for mother and baby. And people should stick their beaks out of everyone elses choice.

OhmygodDont · 03/10/2023 15:46

Honestly most of the bitchy comments I’ve ever had are because I had easy births. I’ve never once heard in real life anyone being bitchy or sarky to those who had csections or epidurals.

however us who did no drugs, water births and home births where mental and crazy and wanting to risk our babies lives 🥱 or we where smug hippies or whatever else people wanted to call us.

Tg2023 · 03/10/2023 15:27

My midwives described mine as natural births DT's & DS as they were both vaginal & both without pain relief.

However I watched as my poor Dsis was in a labour for 16 hours in ridiculous pain & absolutely exhausted to end up being rushed to theatre for an emergency c section & I can honestly say call it what you like I wouldn't of like to be in my sister position.

Swipe left for the next trending thread