Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anyone in HR? I’ve f’d up big time

131 replies

Fundamentallyfurked · 02/10/2023 21:44

So about 2 years ago, my good friend helped me get a job. It was a job that I was qualified for and had the necessary skills and qualifications but she coached me through the interview. She was one of the hiring managers (although she said at decision making she didn’t advocate for me as she didn’t want it to appear dodgy when it clearly was). She didn’t declare conflict of interest and coached me through key skills to hit. she knew it was coming up and was having trouble filling the position so told me to apply.

Prior to this she always moaned about her direct reports, how bad they were, how much she covered for them when they f’d up which apparently was often. They’d complained about her management style, said she was too harsh but she was just trying to help them. Fast forward, I was offered the job and started and things were fine, for a while and then she started to ask me to do things, inform on them, feedback anything they said about her to get them in trouble, disclosing how she was trying to manage someone out, mocking her direct reports mental health, disclosing really personal things about them. I said I didn’t feel comfortable trying to get my colleagues in trouble but glossed over what anyone said about her. Things started to decline from there, just an incremental change. My feedback on my work got harsher but I took it in stride and tried to work harder, even got recognised by the head of department for it. Things got worse in a 360 feedback I gave some, very light constructive feedback and then I started to get shut down in meetings, she started to take credit for my work. But personally things were ok. I then put in a request for my work hrs to be amended due to caring responsibilities that I have (parent with dementia) I discussed it at interview and with her personally and she said it was ok. BUT then things drastically changed. She told me in a meeting she no longer wished to talk to me personally but would be professional.
since then she’s actively tried to ruin my life and is now trying any trick in the book to manage me out. End of year downgraded my rating by force, put me on a PIP, is hyper critical, has been slagging me off left right and centre to any snr management that will listen, fabricated feedback (hidden behind the person being too afraid to say anything about me and the others wanting to remain anonymous. One told me in confidence that she tried to get her to make allegations about me. I’m unequivocally being set up to fail. She has bullied several people out of the team and often reduces people to tears but she has a vendetta against me. When things started to go wrong, I tried to talk to her and smooth things over and find out what I’d done, but frankly it was nonsense, that I didn’t show integrity getting the job, I reminded her it was her idea which she denied. She said my carer responsibility wasn’t her problem and I’m not the only one in the world with problems and to stop being so entitled. I reminded her that in the interview I asked her and the department head about it and they said it was absolutely fine and others do the same thing, she also denied that.

I can’t do anything right now, I had help getting the job. And I know I know never mix business with pleasure, and I shouldn’t have but never in my wildest dreams did I think it would turn to this.

ive even had malicious allegations to social services about my child, it was an anonymous ‘concerned former friend’.

i desperately need another job but when I find one, can I share what she’s done? I’m not the first person she has done this to (perhaps not to this extent) and I won’t be the last. She’s being rewarded with promotions whilst taking the ideas of others and actively punishing them. Can I share she got me the job, and explain the whole situation to the HR partner for our area? If I secure a new job can there possibly be any blow back on me? References just include the time you’ve worked there form HR right? I know for her it would be gross misconduct but what about me if I’ve already handed in my notice?

i apologise this is so long, and if you’ve read to the bottom. Thank you for your time

OP posts:
Fundamentallyfurked · 03/10/2023 10:34

Mrsttcno1 · 03/10/2023 09:56

You’ve received a lot of good advice here already OP and I agree with a lot of it. I would even say there’s potential that you have a case for constructive dismissal, evidence dependent.

You need to find out what your companies policy is on behaviour and bullying in the workplace. Most now will have one, follow that process.

Gather a record of everything you’ve said said, dates, times, any evidence you currently have. If you do a SAR that may give you more evidence for this. I know you’re wary of speaking to others she has treated this way, but there is honestly power in numbers. Has there been anybody you know who has left the company due to her treatment - if so ask them if they would be willing to stand with you.

I would also say, if we’re talking about a decent sized company here, her gross misconduct really overpowers any on your side. She as a senior member of staff AND a hiring manager has provided you with the questions in advance, and has sat on a panel regarding your employment without declaring a conflict of interest. In your interview/panel interview however it was, were you ever specifically asked if you personally knew either of the interviewers? If not, then you haven’t lied. Whereas I would absolutely say she will have been asked as a senior hiring manager to declare that conflict. She is the one who crossed that line, you accepted help applying for a job from someone who works there. That happens literally ALL of the time, in all jobs. You didn’t skip the application process, you followed it all through correctly, you have the relevant qualifications for the job and it doesn’t sound as if it was solely her who decided to give you the job it was a panel of people.

If you can gather the evidence together, with the evidence you already have of her sharing interview content, plus the knowledge you only have due to her sharing confidential information about colleagues, and you can use your report to show that on x date you told her you do not feel comfortable reporting to her on colleagues, then suddenly on y date you are put on PIP, on x date you receive social services call, on z date you’re told you can no longer have flexible working previously agreed at interview, you are able to show a pattern of behaviour for bullying and arguably harassment in the workplace.

There are other people that have moved to other teams because of her, I know that for a fact and one who left very very abruptly and when we were on good terms she told me she was gunning for (they also had caring responsibilities) I don’t know the specifics there but I’d imagine they were pushed out.

no one ever asked me if I knew her or anyone or anything questions about conflict of interest.

that’s what I was hoping to do, but I don’t think I can do it if I’m still working there, I’d need to do it where I know I can’t be punished.

thank you for your encouragement x

OP posts:
NeedToChangeName · 03/10/2023 10:28

How you got the job / her sharing confidential info / you not being up front, doesn't reflect well on either of you. I'd keep quiet about that

Your best option is to leave and put all this behind you

booksandbeans · 03/10/2023 10:08

Having survived something similar with a couple of managers for whom behaving with decency & integrity were unheard of.

i desperately need another job but when I find one, can I share what she’s done? With a prospective employer absolutely not. With your current one yes as a grievance. Or see what whistle blowing options there are.

Keep acting with integrity, maybe ask for a HR rep at any pip meetings. One manager I had was ‘ found out’ by another & managed out. Second time round they came as a pack with a lead bully.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 03/10/2023 09:56

It does sound really tough. You can still challenge her assessment each time and follow it up in writing. So if she says something isn’t satisfactory ask her to give objective criteria as to what satisfactory looks like, ask her what support and training she is going to put in place to assist you in meeting these criteria. Follow up in writing with HR in copy.

If your current manager is not following the Occ Health advice to the letter then remind them in writing with a copy to HR.

The more you look like you are building a case the more HR might just want you to leave quietly.
Nobody will protect your interests apart from you so don’t feel embarrassed about appearing bloody minded.

The point of things like ACAS guidelines/codes of practice is not that ACAS is marvellous but that you can argue your firm is failing to follow best practice and ask HR why that is the case.
eg ACAS code states best practice is for companies to do x. You are failing to do x in my case, which I believe maybe to my detriment, please outline in writing why you are not following best practice.

Flexible working requests have a whole statutory framework around them so have to be responded to in a particular way. You can currently make 1 request a year but I think that is increasing to 2 next year.

It’s a horrible situation to be in and all you can do is your best.

Mrsttcno1 · 03/10/2023 09:56

You’ve received a lot of good advice here already OP and I agree with a lot of it. I would even say there’s potential that you have a case for constructive dismissal, evidence dependent.

You need to find out what your companies policy is on behaviour and bullying in the workplace. Most now will have one, follow that process.

Gather a record of everything you’ve said said, dates, times, any evidence you currently have. If you do a SAR that may give you more evidence for this. I know you’re wary of speaking to others she has treated this way, but there is honestly power in numbers. Has there been anybody you know who has left the company due to her treatment - if so ask them if they would be willing to stand with you.

I would also say, if we’re talking about a decent sized company here, her gross misconduct really overpowers any on your side. She as a senior member of staff AND a hiring manager has provided you with the questions in advance, and has sat on a panel regarding your employment without declaring a conflict of interest. In your interview/panel interview however it was, were you ever specifically asked if you personally knew either of the interviewers? If not, then you haven’t lied. Whereas I would absolutely say she will have been asked as a senior hiring manager to declare that conflict. She is the one who crossed that line, you accepted help applying for a job from someone who works there. That happens literally ALL of the time, in all jobs. You didn’t skip the application process, you followed it all through correctly, you have the relevant qualifications for the job and it doesn’t sound as if it was solely her who decided to give you the job it was a panel of people.

If you can gather the evidence together, with the evidence you already have of her sharing interview content, plus the knowledge you only have due to her sharing confidential information about colleagues, and you can use your report to show that on x date you told her you do not feel comfortable reporting to her on colleagues, then suddenly on y date you are put on PIP, on x date you receive social services call, on z date you’re told you can no longer have flexible working previously agreed at interview, you are able to show a pattern of behaviour for bullying and arguably harassment in the workplace.

Fundamentallyfurked · 03/10/2023 09:39

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 03/10/2023 09:28

HR still have to ensure that the process is operated fairly and consistently otherwise it opens up the risk of accusations of bullying and discrimination. You need to make this HR’s problem. They won’t back you against your manager but if they can see the risk of a grievance/ whistleblowing they may be inclined to push for a negotiated exit with an agreed reference. You might be able to get a couple of months gardening leave which will let you look for a new job in peace.

Ask for policies on flexible working and performance management. Document everything and question everything. If you have a diagnosis of IBS consider asking to discuss reasonable adjustments with Occupational Health.

You can’t salvage your job but you can create a situation where it’s in their interests to let you leave on reasonable terms.

Allowances have been made on occupational health and it influenced the PIP something she was not happy about.

a Union rep is going to attend my 1:1s with me to ensure I’m not being set up to fail. Thing is the PIP looks above board, you can challenge a rating and a decision for a pip but i think I’ve left it too long, I didn’t have it in me to fight it, I had no evidence and she was fabricating things left right and centre- I thought it would make it worse for myself, which I probably would as she’s definitely punishing me for going against her

OP posts:
ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 03/10/2023 09:28

Fundamentallyfurked · 03/10/2023 09:17

So it’s not HR that do the PIP at my company it’s your line manager / snr manager aka her. It’s then run past HR. So I don’t think there is anything in that sadly

HR still have to ensure that the process is operated fairly and consistently otherwise it opens up the risk of accusations of bullying and discrimination. You need to make this HR’s problem. They won’t back you against your manager but if they can see the risk of a grievance/ whistleblowing they may be inclined to push for a negotiated exit with an agreed reference. You might be able to get a couple of months gardening leave which will let you look for a new job in peace.

Ask for policies on flexible working and performance management. Document everything and question everything. If you have a diagnosis of IBS consider asking to discuss reasonable adjustments with Occupational Health.

You can’t salvage your job but you can create a situation where it’s in their interests to let you leave on reasonable terms.

Fundamentallyfurked · 03/10/2023 09:19

JoyApple · 03/10/2023 00:29

And ACAS are completely useless btw.

She hasn't won if you leave for a lower paid job. You put your health and wellbeing first, that's what matters ultimately - and that's a sign of you winning!

I agree on acas, Ive called and they were also incredibly wishy washy (word of the day haha)

i appreciate the sentiment but I need the money from a cost of living point of view, I don’t want to lose my home. My mortgage has just sky rocketed

OP posts:
Fundamentallyfurked · 03/10/2023 09:17

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 03/10/2023 00:08

Did you make a formal flexible working request? If so, did the company process your request in line with the ACAS code of practice?
https://www.acas.org.uk/acas-code-of-practice-on-flexible-working-requests/html
Do you have a copy of the policies on flexible working requests and any policies relating to caring responsibilities?

Ask HR to set out in writing clear objective SMART targets for the PIP. Ask them to outline what steps HR are taking to ensure fair treatment and consistency in the process to ensure that you are treated in the same way as other employees.

None of these things will make the job tenable in the long run but what you may be able to do is make HR uncomfortable enough that they agree a sensible settlement. That settlement should include an agreed form of reference.

So it’s not HR that do the PIP at my company it’s your line manager / snr manager aka her. It’s then run past HR. So I don’t think there is anything in that sadly

OP posts:
Fundamentallyfurked · 03/10/2023 08:40

TheCurtainQueen · 03/10/2023 06:44

That makes her look 100x worse than you. But do you have evidence of this? Did she WhatsApp or email you questions and answers?

I think you need to go to HR now.

Yes to both, I can’t do it when I work there, it will look like vengeance for the PIP like another poster said.

i don’t know what to do. I’m a grown up at the end of the day if there was concerns about output or performance I should’ve been told but our dynamic changed overnight. I definitely wasn’t getting an easy ride of it before, but now I’m under ridiculous scrutiny.

if I’m away from my desk for 10 mins I’m pulled up on it, ive developed Ibs since all of this so there have been times when I’ve urgently needed to loo, and I’ve had to explain this to my new line manager and it’s mortifying

OP posts:
YouveGotAFastCar · 03/10/2023 07:05

Although perhaps you could leave and then anonymously report what she did once you’re gone and settled elsewhere. You’d need to provide evidence and they probably could then track it back to you but they’d be unlikely to do much when they discovered you’d already left, and you’d have a newer reference then from your new job.

if they decide they can’t take action on an anonymous complaint, at least it’ll be on her file.

Poppyhopscotch · 03/10/2023 07:04

Do you not have a whistleblowing line that you can confidentially pass on the information for it to be formally investigated?

YouveGotAFastCar · 03/10/2023 06:51

Fundamentallyfurked · 02/10/2023 22:59

From a HR point of view she’s leaked confidential documents that’s gross misconduct. It would be how HR see it, hiring your mate and not disclosing it and then all the other things she’s said suddenly have more weight or else she’ll lie her way out of it and paint me as the struggling person flinging shit

Have you considered that it will look like this anyway?

You accepted the help from her, and the confidential documents, and used them in your interview. Most people are not going to believe that you developed a conscience after that. They’re going to believe that you expected an easy ride because she’s your friend, and now you’re on a PIP, you’re trying to get revenge.

She sounds horrific and you need to get away, but you can’t be the whistleblower on how unfair her actions were to get you the job when you were involved too. I’d be very surprised if it wasn’t considered gross misconduct on both sides, to be honest, it’d severely undermine their trust in you to know that you accepted documents and took part in this.

If you are certain your reference will only be dates, you could ignore that and hope for the best, but I’d be stunned if any regulated industry isn’t passing on more information than that even if it’s verbal.

But I suspect you’d be a lot better to leave and hope karma gets her in time. I don’t think you can realistically take her down for breaking the rules to help you get the job when you accepted that help.

TheCurtainQueen · 03/10/2023 06:44

That makes her look 100x worse than you. But do you have evidence of this? Did she WhatsApp or email you questions and answers?

I think you need to go to HR now.

Atticustheaardvark · 03/10/2023 06:33

MsCactus · 02/10/2023 22:33

You could put in a bullying complaint against her, raise objections that the PIP is being rated based on opinion rather than fact, and ask for factual measures as you don't think her assessment is objective on the basis of bullying (which is why you've raised the complaint).

There's nothing really they can do then. They might start offering to pay you off.

I agree 100% with this.

fedupathome · 03/10/2023 01:14

She sounds exactly like my old boss!!! Even down to rewording things but basically saying the same!
My work would be marked like a child and corrected even though it wasn't wrong. She just preferred it worded her way. It was so degrading.

Fab973 · 03/10/2023 01:04

Ok so sheis being a nightmare manager who is clearly not remotely good at her job. HOWEVER, you took the interview, she helped you, helpd land you the job which you took with both hands. Now she is nightmsre manager. I don’t think this will go well for you as it looks like spite and retaillation for you to bring this up now well after the fact.

if you want to challenge her management approach, do it. Make it formal but dont go trying to throw her under the bus when she went out of her way to help you get a job you have benifited from just beacuse shes a bad manager-it makes you look spiteful and vindictive. Plus it’s just a dick move, on natter what shes done since.

TheLightProgramme · 03/10/2023 00:53

Honestly? Forget about her.

Ignore any thoughts focussed on retaliation, bringing her down etc for the sake of it - its not productive. The circumstances of your hiring really aren't that relevant.

Focus on:

  • getting another job, fast
  • seeing the PIP and your response to it as your defensive arsenal, and using as a tool to put yourself in a position where if they want you gone, they have to pay
  • defending your self - paper trail for EVERYTHING.
  • Be lilly white in terms of your own behaviour.
Failingatthemoment · 03/10/2023 00:48

An employer cant officially give a bad reference BUT ( as im suspicious might have happened in my case ) the ex employer can privately email or speak to the prospective employer.........

JoyApple · 03/10/2023 00:29

And ACAS are completely useless btw.

She hasn't won if you leave for a lower paid job. You put your health and wellbeing first, that's what matters ultimately - and that's a sign of you winning!

JoyApple · 03/10/2023 00:24

Firebug007 · 02/10/2023 23:29

Honestly it's not worth it, you'll just earmark yourself as a troublemaker, too risky and it could backfire on you in that it could be said you would not have been suitable for the role had it not been for your friendship. People like this implode their careers eventually, take the high road and wait it out 🤷‍♀️

Sadly I agree with this.

I put the complaint in and started the process of taking it to the employment tribunal, all because I didn't want this to happen to anyone else. But she quickly moved on, and I was left with the emotional and physical trauma of re-living it through such a stressful and unsupportive process. Literally no one is on your side, and they turn against you so quickly and will make up complete lies about you and harm your reputation and confidence.

It just isn't worth it. Hand your notice in asap and leave is what I would recommend. And move on.

Nearlyspring23 · 03/10/2023 00:20

Out of interest why is she progressing in the company and why don’t others above her see it?
Is it because she has friends in management, puts on a strategic false front, management/company ethos is as bad as her, is cut throat and good at her role?
It just always baffles me how people like this progress and how management don’t see it when literally everyone else does.

Sending you solidarity op.

Pammy28 · 03/10/2023 00:19

Also, she shouldn't have shown you confidential docs or given you tips. She is in HR !!

JoyApple · 03/10/2023 00:17

Gosh she sounds like my old manager.

HR are not there to protect your interests. I left and raised a grievance and they denied it all and tried to turn it on me. She moved onto somewhere else within a few months.

I tried to take it to employment tribunal but it is a very very long and rough journey and in hindsight was not worth it. Part of me wishes I shouldn't have bothered even putting the grievance in - it took away too much of my energy and time, and it was very traumatic reading all they denied and the complete fabrications they made up about me.

My advice me try your best to get another job quickly and move on. This isn't worthwhile your energy and complaining is not going to get you anywhere.

I actually left without having another job to go to. I had a mini breakdown afterwards but within a few months got a job that paid around 4 times more. So stuff then and their lies. But it is taking me years to heal from the horrible bullying.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 03/10/2023 00:08

Did you make a formal flexible working request? If so, did the company process your request in line with the ACAS code of practice?
https://www.acas.org.uk/acas-code-of-practice-on-flexible-working-requests/html
Do you have a copy of the policies on flexible working requests and any policies relating to caring responsibilities?

Ask HR to set out in writing clear objective SMART targets for the PIP. Ask them to outline what steps HR are taking to ensure fair treatment and consistency in the process to ensure that you are treated in the same way as other employees.

None of these things will make the job tenable in the long run but what you may be able to do is make HR uncomfortable enough that they agree a sensible settlement. That settlement should include an agreed form of reference.

Code of Practice on handling in a reasonable manner requests to work flexibly | Acas

https://www.acas.org.uk/acas-code-of-practice-on-flexible-working-requests/html

Swipe left for the next trending thread