Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Animals treated better than humans by the NHS

61 replies

Letsgetouttahere2023 · 02/10/2023 13:19

Scary cheap money saving by the nhs!!

Would you be happy to be treated by a physicians assistant; someone with no medical qualifications! (Link to article below)

YABU - Yes I'd happily be treated by a "physican assistant"- someone with no medical degree and just a few weeks / months training

YANBU - Medcial care should be performed by someone with a medical degree and relevant post graduate training and exams, ie a Doctor

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/09/30/animals-treated-better-than-humans-say-doctors-row/

Animals treated more safely than humans, doctors say, as ‘non-medical staff have surgical training’

‘Risky and inappropriate practices’ must stop, warn medics, as unregulated physician associates are used to plug NHS workforce gap

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/09/30/animals-treated-better-than-humans-say-doctors-row

OP posts:
anniegun · 02/10/2023 14:04

Keep voting Tory and you will be operating on yourself based on a Youtube video

StuffedToys · 02/10/2023 14:02

My understanding is that the roles have become blurred. PAs were meant to take the admin load off doctors, do bloods etc and leave the more responsible tasks to the junior doctors who are the ones who can prescribe.

But instead, some PAs are delegating their work to junior doctors and going off to take up opportunities for experience in the operating theatres etc so doctors are being denied training opportunities. This is not right.

Some alarming stories in the medical and other press too.

A lot of work still to be done.

VisaWoes · 02/10/2023 14:00

Yes I’d prefer a doctor but your OP is misleading and full of duff information. Training is not weeks/months.

There’s a valid argument that if they stay in one area for a longer period of time they’re more competent than an f1 or f2 who is a dr (with no postgrad stuff which btw you don’t have to have to be a doctor).

a decent PA will be as good as an advanced practitioner nurse and such ANPs are often better than doctors up to and including SHO level. I worked in a hospital for years and used to prefer the ANPs over the SHOs. Also had great emergency treatment from an ANP myself

Letsgetouttahere2023 · 02/10/2023 13:55

Kaill · 02/10/2023 13:39

This has been happening for years with teachers, who are being replaced by “unqualified teachers”. And we already have GP appointments being replaced by the nurse. It’s very difficult to see a qualified GP unless you’re able to wait a couple of weeks. Now they want “unqualified surgeons” too. The mind boggles!

Yes, it's ridiculous!

OP posts:
Worddance · 02/10/2023 13:54

ncob · 02/10/2023 13:41

You know its not just the duration of training that makes a doctor.. a doctor, right?

Otherwise anyone off the street could go off and study for 6 years, and suddenly theyre a "doctor"? Lol. No.

The entrance to medical school is mad competitive, only the very smartest get through then there are countless hurdles throughout medical school meaning of this very brightest group - the best come out the other end having been trained to a high standard. Then there is foundation training and speciality training (most doctors take additional years before/during/after) all in all probably taking around 10 years of "training" beyond their 5-6 medical degree during which they are working and taking immensely difficult postgraduate exams.

I don't personally know anybody in healthcare who would want to be treated by a PA instead of a qualified doctor (and this includes PAs themselves!)

Why do you sound like such a patronising know it all? I wouldn't want someone with your manner and outlook as my doctor in a million years.

MintJulia · 02/10/2023 13:52

@ncob 'The problem isnt with them as people but with the role. They get paid more for less responsibility and steal training opportunities from actual doctors... the kind that go on to become consultants. PAs will never be that.'

Firstly, not everyone working in healthcare can be a consultant. There is neither the need not the funding for that. And secondly, yes, she will be a qualified doctor, when a place at the medical school she wants becomes available.

Until then she benefits from practical experience on the ward.

jlpth · 02/10/2023 13:48

I've known for a long time that my dog gets far, far superior healthcare to me or my children.

Pugfin · 02/10/2023 13:47

Meloncocomelon · 02/10/2023 13:43

This:

OP seems to want people to think PAs are the equivalent of a YTS scheme or something and not highly trained and qualified professionals.

This kind of thing has been going on for years with nurse prescribers who undergo a really intensive educational and practical course with very high pass marks required.

And in MH, for a while now there have been high-grade nurses who train to be senior MH professionals and able to take part in sectioning, diagnosing and treating people.

And yet neither of those are PAs to whom OP was referring to...

Pugfin · 02/10/2023 13:45

If a PA can pick up more of the administrative or process driven clinical work - for example in A&E following a suspected blood clot protocol and ordering bloods, or doing discharge summaries, then it frees up doctors to do more complex medicine.

Indeed, as was their intended role, it would be brilliant if this was what was happening wouldn't it.

@CoughingMajoress so anything negative should be swept under the rug rather than reported on because it's seen as right wing press? Doctors and other professionals are highlighting this issue because it's positively ludicrous and dangerous to have unregulated and lesser trained people expanding their roles into all sorts of directions without any real handle on it. Especially ridiculous when there are qualified doctors waiting for training posts but not getting the opportunities that are increasingly being handed to PAs.

ncob · 02/10/2023 13:44

MintJulia · 02/10/2023 13:39

This is inaccurate scaremongering.

My niece is a physician's assistant. She has a Bachelors(1st) taking 3 years, in Bio-medical science and a masters (distinction) taking 2 years in PA Studies followed by a year's experience in the renal department of a large NHS trust.

She works within a team lead by a renal consultant, focusing on ward-based care.

Not 'a few weeks/months training'!

Cool. So nothing on a doctor's training (see my prev post). If you want to be treated by PAs going forward, then please be my guest.

Most PAs I have met are lovely, kind people. The problem isnt with them as people but with the role. They get paid more for less responsibility and steal training opportunities from actual doctors... the kind that go on to become consultants. PAs will never be that.

Meloncocomelon · 02/10/2023 13:43

Worddance · 02/10/2023 13:30

Your op reads like you're a militant junior doctor who thinks you can influence the uncultured masses because you're the brightest and the best. Honestly, we're all capable of googling how long it takes to train in this profession. A science degree or similar (like nursing) first, then a conversion degree.

This:

OP seems to want people to think PAs are the equivalent of a YTS scheme or something and not highly trained and qualified professionals.

This kind of thing has been going on for years with nurse prescribers who undergo a really intensive educational and practical course with very high pass marks required.

And in MH, for a while now there have been high-grade nurses who train to be senior MH professionals and able to take part in sectioning, diagnosing and treating people.

Crinklecutchips1 · 02/10/2023 13:42

Pugfin · 02/10/2023 13:36

It's good though, the more people who are happy to be treated by PAs the more doctors for the rest of us.

I doubt whether, on the NHS at least, you will get a choice whether you are seen by a PA or a doctor

ncob · 02/10/2023 13:41

You know its not just the duration of training that makes a doctor.. a doctor, right?

Otherwise anyone off the street could go off and study for 6 years, and suddenly theyre a "doctor"? Lol. No.

The entrance to medical school is mad competitive, only the very smartest get through then there are countless hurdles throughout medical school meaning of this very brightest group - the best come out the other end having been trained to a high standard. Then there is foundation training and speciality training (most doctors take additional years before/during/after) all in all probably taking around 10 years of "training" beyond their 5-6 medical degree during which they are working and taking immensely difficult postgraduate exams.

I don't personally know anybody in healthcare who would want to be treated by a PA instead of a qualified doctor (and this includes PAs themselves!)

YouAndMeAndThem · 02/10/2023 13:40

PAs aren't doing operations or anaesthetics though. They are doing consultations for those things not necessary for a doctor's input and are trained accordingly.

CoughingMajoress · 02/10/2023 13:40

Stupid right wing clickbait.

The Tories are actively trying to destroy trust in the NHS because they want to sell it. It's just about money and greed. The Tories know they're going to get kicked out so they want to sell everything they can get their hands on first to line their own pockets as much as possible. The Tories are astonishingly corrupt - look how many people died because the Tories gave medical contracts and PPE contracts to mates with literally zero experience for kickbacks.

That's why the Tory papers are pushing the anti-NHS line so hard. To make it easier to sell.

RosesAndHellebores · 02/10/2023 13:40

For minor things no issue whatsoever. Probably a safer pair of hands than many F2s. Undoubtedly also significantly less cocky and self important.

Nohj · 02/10/2023 13:40

I am a doctor and there is an argument here on both sides

PA training and Dr training are not equivalent at all and they will never have the depth and breadth of knowledge of a doctor.
After a two year conversion course a PA is fully qualified, and may well only have spent a couple of weeks doing the speciality they work in- say cardiology for an example.

After five years medicine a doctor is ‘provisionally registered’ for a year, and then does an additional foundation training year, and then after that starts on a training programme In a speciality. To complete training in the speciality they also have to self fund exams through the royal college of their specialty. So for example I’m 10 years post graduation, have done my royal college exams, but I’m still not yet a consultant.

Its just incomparable.

However, there is a crisis in recruitment and retention in the NHS. If a PA can pick up more of the administrative or process driven clinical work - for example in A&E following a suspected blood clot protocol and ordering bloods, or doing discharge summaries, then it frees up doctors to do more complex medicine.

The danger is when PAs come with egos and don’t know what they don’t know…
I’ve worked with some amazing ones and some very dangerous ones.
I’ve worked with crap doctors but the difference is doctors are tightly regulated ina. Way PAs are not.

PosterBoy · 02/10/2023 13:39

Worddance · 02/10/2023 13:31

That's good because only an actual doctor would be operating. What's your point?

The point is that not an actual doctor will be doing the anaesthetics ... unlike an actual doctor who completed several additional years of training in anaesthetics.

I guess things don't often go wrong so hopefully you won't be unlucky

MintJulia · 02/10/2023 13:39

This is inaccurate scaremongering.

My niece is a physician's assistant. She has a Bachelors(1st) taking 3 years, in Bio-medical science and a masters (distinction) taking 2 years in PA Studies followed by a year's experience in the renal department of a large NHS trust.

She works within a team lead by a renal consultant, focusing on ward-based care.

Not 'a few weeks/months training'!

Kaill · 02/10/2023 13:39

This has been happening for years with teachers, who are being replaced by “unqualified teachers”. And we already have GP appointments being replaced by the nurse. It’s very difficult to see a qualified GP unless you’re able to wait a couple of weeks. Now they want “unqualified surgeons” too. The mind boggles!

IkeandKyle · 02/10/2023 13:38

Don’t be disingenuous. You know full well the OP was inferring in the opening post that PAs only have a few weeks/months of training, which is wildly inaccurate and irresponsible.

PAs are not masquerading as doctors. We need a multi-skilled, dynamic workforce to meet the challenges of the health service in its current state and PAs are part of that.

Meloncocomelon · 02/10/2023 13:37

Pugfin · 02/10/2023 13:29

It's not free is it, its free at point of use. PAs get paid a lot more than a newly qualified doctor and it actually takes a fair few years for earnings to 'catch up'; why on earth are lesser qualified people with less responsibilities and less capabilities being paid more? Its very clearly a government agenda, same as their stance on the strikes- they've paid more in cover than they would have for FPR for a year and beyond. I would bet a million pounds that if any of them require an operation they'd demand an actual doctor.

It's free to the consumer. Unless you know of people being billed by the NHS?

Pugfin · 02/10/2023 13:36

It's good though, the more people who are happy to be treated by PAs the more doctors for the rest of us.

Letsgetouttahere2023 · 02/10/2023 13:35

Exactly @Pugfin

There seems to be an intentional blurring of what their scope is, and as per pp anyone who questions it is labelled as "militant doctor", just bizarre.

OP posts:
Pugfin · 02/10/2023 13:32

Worddance · 02/10/2023 13:31

That's good because only an actual doctor would be operating. What's your point?

Then why are they being sent on funded courses then? Why are there numerous examples of them performing functions they should be nowhere near? PAs should be regulated with clear scopes of practice yet they're not.

Swipe left for the next trending thread