Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Animals treated better than humans by the NHS

61 replies

Letsgetouttahere2023 · 02/10/2023 13:19

Scary cheap money saving by the nhs!!

Would you be happy to be treated by a physicians assistant; someone with no medical qualifications! (Link to article below)

YABU - Yes I'd happily be treated by a "physican assistant"- someone with no medical degree and just a few weeks / months training

YANBU - Medcial care should be performed by someone with a medical degree and relevant post graduate training and exams, ie a Doctor

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/09/30/animals-treated-better-than-humans-say-doctors-row/

Animals treated more safely than humans, doctors say, as ‘non-medical staff have surgical training’

‘Risky and inappropriate practices’ must stop, warn medics, as unregulated physician associates are used to plug NHS workforce gap

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/09/30/animals-treated-better-than-humans-say-doctors-row

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
VisaWoes · 02/10/2023 19:16

Pugfin · 02/10/2023 18:53

No one is saying doctors are infallible though are they? Do you seriously think someone with substantially less training who couldn't refer for any tests etc would be better? I'm curious to the logic of that.

I’m not saying they are any better (though ime an experienced, specialised nurse who you can also say has less training has been better), but mainly that they might be no worse.

I think it depends on the individual, and the experience they’ve had combined with how much curiosity they have and how much effort they’re prepared to put in to actually resolving the issue for someone as opposed to how quickly they can fob them off and get them out the door. Having a medical degree certainly doesn’t make someone infallible.

Pugfin · 02/10/2023 18:53

VisaWoes · 02/10/2023 17:32

You could certainly be describing plenty of doctors who I’ve met both as a patient and a colleague. Drs don’t know what they don’t know and I’ve met plenty who haven’t known enough to correctly diagnose Dd with any of her multiple medical conditions. And over confident and don’t listen.

She does have diagnosis now but only because MN diagnosed her with her two main conditions and I went to the GP and said I think she has x and y. This was after years of appointments. Oh and three doctors missed her PE but a nurse diagnosed it.

even now, the gp rang her up last week told her her iron levels were “dangerously low”. Asked her if she’d been in an accident and lost a lot of blood recently (she hasnt), then realised she’s on blood thinners and told her he was worried she had internal bleeding. So do you know what he eventually decided to do……prescribe iron tablets! No fucking investigation into whether she has got internal bleeding or not. But yes, doctors are infallible and wonderful aren’t they. I seriously believe Dd is alive in spite of doctors. It’s a combination of MN, me and a great nurse who have saved her life.

No one is saying doctors are infallible though are they? Do you seriously think someone with substantially less training who couldn't refer for any tests etc would be better? I'm curious to the logic of that.

Worddance · 02/10/2023 18:49

The PA role in the states is fine and the hysteria surrounding it here is ridiculous. However, given our staffing crisis, there does seem to be a real danger that - and this is already happening - PAs are being left to the work of GPs under the 'supervision' of one GP who isn't even on site and discourages consults. What a horrible position for PAs and patients. This isn't what they trained for and it's not fair to patients. Private contractors are the bad guys here - why don't the doctors acknowledge this? Is it because they're being highly paid by private contractors for working part time hours? The fault is to do with a broken, rather corrupt healthcare system, not the role of a PA. Doctors turning on PAs is like shooting the messenger as their existence here is a symptom of the staffing crisis and could theoretically offer real support to overwhelmed doctors if correctly supported and used in a way that befits their job description. Unfortunately doctors here have become so militant and arrogant that they don't seem to want to think constructively about how patients could benefit.

The optics of doctors refusing to work full time hours, refusing to come to work, emigrating and retiring early while slating highly qualified people who could support them is akin to doctors skating paramedics caring for patients for hours in the back of ambulances. It's not their fault and it's a bit low. Dissing the experience or skill set of PAs is silly. These professionals could be a boon to patients if used as a doctor's best friend, as in the states. Doctors can do what they're trained to do and so can PAs. Criticising PAs is unlikely to create a dynamic where they can contribute effectively as they need to feel able to do what they can do and be able to step back when they've reached their professional limit. For that, they need to be appreciated and have their skill set validated, not criticised for existing and viewed with suspicion. They are highly trained and the course is tough. Bullying PAs won't help patients or doctors.

Alexandra2001 · 02/10/2023 17:47

This is what happens when people want free healthcare, don't often value it but don't want it to cost too much to the taxpayers either

Healthcare is free across Europe, yet don't have the issues we do and have far more Dr's and Nurses pr capita too....

And when Dr's make demands for more money and go on strike for long periods

Govt is refusing to negotiate and Dr's pay in real terms has fallen over 20% in the last 10 years, they are also leaving to go over seas and private sector.. what do we do when there are no Dr's ?

Alternatives have to be found and what will ultimately happen is a healthcare system which is no longer free

European systems mean the citizen pays far more than UK folk do... should prove popular...

Un7breakable · 02/10/2023 17:37

It's two years not a few weeks training, and for certain tasks it's perfectly fine, noone questions paramedics!
They are meant to be used to take over things that you do not need to be a doctor to do.

VisaWoes · 02/10/2023 17:32

Letsgetouttahere2023 · 02/10/2023 15:38

The issue is

A PA doesn't know what a PA doesn't know.

very one dimensional. Sadly often coupled with massive over confidence .

Leaves them lacking insight, lacking supervision, lacking regulation.... Big problems

You could certainly be describing plenty of doctors who I’ve met both as a patient and a colleague. Drs don’t know what they don’t know and I’ve met plenty who haven’t known enough to correctly diagnose Dd with any of her multiple medical conditions. And over confident and don’t listen.

She does have diagnosis now but only because MN diagnosed her with her two main conditions and I went to the GP and said I think she has x and y. This was after years of appointments. Oh and three doctors missed her PE but a nurse diagnosed it.

even now, the gp rang her up last week told her her iron levels were “dangerously low”. Asked her if she’d been in an accident and lost a lot of blood recently (she hasnt), then realised she’s on blood thinners and told her he was worried she had internal bleeding. So do you know what he eventually decided to do……prescribe iron tablets! No fucking investigation into whether she has got internal bleeding or not. But yes, doctors are infallible and wonderful aren’t they. I seriously believe Dd is alive in spite of doctors. It’s a combination of MN, me and a great nurse who have saved her life.

Sleepimpossible · 02/10/2023 16:03

After a troubling experience in which a PA decided that my back pain was muscular, when in fact it was a symptom of a much more complex internal problem, I’m afraid that I’d always want to be seen by a doctor.
Luckily I’m able to advocate for myself and insisted on being seen by a doctor a few weeks later.

MintJulia · 02/10/2023 15:59

@Sunshinenrain Can I ask what your niece actually does?

She spends time with the patients, documents symptoms, progress, responses to drugs, builds relationships & trust with the patients, listens and compiles all the information, so that it is all available and concise to be read by the consultant. It speeds up the consultation, ensures nothing is missed, allows the patient to explain at length, allows them to feel that they have been heard, and provides masses of extra valuable information to the doctors.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 02/10/2023 15:50

Letsgetouttahere2023 · 02/10/2023 15:38

The issue is

A PA doesn't know what a PA doesn't know.

very one dimensional. Sadly often coupled with massive over confidence .

Leaves them lacking insight, lacking supervision, lacking regulation.... Big problems

The same as some doctors. Insufficient knowledge and over confident bordering on arrogance that does nothing to help patients.

Letsgetouttahere2023 · 02/10/2023 15:41

StuffedToys · 02/10/2023 14:02

My understanding is that the roles have become blurred. PAs were meant to take the admin load off doctors, do bloods etc and leave the more responsible tasks to the junior doctors who are the ones who can prescribe.

But instead, some PAs are delegating their work to junior doctors and going off to take up opportunities for experience in the operating theatres etc so doctors are being denied training opportunities. This is not right.

Some alarming stories in the medical and other press too.

A lot of work still to be done.

Exactly, if posters actually read the article it's frightening what's planned by the government in spite of very vocal opposition from experts on the ground

OP posts:
Letsgetouttahere2023 · 02/10/2023 15:38

The issue is

A PA doesn't know what a PA doesn't know.

very one dimensional. Sadly often coupled with massive over confidence .

Leaves them lacking insight, lacking supervision, lacking regulation.... Big problems

OP posts:
Pugfin · 02/10/2023 15:22

In some sense I actually don’t think surgeons need the same training as a doctor.
Why would they need to know how to diagnose asthma etc when their jobs are to do surgery.

They need an understanding of the physiology of the body and more importantly, to know what to do if things go wrong. Learning to do a surgery isn't the same as also having the supporting knowledge to support decisions, management and everything else that comes with being a surgeon. This is the concern with PAs being paid to go on training courses to conduct minor surgeries, they don't have the same level of underlying knowledge.

Pugfin · 02/10/2023 15:19

FormerlyPathologicallyHappy · 02/10/2023 15:05

Well the Drs and surgeons fuck things up regularly so really as a patient there’s not much to lose.

Don't get me started on dhs ANP when he was alive, there was no way in heaven that woman had a masters degree or was capable of getting one. Thick as mince.

There's a lot to lose. Recognising doctors do sadly make mistakes, the mistakes someone much lesser qualified will make are likely to be more numerous aren't they.

Sunshinenrain · 02/10/2023 15:13

MintJulia · 02/10/2023 13:39

This is inaccurate scaremongering.

My niece is a physician's assistant. She has a Bachelors(1st) taking 3 years, in Bio-medical science and a masters (distinction) taking 2 years in PA Studies followed by a year's experience in the renal department of a large NHS trust.

She works within a team lead by a renal consultant, focusing on ward-based care.

Not 'a few weeks/months training'!

Can I ask what your niece actually does?

Does she perform surgical procedures without a physician present or is there always a physician there with her (a bit like a TA to a teacher)?

As @Kaill said, in schools more and more unqualified teachers including TAs and HLTAs are expected to do the job of a teacher and so I’m wondering if this is the same thing.

In some sense I actually don’t think surgeons need the same training as a doctor.
Why would they need to know how to diagnose asthma etc when their jobs are to do surgery.

But I can’t help feel this is a way of getting people to do a doctors job without the pay.

FormerlyPathologicallyHappy · 02/10/2023 15:05

Well the Drs and surgeons fuck things up regularly so really as a patient there’s not much to lose.

Don't get me started on dhs ANP when he was alive, there was no way in heaven that woman had a masters degree or was capable of getting one. Thick as mince.

Treelesschristmas · 02/10/2023 15:01

My concern big about physicians assistants is who is overseeing them professionally? I know as a nurse I have a code of practice from the NMC I have to adhere to, and I will answer to them (and quite possibly the courts) if I fuck up. Drs will be held accountable by the GMC. What body does the same for a physicians assistant? Or can they just be a Lone Ranger and skip off without ramifications if they ever fuck up? No thanks.

DreamingofGinoclock · 02/10/2023 14:56

In theory the idea is good ...free up doctors time ...I had an excellent experience with a PA at my GP surgery when I found a lump in my breast (subsequently have had all clear from breast clinic)...all the initial appointment required was someone to confirm they could feel a lump and follow the referral procedure (which is exactly what was done by the PA) ...meant I could see someone fast than waiting for a doctor or nurse appointment and freed up their time ...she also checked my blood pressure and noted it seemed a little high ...I explained I suffer from white coat syndrome and was arranged a loan blood pressure machine to record twice a day for a week (which also turned out fine)

However the issues come when as detailed in this thread the boundaries of the role are blurred and either the PA oversteps their competencies and/or they are given tasks that should fall outside their role ...this combined with lack of regulation is a disaster waiting to happen.

Charliebrow · 02/10/2023 14:55

Are the patients there for her benefit; or is she there for the patients benefit?

vivainsomnia · 02/10/2023 14:55

I hate posts when people shout horror about something they clearly know nothing about.

PA take on the jobs of doctors that PA are capable of doing and do not require the skills and experience of doctors. They usually follow up patients after they've had treatment.

Most importantly, the overall care and responsibility of patients remain with the consultant. Consultants supervise all PAs and the work they do. They do a fantastic job and are a very good addition to the team.

But you must be right, let's instead keep looking for consultants that don't exist and allow waiting lists to grow whilst patients deteriorate and die in between.

You and similar uneducated about medical care know better than anyone else!

jenpil · 02/10/2023 14:52

PerfectMatch · 02/10/2023 13:27

Agree with @Meloncocomelon . The NHS can't cope with the ageing population. We need to stop expecting healthcare to be free and start looking into ways of it being part funded (like many European countries already do).

But our NHS healthcare isn't free..... we pay for it !

ncob · 02/10/2023 14:47

Worddance · 02/10/2023 13:54

Why do you sound like such a patronising know it all? I wouldn't want someone with your manner and outlook as my doctor in a million years.

I have no idea, but luckily for you that won't happen as I don't work that sector.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 02/10/2023 14:39

jlpth · 02/10/2023 13:48

I've known for a long time that my dog gets far, far superior healthcare to me or my children.

Having had the misfortune to deal with my local fracture clinic (virtual so they don't have to bother seeing anyone) I'd rather be seen by my cat's vets. At least they seem to have an idea of what they're doing unlike the doctors

Meloncocomelon · 02/10/2023 14:32

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 02/10/2023 14:24

I've known for a long time that my dog gets far, far superior healthcare to me or my children.

Yes, same. But that’s because we pay a lot for our dogs’ healthcare!

Exactly, you pay for it. Huge amounts of money usually which a lot of people don't think equates to human healthcare but it does, the person just doesn't get a bill so they can see the cost of what they've used.

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 02/10/2023 14:24

I've known for a long time that my dog gets far, far superior healthcare to me or my children.

Yes, same. But that’s because we pay a lot for our dogs’ healthcare!

Meloncocomelon · 02/10/2023 14:08

Pugfin · 02/10/2023 13:47

And yet neither of those are PAs to whom OP was referring to...

But they are included in OPS post

"YANBU - Medcial care should be performed by someone with a medical degree and relevant post graduate training and exams, ie a Doctor"

If the highly qualified and experienced professionals I'm referring to don't have a medical degree and are not I.e a Doctor then that's who OP is including in their post and wanting people to vote for or against.

Which is why my post is entirely relevant.

Swipe left for the next trending thread