Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should you get home insurance and how much do you pay?

88 replies

ncob · 02/10/2023 10:06

FTB, new home-owner. Seems like theres endless costs. Erring towards getting home insurance but have almost nothing of value at the moment (need to buy furniture etc, currently just have odd bits donated by friends/family to get by until I furnish the place). I guess I should just get buildings insurance? (and not contents)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tryingtokeepgoing · 02/10/2023 16:54

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 02/10/2023 10:25

It isn't just about theft. It is about fire and flood too.

If your house flooded and you needed to throw out all your carpets and flooring, all electricals, all kitchen units, all furniture on the ground floor and redecorate could you afford this or would you be glad of insurance?

Even replacing cheap secondhand stuff mounts up quickly. I have had to deal with people who have houses full of a few feet of muddy water despite not living near a river and no insurance to cover it. They are devastated and desperate. Contents insurance is worthwhile even if you don't have stuff worth nicking.

Not that it's an argument to skip contents cover, which is usually pretty cheap in the great scheme of things, but fitted kitchens and bathrooms are generally covered under the 'buildings' part of the policy, not contents. Flooring however is contents!

If money is tight, I'd select the most basic contents cover I could find, and not have accidental damage cover or cover for things outside the home, or for stuff in sheds/garages. That's what I have for my place in the Cotswolds, and it's under £100 a year.

StowOnTheWold · 02/10/2023 16:45

There is a saying that one should only insure against calamitous losses. Most people insure their house because if it is destroyed they need funds to rebuild it. For the same reason, mortgagees will require it so it becomes contractual.

Otherwise, it is not compulsory. I know of people who have zero insurance on their homes. Contents insurance follows the same rules. If the contents of your home are worth £1,000 is there really a need to insure? Similarly, if someone is rich and can replace £100,000 of contents from proverbial loose change down the back of their proverbial sofa do they really need to insure?

The real test is whether, in the absence of a legal requirement, it would be calamitous if you suffer an otherwise insurable loss. If so then insure. If there is no foreseeable calamity, save the money.

AllyCart · 02/10/2023 16:31

@FarmGirl78

Ignore the poster who said about paying a fiver, that was just for contents as her son rented so it's s red herring.

That's rather rude. The OP already said she's looking at just getting buildings insurance and is asking whether she needs contents cover too, so the person posting about the cheap content cover for her son was absolutely relevant.

There's always someone on MN telling people to ignore other posts. It's they who should be ignored.

PinotPony · 02/10/2023 13:45

Your mortgage lender will insist that you have buildings insurance to cover the risk of the building being destroyed.

You should get contents insurance even you don't have much in the way of furnishings. If the house burnt to the ground could you afford to replace all your clothes, toiletries, the carpets, curtains, white goods?

Standard cover for buildings and contents covers risks such as fire, theft, flood, storm. You should have that as a minimum.

Accidental damage does what it says on the tin. Spillages, dropped items, balls through windows...

FusionChefGeoff · 02/10/2023 13:40

Contents is also carpets / flooring etc which would cost a lot of money in a flood. Even a small fire is likely to damage beyond repair due to water from fire hoses.

OldTinHat · 02/10/2023 13:35

Try combined. I have good cover for £20 a month (pay by direct debit so it will be cheaper if you pay upfront).

woodentrunk · 02/10/2023 13:35

I don't have loads of valuable stuff but I just got a quote for £30,000 worth of cover and it's £7 a month. That also includes two pieces of high value jewellery that I wear outside of the house.

Your house insurance can cover things like bikes, wedding rings etc or accidental damage. Ultimately up to you but I think if a house burned down, it'd be good to know there was at least something in place to help replace the basics.

Clarinet1 · 02/10/2023 13:34

Just a thought - you are not quite clear whether you are buying a house (freehold) or a flat (leasehold). In the case of a leasehold property, including share of freehold, the service charge will include a contribution to the building insurance so you only need contents cover.

As PP have said, this will often include cover for personal items outside the home such as phone, laptop, even possibly cash. If you are concerned about paying the premium of maybe £20 per month, how are you going to find the money to replace those in a hurry? Also, I once woke up to a leak from two floors above me which damaged the walls and carpet. Insurance covered the remedial works including new carpet throughout most of the flat because it had all matched and also a dehumidifier.

Incidentally, in case you haven’t realised, most providers allow you to pay by monthly direct debit so it becomes easier to budget for.

Also, you say you don’t have much at the moment but, realistically, how often are you going to take the time to review what the value of the contents is?

skyeisthelimit · 02/10/2023 13:31

OP, imagine that there is a fire and you lose every single thing in your house.

Write down a list of your belongings, doing each room in turn. This includes everything in that room, so clothes, shoes, jewellery, electronics, gadgets, personal belongings, all furniture, all bathroom and kitchen equipment. Also, carpets, curtains etc.

Could you afford to replace everything if you lost it all?

Make sure that you don't under insure either. We had contents insured for £25K and when an assessor came to look at the roof after a storm, after he had walked through the house, he said, I think you should up your contents cover. We do not own expensive items, this was just standard Argos type furniture.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 02/10/2023 13:29

OP, if you don't get Buildings Insurance and a fire rips through the house and burns it down, how do you plan on repaying the bank for the mortgage on it and still fund somewhere else to live, and the repairs/demo/rebuild?

£200pa is a tiny amount to pay to take care of all the above and make sure you always have a home worth money.

User174085934 · 02/10/2023 13:29

Are you a cash buyer, hence no buildings insurance already, unless the house is huge, unusual or on a flood plain you should be able to get a basic insurance quite cheaply and as PP says go through a cashback website

BooksAndHooks · 02/10/2023 13:15

If you buy the insurance via Quidco you can get a good amount of cash back, I think I got £38 back on each policy this year.

I would never not have contents. Even if you have cheap stuff could you honestly afford to replace every single item you own?

We pay around £30 a month but that is the most comprehensive cover we could get, with added legal, accidental damage etc, items covered outside the home. You can get much cheaper than that if you want basic cover.

myusernamewastakenbyme · 02/10/2023 13:08

Im mortgage free and have buildings insurance only...costs me about £100 a year....I have no contents of any significant value and as ive never made a claim in my life on any insurance policy its a risk im happy to take.

Nat6999 · 02/10/2023 13:06

I pay less than £4 a week for £50k cover on contents with accidental damage & freezer cover. It gives me peace of mind.

User174085934 · 02/10/2023 13:02

About £300 for Lloyds premium insurance for 4 bed detached house, I prefer to pay a bit more and have everything covered, we also added high out of the home cover and have 4 expensive bikes to include, often cheaper insurance is quite basic.

loislovesstewie · 02/10/2023 12:55

Of course you need buildings and contents insurance. If you have a mortgage you will have to take out buildings insurance, remember if you have neighbours if their house goes up in smoke/floods/whatever then yours could also be damaged, and if that happens then your belongings could also be damaged or ruined. I get it that you might never make a claim ,but if the worst happens....! And be honest in your dealings with the insurance company as failure to be honest might invalidate any claim.

Goldmember · 02/10/2023 12:41

We pay around £200per year for buildings and contents. We include outbuildings for theft from shed, lawnmower and tools etc also accidental damage in the home but we don't have expensive bikes to cover or cover for away from home.

Like you, we don't have overly expensive items but it does really add up when you claim.

For example, our first claim was a hot water leak from our washing machine, must have been a mouse nibble through the pipe. Not only all the carpets were ruined but also the wallpaper was steamed off due to hot water leak.

When we were burgled, it was probably only £5k claim due to cheap ish items but it was a lot of items gone in one go that needed to be replaced.

PurpleBananaSmoothie · 02/10/2023 12:33

Have you completed the purchase of the house? You need to have building insurance from exchange because you are liable for costs from that moment. It’s like car insurance, it’s not an optional nice to have.

Buildings insurance is the cost of something happens to your house to rebuild it, you will still owe the amount on your mortgage. You will still be paying your mortgage so where would you find the funds to rent a new place or rebuild your home? It covers you for flood and fire but it also covers you if someone drunkenly drives into your front room, a tree falls on your roof, the property is subject to subsidence.

Contents does push up the premium but I would argue it’s also essential. It’s not about the quality of those things but it’s if you have to replace those all in one go. So if your home had a fire, the fire might be relatively well contained to the back of the house but you’ll likely still have smoke and water damage throughout. You’ll be paying for a new kitchen to be put in, buying new plates, new pans, new washing machine, new fridge, new towels, new bedding, replacing your wardrobe, replacing your couch, your desk, the beds, the curtains, rugs, new flooring. You’ll be replacing your pictures on the wall. You might be replacing a bike, depending on where it is stored, your lawnmower. Even things you wouldn’t think of like the ironing board and iron. You’ve been given some stuff because people have those to hand but people won’t have an entire house and wardrobe to hand. If you need to buy these new, how much would it cost you to replace everything in your house?

wildwestpioneer · 02/10/2023 12:32

Insurance is only worth having if you need to claim on it.

I had a water pipe burst and needed about 13k worth of buildings and contents replaced. The buildings covered the ceiling and decoration, but contents covered things like floorings, sofa etc.

I've had buildings and contents insurance for about 35 years. I pay about £500 a year, ans made maybe 3 claims during that time which amount to about what I've paid in premiums - so I'm even stevens.

Thelittleweasel · 02/10/2023 12:31

@ncob

Get quotes. Buildings insurance is absolutely vital; adding contents may add little. Our modern 3-bed house, reasonable area, reasonably new with traditional contents - nothing luxurious [!] costs just over £100 per year at present

ThinWomansBrain · 02/10/2023 12:31

a few years ago when I used to switch insurers regularly, I checked my contents insurance when there were riots in London to see what was covered - only to find it had lapsed, I was horrified.

I also (a few years later) had a huge claim because of flood damage from the apartment upstairs. No major issues with getting it settled, but there was some hassle between what was contents and what was buildings insurance (as its a leasehold apartment, buildings is arranged centrally by the managing agent.)

If I hadn't had contents insurance, I do wonder whether the buildings insurance would have been more difficult on what was/wasn't covered.

the usual criteria is if it's fitted, it's buildings, the to and fro-ing was mostly over electric curtain tracks.

Floralnomad · 02/10/2023 12:28

My buildings and contents was about £220 , renewed in April . That’s on Churchills top policy for a large 4 bed detached in the SE .

Amba1998 · 02/10/2023 12:26

Also please tell me you haven’t already moved in without this?! What if you have a fire tonight!!!

Amba1998 · 02/10/2023 12:25

Couldn’t imagine only getting building. If there’s a serious fire you have to re do all your carpets tiles decorating kitchen bathroom fittings furniture all your clothes literally every possession you own. That could be £100k

Loverofoxbowlakes · 02/10/2023 12:22

Have you already moved in?

Do you have a mortgage?

As pp said, having building insurance is a condition of every mortgage I've ever had, and compulsory from exchange.

Contents is optional, really depends on your attitude to risk.

One of my neighbours house was struck by lightning and there was a huge fire. What didn't get burned was destroyed by water damage, they had to replace everything and we're out of their home for 16 months until it was rebuilt/decorated. £25 a month I think is a very small price to pay.