Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

As a man, should I post on MN

317 replies

Dadfromthesea · 02/10/2023 10:03

I love the MN forums. More often than not I just read them, as they’re useful from a parenting point of view and often very funny to boot. I occasionally comment. I’ve started one thread ever, before this one.

Saw a thread this morning about a perceived rise in ‘women hating’ men posting on here. I’m definitely not one of those, and would be mortified to come across as one. But before long the thread started talking about men in general, and whether or not they should be posting at all on a forum called Mumsnet that’s predominantly aimed at women.

I get the need for women-only spaces, and would hate to intrude on one unintentionally.

So as a man, as a dad, am I being unreasonable by posting on Mumsnet? If the consensus is that I am, then I’ll stop.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Rubyruby2222 · 03/10/2023 10:05

KidneyWarrior · 03/10/2023 09:08

@CurlewKate I think it's more balanced to hear differing viewpoints from different demographics. I'm a white, middle class, 40 year old lady - if I just hear viewpoints from other people exactly like myself, for me that just becomes an echo chamber. I like to hear from people who come at things from a different background as it gives a wider view.

Edited

If a "balanced view" means men's views in a women's group it's no longer a women's group.

It is then the same as Reddit, Twitter, Facebook etc.

(I don't feel strongly either way, but the points raised in this thread have given me food for thought).

KidneyWarrior · 03/10/2023 10:04

@CurlewKate that makes sense too, tbh - I guess we're all here for different reasons x

TotalOverhaul · 03/10/2023 10:02

You're fine to post on here these days.

Years ago, I would have said it's for mums i.e. women who have or raise children. But it's not now. It's a general, worldwide forum for anyone, with a big bias towards parenting, but loads of other corners.

It's good to have all views. i don't think echo chambers are healthy.

StephanieSuperpowers · 03/10/2023 10:00

KidneyWarrior · 03/10/2023 09:08

@CurlewKate I think it's more balanced to hear differing viewpoints from different demographics. I'm a white, middle class, 40 year old lady - if I just hear viewpoints from other people exactly like myself, for me that just becomes an echo chamber. I like to hear from people who come at things from a different background as it gives a wider view.

Edited

Not to disagree entirely, but overall, aren't we kind of inundated with men's opinions in general? I'd personally like to hear viewpoints from other women.

Aerin1999 · 03/10/2023 09:59

beastlyslumber · 03/10/2023 09:57

Personally I come to MN to listen and talk with other women.

The fact that you've posted for reassurance and validation - and got it in spades - is a bit sick making, imo. One of the things I love about MN is that usually the women here are great at picking out when someone is being self-serving, and have no fear about calling them on it. Okay, sometimes it can be a bit mean, but it creates a culture in which we don't have 'stars' or posters who can't be challenged or subjects that can't be talked about. It keeps egos in check and everyone a bit more down to earth.

Then a man turns up and half of MN swoons and rushes to give validation and support.

Imagine if a woman had posted this. Comments would be along the lines of "attention-seeking much, OP?" and "Why do you need so much reassurance? Are you always this needy?" and "Is this a TAAT? Reported."

Agree. And no less than five times I have engaged with a thread, where we are all meant to fell safe, only to then receive lecherous PMs from various posters afterwards. I had no clue they were men.

HeatherMoores · 03/10/2023 09:58

I value that it is primarily a female space and hope it stays that way. It’s a good place for sensible safe intelligent advice informed by life experience and thought provoking opinions etc. Not coloured by male bias. I don’t mind the odd man here (how gracious lol) mumsnet describe it as by parents for parents, if they wanted it women only surely they’d describe it as by mums, for mums?

I enjoyed OP’s other thread and did think it was a woman at first, but I agree it became a bit self-congratulatory overdone quips towards the end.

beastlyslumber · 03/10/2023 09:57

Personally I come to MN to listen and talk with other women.

The fact that you've posted for reassurance and validation - and got it in spades - is a bit sick making, imo. One of the things I love about MN is that usually the women here are great at picking out when someone is being self-serving, and have no fear about calling them on it. Okay, sometimes it can be a bit mean, but it creates a culture in which we don't have 'stars' or posters who can't be challenged or subjects that can't be talked about. It keeps egos in check and everyone a bit more down to earth.

Then a man turns up and half of MN swoons and rushes to give validation and support.

Imagine if a woman had posted this. Comments would be along the lines of "attention-seeking much, OP?" and "Why do you need so much reassurance? Are you always this needy?" and "Is this a TAAT? Reported."

FluffyCatBonzo · 03/10/2023 09:55

There is no point in reading any of the blurb either as that can't even get beyond the idea of Gender .

If it doesn't sound too pompous we think the concept of “mumming/mothering” goes beyond gender so don't feel Mumsnet is too exclusive.

ilovemydogmore · 03/10/2023 09:53

Tavernatess · 03/10/2023 09:44

@ilovemydogmore you literally put ‘I wouldn't dream of joining a site for dads and start sharing my opinions 'as a mum'. It's a very male thing to do to be honest.’

thats not what men are doing by posting on MN. As it’s not for mums.

Then why in the fuck is it called mumsnet

Tavernatess · 03/10/2023 09:44

@ilovemydogmore you literally put ‘I wouldn't dream of joining a site for dads and start sharing my opinions 'as a mum'. It's a very male thing to do to be honest.’

thats not what men are doing by posting on MN. As it’s not for mums.

ilovemydogmore · 03/10/2023 09:41

Tavernatess · 03/10/2023 09:33

@ilovemydogmore but it’s not a forum for women

its for parents

your issue is you’ve wrongly assumed otherwise

I don't have an issue I'm just sharing my opinion. I don't really engage in posts from men

5128gap · 03/10/2023 09:40

PoseasRadicalActuallyMisogynistic · 03/10/2023 08:50

I come here to get away from hearing men’s viewpoints. Honestly IRL they are always happy to pontificate and advise.

Agree. There are women on here from literally every demographic you could wish for. Huge variety of ages, ethnicities, social backgrounds, beliefs, attitudes, political persuasions. I struggle to see what a man could add to that just by virtue of his sex.
Plus 'As a man...' is largely meaningless given that just like women, a man will be speaking from a perspective informed by his own life stage personality and circumstances, so gives no great insight into 'men' as a whole.
There may be some shared characteristics, but just because Bryan from Slough didnt change nappies because he felt overwhelmed by the responsibility of fatherhood, doesnt mean Steve from Sidmouth isnt an idle wastrel who'd rather be in the pub.

Tavernatess · 03/10/2023 09:33

@ilovemydogmore but it’s not a forum for women

its for parents

your issue is you’ve wrongly assumed otherwise

CurlewKate · 03/10/2023 09:31

@KidneyWarrior Fair enough. Personally I think it's so difficult to AVOID the male viewpoint on practically everything that Mumsnet is a refreshing change.

AuntieStella · 03/10/2023 09:21

SoundingGood · 03/10/2023 08:34

How is the OP afraid to post on Mumsnet?
He has started 2 threads in as many days!

Exactly. He's not scared to post.

He posting away quite happily but that's not enough for this man. He needs to know he's very wanted here which is why he's posted this. He needs to stand out, he needs to be noticed and feel important. Unlike the women here that just get on with posting.

I see certain women are like a moth to a flame.

🙄

And further to my last...

Posting, by contributing to or starting threads, is fine. As is wanting to know if XYZ is OK here (learning how the community works by asking)

Repeatedly asking the same thing is getting a bit dick-ish

Wanting validation is not just a male trait though - women can be just as dogged in seeking validation, so MN is stuffed with it (for their appearance, their parenting, their work relationships, their housekeeping standards, their ILs)

AuntieStella · 03/10/2023 09:16

Having a dick = fine
Being a dick = not fine

WearyAuldWumman · 03/10/2023 09:13

I worried about commenting on here because I'm not actually a mum, unfortunately. (I'm an oldish widow.)

Your other thread gave me the courage to comment and also cheered me up a great deal.

SallyWD · 03/10/2023 09:10

KidneyWarrior · 03/10/2023 09:08

@CurlewKate I think it's more balanced to hear differing viewpoints from different demographics. I'm a white, middle class, 40 year old lady - if I just hear viewpoints from other people exactly like myself, for me that just becomes an echo chamber. I like to hear from people who come at things from a different background as it gives a wider view.

Edited

I agree with this 100%.

KidneyWarrior · 03/10/2023 09:08

@CurlewKate I think it's more balanced to hear differing viewpoints from different demographics. I'm a white, middle class, 40 year old lady - if I just hear viewpoints from other people exactly like myself, for me that just becomes an echo chamber. I like to hear from people who come at things from a different background as it gives a wider view.

Rubyruby2222 · 03/10/2023 08:56

Some really interesting points in this thread. I didn't think men posting was a problem but the comments have completely changed my mind.

The "male feminists" and "I'm one of the good guys" are always a bit 😬

Someone below stating that he changes his username to something neutral "so as not to distract" is also a bit 😬

PoseasRadicalActuallyMisogynistic · 03/10/2023 08:50

KidneyWarrior · 03/10/2023 08:21

I really welcome a man's viewpoint, so I'm glad you're here 🙂

I come here to get away from hearing men’s viewpoints. Honestly IRL they are always happy to pontificate and advise.

CurlewKate · 03/10/2023 08:43

@KidneyWarrior
"I really welcome a man's viewpoint, so I'm glad you're here"

Can I ask-genuine question, as they say-why?

MNetcurtains · 03/10/2023 08:42

I'd say you have more right to be here than I. At least you're a parent😬

FluffyCatBonzo · 03/10/2023 08:38

I noticed a guy posting all over the place yesterday and I did think why.. there seems to have been a rash of them lately.

SoundingGood · 03/10/2023 08:34

How is the OP afraid to post on Mumsnet?
He has started 2 threads in as many days!

Exactly. He's not scared to post.

He posting away quite happily but that's not enough for this man. He needs to know he's very wanted here which is why he's posted this. He needs to stand out, he needs to be noticed and feel important. Unlike the women here that just get on with posting.

I see certain women are like a moth to a flame.

🙄

Swipe left for the next trending thread