Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

As a man, should I post on MN

317 replies

Dadfromthesea · 02/10/2023 10:03

I love the MN forums. More often than not I just read them, as they’re useful from a parenting point of view and often very funny to boot. I occasionally comment. I’ve started one thread ever, before this one.

Saw a thread this morning about a perceived rise in ‘women hating’ men posting on here. I’m definitely not one of those, and would be mortified to come across as one. But before long the thread started talking about men in general, and whether or not they should be posting at all on a forum called Mumsnet that’s predominantly aimed at women.

I get the need for women-only spaces, and would hate to intrude on one unintentionally.

So as a man, as a dad, am I being unreasonable by posting on Mumsnet? If the consensus is that I am, then I’ll stop.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
ErrolTheDragon · 03/10/2023 14:38
  • My first post was me suggesting to the OP that it might be wise to hide his sex. I stand by that advice.*

The OPs first thread, in which he didn't hide his sex, went absolutely fine. Of course, it wasn't a sensitive subject where sex might be expected to be relevant.

I don't agree with
I think it's clear that most decent men wouldn't dream of posting on MN in any capacity.

But there are definitely some threads where a decent man wouldn't dream of posting, and many where anyone with an ounce of emotional intelligence would know that doing so without being transparent about his sex would be problematic (to put it mildly)

MatchingPendants · 03/10/2023 14:30

Thank fuck for that.

Although soon to pop up in threads as a 'woman'. 🤮

Pretendordrown · 03/10/2023 14:25

DeeCeeCherry · 03/10/2023 14:04

Pretendordrown spraying all over thread is a classic example of why its never wise to engage with men here. Arguing with women online/wanting input into womens' conversations🚩🚩🚩. Leave it to the fangirls to dialogue, although they seem a bit quieter just at the moment...

When I am openly male on MN all sorts of grief follows. When I'm not it doesn't.

My first post was me suggesting to the OP that it might be wise to hide his sex.
I stand by that advice.

Anyway, good luck OP. I've had enough of being a man, far too stressful. I'm out.

Rubyruby2222 · 03/10/2023 14:10

@Pretendordrown
I think that anyone that might have been sitting on the fence about the OP's question, will have been persuaded by your input so far!

MatchingPendants · 03/10/2023 14:08

🚩 is the perfect emoji for posters like that. I think they're best ignored as they seem to thrive on arguing with women and getting attention. Something very off.

Pretendordrown · 03/10/2023 14:04

beastlyslumber · 03/10/2023 13:49

Thank you for showing how you twisted my words to suit your narrative. Saved me the bother.

How I had to twist your words.

You said: I think it's clear that most decent men wouldn't dream of posting on MN in any capacity.

I said, according to you, I post on MN therefore I can't be a decent man.

In effect I replaced your 'most' men with 'all' men. How I twisted your words. What a bullshitter I am.

DeeCeeCherry · 03/10/2023 14:04

Pretendordrown spraying all over thread is a classic example of why its never wise to engage with men here. Arguing with women online/wanting input into womens' conversations🚩🚩🚩. Leave it to the fangirls to dialogue, although they seem a bit quieter just at the moment...

Rubyruby2222 · 03/10/2023 14:03

Pretendordrown · 03/10/2023 13:33

Thank you for also proving my point.

You ask why I hide that I am a man, but I have already explained why I do it. I initially gave 2 reasons. The first being I received gratuitous abuse and the second that I thought my points were often discounted. You have confirmed that because you have to ask about something I have already explained. If you thought I was a woman you at least would have read and understood what I said before disagreeing with it.

I didn't say that only men were called liars. I said I was abused by being accused of lying. Being wrongly accused of lying is abusive. In the many posts I have made when my sex is assumed to be female, that has never happened to me. I am often disagreed with, but never have I been accused of making something up.

*"I'm a man therefore, I'm a liar. I post on MN therefore I can't be a decent man."
*
Also you accused the poster of calling you a liar because you are a man.

You clearly have a real chip on your shoulder with women. Why do you go to such lengths to be in a predominantly female chat group?

ErrolTheDragon · 03/10/2023 13:57

@Pretendordrown - if you think you're being abused, have you reported such posts to MNHQ?

MatchingPendants · 03/10/2023 13:54

@Pretendordrown I can see why your posts have been ignored in the past.

beastlyslumber · 03/10/2023 13:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Thank you for showing how you twisted my words to suit your narrative. Saved me the bother.

Pretendordrown · 03/10/2023 13:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ErrolTheDragon · 03/10/2023 13:44

@Pretendordrown
Do you understand that there are some topics where a woman may post assuming (rightly or wrongly) that posters are female - because although this is not a women's only site it is, unusually vs the rest of the web 'default female'. And on such threads, they may feel very betrayed if they do subsequently realise that someone engaging on the thread is a man?

This is why, in general, some of us find it preferable for there to be some clue if a poster is male.

A 'decent man' will hopefully have some idea as to whether a topic is one where it'd be better for him to stay out of.

beastlyslumber · 03/10/2023 13:40

Mate, if you can't cope with women calling you out on your bullshit, don't post on MN. I don't think there's a poster on here who hasn't had their arse handed to them at some point. If you find that 'abusive' this is not the place for you.

And by the way, claiming to be the victim of "abuse" because someone called you out after you admitted that you lie about your sex and pretend to be a woman is actually offensive.

Edited to add: this is in response to @Pretendordrown

maybewhoknows · 03/10/2023 13:38

Of course post - whoever you are. It's the internet! Why some women seem to think they own the internet, I've no idea.

Rubyruby2222 · 03/10/2023 13:37

Pretendordrown · 03/10/2023 13:33

Thank you for also proving my point.

You ask why I hide that I am a man, but I have already explained why I do it. I initially gave 2 reasons. The first being I received gratuitous abuse and the second that I thought my points were often discounted. You have confirmed that because you have to ask about something I have already explained. If you thought I was a woman you at least would have read and understood what I said before disagreeing with it.

I didn't say that only men were called liars. I said I was abused by being accused of lying. Being wrongly accused of lying is abusive. In the many posts I have made when my sex is assumed to be female, that has never happened to me. I am often disagreed with, but never have I been accused of making something up.

Maybe I should have been clearer.

Do you think women are allowed boundaries?

Do you think it's acceptable to breach those boundaries by deception?

Pretendordrown · 03/10/2023 13:33

Thank you for also proving my point.

You ask why I hide that I am a man, but I have already explained why I do it. I initially gave 2 reasons. The first being I received gratuitous abuse and the second that I thought my points were often discounted. You have confirmed that because you have to ask about something I have already explained. If you thought I was a woman you at least would have read and understood what I said before disagreeing with it.

I didn't say that only men were called liars. I said I was abused by being accused of lying. Being wrongly accused of lying is abusive. In the many posts I have made when my sex is assumed to be female, that has never happened to me. I am often disagreed with, but never have I been accused of making something up.

OneTC · 03/10/2023 13:31

I personally see Mumsnet as being quite separate to AIBU, which is just a funny site where there's some interesting debates and genuinely funny posters. I do read FWR and some other boards but don't post there. If there was any other site that was as busy and interesting (with old school formatting) I'd probably post there

beastlyslumber · 03/10/2023 13:22

I'm a man therefore, I'm a liar. I post on MN therefore I can't be a decent man.

I didn't say any of that. You're making shit up. Is this what you mean by "gratuitous abuse" - women calling out your bullshit and you then pretending they've said something they haven't?

Rubyruby2222 · 03/10/2023 13:22

@Pretendordrown

*Bingo. You just proved my point.

I'm a man therefore, I'm a liar. I post on MN therefore I can't be a decent man.

If I want my views listened to rather than filed in the bin that never happened, I have to hide my gender/sex. You couldn't make it up.*

Erm... no, the point isn't made at all. Do you think women on here aren't accused of being liars?

Why do you deceive people online by hiding that you are a man?

ErrolTheDragon · 03/10/2023 13:20

If I want my views listened to rather than filed in the bin that never happened, I have to hide my gender/sex. You couldn't make it up.

Do you think women don't know all about what you experienced? ConfusedLet's just edit what you said ..

I found that when I openly posted as a woman not only did I receive quite a lot gratuitous abuse but I also felt that my post was often discounted. Say the same things without revealing your gender and Reddit/Twitter/etc/etc usually takes your point more seriously.

I actually think it's quite good for blokes to be exposed to the experience of being 'the second sex', 'the other' - hopefully at least some will reflect on this.

Pretendordrown · 03/10/2023 13:16

beastlyslumber · 03/10/2023 13:10

"Gratuitous abuse" just for being a man, eh? I think I'm going to file that in the Never Happened bin.

As for pretending to be a woman - that's gross, but it does seem to be what many men do. Post in sex or relationships pretending to be female while gaslighting and victim blaming or leching on the posters.

I think it's clear that most decent men wouldn't dream of posting on MN in any capacity. And we have every right to be suspicious or disdainful of those men who pretend to be women on here.

Bingo. You just proved my point.

I'm a man therefore, I'm a liar. I post on MN therefore I can't be a decent man.

If I want my views listened to rather than filed in the bin that never happened, I have to hide my gender/sex. You couldn't make it up.

Rubyruby2222 · 03/10/2023 13:13

Pretendordrown · 03/10/2023 13:04

Assuming you decide to post, whether to be openly male is tricky.

I found that when I openly posted as a man not only did I receive quite a lot gratuitous abuse but I also felt that my post was often discounted. Say the same things without revealing your gender and MN usually takes your point more seriously.
When considering the feelings of the women who don't want men here, if they don't know you are a man and you are being polite and considered then it is pretty difficult for them to be discomforted.

I'm confused why you would want to post in a place in which you felt you needed to deceive the other posters in to being taken seriously?

beastlyslumber · 03/10/2023 13:10

Pretendordrown · 03/10/2023 13:04

Assuming you decide to post, whether to be openly male is tricky.

I found that when I openly posted as a man not only did I receive quite a lot gratuitous abuse but I also felt that my post was often discounted. Say the same things without revealing your gender and MN usually takes your point more seriously.
When considering the feelings of the women who don't want men here, if they don't know you are a man and you are being polite and considered then it is pretty difficult for them to be discomforted.

"Gratuitous abuse" just for being a man, eh? I think I'm going to file that in the Never Happened bin.

As for pretending to be a woman - that's gross, but it does seem to be what many men do. Post in sex or relationships pretending to be female while gaslighting and victim blaming or leching on the posters.

I think it's clear that most decent men wouldn't dream of posting on MN in any capacity. And we have every right to be suspicious or disdainful of those men who pretend to be women on here.

ErrolTheDragon · 03/10/2023 13:05

Finlesswonder · 03/10/2023 12:59

@ErrolTheDragon
I'm not interested in how it started out, I'm interested in present-day facts, and as of 2022, 90% of users were women.

And the present day fact is that the site is still open to anyone who can post within guidelines.

I'm delighted it's very much a majority women's site, that men are allowed but haven't taken over.

I'd be delighted if there was also a site that really was just for women, but whether we like it or not, MN isn't it.