Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or is mumsnet slowly being infiltrated by women hating men.

306 replies

NotSuchASmugMarried · 02/10/2023 08:20

Am I imagining things or is it getting worse here. Every single time we post something a poster will immediately pop up and hijack the thread with a pro-men agenda instead of actually contributing to the thread.

Please tell me if you agree. I can't possibly be the only one who thinks this.

OP posts:
TheLongGloriesOfTheWinterMoon · 02/10/2023 11:44

Kemper · 02/10/2023 09:25

Perhaps you should. As a man he is more than twice as likely to get murdered.

Not by his partner he isn't.

5128gap · 02/10/2023 11:29

Defiantjazz · 02/10/2023 10:45

Because I don't think the OP thinks that women expressing opinions that conflict with the stereotypical ideas of womanhood are men.
I think she's referring to posters who misrepresent facts to minimise male bad behaviours and malign women. Who divert discussions where women are sharing and supporting each other with issues arising from male behaviour, to centre, excuse and portray men as victims.

Can you (or the OP if she can be arsed) give some examples of this?

As a PP has already suggested, look at any of the threads about Russell Brand for examples of the first.
The most recent and fresh in my mind example of the second is the 'is it mostly men?' thread which at one point had posters making false comparisons with racism to discredit women criticising men. Conveniently ignoring that anyone with the most rudimentary undertanding of the role of power means one cannot simply substitute 'people of colour' for 'men'.
Whether they did this because their understanding is genuinely very limited, or deliberately to sabotage the thread, the result was to divert women from the topic in hand to defend themselves from accusations of prejudice and discrimination against men. Once again centring men's feelings, and presenting them as victims akin to POC experiencing racism.

Thepeopleversuswork · 02/10/2023 11:20

@Potiphar

So…you’re right and anyone who thinks differently is wrong?
Does that sum it up succinctly?

Well, if you want to put it like that, yes. Believing your opinion is correct and expressing why you believe that to be the case is pretty much a textbook definition of having a debate.

Why would you bother arguing for something you didn't believe to be correct?

As I've already said, I'm perfectly content for people to believe that these things are in their best interests if it makes them happy but I'm not going to argue that their opinion is as valid as mine. Life is too short for me to give a "all must have prizes" approach to people's views in a debate when it's something I care strongly about and I believe they are wrong.

Potiphar · 02/10/2023 11:00

Thepeopleversuswork · 02/10/2023 10:51

@Potiphar

Isn’t it a bit insulting to suggest that these things must be down to “internalised misogyny” rather than someone’s genuine opinion? Some people have different options.

btw I think it’s fine to think the pay gap isn’t a big deal, that a women’s place is in the home, and that a woman going to work risks damaging her children.

I really don't think it's "fine" to think a man should be paid more than a woman purely by virtue of the fact that he has a penis or that a woman's place is automatically always in the home, no. And I find it extremely offensive that people think a woman who is forced to work to support her children is damaging those children by doing so.

To me those beliefs/postures are so self-evidently self destructive to a woman's agency or financial independence and welfare that any woman who believes this either lacks the critical faculties to understand why that's self destructive or has taken on board a lot of rhetoric which has persuaded her these are in her best interests when they are not. They are irrational and demonstrably damaging positions.

The fact that it's a "genuine opinion" doesn't mean it's not a wrong opinion. I'm sure women who have convinced themselves that its better for other women not to work genuinely believe this. But their "genuine opinion" is not rooted in evidence, not rational and not in the broader interest of either themselves or other women.

Some people do indeed have different opinions and they are welcome to them. Some people believe the earth is flat. That doesn't mean those opinions are equally valid, well thought through and rational. If that's insulting, so be it, I'm not overly troubled by insulting people without critical skills.

So…you’re right and anyone who thinks differently is wrong?
Does that sum it up succinctly?

EarthlyNightshade · 02/10/2023 10:52

Defiantjazz · 02/10/2023 10:45

Because I don't think the OP thinks that women expressing opinions that conflict with the stereotypical ideas of womanhood are men.
I think she's referring to posters who misrepresent facts to minimise male bad behaviours and malign women. Who divert discussions where women are sharing and supporting each other with issues arising from male behaviour, to centre, excuse and portray men as victims.

Can you (or the OP if she can be arsed) give some examples of this?

There's some at the start of this thread talking about male on male violence.

Thepeopleversuswork · 02/10/2023 10:51

@Potiphar

Isn’t it a bit insulting to suggest that these things must be down to “internalised misogyny” rather than someone’s genuine opinion? Some people have different options.

btw I think it’s fine to think the pay gap isn’t a big deal, that a women’s place is in the home, and that a woman going to work risks damaging her children.

I really don't think it's "fine" to think a man should be paid more than a woman purely by virtue of the fact that he has a penis or that a woman's place is automatically always in the home, no. And I find it extremely offensive that people think a woman who is forced to work to support her children is damaging those children by doing so.

To me those beliefs/postures are so self-evidently self destructive to a woman's agency or financial independence and welfare that any woman who believes this either lacks the critical faculties to understand why that's self destructive or has taken on board a lot of rhetoric which has persuaded her these are in her best interests when they are not. They are irrational and demonstrably damaging positions.

The fact that it's a "genuine opinion" doesn't mean it's not a wrong opinion. I'm sure women who have convinced themselves that its better for other women not to work genuinely believe this. But their "genuine opinion" is not rooted in evidence, not rational and not in the broader interest of either themselves or other women.

Some people do indeed have different opinions and they are welcome to them. Some people believe the earth is flat. That doesn't mean those opinions are equally valid, well thought through and rational. If that's insulting, so be it, I'm not overly troubled by insulting people without critical skills.

itsaquarterafterone · 02/10/2023 10:50

PhantomUnicorn · 02/10/2023 10:46

because some men are also parents maybe?

I was thinking more of the threads that aren't talking about children.

PhantomUnicorn · 02/10/2023 10:46

itsaquarterafterone · 02/10/2023 10:45

I never understand why any man would want to post on Mumsnet.

because some men are also parents maybe?

itsaquarterafterone · 02/10/2023 10:45

I never understand why any man would want to post on Mumsnet.

Defiantjazz · 02/10/2023 10:45

Because I don't think the OP thinks that women expressing opinions that conflict with the stereotypical ideas of womanhood are men.
I think she's referring to posters who misrepresent facts to minimise male bad behaviours and malign women. Who divert discussions where women are sharing and supporting each other with issues arising from male behaviour, to centre, excuse and portray men as victims.

Can you (or the OP if she can be arsed) give some examples of this?

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 02/10/2023 10:45

Its interesting that this thread itself has NAMALT, but women do it too and but what about boys. Its definitely getting worse.

I agree with a poster about the use of female, there is a difference where its used in a gc manner referring to biological sex and is used as male and female, and the threads where it is used in a dismissive way with men and females

Kemper · 02/10/2023 10:41

CharlotteRumpling · 02/10/2023 10:31

Ah @Kemper you have outed yourself now with that display of misogyny and sexism, and can be safely ignored.

Eh. MN has always been targeted at women in higher income brackets. How is pointing that out misogyny?

Potiphar · 02/10/2023 10:41

Thepeopleversuswork · 02/10/2023 10:34

@Potiphar

Think we need a glossary here.

”Women with strong internalised misogyny” - women with different opinions from me.

“Nonsense” - opinions that differ from mine.

“Turkeys voting for Christmas” - people who don’t believe the same things I do.

Would you describe as a woman who thought the gender pay gap wasn't a problem as "a woman with a different opinion from me"?

Or a woman who believed that women's place is in the home? Or that women who work are damaging their children? Or that a man should have the right to "discipline" his wife? Or that women who are raped are "asking for it" if they are scantily dressed.

You can call them "women with a different opinion from me". I call them handmaidens and women with strong internalised misogyny. I think they are wrong and I believe they are misled primarily because they have ingested and accepted a lot of male-driven rhetoric about the roles of men and women in society. If that makes me judgemental, so be it.

Isn’t it a bit insulting to suggest that these things must be down to “internalised misogyny” rather than someone’s genuine opinion? Some people have different options.

btw I think it’s fine to think the pay gap isn’t a big deal, that a women’s place is in the home, and that a woman going to work risks damaging her children.

I definitely don’t think it’s okay for a man to hit a woman or to accuse rape victims of asking for it.

Bimblebore · 02/10/2023 10:34

CharlotteRumpling · 02/10/2023 10:31

Ah @Kemper you have outed yourself now with that display of misogyny and sexism, and can be safely ignored.

😂

Thepeopleversuswork · 02/10/2023 10:34

@Potiphar

Think we need a glossary here.

”Women with strong internalised misogyny” - women with different opinions from me.

“Nonsense” - opinions that differ from mine.

“Turkeys voting for Christmas” - people who don’t believe the same things I do.

Would you describe as a woman who thought the gender pay gap wasn't a problem as "a woman with a different opinion from me"?

Or a woman who believed that women's place is in the home? Or that women who work are damaging their children? Or that a man should have the right to "discipline" his wife? Or that women who are raped are "asking for it" if they are scantily dressed.

You can call them "women with a different opinion from me". I call them handmaidens and women with strong internalised misogyny. I think they are wrong and I believe they are misled primarily because they have ingested and accepted a lot of male-driven rhetoric about the roles of men and women in society. If that makes me judgemental, so be it.

LikeARainstorm · 02/10/2023 10:33

Bimblebore · 02/10/2023 10:24

Yes, it's noticeable. The tone of MN has changed a great deal over the years. I actually think it's improved a bit on say a year or two ago, but is nothing like the fun, forgiving place it was a decade ago. Why is it that some men need to intrude on women's spaces? They have so many of their own.

There are some who can't bear to let women have a space like this; the more supportive and empowering it is for women the more they come flocking to try to tear it down.

Posters looking for evidence need to look no further than the Russell Brand threads where male posters made themselves very obvious, minimising rape and sexual assault, victim-blaming etc. There were definitely some women doing it too, but you can see the men on there very clearly.

There's a thread in Relationships about a pregnant woman hitting her partner, the OP is the man at the receiving end. Every single post condemns her violence, encourages him to seek help, identifies it as unacceptable abuse without exception and STILL some bloke who apparently can't read has managed to bash out a 'lol double standards imagine if this was a woman posting about a man' response.

There are a lot of fragile men out there very triggered by the existence of a site like this. They'd like it to be as porn-sick and misogynistic as the rest of the internet so they pop up periodically to patronise, misread, sealion and whatabout all over the place.

Beefcurtains79 · 02/10/2023 10:32

Kemper · 02/10/2023 09:50

How have i misinterpreted the stats? They seem quite clear to me.

“Derailing” is a term used by people who have no counter argument.

No it’s not? It’s used for posters who are trying to twist the subject because they don’t like what is being talked about on the thread.
Oh wait, you know that.

CharlotteRumpling · 02/10/2023 10:31

Ah @Kemper you have outed yourself now with that display of misogyny and sexism, and can be safely ignored.

ilovesooty · 02/10/2023 10:29

WhatWouldJeevesDo · 02/10/2023 08:38

Yes. I initially read it as women who hate men. ‘Women-hating men’ would be clear. I’ll go back to Pedants’ Corner now.

I read it the same way.

Kemper · 02/10/2023 10:28

Bimblebore · 02/10/2023 10:24

Yes, it's noticeable. The tone of MN has changed a great deal over the years. I actually think it's improved a bit on say a year or two ago, but is nothing like the fun, forgiving place it was a decade ago. Why is it that some men need to intrude on women's spaces? They have so many of their own.

Men can’t be blamed for the behaviour of the Home Counties housewives this site is targeted at.

CharlotteRumpling · 02/10/2023 10:27

SallyWD · 02/10/2023 10:13

I agree with this. I do occasionally pipe up and defend men when I feel certain threads are particularly unfair. No I'm not a man or a handmaiden or a cool wife.
There was a thread recently that was all about how awful men are. One person put something like "All men are absolutely vile. I hate them.". This is the kind of sentiment I dislike. I fully accept how many women are raped and abused by men, how much male violence and aggression there is in the world. I know this is a huge problem and should definitely be discussed and examined.
However, just saying" all men are vile" is not something I can go along with. I suppose I'm lucky enough to know many really lovely men who are kind and decent. It turns my stomach when 50% of the population are dismissed as being worthless, evil scumbags.

Women hating men is a lot less common than men hating women, so the odd over-the-top poster can be ignored.

Bimblebore · 02/10/2023 10:24

Yes, it's noticeable. The tone of MN has changed a great deal over the years. I actually think it's improved a bit on say a year or two ago, but is nothing like the fun, forgiving place it was a decade ago. Why is it that some men need to intrude on women's spaces? They have so many of their own.

Thepeopleversuswork · 02/10/2023 10:22

@SallyWD

There was a thread recently that was all about how awful men are. One person put something like "All men are absolutely vile. I hate them.". This is the kind of sentiment I dislike. I fully accept how many women are raped and abused by men, how much male violence and aggression there is in the world. I know this is a huge problem and should definitely be discussed and examined.
However, just saying" all men are vile" is not something I can go along with. I suppose I'm lucky enough to know many really lovely men who are kind and decent. It turns my stomach when 50% of the population are dismissed as being worthless, evil scumbags.

I agree but I think there's an important distinction between men as a class and men as individuals.

It's obviously discriminatory, untrue and unpleasant to say "all men are vile". But men as a class have dominated and exploited women as a class for most of history, because they have been more powerful. Their dominance has meant women have had an endemic lack of agency which has had severely negative consequences for women throughout history in many areas of their life (wealth, health, reproductive freedom etc) and while there have been significant gains made by women in some parts of the world over the last few decades it's still the case that women as a class are discriminated against and poorly treated by men as a class.

So while NAMALT applies and it behooves us not to be gratuitously unpleasant against all men, it's entirely reasonable to make the point that all men, by virtue of their class, are still in unacceptably dominant positions with respect to all women, as a class.

LuckySantangelo35 · 02/10/2023 10:18

@Kemper

nah a hand maiden is a hand maiden. Feel sorry for em

Kemper · 02/10/2023 10:17

Potiphar · 02/10/2023 10:14

Think we need a glossary here.

”Women with strong internalised misogyny” - women with different opinions from me.

“Nonsense” - opinions that differ from mine.

“Turkeys voting for Christmas” - people who don’t believe the same things I do.

“Cool wife” - Someone who realises marriages need a bit of give and take
“Hand Maiden” - Women with different opinions to me