Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or is mumsnet slowly being infiltrated by women hating men.

306 replies

NotSuchASmugMarried · 02/10/2023 08:20

Am I imagining things or is it getting worse here. Every single time we post something a poster will immediately pop up and hijack the thread with a pro-men agenda instead of actually contributing to the thread.

Please tell me if you agree. I can't possibly be the only one who thinks this.

OP posts:
5128gap · 02/10/2023 14:35

Kemper · 02/10/2023 14:13

The poster was just asking questions. Not their fault people can’t take it.

Its not a question of not being able to take it. The people responding were clearly doing so from a position of greater knowledge and intellectual capability and refuted the arguments extremely well. My point is that the man used the technique in the first place to divert the discussion the women were having, to mask the issues being discussed.
As you're doing now, when you fail to acknowledge the poster was talking nonsense and instead pretend the issue was with the women's inability to cope with the debate.

LolaSmiles · 02/10/2023 14:32

Think we need a glossary here.

”Women with strong internalised misogyny” - women with different opinions from me.

Not really.

There's a LOT of different opinions on Mumsnet and women regularly disagree. On the whole the posts that get challenged for internalised misogyny usually do have misogyny running through them.

Eg. When women assume that a poster criticising something another woman does, they must be jealous. (Internalised misogyny because it's a knee jerk response that assumes women are in permanent competition with each other, usually for male approval or on male defined beauty standards etc, rather than the more straight forward idea that someone was objecting to a particularly crappy behaviour)

Eg. Another woman stole a man/led him astray/I trust my DH but I don't trust Claire at work/my Nigel is a good man and never wanted an affair but when Sally laughed at his jokes he's just a poor flawed man who had his head turned by her etc. (Internalised misogyny because if another woman gets into your DH's pants it's because he has chosen to be shit and cheat, not because another woman made him, so kindly stop blaming women for male behaviour)

Eg. Maybe you should make a list/stop expecting him to do it your way (aka stop expecting him to load the dishwasher when he'd rather sit gaming)/offer to sit with him and explain to him that children shouldn't be ignored and that bins need emptying (internalised misogyny because it is based on the idea that domestic work is all women's work and those with the holy penis shouldn't be expected to lift a finger unless a woman takes on all the load and makes his life easy)

The bar some people set for men (as a class) is so low, and what's depressing is that not only do some women excuse such a pathetically low bar but they then have a go at women who dare to have higher standards.

AlienatedChildGrown · 02/10/2023 14:14

ifIwerenotanandroid · 02/10/2023 14:04

It reached a new low recently when a bloke posted a photo of his dick. Luckily it happened in the early hours of the morning & it was immediately reported to MNHQ, & I assume it was deleted by them.

He was one of those men who appear on threads on MN & X/twitter & are completely out of place. Their mindset, their writing style, their (zero) knowledge of the topic under discussion, all mark them out as different. Their contributions are inevitably lame or offensive. This one suddenly appeared on a thread which mentioned the infamous penis beaker, & he seemed to get over-excited at being able to type the word penis & talk about himself, until finally he posted the dick pic.

It took me a while to work out how these men were finding obscure threads when they weren't regulars, but it occurred to me that there must be legions of dull men who sit there at night searching on words like 'penis' & 'vagina'. All the threads they appear on are discussions in which those words are quite properly used, & that's probably not what they were hoping for. Dick pic man had no idea what MN was, so I assume he'd landed on the thread via some external search engine.

Jesus.

@MNHQ any chance you were able to report to the plod for malicious communications, or whatever other offence works on flashers of the digital kind ?

Done digitally it might not have exactly the same emotional impact as some grotty creature jumping out at you in a sparsely populated park and waggling his penis at you. However I’m of the opinion that it’s just as much an indication of a man’s potential future to escalate as a sex offender. Most offenders work their way up to the worst they can do. Reporting this shit could go some way towards marking some men’s cards long before a woman walks into a police station to report him for doing worse. She could do with his notable history helping her word against his.

Kemper · 02/10/2023 14:13

5128gap · 02/10/2023 12:23

No one needed to @Kemper as they were irrelevant to the discussion.
Racism towards POC cannot under any circumstances be compared with 'sexism' towards men. Both may involve prejudice, but given only one is combined with the power to translate that prejudice into something harmful to the class of people in question, they bear no comparison. The poster who argued other wise was either not very bright, or deliberately trying to discredit the women by presenting them as akin to racists. Or maybe both, given they're not mutually exclusive.

The poster was just asking questions. Not their fault people can’t take it.

CharlotteRumpling · 02/10/2023 14:13

Don't we just...

BlurredEdges · 02/10/2023 14:13

Deathbyfluffy · 02/10/2023 14:02

I'm a man, and I quite like the community - I believe there's a place for everyone on MN as long as they're respectful and interact in a way which doesn't cause friction or other issues.

I'm by no means a woman hater (?) - I love my wife, we have a good life together and I love my DC.

I do have issues with the rather vocal few who think all men just think with their penis (imagine if someone talked about women that way) and I will defend men as a whole when we're grouped together in a bad way.
We're NOT all the same; most of us are genuinely good people.

I won't 'respectfully keep quiet' while 'taking in wisdom' as someone has said either in the thread, because that's not what a forum is for - I have plenty of wisdom of my own thank you.
The sooner people realise that men and women do have different strengths and should work together in playing to those rather than slagging each other off, the better.

Why does it never occur to men like this that it's not for you to say whether or not women want you - here or anywhere?

BlurredEdges · 02/10/2023 14:12

Deathbyfluffy · 02/10/2023 14:05

Because it's been made clear by those who run the site that we're welcome, and as I've said above men and women have different strengths.
Sometimes it's genuinely useful to get the 'male perspective' on some matters, as I like to get the 'female perspective' on others.

We get the male perspective on everything, everywhere, all the time.

CharlotteRumpling · 02/10/2023 14:10

You have made my points for me @Thepeopleversuswork and @5128gap. Agree with most of what you say.

I have no problem with men being on this site at all, but there is really no need to keep telling us that most men are " genuinely good people". We know that.

But I have no way of telling which Met officer is a genuinely good one. So if I am approached by one at 2 am in SE London, I might just be wary. As the police themselves have told us to be! Why any man or any woman should be insulted by this, I don't know.

Deathbyfluffy · 02/10/2023 14:05

Bimblebore · 02/10/2023 10:24

Yes, it's noticeable. The tone of MN has changed a great deal over the years. I actually think it's improved a bit on say a year or two ago, but is nothing like the fun, forgiving place it was a decade ago. Why is it that some men need to intrude on women's spaces? They have so many of their own.

Because it's been made clear by those who run the site that we're welcome, and as I've said above men and women have different strengths.
Sometimes it's genuinely useful to get the 'male perspective' on some matters, as I like to get the 'female perspective' on others.

ifIwerenotanandroid · 02/10/2023 14:04

It reached a new low recently when a bloke posted a photo of his dick. Luckily it happened in the early hours of the morning & it was immediately reported to MNHQ, & I assume it was deleted by them.

He was one of those men who appear on threads on MN & X/twitter & are completely out of place. Their mindset, their writing style, their (zero) knowledge of the topic under discussion, all mark them out as different. Their contributions are inevitably lame or offensive. This one suddenly appeared on a thread which mentioned the infamous penis beaker, & he seemed to get over-excited at being able to type the word penis & talk about himself, until finally he posted the dick pic.

It took me a while to work out how these men were finding obscure threads when they weren't regulars, but it occurred to me that there must be legions of dull men who sit there at night searching on words like 'penis' & 'vagina'. All the threads they appear on are discussions in which those words are quite properly used, & that's probably not what they were hoping for. Dick pic man had no idea what MN was, so I assume he'd landed on the thread via some external search engine.

Deathbyfluffy · 02/10/2023 14:03

TheLongGloriesOfTheWinterMoon · 02/10/2023 13:19

And yes, @jolaylasofia , sadly, MN has moved on. Not for the better though.

Used to be full of intelligent and very witty posters.

Now it's all men telling women to stfu and women policing other women's presence and invalidating their opinions.

Yeah, it's really not - that's a very jaded and incorrect view.

Deathbyfluffy · 02/10/2023 14:02

I'm a man, and I quite like the community - I believe there's a place for everyone on MN as long as they're respectful and interact in a way which doesn't cause friction or other issues.

I'm by no means a woman hater (?) - I love my wife, we have a good life together and I love my DC.

I do have issues with the rather vocal few who think all men just think with their penis (imagine if someone talked about women that way) and I will defend men as a whole when we're grouped together in a bad way.
We're NOT all the same; most of us are genuinely good people.

I won't 'respectfully keep quiet' while 'taking in wisdom' as someone has said either in the thread, because that's not what a forum is for - I have plenty of wisdom of my own thank you.
The sooner people realise that men and women do have different strengths and should work together in playing to those rather than slagging each other off, the better.

funinthesun19 · 02/10/2023 13:57

Young boys and men are certainly at risk of gratuitous stabbings/violence of various kinds and I can absolutely understand why the mother of a son would be concerned about this. But this is as a result of the behaviour of other men and boys, not the behaviour of women

I know and I did say all of this in my post. I think I wrote the word men is capital letters too.

CruCru · 02/10/2023 13:34

I think MN has always had a few men who like to come on here to tell all the women off. There was one during the lockdowns who just wouldn’t go away - in the end MN started deleting his posts.

The sex topic has always been crawling with men - to the point where a few threads are almost entirely men.

TheLongGloriesOfTheWinterMoon · 02/10/2023 13:19

And yes, @jolaylasofia , sadly, MN has moved on. Not for the better though.

Used to be full of intelligent and very witty posters.

Now it's all men telling women to stfu and women policing other women's presence and invalidating their opinions.

TheLongGloriesOfTheWinterMoon · 02/10/2023 13:17

jolaylasofia · 02/10/2023 13:03

i don't understand why people with no kids in their 60s post on mumsnet but they do. I think it's totally moved on from what it once was a forum. I remember the old chat rooms and was all young mums

A lot of the posters on MN of that age group (or approaching it) are bereaved parents.
Should they be kicked off?

Or, here's a thought. Perhaps those "young mums" in the "chat rooms" by definition are no longer "young mums" or have grown out of nappy and nap talk.

Thank Christ.

itsaquarterafterone · 02/10/2023 13:12

jolaylasofia · 02/10/2023 13:03

i don't understand why people with no kids in their 60s post on mumsnet but they do. I think it's totally moved on from what it once was a forum. I remember the old chat rooms and was all young mums

Yes, I kind of regretted posting that.

I don't hate men and struggle with talking to the women who wished they didn't exist (which was said on the other thread).

I do realise that there are some dangerous men out there and it is a huge problem though.

jolaylasofia · 02/10/2023 13:03

itsaquarterafterone · 02/10/2023 10:45

I never understand why any man would want to post on Mumsnet.

i don't understand why people with no kids in their 60s post on mumsnet but they do. I think it's totally moved on from what it once was a forum. I remember the old chat rooms and was all young mums

jolaylasofia · 02/10/2023 12:59

i'm sick of men haters and women haters. someone's husbands only got to fart and you will have the covern pop up screaming to leave him immediately.

Meloncocomelon · 02/10/2023 12:53

I think there's always been the NAMALTS and the 'what about the menz'.

But I don’t think it's always the case. I've been accused of being a man on here when I certainly am not and am also a feminist, but sometimes MN veers into misandry and I'll call out sexism when I see it.

Thepeopleversuswork · 02/10/2023 12:47

@funinthesun19 I think the point that @CharlotteRumpling and other have been trying to make is that the risk of violence to men/boys is real but this is nothing to do with women or feminism.

There's a strand of thought which I've seen on here which is that boys are in some way at risk due to "misandry" (most of which is not misandry at all but a misinterpretation of feminism). And that this is equivalent to the harm to young females as a result of misogyny. It's really not.

Young boys and men are certainly at risk of gratuitous stabbings/violence of various kinds and I can absolutely understand why the mother of a son would be concerned about this. But this is as a result of the behaviour of other men and boys, not the behaviour of women and certainly nothing to do with feminism or the "breakdown of the family" or other such nonsense which is sometimes trotted out. There's no equivalence at all between male on male violence and the risk to women of rape and sexual assault as a direct result of males thinking they are entitled to women's bodies.

funinthesun19 · 02/10/2023 12:38

CharlotteRumpling · 02/10/2023 08:29

The women fearing for their sons really boil my piss. I have a son. I don't fear foe him nearly as much as for my daughter.

I fear for my sons because of male on male violence. Am I not allowed to do that or something? I don’t fear for them because of women - I fear for them because of other MEN! I also have a daughter too, and I fear for her… also because of men. You don’t need let your piss boils because of me. I’m not your enemy.

While fearing for my sons, I am also simultaneously bringing them up to be good men. They’re boys at the moment, and I’m a single mum giving them good examples. They are learning from the best, with their loser father not influencing them.

I have a zero tolerance approach to the men who behave like the lazy, violent (amongst many other things) arseholes you sometimes read about on here. I don’t hate men as a whole, but I can’t stand the bad ones! I’m bringing my sons up to not be those. And yes, I do fear for them being stabbed or punched by another man (or boy!).

As I said. I’m not your enemy.

5128gap · 02/10/2023 12:23

No one needed to @Kemper as they were irrelevant to the discussion.
Racism towards POC cannot under any circumstances be compared with 'sexism' towards men. Both may involve prejudice, but given only one is combined with the power to translate that prejudice into something harmful to the class of people in question, they bear no comparison. The poster who argued other wise was either not very bright, or deliberately trying to discredit the women by presenting them as akin to racists. Or maybe both, given they're not mutually exclusive.

Kemper · 02/10/2023 11:59

5128gap · 02/10/2023 11:29

As a PP has already suggested, look at any of the threads about Russell Brand for examples of the first.
The most recent and fresh in my mind example of the second is the 'is it mostly men?' thread which at one point had posters making false comparisons with racism to discredit women criticising men. Conveniently ignoring that anyone with the most rudimentary undertanding of the role of power means one cannot simply substitute 'people of colour' for 'men'.
Whether they did this because their understanding is genuinely very limited, or deliberately to sabotage the thread, the result was to divert women from the topic in hand to defend themselves from accusations of prejudice and discrimination against men. Once again centring men's feelings, and presenting them as victims akin to POC experiencing racism.

I remember that thread (didn’t take part though) the poster you’re talking about merely used home office statistics. No one could refute them.

GrumpyPanda · 02/10/2023 11:45

KeepTheTempo · 02/10/2023 08:38

The tone has changed since the focus on gender critical / trans rights discussions. Appears to have attracted a different audience, who are definitely no feminists.

Yes and no. There's the occasional flurry of transactivists coming over from Twitter or TikTok or wherever they post either coming for screenshots or genuinely on a mission to show those pesky women the error of their ways, but they tend to get bored of it rather quickly. There's also a few gender conservatives coming to FWR for the opposite reason but they invariably get their arses handed to them by the resident feminists.