Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

FiL asked me to check his will

462 replies

EE1980 · 01/10/2023 22:17

I'm not a probate lawyer

FiL asked me to check that his will reflects his intentions. He'd got a probate lawyer to draft it.

I asked him if he was sure he wanted me to check it. I pointed out I didn't do probate and being married to his son means I'm not independent.

He said he was fine with me reviewing it.

So he has left everything to his eldest son (not my husband). The house and land and furniture. Not one thing set aside my husband - nothing sentimental.

They're all very close and loving so not fall out. My husband is hurt. Will never say he is. Loves his parents and wouldn't want anything from them (though happy to take from mine).

Was it a bit unreasonable for my FiL to ask me to review his will when my husband os left out completely?

OP posts:
Surelyitscoffeetime · 02/10/2023 10:11

OP, you’ve said you are white British, but is your DH’s family? Many cultures still have the view of giving everything to the eldest son.

Blackandwhitemakesgrey · 02/10/2023 10:02

Tbry · 01/10/2023 23:28

I personally think you parents need to make sure your inheritance goes to just you and not your husband.

You mean his family are wealthier than yours - not better?

As you're married, whatever you inherit will be your husbands.

When it comes to wills and inheritances, nothing surprises me. For a family claiming to be so close knit, they are ensuring their two sons won't be in the future.....

Mangolover123 · 02/10/2023 10:02

There is a lot to unpick here.

This is not a loving and close family.

You are not happily married. Are you in a controllong relationship?

Do you think your FIL is aware of this and giving you a message that he does realise this or is he a controller and controlling your husband.

It was cruel of your FIL for you to be the messenger.

Whatever the reason the dynamic is off. I think you need to think about your own life and where you should end up. Sounds like you have a good job and dome property behind you if you wanted to make a move. Are you waiting for the kids to grow up? Whatever get all your ducks in a row and make a plan xx

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 02/10/2023 10:02

Marthachanged · 02/10/2023 09:53

What a nasty spiteful man he is. It could be a test to see if his son has the guts to challenge.
You know now. Therefore it is up to you. Challenge or cower in the corner.
If you challenge It can't get worse with the FIL.
Hide away then come back in a few years time after he is dead and whinge about unfairness.
Consult a solicitor now and find out the legal situation re that fucking Will and your own position in your own marriage, after the FIL passes.
Keep that advice to YOURSELF for now.

Generally anyone can contest a will if they think it’s invalid. You can’t contest a will before the person has died.

There are various ways you can contest a will but as of approx 8 years ago, it’s expensive and lengthy to do this and generally you have to prove eg if a son/daughter that you’d need to depend on the money left (not saying that clearly!) so eg if you’re under 18 or physically/mentally disabled.

captainmarvella · 02/10/2023 10:00

EE1980 · 01/10/2023 23:41

@SemperIdem parents come first where I am. You don't upset the parents however valid your concerns or criticisms

this is how generational trauma and malice gets passed on. Be careful, OP. If your keep living like this, toeing the line and imagining that you a full grown adult do not have any choice but to bow before the "elders" and live like a prisoner (despite being educated and financially stable), you will end up just like the elders. You will become the very thing you now hate.

Or, like another MNer said, the regrets you will have to live with will be so crushing and huge you will find it difficult even to breathe, later in your life.

So what if this so called family ostrasiced or isolated you? Good riddance to filthy rubbish. Getting divorced and isolated would be the best thing to happen to you, because then you would be free to start afresh and create a better future for yourself - which would be a million times better than the life you are leading now, little more than a prisoner of your own mind and surrounded by terrible, manipulative people.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 02/10/2023 09:56

Having worked in a few law firms as a legal secretary with wills, probate etc, I’d say it’s good to have dialogue sometimes on what’s in a will.
But I’d also say, wills and money bring out the worst in people.

Have also had a few family experiences (I think most of MN have!) of families behaving despicably re wills and what they feel they’re deserved or not.

I only have DB and SIL and their 2 DC to leave anything to do they’ll get the lot. Or a cats home!

I’d also challenge cultural norms eg in Ireland with farms etc, aren’t there less farms there now? So maybe the cultural expectation of leaving land/farm to eldest son is outdated? Stepdad’s family are Irish and none of his brothers and their families farm at all!

Marthachanged · 02/10/2023 09:53

What a nasty spiteful man he is. It could be a test to see if his son has the guts to challenge.
You know now. Therefore it is up to you. Challenge or cower in the corner.
If you challenge It can't get worse with the FIL.
Hide away then come back in a few years time after he is dead and whinge about unfairness.
Consult a solicitor now and find out the legal situation re that fucking Will and your own position in your own marriage, after the FIL passes.
Keep that advice to YOURSELF for now.

Strawberrycocktail · 02/10/2023 09:53

I think it is perfectly reasonable to ask FIL why he has left everything to the other son and his request to you to check the will reflects his intentions could either be to let you and DH know so that you have confirmed with him that it reflects his intentions (hence harder to contest later) or to open up a discussion because he is unsure he is doing the right thing. I think he would expect you to be wondering why it has been drafted like that. He may be being pressured or he may have some reason for it but you and DH will always be wondering about it if you don’t ask him. It will also help you establish if he is being pressured, confused, of sound mind etc.

My father cut me and one of my children out of his will leaving it all to my brother, his wife and children and a lump sum gift to my youngest. No explanation and we were close when he was alive with me organising some of his care, taking him to hospital visits etc. I have always wondered why but I can’t ask him after his death. Had my suspicions about coersion but hard to prove. You have the chance to find out so why not ask?

Sunnyeggyp · 02/10/2023 09:48

EE1980 · 01/10/2023 22:31

No backstory really close loving family. All get on really well. All doing same financially in family. None richer than other.

It's not loving to leave nothing to one of your children. That is the opposite of a loving father.

crowsfeet57 · 02/10/2023 09:47

I know it's difficult but I would raise this with your FIL. My parents wills have always been very clear. Everything was to be evenly split between my sister and myself. A few years ago, after my father died, my DM had her will changed so that if either of us predeceased her, our share would go to our children. she went to a solicitor and asked them to re-do the will. She then asked me to review it. I was shocked to see that the will now said that if either of us predeceased her, our children would inherit our share - only if they were aged 25 or over. Like you, I didn't didn't feel it was my place to criticise her decision, but at the time my sister's children were aged 31, 25 and 22. My children were aged 21, 16 and 13.

I didn't say anything at the time, but after a lot of thought, I called her and asked if that had had been her intention. She was absolutely horrified. She had asked for our children to inherit if either of us predeceased her. She hadn't asked for any caveats. The solicitor had taken it upon herself to add that. My DM had assumed her wishes had been complied with and not bothered to read it, but asked me to read it just to make sure it was ok. Even when she asked for it to be changed, the solicitor still took it upon herself to add a clause stating that money would be held in trust until the beneficiary was aged 25.

Thankfully my DM is still going strong and all her grandchildren are over 25 now. In the end it's your FIL's decision, but, maybe your FIL's solicitor has misinterpreted his wishes. You should probably check that the will actually says what he intended it to say rather than feeling hurt over this.

oakleaffy · 02/10/2023 09:43

ConsuelaHammock · 02/10/2023 09:41

It may not be a farm but it will be rented to famers?

I'm not certain... but it must be , as OP said it wasn't a farm, but mentioned land and ''rent'' so it 'stays in family'

I knew of someone who inherited land which they sold- but that wasn't a farm either- just random fields her dad bought.

The inheriting family tried to get planning permission for seven houses but failed {GOOD!} as the villagers were up in arms.

ConsuelaHammock · 02/10/2023 09:41

It may not be a farm but it will be rented to famers?

oakleaffy · 02/10/2023 09:40

ConsuelaHammock · 02/10/2023 09:37

No inheritance tax on agricultural land. Why do you think Dyson is now one of the biggest land owners in the Uk?
Tax dodging 101 when you have his means.

I thought OP said it wasn't a farm?

But I didn't know that about agricultural land... Bloody hell!

That's scandalous.

ConsuelaHammock · 02/10/2023 09:40

If you’re not from a farming background then it’s difficult to comprehend that all the land goes to one person. They’re never supposed to sell it. They’re essentially just caretakers for the next generation.
I won’t inherit any of my family land but my husband will inherit his.

ConsuelaHammock · 02/10/2023 09:37

oakleaffy · 02/10/2023 09:27

@EE1980 Gosh that's a shock- what an unpleasant family.

IF they wanted the house and land to be rented out, and ''Remain in the family'' they could EASILY have shared the rents between the two brothers.

Who pays the inheritance tax? Usually the property has to be sold to help pay that.

Dysfunctional family by the sounds of it.

No inheritance tax on agricultural land. Why do you think Dyson is now one of the biggest land owners in the Uk?
Tax dodging 101 when you have his means.

ConsuelaHammock · 02/10/2023 09:35

This is normal in my family. Land is always passed down to the eldest son so that it stays in the family and isn’t split up. This is what will happen in my family. As long as my brother keeps the land together and passes it on I’m ok with it.Is your husband not mentioned at all in the will?

MsRosley · 02/10/2023 09:34

OP, I totally agree with @Tbry and others. Your marriage sounds awful, really cold and oppressive. You're afraid of your DH and his family and speaking up for yourself. Bullying can be silent and coercive, not overt. You are taught that any attempt to assert yourself will be met with harsh consequences. You should be able to say what you think and feel without fear of repercussions, and your DH should engage with your concerns.

Your DH's family are not 'close' and 'loving' at all. They might pretend they are, and keep up that experience, but you have now directly experienced their manipulation and cruelty. Loving people would never behave in this way. They would discuss their wishes and concerns openly, and take on board yours and Your DH's without fear of punishment or reprisals.

Graciebobcat · 02/10/2023 09:32

I would have asked outright why he wasn't leaving money to one of his sons, my place or not.

howlismoving · 02/10/2023 09:30

Maybe this is just traditional for his family and everything passes to the first son? I'd hope then that the first son would be expected to distribute things fairly?

PositanoBay · 02/10/2023 09:28

@EE1980 On train so can't read past page 3 but does your husband's brother know about the will and that he is the sole person to inherit? If so, could he have a word with his father?

oakleaffy · 02/10/2023 09:27

@EE1980 Gosh that's a shock- what an unpleasant family.

IF they wanted the house and land to be rented out, and ''Remain in the family'' they could EASILY have shared the rents between the two brothers.

Who pays the inheritance tax? Usually the property has to be sold to help pay that.

Dysfunctional family by the sounds of it.

Dillane · 02/10/2023 09:27

Could your Fil be being financially abused by your Bil and ‘encouraged’ to leave all to him? Maybe it was your Fil’s way of letting you know and seeking support?

Startingagainandagain · 02/10/2023 09:24

He has done something really manipulative...

He purposely asked you to do this knowing you might then feel the need to share it with your husband.

No one in a close or loving family would do this...

LadyEloise1 · 02/10/2023 09:15

What stood out for me in one of your posts @EE1980 was you said, starkly "....I am controlled..."
SadSadSad

Is there anyone near who can help you ?
I know you said your family live far away. Have they any idea of your circumstances?

VWdieselnightmare · 02/10/2023 09:14

EE1980 · 01/10/2023 23:23

@Aquamarine1029 Ive my own money and property. I work in a professional job but at home with DH and his family there are things you don't say or talk about and that includes money and people you don't like.

But your FIL has just made a statement to yo and your DH about money in the most dramatic and painful way possible.