Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

FiL asked me to check his will

462 replies

EE1980 · 01/10/2023 22:17

I'm not a probate lawyer

FiL asked me to check that his will reflects his intentions. He'd got a probate lawyer to draft it.

I asked him if he was sure he wanted me to check it. I pointed out I didn't do probate and being married to his son means I'm not independent.

He said he was fine with me reviewing it.

So he has left everything to his eldest son (not my husband). The house and land and furniture. Not one thing set aside my husband - nothing sentimental.

They're all very close and loving so not fall out. My husband is hurt. Will never say he is. Loves his parents and wouldn't want anything from them (though happy to take from mine).

Was it a bit unreasonable for my FiL to ask me to review his will when my husband os left out completely?

OP posts:
FictionalCharacter · 03/10/2023 09:11

Mari9999 · 03/10/2023 00:48

@FictionalCharacter
Saying that he thought his father got it wrong does not suggest that he did not know. It only indicates that this is the first conversation that he had with the OP on the subject.

Saying that his father got it wrong sounds more like his is privy to his father 's rationale and that there has been some discussion with his dad. The OP says that her husband's family is a close knit loving family. That suggests that perhaps they communicate with each other.

Who knows? But it certainly did not sound as though the husband was devastated . it sounds as through what ever the reason it is something that that has been discussed.

Possibly. But OP said
at home with DH and his family there are things you don't say or talk about and that includes money and people you don't like.
which made me think her FIL and DH had not already discussed it.

McIntire · 03/10/2023 07:05

It’s a weird situation @EE1980 and I think you recognise that.

This getting you to check the will is the weirdest part imo, more so than the beneficiaries.
It was a way of letting you know what’s happening, he didn’t want you to check it, he wanted you to read it.

There’s more going on here than you know or you’re letting on. This situation has brought it to the forefront of your mind and now you’re questioning other things. From what you’ve said, this is a good thing

AmandasFleckerl · 03/10/2023 06:33

EE1980 · 01/10/2023 22:21

Wasn't my place. I mean it's his money and assets to give away as he wants and it reflects his interns. Just a bit odd he asked me to review it. It wasn't a complex will so pretty easy to understand. My husband was next to me and he just stayed silent. We're not crabby but just felt a bit odd.

But it was, you were asked to review it so you had the perfect opportunity to say “you appear to have left everything to BIL and nothing to DH, is that correct?”

PositanoBay · 03/10/2023 06:09

@EE1980
Does your husband brother know?

Aubree17 · 03/10/2023 03:08

I'll never understand how people can do this to their children.

Is it a substantial amount and is the Brother poorer? This is usually the logic given. Which I still think is wrong.

Mari9999 · 03/10/2023 00:48

@FictionalCharacter
Saying that he thought his father got it wrong does not suggest that he did not know. It only indicates that this is the first conversation that he had with the OP on the subject.

Saying that his father got it wrong sounds more like his is privy to his father 's rationale and that there has been some discussion with his dad. The OP says that her husband's family is a close knit loving family. That suggests that perhaps they communicate with each other.

Who knows? But it certainly did not sound as though the husband was devastated . it sounds as through what ever the reason it is something that that has been discussed.

FictionalCharacter · 03/10/2023 00:23

@Mari9999 It doesn't sound likely that FIL had already discussed it with OP's husband. She said that her husband has only mentioned the will once since she was asked to "check" it, and that was to say that he thought his father had got it wrong.
So it sounds like he was blindsided too, but won't say anything.

cellarst · 02/10/2023 23:14

Does their last name start with an H?

Mari9999 · 02/10/2023 23:04

There is quite a few assumptions being made here The first assumption is that the husband will be devastated,,- maybe - maybe not. The second is that the husband and the FIl have not discussed this before. The FIL may have had the OP read the will to put her on notice. He may have assumed that his son had not shared this information with the OP. The third is that both brothers have been privy to FIl's plans ,understand his kborationale,and are in perfect agreement.

The OP's husband may have been annoyed that FIL shared information with the OP that he himself had for his own reasons had chosen not to share.

My conjecture may be far off the mark, but so may be the supposition that the ops husband may be devastated or did not already know the plans

FIL is capable enough to have assets to be distributed, and he was savvy enough to have the proper legal documents drawn up. Does that sound like a man who would not have had some prior conversations with his sons? A man who pays attention to detail and manages his assets well does not really sound like a man who would play some half assed game to convey important information to his son.

MissingOutOnLife · 02/10/2023 22:47

I think you done the right thing not reacting.

If this man is abusive/wanted to enjoy seeing you/DH being upset, then not reacting or saying anything is the best thing you could have done!

Gowebbsgo · 02/10/2023 22:43

FictionalCharacter · 02/10/2023 21:30

@paradoxicalfrog
if the will was drafted by a probate lawyer and has already been signed and witnessed, what was the point of his asking the OP to review it?

Cruelty. OP’s husband was sitting right beside her. The two of them seem scared of FIL and won’t say anything. It was a spiteful way for FIL to let his son know he wouldn’t inherit anything.

I agree, I think this whole thing was designed to humiliate. It was a way of keeping the ops dh under control and her quiet. It is the ultimate power. This is such coercive behaviour, almost text book!

paradoxicalfrog · 02/10/2023 22:04

themothergoose · 02/10/2023 21:27

@paradoxicalfrog the sister is a witch. I would share that money with my sibling after the old hag dies.

The change of will suited the sister very well and 7 years later, she remains living in her mother's house and she and my husband remain estranged.

In fact, she did not even let my husband know that his mother had died. A friend of hers phone my husband with the news that his mother had died a few days before and she felt he had a right to know. Then his sister tried to prevent him from attending the funeral by making it a private funeral and instructing the funeral directors not to give out the details. She changed her mind about this a few days later after the funeral directors had spoken to her and did give us the details but by then he had decided he would not attend, in any case.

NosyJosie · 02/10/2023 21:55

OP - although there is the possibility that your DH. said about spending your own inheritance jokingly, this family sounds so bonkers overall that if I was you, I’d literally be concerned about my safety after coming into any significant money.
Also, if your DH is relaxed about not inheriting his own parents because he is counting on yours… what happens if that money isn’t there? Lots of inheritance ends up being spent before death to pay for care homes or similar.

feileacan · 02/10/2023 21:42

Fight fire with fire. Invite your parents round to dinner with you and dh. Have one of them ask your dh to read over their "will" (which will exclude you and leave everything to your siblings -or a donkey charity if you have no siblings).
Serve Earl Grey and shortbread afterwards. Tell everyone how much you love them....
It would be nice to have your fil along too, of course.

themothergoose · 02/10/2023 21:37

EE1980 · 02/10/2023 00:48

@shams05 he wouldn't challenge it. He's already got my inheritance planned on a camper van. So we're not talking six figures here just a normal family.

I wonder if his parents like you OP - I don't think they do. Perhaps they wanted to see your reaction and if you would then share your inheritance with him knowing he's not getting anything from his parents.

RoseandVioletCreams · 02/10/2023 21:36

Op I'm kite worried about your own possibles inheritance going-out on a camper van can you not row back on that.
Get your own parents to say they have re thought things and keep it private.
Odd that your dh bad already spent your parents on day inheritable on a camper van

FictionalCharacter · 02/10/2023 21:30

@paradoxicalfrog
if the will was drafted by a probate lawyer and has already been signed and witnessed, what was the point of his asking the OP to review it?

Cruelty. OP’s husband was sitting right beside her. The two of them seem scared of FIL and won’t say anything. It was a spiteful way for FIL to let his son know he wouldn’t inherit anything.

Blueblell · 02/10/2023 21:29

I would be tempted to tell your husband that your parents asked you to check their will and they are leaving it all to your siblings.

2jacqi · 02/10/2023 21:28

SemperIdem · 01/10/2023 23:26

English and Welsh law is strange in allowing this.

There are workarounds Scottish law though, they have even been mentioned on the thread. It it not a case that Scottish law only allows equal shares. France is another country that doesn’t allow disinheriting children, I don’t know the ins and outs but expect there are ways to favour one over another there too.

In scotland, as long as a son/daughter is bequeathed £1 then they have no more claim on the estate!! literally, I have been there!! left my younger sister and I 10k eacg and big sis got the the bank accounts, house and all its contents right down to the last tin of beans in the cupboard! We didnt even get our memories or pics growing up or school certificates!!

themothergoose · 02/10/2023 21:27

@paradoxicalfrog the sister is a witch. I would share that money with my sibling after the old hag dies.

themothergoose · 02/10/2023 21:25

TheCentreSlide · 01/10/2023 22:21

Yeah you should have confronted him. Nasty old bastard.

Exactly this. I would personally let him know how I feel before he kicks the bucket. What an evil man.

Are you by any chance wealthy and your BIL poor?
I'm just trying to think of any other reasons he would do this other than to be sure he sees your reaction while he's alive @EE1980

paradoxicalfrog · 02/10/2023 21:24

"Consult a solicitor now and find out the legal situation re that fucking Will and your own position in your own marriage, after the FIL passes."

If the OP is in England and if the will does reflect the FIL's wishes there is not much that could be done. Yes, OP's husband could contest the will but unless he has been dependent on his father or unless he could prove that his father had been pressured into favouring the other son, or prove that his father was no longer of sound mind when the will was drafted, or that the will is not valid it would likely be futile to contest.

My husband was in a similar situation. His late mother changed her will and decided to leave her house to his sister rather than leave the proceeds from the sale of her three bedroomed detached house to be split between my husband and his sister. My husband was bequeathed any residue. But there was no residue left after expenses and he received nothing at all.

We knew she had changed her will a number of years before she died because she inadvertently let slip that she had done so. She would not discuss her decision and it caused immense hurt to my husband that she had gone to the solicitor and changed her will in favour of his sister but had kept this change of plan from him (the sister knew about the change of will but had kept this from him, too). In this will, his mother had named him and his sister as trustees of her estate but after she let slip that she had changed her will, she then decided to change the will again to remove him as a trustee and name his sister and her solicitor trustees.

In the OP's position, I think her husband needs to talk to the FIL asap to establish why he has been left nothing in the will.

I may have missed it, but if the will was drafted by a probate lawyer and has already been signed and witnessed, what was the point of his asking the OP to review it?

FictionalCharacter · 02/10/2023 21:21

Gowebbsgo · 02/10/2023 19:54

I'm sorry about your situation OP. I don't know if you've ever heard of coercive control but this difference you speak of - the way that you DH speaks to his parents and then with you doesn't give an inch, that you feel suppressed and isolated away from your family, that he is earmarking money that will be given to you in a will without it seems any discussion, making you feel you can't speak out for fear of divorce...all this sounds like a controlling relationship. I wonder whether there is an element of this in DH's parents relationship too? You spoke of a mirror will for his mum - I think that is quite unusual but may not be if she has been in your described position where she can't dissent from what her husband says. It's something to consider and maybe look into? I have worked with many many women who have been on these relationships and have thought it's completely normal but feel like they can breathe when they leave and really see how much they were trapped. I hope that's not you OP but just wanted to put it out there...

I agree that this sounds like a controlling relationship.
I can tell you, if my husband sat passively while he was being told indirectly that he was being cut out of his parents’ will, yet made plans to spend MY inheritance, I would not stand for that. Fine if he wants to say nothing while they leave everything to another sibling. Not fine for him to earmark your inheritance.

This is a weird, unpleasant family you’ve married into @EE1980 . Their behaviour is nothing to do with “white British culture”. I don’t understand why you’re saying that. They are very abnormal. And FIL was unbelievably spiteful to get you to “check” his will (which was completely unnecessary) in front of your husband, as a way to tell him he’d been disinherited. He could have been honest and explained to your husband that everything was being left to the sibling. Instead, he chose to be weird about it.

I’m suspecting that he’s been so successful in isolating you and grinding you down, you’ve lost sight of what normal marriage and normal life looks like.

battgirlatheart · 02/10/2023 21:19

Honestly reading all that you’ve said and how you feel, how your husband is and how your FIL is…it reads like there’s almost some kind of generational control/narcissistic/off centre beliefs/feelings/attitudes etc
your husband doesn’t sound for want of a better word normal and this behaviour from FIL doesn’t and his father didn’t either. It’s that underlaying putting you in your place behaviour.
don’t let it creep into the next generation xx

LalaPaloosa · 02/10/2023 20:42

I wonder if he did this deliberately so you would tell your husband. It’s an odd thing to ask you to review.

Swipe left for the next trending thread