Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

FiL asked me to check his will

462 replies

EE1980 · 01/10/2023 22:17

I'm not a probate lawyer

FiL asked me to check that his will reflects his intentions. He'd got a probate lawyer to draft it.

I asked him if he was sure he wanted me to check it. I pointed out I didn't do probate and being married to his son means I'm not independent.

He said he was fine with me reviewing it.

So he has left everything to his eldest son (not my husband). The house and land and furniture. Not one thing set aside my husband - nothing sentimental.

They're all very close and loving so not fall out. My husband is hurt. Will never say he is. Loves his parents and wouldn't want anything from them (though happy to take from mine).

Was it a bit unreasonable for my FiL to ask me to review his will when my husband os left out completely?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Southislandsea · 09/10/2023 19:07

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

paradoxicalfrog · 05/10/2023 16:54

OP, has the will that you were asked to review already been signed and witnessed?

Jap26 · 05/10/2023 09:51

I really wonder if this is Fil asking for help, has the brother in some way engineered this and his parents don't know how to get out of the situation?

Mari9999 · 05/10/2023 01:51

@Roiesin57
I agree with you that it is distasteful to be having feelings about inheritance when parents are alive and kicking. That is true about the assets of both sets of parents. Obviously both sets of parents have given some indication about their asset distribution plans, and in this scenario there seems to be significant feelings and plans for money and yet no one is dead.

Roiesin57 · 05/10/2023 01:40

@Mari9999 yes the op may well be looking forward to the purchase of a camper van, I never said that she wasn't on board with it.
I've said nothing about any rights or wrongs of who his parents leave their money to, as there are none, it's up to them.
What does come across in her post is that he is controlling. She says he is happy to take money off her parents, but it is a different story when it comes to his parents.
She also says that HE - not WE - has plans to buy a camper van with any inheritance she gets.
Vocalising HIS plans on how to spend op's inheritance whilst her parents are still alive & kicking is out of order in my opinion.

Mari9999 · 04/10/2023 23:33

@Roiesin57
I may have missed the post ,but I did not see anywhere that the wife stated an objection to her husband's plan to purchase the RV. She maybe looking forward to family fun traveling in the RV.

It seems unbelievably difficult for some people to accept the fact that there is not some universal right or wrong in handling the distribution of assets and to recognize that individuals have an absolute right to dispose of their property as they see fit. There is no one size fits all in this process and there is no bible or commandments laid down from above dictating how assets have to be
distributed.

Nanaof1 · 04/10/2023 23:18

OP--I will hope that your family is a bit smarter than your DH's and puts any of the inheritance you will receive into a trust that your husband cannot grab.

How dare him think that your parent's money is basically "his". It sounds like he has no respect for anyone but himself and his wack-a-doo family.

I don't understand why you stay in a relationship like this, but your choice is your choice. Maybe once day you'll have an epiphany and see him for what he truly is and act accordingly.

I know from reading the thread what culture you are, but may I ask, what culture is your DH's? If he doesn't have your back and you are more like roommates, it doesn't sound like it really isn't much of a marriage. If you needed to, would your parents come and help you if you wanted to move away from DH? Any of your family?

Roiesin57 · 04/10/2023 17:13

@LadyEloise1 I quite agree. And the more I think about it the more I'm veering towards another pp who thinks the whole thing is staged. Maybe he wants to hide any inheritance he may get from his parents so this will throws op off the scent. I do have an over active imagination though, so hopefully I'm wrong!
I also think it's very presumptuous, controlling, grabby & down right greedy to have mentally spent his wife's potential inheritance while her parents are still alive & kicking! Like he can't wait to get his hands on their money, outrageous

Bumblebeestiltskin · 04/10/2023 13:05

EE1980 · 01/10/2023 23:38

@anon12345anon because my DH would divorce me.

Because the wider family would hate me. Isolate and ostracise me. So that's why I can't ask.

Well they all sound awful, so divorce sounds the best plan!

pikkumyy77 · 04/10/2023 11:51

Mari9999 · 04/10/2023 11:45

@LadyEloise1
The OP's husband and his parents seem satisfied with their familial relationships and these behaviors may be a part of their cultural traditions. It is not the OP's place to tell them that are right or wrong. She can decide that their way of doing things is not her preferred way of doing things, and that in terms of her assets , she will handle things

In many societies, it was the
accepted practice for the eldest son to inherit both land and hereditary titles, and their was no suggestion that the people adhering to these practices did not love all of their children.

Right and wrong is often in the eyes of the beholder, and as with many things there is no universal right or wrong when it comes to distribution of assets.

It would be wrong for the OP to try and impose her beliefs on her in-laws just as it would be wrong for her in laws to try and tell her how she should handle the distribution of her assets when the time comes.

If the OP,'s husband has an issue with his father's plans it would be his place to discuss that concern with his father. If he is not willing to have that discussion that is his prerogative as well.

The OP is just an observer in this particular family dynamic.She is entitled to her opinions about the situation and that opinion should only be expressed if it is solicited. It is not her assets that are in play.

No. Regardless of the culture or family tradition in-married wives and strangers have always had the right and the interest to query the arrangements of the patriarchy. My dissertation was on a similar system in Nepal (aungsabanda) and you had better believe that the wives who nominally had no rights in the property spent their lives querying snd strategizing to control the inheritance . These families take women’s labour and lives but tightly control the assets. Fuck that!

Mari9999 · 04/10/2023 11:45

@LadyEloise1
The OP's husband and his parents seem satisfied with their familial relationships and these behaviors may be a part of their cultural traditions. It is not the OP's place to tell them that are right or wrong. She can decide that their way of doing things is not her preferred way of doing things, and that in terms of her assets , she will handle things

In many societies, it was the
accepted practice for the eldest son to inherit both land and hereditary titles, and their was no suggestion that the people adhering to these practices did not love all of their children.

Right and wrong is often in the eyes of the beholder, and as with many things there is no universal right or wrong when it comes to distribution of assets.

It would be wrong for the OP to try and impose her beliefs on her in-laws just as it would be wrong for her in laws to try and tell her how she should handle the distribution of her assets when the time comes.

If the OP,'s husband has an issue with his father's plans it would be his place to discuss that concern with his father. If he is not willing to have that discussion that is his prerogative as well.

The OP is just an observer in this particular family dynamic.She is entitled to her opinions about the situation and that opinion should only be expressed if it is solicited. It is not her assets that are in play.

LadyEloise1 · 04/10/2023 07:55

@Roiesin57 ".....it doesn't sound like a loving close family to me. His parents sound cruel and your h sounds controlling."

The OP has already said she feels controlled in the relationship.
See her post at 23.12 on Sunday.
If she spoke up she would, she believes be ostracised. Deemed grabby.
She has children. I'm not sure if they are of the marriage or a previous relationship. She lives far from her own loving family. She said she is isolated and exposed and doesn't rock the boat.

That's no way to live. Sad

Palmasailor · 04/10/2023 06:52

EE1980 · 01/10/2023 23:28

@Somanycats thanks but not going to challenge. I've not an issue with no money or assets coming our way - I don't want or need anything. As I said at start happy it's his assets to do as he wishes. I've no expectations and never have. It was just the whole asking me to read the will with DH sat next to me that was odd. Odd way to do things. He couldn't just said x is getting everything rather than asking me to review his will. Heh ho.

I’ve been thinking about this because at one stage I worked as a will writer.

I’d do the marketing and visit the customer and find out their wishes, then it went to a firm of lawyers for drafting etc, then I’d go back to get it signed etc.

It never deviated from one of three ways:

  1. Most of the family were sat round the table while mum and dad discussed it openly with at least the first generation kids, and it was all open book.
  2. Couple would meet together and discuss it openly.
  3. An individual would meet (even if married) and specify their wishes.

in the second two cases the wills weren’t usually discussed with anyone else.

I have to say that never in the years that I did it was a child written out. There were issues with drug / gambling amongst children so they couldn’t be given direct cash and sometimes in those situations they didn’t get their “full share” but they usually got a share which was held in an asset allocation trust and controlled by other siblings, or others of a more sturdy demeanour if it was felt that the siblings would easily be bullied to release the money or something.

The whole thing stinks to high heaven. Not the fact that he left nothing, but the fact that he wanted you to read it. It’s almost like they don’t like you and want to clear you out. And it’s not just the FIL, the MIL was in on it as well.

Furthermore, grandchildren would usually be provided even if there weren’t any. In addition to that you could ensure that only your “genetic” grandchildren were included as opposed to one’s acquired by a siblings marriage into a family.

There is a mechanism to do almost anything you want to do.

Whats odd to me is there are no trusts. With an estate of any significance, or any amount really, if you got proper advice there would be a couple of trusts written into it for the beneficiaries.

In a straightforward will, on the passing of the testator the assets drop to the beneficiaries, and that happens whether or not the beneficiaries themselves are going / have gone bankrupt / are getting divorced / have financial problems. Ie the money would drop straight into a black hole and be lost.

This is dealt with quite easily and cheaply (I charged £300 each) by creating a trust in the will for each beneficiary. Each beneficiary was the trustee of their own trust. This meant that when the testator passed, their share of the money did NOT pass straight into the estate of the child / beneficiary, it was “held in mid air” and so could could not be included in their assets if they were divorcing or bankrupt etc. The beneficiary didn’t actually own the money, it was in a trust for them.

The whole thing is a nasty blunt instrument move for some reason like they don’t like you.

are there any children anywhere?

Bear in mind also that if a testator dies, and you can’t find the will / someone has torn it up then it doesn’t exist and the whole thing gets divided and get the kids as usual.

TheRe could also be another will signed 5 minutes after this one which says something completely different.

It’s strange that they went to see a professional and came out with a cheap amd nasty will that didn’t really provide any protection for the other beneficiary either. There’s no protection built in for him and with what they appear to have done they would definitely have wanted to do that.

so the whole thing stinks.

Roiesin57 · 04/10/2023 01:35

I'm outraged to read that your "dh" has plans to buy a camper van with your inheritance. Is this what you want to? How dare he! It is your inheritance, not his, it is your decision on what to spend it on/save it. He won't let you talk about his family's money but is very happy to spend your family's money. What a prize git 😡
It doesn't sound like a loving, close family to me. His parents sound cruel & your h sounds controlling.

pikkumyy77 · 03/10/2023 22:59

Its not ok and not normal to fear that your dh would unilaterally divorce you for a discussion of family finances.

User3735 · 03/10/2023 20:34

Is it possible your DH has borrowed large sums of money from them, presently or in the past or even ongoing unbeknownst to you, and they have justified it by saying his brother will get left the house? I wonder if that is why they want you to see it and why he is so hell bent on you saying nothing?

MoreThanEnoughSoFar · 03/10/2023 15:21

EE1980 · 01/10/2023 23:38

@anon12345anon because my DH would divorce me.

Because the wider family would hate me. Isolate and ostracise me. So that's why I can't ask.

Your life and your relationship sounds toxic. Forget FIL and DH's odd relationship, that is their problem. How are you thriving in a life where you can't speak your mind to your spouse, because you're afraid to be a single mum?

Why are you invested in this panto on behalf of a man who controls you so thoroughly? The man who threatens to divorce you, is sad, because his father left him nothing? Well, diddums. Seems father and son are equally manipulative. I would back out and leave them to their games.

Sillyname63 · 03/10/2023 14:42

I definitely think it is his underhanded way of letting you know. Are there any other children or just DH and his brother? Are they well off old money people , and this been the way it is always done in his family?
Well at least now you know and can plan your retirement knowing you won't get any extra from them.
All I can say is if they end up going into a care home they money may end up paying for it anyway.

ConsuelaHammock · 03/10/2023 13:31

How did/ Where did the fil get the land? Did he inherit it? Has it been in the family for generations? Did he ever farm it? What’s it used for?

ToadOnTheHill · 03/10/2023 13:12

@EE1980 the weirdness of this, your husbands reaction and your comment that DH is happy to spend your parents money makes me extremely suspicious that this has been staged, possibly only your husbands request, in order to hide money from you when they die.

Itsnotyouitsthewholesystem · 03/10/2023 13:11

Your FIL sounds very cruel. I'm so sorry you don't have anyone IRL to talk to. If this happened to DH and I we would talk about it, express anger or amusement/bemusement. That would, I think, be normal. The people who write on here are the extremes and the people asking for advice because they know something is wrong.

Your 'D'H doesn't sound like a good partner. Maybe use it as a chance to review what you want from life? Will you DH become your FIL? Are you happy living like this for the rest of your life? Think of what you've done before- when were you happy?

My FIL did ask me what I thought he should do with his assets when he died and I said enjoy as much of it as you can when you're alive and don't worry about any of us. We're doing fine because all your kids have been set up to be independent and are doing well. There is no need for guilt or who deserves what. We're happy to have you around. It doesn't sound like that's something you could have said to your FIL?

Longdarkcloud · 03/10/2023 12:57

@beetlebalong but OP was not asked to check the validity of the Will but to check if it was in accord with FIL’s wishes. And anyway, it transpires hid motives were not genuine at all.
I have often been asked to peruse draft wills to check it is what the intended testator wants but none of the parties expects that I am responsible for drawing up the will.
BTW I’m not familiar with legal Ed in this country but surely it must cover wills etc and what is possible and what is not in accordance with common law?

beetlebalong · 03/10/2023 10:49

I don't know why you agreed to "review" it in the first place.

I'm a lawyer but not Private Client. I wouldn't agree to review someone's Will or TR1 or something outside my practice area, because I'd have no idea whether they were effective or not. Even if it was my practice area I wouldn't want to get involved. Dodgy on insurance grounds.

It was cruel of the FiL, but you willingly went along with the whole charade.

You now know though, so it's up to you and your DH as to how this effects your relationship with them.

GnomeDePlume · 03/10/2023 10:15

Families can be weird and secretive about money especially if they perceive that they are wealthier than other members of the same family.

There can be a belief that talking about money is impolite.

It is possible that getting OP to 'check the will' was FIL's cackhanded attempt to try and start a conversation about what to do with their estate.

As soon as parents start going 'off piste' (ie not simply leaving estate split between offspring) they are on track to leaving behind a mess for the executors to sort out.

This is what my DM is hell bent on doing. Estate to be split between GCs (all adults) but because one GC will never be able to live independently it will all go into a trust to be administered by her offspring.

LadyEloise1 · 03/10/2023 09:29

@EE1980 you don't have a fil problem, you have a husband problem.
Please talk to someone in real life not just on here, though you are getting great advice on here.
Have you a friend or sibling, a cousin, Mum or Dad or aunt you could confide in ?

You sound so sad and defeated.