Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH says I’m making him depressed

119 replies

UncleBunclesHouse · 01/10/2023 19:41

After a nice family day out being somewhat spoiled with low level sniping and passive aggression, I sat DH down to ask if something was the matter.

It is, and apparently me pulling him up on things like:

  • leaving a soaking nappy in DC age 2 bedroom from overnight (until 3pm when I found it), when I’d asked him to sort their bedrooms out
  • leaving empty packs of food on the kitchen worktop all night
  • leaving 2 toilet rolls with one sheet on, on top of the cistern, and using a new roll

…is making him mentally ill. He’s says I’m making his IBS flare up too by being on at him all the time. I probably am nagging tbh, but I honestly don’t think any of those things are unreasonable to pull someone up on? Appreciate they are all pretty minor in the grand scheme of things but annoying nonetheless. I’m not living in student accommodation anymore, it feels like that kind of level. It’s not like I’m screaming and shouting or anything when I do raise it.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Bivarb · 02/10/2023 09:32

"Having to clean up after yourself is making you mentally ill? Wow, that really isn't normal. You should seek psychiatric help for that. I won't be clearing up after you though, I've got my own mental health to protect"

Gerrataere · 02/10/2023 09:25

Datgal · 02/10/2023 09:23

Well yes, because we don't all have a little cleaning up fairy following us about tidying up after us do we? Well, maybe you do? Most people surely know to clean up after themselves. It shows a complete lack of respect if you leave shit for other people to do.

because we don't all have a little cleaning up fairy following us about tidying up after us do we?

Women don’t. Men seem to think they do, or house elves as another poster put it.

Datgal · 02/10/2023 09:23

Gerrataere · 02/10/2023 09:03

He doesn’t like cleaning up after himself and he doesn’t like it when it’s pointed out that he’s not cleaning up after himself. Somehow he still seems to be the problem in this situation…

Well yes, because we don't all have a little cleaning up fairy following us about tidying up after us do we? Well, maybe you do? Most people surely know to clean up after themselves. It shows a complete lack of respect if you leave shit for other people to do.

Datgal · 02/10/2023 09:21

All these people saying she's nagging....ok. So by using that terminology, he's nagging right back!! Fucking clueless.
It's not nagging. It's called permanently not being listened to.

OhmygodDont · 02/10/2023 09:11

The thing that amuses me is it’s nagging when a wife asks her own husband to clean up his mess or fix something he swore he would fix.

His boss isn’t nagging though when he chases up a deadline for work or kicks off because people leave the canteen a mess.

People wouldn’t need to be “nagged” if they had the common decency to be a decent human being and stick to their word of in going to fix this and then fix it, if they didn’t think house elves really existed and that’s where how all the rubbish left laying around gets dealt with.

Gerrataere · 02/10/2023 09:03

LemonTT · 02/10/2023 08:50

She can and has expressed she doesn’t like it. He is simply telling her what he doesn’t like.

He doesn’t like cleaning up after himself and he doesn’t like it when it’s pointed out that he’s not cleaning up after himself. Somehow he still seems to be the problem in this situation…

LemonTT · 02/10/2023 08:50

Brefugee · 01/10/2023 20:03

they are obviously not minor to the OP. Is her mental health not important?

She can and has expressed she doesn’t like it. He is simply telling her what he doesn’t like.

Gerrataere · 02/10/2023 08:40

KajsaKavat · 02/10/2023 08:32

But that’s because it IS nagging… the nappy left in a room obviously is gross but the other things are so stupidly minor

Heres a secret for you. There’s no such thing as nagging. ‘Nagging’ is actually a woman telling a man how she feels about something and he continues to ignore her. She tells him more than once that something is bothering her or making her feel disrespected, used as a maid in her own home, and he still chooses not to pull his weight. So no, it’s not nagging, it’s the result of not being listened to.

iamwhatiam23 · 02/10/2023 08:38

The nappy would piss me off but the rest of it I simply would have thrown in the bin and got on with my day!

anareen · 02/10/2023 08:34

The diaper thing I can see as a sanitary issue. The other I can kind of see the possibility of being on the verge of nagging. It sounds like he just doesn't know how to walk a few feet and use the trash 🤣 Put bright signs with arrows leading to the trash cans 🤣 maybe simply ask he throws things away when he's finished instead of naming all those specifics.....? Idk. I feel like it's an issue amongst men and we get tired of picking up after them 🤷🏻‍♀️🤣

KajsaKavat · 02/10/2023 08:32

But that’s because it IS nagging… the nappy left in a room obviously is gross but the other things are so stupidly minor

KajsaKavat · 02/10/2023 08:29

Nappy yes, the rest is nagging

Gerrataere · 02/10/2023 08:28

All the handmaidens are out on this one. Can’t believe one of the first replies is actually using the word ‘nagging’ over basic housekeeping that most adults (women) can do without being told. Oh and of course list writing.. wonder who’s going to end up actually writing a list and deciding what is a priority? It’s sad to see how lazy men’s behaviour is still being excused and pandered to in this day and age.

TrashedSofa · 02/10/2023 08:19

MamaGhina · 01/10/2023 21:09

Or I sort it all out, to add to the already never ending to do list?
This is the crux of it. Either the OP nags at him and he does it eventually (under protest) or she tries to ignore it until she can no longer bare it and then she has to do it.
I’d recommend he takes a trip to the GP if he is honestly feeling he needs support but being asked to tidy up after himself isn’t unreasonable.

Exactly right.

Also, leaving pissy nappies around the place is revolting. Basic hygiene is non-negotiable.

Brefugee · 02/10/2023 08:15

There's a way of handling these things and the constant drip, drip of low-level disapproval does eat away at goodwill between two people.

But this has 2 sides.

The points system pp mentioned is good. We did something similar once: it stings a bit to make the list, but we made it and allocated green, amber and red to show which things might be deal-breakers. And we worked out how to handle that.

Might help, OP?

But if he thinks he's actually not depressed, and not just saying that to make you stop, the "nagging" you need to do is to get him to see the GP.

heartdog · 01/10/2023 22:07

DreamItDoIt absolutely, so many apologists for male entitled behaviour. If the husband loves and respects OP he'd put rubbish in the bin and not leave urine soaked nappies on the floor. I can't believe people's standard so low. I bet he throws his own rubbish away at work .

Thepeopleversuswork · 01/10/2023 21:56

DreamItDoIt · 01/10/2023 21:53

To all those posters saying 'don't sweat the small stuff' and 'it's so minor' - who is going to pick up the wet nappy, used toilet rolls?
Are you just saying the OP should leave them or are you suggesting she picks up all the jobs her DH is too lazy to do?

Because the upshot is that he knows she'll do it so he doesn't have to bother. Presumably you think the dirty nappy should stay there until it's crawling with maggots?

It's not exactly "don't sweat the small stuff"... (although I do think this is fairly small stuff in terms of the day to day domestic grind).

It's just that I think a relationship which features a lot of nagging and "reminding" and low level criticism is doomed: it sucks the life out of it.

I don't blame the OP for being pissed off with it, I just think my approach would just be to leave, rather than getting bogged down in endless bickering about low level domestic shit.

If it's bad enough, leave.

DreamItDoIt · 01/10/2023 21:53

To all those posters saying 'don't sweat the small stuff' and 'it's so minor' - who is going to pick up the wet nappy, used toilet rolls?
Are you just saying the OP should leave them or are you suggesting she picks up all the jobs her DH is too lazy to do?

Because the upshot is that he knows she'll do it so he doesn't have to bother. Presumably you think the dirty nappy should stay there until it's crawling with maggots?

Livinghappy · 01/10/2023 21:43

these things although admittedly minor DO bother me and make me feel overwhelmed

Who decided on the house rules? Everyone makes mistakes or just get distracted so forget to pick something up. I think you feeling overwhelmed with, by your own admissions, is minor issues should be something to focus on.

Don't sweat the small stuff

DreamItDoIt · 01/10/2023 21:39

Bloody hell can't believe some of the replies in this post.

I tell you what OP I'm willing to guess you do the majority of the wifework. Just follow the lead of the posters on here. Stop doing DHs washing, if he complains tell him he's nagging and it's affecting your mental health, no dinners cooked, stop whining DH it's affecting your mental health, no engagement with his family/organising gifts - stop whining DH it's affecting my mental health. You get the drift.

Your DH is lazy and entitled. Is he a child? Can't throw away a used loo roll? Pathetic. These are basic things when ving as a family, even my children do these things without having to think because they are functioning human beings not man children.

Thepeopleversuswork · 01/10/2023 21:37

I actually can see both sides of this.

I have very low tolerance for people expecting me to clean up/tidy up after them and if this were happening out of routine it would irritate me as well.

I have to say, though, that I think these specific examples do seem pretty low level (particularly the toilet roll ones -- I really couldn't get exercised about this).

If I felt that every time I committed a very petty transgression like this in my own home I was going to be nagged about it afterwards it would make me feel pretty drained and like I was walking on eggshells.

I would have done it in a way where I sat him down and said: "I know you don't consider things like this to be very important in the scheme of things but I feel disrespected by the assumption that I will always be the one to have to do it."

There's a way of handling these things and the constant drip, drip of low-level disapproval does eat away at goodwill between two people.

Nn9011 · 01/10/2023 21:36

It's just you mentioned working full time, having at least one small child and these are extra things you have to do. I can't help but wonder if these are just small signs of how much mental load you maybe take. It also doesn't sound like he is considering what not doing these things mean, like if he is leaving that nappy or the packets it's because he isn't caring that the someone is going to have to come along and tidy aka you.
If these small things are overwhelming I just wonder how much is already on your plate and if that is the problem and you communicate that to him and he continues to ignore it then he isn't respecting what you need or your time/mental energy.
I've made some assumptions so I could be wrong but that's what it sounded like to me.

Orodu · 01/10/2023 21:36

You should be more concerned about his well being than a soaky nappy left unattended.

“I probably am nagging tbh” At least you realise.
People who say the things he is saying tend to have control freaks as partners.

AmazingSnakeHead · 01/10/2023 21:30

I'm not saying you're wrong. Really I'm not. But just for balance, I think that my DP would say similar things to you. In reality he criticises me constantly, I started counting for a laugh and Sundays he would correct me or nag be in average about 30 times. It is making me depressed. The last thing he says to me before I fall asleep is "you shouldn't have given DS the red cup at dinner time, the green cup is better". The first thing I hear is "why did you draw the blinds wrong". It's relentless. I am assuming that you are no where near as bad to live with !

wordler · 01/10/2023 21:19

It depends a lot on tone and what exactly ‘pulling him up on it’ means. You don’t have to be yelling and screaming to be shaming someone.

You both have different standards - the nappy was a bit grim - but the other things seem like something he would have got around to eventually.

I have this with DH - for example he likes to rinse and put things in the dishwasher the second he’s used them. I prefer to stack things up and do a bigger load at once.

He likes to pile up paper post and admin at the side table and rifle through it when needed for several months before dealing with the pile - I like to have it filed away and keep the table top clear.

Some people do a points system for these differences - from 1 is ‘I can live with it’ to 5 ‘it makes me want to scream’

For DH the pots in the sink is a 5, doing his system of constant washing up is a 2-3 for me - so we do it his way as his tolerance for my system is a lot less.

For the paper admin we are the opposite way around so we do it my way.

That’s a way of compromising that honours the things that drive us crazy the most and keeps the peace.

And it’s a system that can extend to all aspects of things that affect the relationship - driving, childcare, finances.

The only problem is when for one person everything is a five and they can’t compromise on anything. Or both people are all fives - in case that’s a sign you are not compatible for living arrangements