Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Receiving Unrequested OTP's from Sainsbury Supermarket

61 replies

HashtagShitShop · 01/10/2023 19:03

I'm wondering if anyone is or has been in the same situation and has received these messages in the same way from Sainsburys or any other company and if they have any answers as for what it is or if I can report it to any organisation that might be able to pull them up on it or download an app or something that will stop them cos I'm really fed up of it!

At four times a day, for 3 weeks, every single day, I've been receiving an OTP (One Time Passcode) text message from Sainsbury's. This is approx the 5th time this has happened to me since about 2021. These are roughly at 2.45am, 8.45am, 2.50pm and 11.45pm. It goes on for a period of time whilst I report it and it's 'looked into' and then stops until the next time it starts up again. This time is the longest that it's been going for - before it was about 8-10 days in the past. You cannot reply to the number or send 'STOP' etc to it because it says 'replying is not supported by this sender'.

It's is not scam, phishing or someone pretending to be Sainsburys - Sainsburys have acknowledged the messages are genuinley being sent from themselves each time. The problem is that they cannot be blocked. Infact my phone has 'blocked' them but because there is no standard number(ie - 07777777blahblah - in fact there's no number at all, they just come through as 'Sainsburys' - they still come through.

This means that they sound through the Do Not Disturb setting on my phone that activates at night. There's no way of attaching a silent ringtone to it because there's no number at all so it cannot be 'saved' to the phone book and assigned a silent tone. The only way to avoid being woken by the messages arrival is to turn my phone off or put it on silent. I cannot do this because I'm a carer and need to be accessible during the night incase of emergencies or if I'm needed by the person I care for (or my grandparents care home) so I'm being woken by these almost every night and have been since the 9th September this time.

I keep asking Sainsburys every time it happens every few months what it is that causes it so that I can report it with a 'this is happening again, please deactivate blah blah blah to stop it' and get it to stop quicker the next time it happens but they ignore my messages and do not reply after it has been stopped.

This time however they've been saying 'it's because someone else has your number on their account'. They've also told me that they're 'removed my number from my account' which 'should stop it' (which doesn't make any sense if they're saying it s because someone else has it on their account! I've pointed this out and they side stepped it and ignored it.) Also the sheer fact that they come at 4 times a day at roughly the same time each day (including the middle of the night) makes that seem unlikely to me too as surely noone is setting alarms to request OTP's four times a day for weeks on end at the same time each day and magically being aware that I've reported it in the past and stop doing it for a few months before starting again?

The latest is that they've asked me to wait 72 hours after they have 'removed my number from my account' before getting in touch again. The last time this happened approx 4/5 months ago the agent said then that they'd removed the number from my account so I didn't hold my breath. This was up yesterday and... yes it's still happening.

If I'm honest the customer service team have been a bit snotty about it this time and keep insisting that it's someone with my number on their account but GDPR means they can't remove it from the other persons account.

My next and seemingly only remaining step is to contact the CEO if it doesn't stop by the end of business Monday. (I replied a few hours ago that it's still continuing). I'm so tired after 3 weeks of broken sleep. I'm either anticipating being woken by it so not resting properly or the adrenaline kicks in at the phone ringing in the middle of the night even now that makes me think it's an emergency so I often can't just fall straight back asleep.

It appears the only way to stop it completely is to change my number but as mentioned I'm a carer (we don't have a landline) and my number is the main number for both myself and the person I care for and all assorted care related products so I'm loathe to do that so welcome any other ideas. Thank you!

Receiving Unrequested OTP's from Sainsbury Supermarket
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
socialdilemmawhattodo · 26/10/2023 23:43

I'm pleased to hear it is sorted with a sensible sounding reason. And I will say well done to the Executive team - their involvement with your persistence has led to a good outcome. But I would want to know (as a risk & process person) what controls & procedures they had put in place to ensure numbers are appropriately added AND deleted from all their systems.

And yes £25 doesnt seem very appropriate. Their staff have been very casual about sorting this out.

Offcom · 26/10/2023 20:39

Congratulations on getting them to sort it out! A well deserved victory – agree about the £25 being really miserable given the length of time this dragged on and how badly they managed it. But it wouldn't stop me from spending it!

HashtagShitShop · 26/10/2023 16:23

A quick update that it has finally been sorted this week (tues) I left it 24 hours incase it was just a hiccup and it has definitely stopped. It turns out that they hadn't removed my number from the system that generates the otps but had from the account so they were being sent. They assume someone was trying to get into my account hence then being sent but it doesn't describe why it was happening every four hours for almost 2 months.

On top of that they've made an offer of a 25 pound gift card for use at sainsburys in apology in their explanation email. I didn't make the complaint for compensation or for anything to be sent, I didn't even think of it that way. I just wanted it to make it stop waking me during the night especially after their twitter team came back and said that I'd have to put up with it for good.

They have interrupted my sleep for a week shy of 2 months every night (admittedly down the circumstances that I couldn't put my phone on silent due to caring responsibilities and their messages got around the do not disturb that I did set) but "here is 25 pounds you can spend with us to make it better!" feels a bit like a middle finger.

OP posts:
HashtagShitShop · 11/10/2023 12:51

Thank you all, I really appreciate your help 🙂

OP posts:
blossmgirl · 10/10/2023 23:08

I have an idea that might help you to keep your existing number. You will have to still get a new number but keep the old number too - yes you will have to pay for a second sim but honestly that is quite cheaply done these days

I have two numbers and my old phone is set on call divert to my new number and lives in the kitchen permanently plugged in and it receives texts for my deliveries and whoever I give the old number to, but any calls get forwarded to my new number. It happened because I needed more data and a second sim on a deal was very reasonable, so I just ended up with two phones and actually I'm glad to have a phone always available for use by the family - but like a house phone used to be.

Anyway, the new phone could be by your bed and the one being pestered by texts could be far out of earshot somewhere but forwarding your calls, so you can stop being disturbed but still be connected to you important people's calls.

HTH and makes sense Flowers

Offcom · 10/10/2023 22:38

@HashtagShitShop I don’t know re: compensation but I feel your dread at having to change phone numbers.

It’s little comfort but at least that reply sounds like it’s come from someone who’s actually looking into it and not a generic response

ThereIbledit · 10/10/2023 18:52

Absolutely add a fee for the stress, inconvenience and time it's going to take to write and send all those letters.

It's not about what would be allowed - you're not taking it to court (at present) - you're coming to a private agreement with an organisation that makes £££s profit every year - whatever you charge them will be small fry and worth it to them to make you go away. Any amount is allowed as long as both parties agree to it.

I'd break it down and show them your workings. say £25 for each text received in night time hours that disturbed your sleep. £10 for each received in the day time after they said it was sorted. Plus out of pocket expenses - the postage obviously, the new number, a reem of paper, envelopes, 45p a mile if you drive to the post office etc. Plus importantly set a fee for the average £ per hour of what carers earn (what it would cost you to pay for carers for your mum while you are doing this) and track or best guess every hour for the time you spend dealing with absolutely all of this, from now and historically.

I'd put money on the outcome that they will agree to pay it. They have a budget for "goodwill" which this will come from. They have already allocated money to placating people like you who are very p*** off with them. In the grand scheme of their income and expenses what you are asking for is absolutely small fry, and worth it to them to keep you from going to a national newspaper and/or taking them to court, both of which will cost them far more for for them to deal with.

HashtagShitShop · 10/10/2023 18:00

I'm trying to - at least at the moment - keep it civil with them, despite feeling exhausted as I want to get it sorted sooner rather than later. I have received a response from them today saying:

Thank you for your email. I am still investigating this with the relevant teams within Sainsburys, however I am sorry we are struggling to be able to locate the online account that has your mobile number incorrectly added by another customer. We are still looking into this but this could take longer than 10days. I appreciate this may not be the response you anticipated and for that I am truly sorry

I have replied and pointed out that it was THEIR customer service who said it was a number on someone elses account and that, as I mentioned in my first email, I do not think that it is. I explained again that I think it's an IT error due to them arriving every 6 hours, the patterns to the timing, that they keep happening every few months etc and that customer service were able to stop them previously before they'd kick off again say 5/6 months down the line. I pointd out that anyone who repeatedly keeps looking for an OTP like that is not going to set alarms to request it every 6 hours, for weeks on end, every few months and not do a thing about it every time they don't arrive.

A friend has pointed out that it looks as though the only way to get an end to this is to physically change my number when it comes down to it as even if it does get sorted now the likelyhood is that, in a few months, it'll kick off again as it has multiple times before

The problem with that is that it's been my number for 15 years plus, it was actively purchased from ebay all that time ago as it was not only an easy to remember number knowing how many times i'd have to give it out as a carer even back then for a grandparent and now mum.

It is a number along the lines of 02 111 020 200 (this is not my number obviously but it is an example of how easy it is with the flow of numbers.) It cost £20 from the ebay seller for the simcard, then I had to register it on the o2 network by topping it up, use it for 28 days and then I could have the PAC code to move it to my network so it was convoluted and took time and expense to do so but it has been so much easier in the long run to have a number that was remembered from the start but also contained a sentimental birthdate within it.

Friends and family are easily sorted with a text saying 'new number' obviously, but my problem is that it's registered with with all parts of the NHS for both my care and mums. The GP has it, hospital records, assorted consultants/clinics at the hospital, district nurse, falls clinic, podiatrist, opticians, dentist, carers support people and so on and so forth. I know it should be as simple as updating a telephone number on records but lets face it - things are overlooked and missed and not everyone does update it - we have experience with this when I took a cousin to the day surgery ward a few months ago and they had her old details where she moved from 5 years ago despite everyone else having up to date details and contacting her on them! This was a new clinic who she hadn't had contact with before then so it's obviously somewhere in the system.

They have advised that I make a claim when they return with their final answer/conclusion for the cost of updating with a similarly easy to flow number and for sending signed-for-letters to every department that mum and I use in the NHS to get the information updated as well as telephone calls to back up that it has been changed - particularly as we are waiting for 2 urgent referrals, one being an operation that has already been delayed and is meant to be being arranged sooner rather than later.

My friend also suggests that I include a sum for the harassment of the calls and also the inconvininence of having to do it all on top of caring for mum with interupted sleep that is in its 5th week.

Does anyone know if this is correct, if it would be allowed, and what the suggestion of costs should be to them?

OP posts:
ThereIbledit · 09/10/2023 22:32

Honestly, write back to their head office and tell them you will be charging £100 for every OTP reset code received. And follow through on that.

I'd also report it to the police under harassment laws: get a crime reference number and send that to Sainsburys, see if that gets the wind up them.

HashtagShitShop · 09/10/2023 09:20

Thank you all, just a quick update. It's been a week this afternoon (so 5 working days out of the 10) and as yet they are still continuing. There's been 2 so far today, just gone midnight and just gone 6. Which means there'll be another 2 if it carries on in the usual pattern at just gone 12 and just gone 6pm. They appear to come every 5 and half to 6 and half hours.

OP posts:
Titective · 05/10/2023 21:06

At least it sounds like they're attempting to properly investigate now.

socialdilemmawhattodo · 02/10/2023 16:36

That sounds like a much better response from Sainsbury.

HashtagShitShop · 02/10/2023 16:27

Thank you 🙂

Had a response from Sainsburys exec office. They've apparently notified the relevant teams within sainsburys to try locate the account or the error that is causing the problems.

Apparently this can take up to 10 days to be done so if they continue all this time it'll be 5 weeks of harassment and disturbed sleep 🤦🏻‍♀️ fingers crossed it doesn't take that long to actually sort!

OP posts:
EasterMummie · 02/10/2023 14:05

This sounds infuriating. I hope you get it sorted

octoegg · 02/10/2023 13:39

Hope you get it sorted. Someone used my email address for their Vietnamese bank account so I get an email every time they make a transaction. I contacted the bank and they too said they can't do anything about it, the owner has to change the email address on their account, so it all just gets sent to my spam now. Nowhere near as annoying as your situation but just to say I understand how crackers it is these huge businesses can be so tech useless!

HashtagShitShop · 02/10/2023 13:20

Thank you! :) Email sent to CEO complete with screenshots and report made to the Information Comissioner.

I've also received a message on Twitter telling me that it will be fed back to the team internally but it cannot be stopped and that they apologise but can do nothing further to stop it (this was whilst I was still composing my email) and it was followed up by then asking me for feedback on the level of support I have received and asked if it had solved my problem. It'd be laughable if it wasn't so bloody stupid!

OP posts:
Reallybadidea · 02/10/2023 12:12

I wonder whether you could have a case for complaining to the information commissioner's office? www.ofcom.org.uk/phones-telecoms-and-internet/advice-for-consumers/problems/tackling-nuisance-calls-and-messages/spam-texts

HashtagShitShop · 02/10/2023 12:08

socialdilemmawhattodo · 02/10/2023 12:06

It is not a breach of GDPR on their part - you are not asking for Sainsbury to provide you with another customer's details. That agent has misunderstood. But you could contact the Data Protection team at Sainsbury

https://privacy-hub.sainsburys.co.uk/your-rights

You could perhaps try a subject access route asking explicitly and narrowly for all instances where Sainsbury are processing (being storing, processing, using, sharing etc) your mobile number. The company should review the SAR for other individuals' details - so you might see your number being used against a redacted name. Which could tell you your number is stored more than once on their systems?

But the quantity and frequency of the OTP's possibly suggests a more systemic failure. So perhaps the IT dept need to check settings. But get the Data Protection team to escalate.

Thank you very much I will include this in my ceo email and make a seperate request too.

OP posts:
HashtagShitShop · 02/10/2023 12:07

Absolutely noone. I'm a 24/7 carer, my social circle is mostly online, and my small family are not techy enough to even think of doing it never mind carrying it out other than 1 or 2 that genuinely wouldn't do it. The biggest "beef" in my life is with a useless doctor who keeps trying to stop medication being on repeats even though hospital consultants are getting v peed off with him for doing so as I have to keep getting in touch to correct this.

OP posts:
socialdilemmawhattodo · 02/10/2023 12:06

It is not a breach of GDPR on their part - you are not asking for Sainsbury to provide you with another customer's details. That agent has misunderstood. But you could contact the Data Protection team at Sainsbury

https://privacy-hub.sainsburys.co.uk/your-rights

You could perhaps try a subject access route asking explicitly and narrowly for all instances where Sainsbury are processing (being storing, processing, using, sharing etc) your mobile number. The company should review the SAR for other individuals' details - so you might see your number being used against a redacted name. Which could tell you your number is stored more than once on their systems?

But the quantity and frequency of the OTP's possibly suggests a more systemic failure. So perhaps the IT dept need to check settings. But get the Data Protection team to escalate.

Reallybadidea · 02/10/2023 11:58

They may be correct that these messages are coming from another account using your mobile number. Are you absolutely certain that there is nobody in your life who could be using this as a way to harass you?

HashtagShitShop · 02/10/2023 11:40

They're text messages not coming from the sainsburys site.

I'm in the process of contacting the ceo et al, and just had a reply on twitter from sainsburys. Essentially 'sorry but we won't stop them." (hopefully screenshot has attached) and they're sticking to the story of someone having it on their account which I don't believe.

Receiving Unrequested OTP's from Sainsbury Supermarket
OP posts:
Lougle · 02/10/2023 05:18

Are you using Android?

You could try specifically blocking push notifications from the Sainsbury's site:

Allow or block notifications from a specific site
On your Android device, open Chrome Chrome.
Go to the site from which you want to change notifications.
To the left of the address bar, tap Lock Lock and then Permissions.
If a menu opens: Select the setting that you want to change.
If no menu opens: Permissions are in their original settings.

HashtagShitShop · 02/10/2023 00:09

It's also interesting to note that I have others I've blocked like Yours Clothing and Temu who I don't get notified about having messages from, they just arrive and go into the blocked part of messages and I know nothing about it until I open that section of the app to occasionally delete them.

Then there's Sainsburys in that same blocked bit of the app with '' blocked' appearing in the thread showing that I've blocked then ... But I get notified of their messages each time ? So so weird!

OP posts:
HashtagShitShop · 02/10/2023 00:05

Thank you all!

Unfortunately @lougle I don't have the options to report spam, only to block (that doesn't block them, it's weird! Even my network can't explain how they're getting through other than its because they have no nunber so nothing can be 'blocked'. It was all they could come up with. We'e you suffering the same issue? I note a lot of otps there.

@Iamanicelady thanks but I'm android not apple.

@Titective I shall add them to the people to email tomorrow, fabulous thank you!

@Reallybadidea thank you but weirdly like they can get round the blocking on the messaging app, they can also get round the do not disturb. Even my network doesn't know 100 percent why the messages aren't blocked even though I've blocked them! I will check the notifications only silence thank you. The relative I live with can often just shout for me or sometimes come wake me if they need me but sometimes it's not possible so they ring from their mobile which is a stable number as is the care home. The issue is hospitals and doctors etc with private numbers.

Im sorry that happened to you @Oopsupsideyourheadache especially at a time of such stress. Glad you got it sorted! I hate that it takes so much to get something that should be so simple sorted!

@Delphigirl thar sounds like it could be an expensive route to set up!

@Hobbes8 thsts encouraging to hear that it can get sorted that quickly. Hopefully this is similar. I'd just relaxed to try get some sleep.... Only for one to arrive 2 minutes ago.

@socialdilemmawhattodo thank you for the heads up. I'm sorry that happened to you. Unfortunately sainsburys customer service are very similar. They're adamant that they've sorted it by "removing the nunber from my account" which they'd said they'd done before and that didn't help it and if it is on someone else's account as they've claimed it doesn't explain the volume of otps at the same time each day (surely it'd be a huge volume at once and then stop when they didn't come through and we're investigated? And then not happen again and again months later?). They are very much not interested in helping, I assume because it's not an easy fix. They're not even trying this time. There's one staff member who replies really quite coldly in particular.

OP posts: