Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to give partner a key?

113 replies

applecakes4 · 01/10/2023 16:26

Me and my partner don't live together but he has asked me several times now for a key to my house.

I dont really feel comfortable doing this for several reasons.

I dont have key to his place.

I am the one who is always hosting, I dont think I have been to his place for years.

Most days he will want to come to mine.

I am currently pregnant and we see hoping to find somewhere but it is proving difficult.

His reasoning is that if something happens to me he will need to gain access urgently.

We have had a rocky relationship and when I needed somewhere to stay many years ago he made it clear he didn't want me living with him.

Things are a lot better now in our relationship but I just dont feel comfortable giving him a key to my house.

OP posts:
DinnaeFashYersel · 02/10/2023 00:55

He's not your 'partner'

He's your sperm donor.

applecakes4 · 02/10/2023 00:45

RantyAnty · 02/10/2023 00:21

Congrats on the baby.

I wouldn't give him a key.

It sounds like the relationship with him has run it's course and just being co parents might work best.

You can start to phase him out with saying no sometimes to him staying over.
Then work out a visitation schedule after the baby is born.

Does he pay for food or anything for all the time he stays over?

The relationship probably has run its course and thank you on the congratulations.

He will eat my food but buy his own food and take it back with him when he goes home.
He never contributes towards anything

He is messy too and treats my place as if it is his own place.

I will tell him that I don't want him to have a key and to stop coming over as it stops me sleeping and also mention the issue that I have not been to his place for years.

I think he assumes that once baby is here he will move in with me, rent his place out, and leave me to pay all the bills and look after the baby whilst he works.

Co parenting seems the best option to be honest.

OP posts:
RantyAnty · 02/10/2023 00:21

Congrats on the baby.

I wouldn't give him a key.

It sounds like the relationship with him has run it's course and just being co parents might work best.

You can start to phase him out with saying no sometimes to him staying over.
Then work out a visitation schedule after the baby is born.

Does he pay for food or anything for all the time he stays over?

jenpil · 02/10/2023 00:16

You don't want the father of your child and current partner in your house?

Even worse, when you go over to his house, which you've never been in, he makes you sit outside in the car?!

What kind of a relationship is that?

I fear it's doomed.

Sorry OP, but that set-up is not healthy and it's not right.

SpacePotato · 02/10/2023 00:14

Why the fuck do you allow this man into your house just because he demands it.

Tell him to sleep in his own house.

He's hiding something from you. It's really fucking weird.

GrannypantsMagee · 02/10/2023 00:13

Definitely not unreasonable. Don't give him a key. You need control over your own space in this situation. As well, think carefully about what you put on the child's birth certificate, it's a different issue but important.

SleepingStandingUp · 02/10/2023 00:06

applecakes4 · 01/10/2023 22:25

I'm not really understanding the comments about my pregnancy.

This baby is very loved and wanted and will always come first.

Loads of single women use sperm donors is that disgraceful too?
Why am I any different for wanting a child?

At least I didn't go out and have one night stand with some random guy.

I am not a bad person and have just as much love to offer a child much as the next person.

I'm not sure bringing a baby into this dysfunction mess of a relationship where neither of you really respect each other is actually better than bringing a baby into the world as a single mother.

Personally it sounds like you need to break up and co parent.

SleepingStandingUp · 02/10/2023 00:04

applecakes4 · 01/10/2023 21:51

When we first began a relationship I would visit his house lot.

Yeah he defo lives alone.

When he needs to go to his place he will just leave me outside to sit in the car.

Even when I temporarily moved of of the area and would visit him, I would have to book hotels. He clearly does not want me in his place.

It is a very strange situation but I am getting fed up of him always demanding to come over.

How many nights a week does he sleep over? He's either got someone else, is a massive hoarder or very dirty
Doesn't bode well for if you eventually love together does it
Will he be taking baby there without you?

What would happen if you got out of the car and followed him into the house? Tell him you need to pee

Redruby2020 · 02/10/2023 00:03

There are others out there in similar situations. I know of one couple whom the gf was waiting on housing so would of been stupid to give that up to find alternative accommodation with her bf. He lived with family until she got her permanent place.
She gave the spill about not wanting to live with someone because of last relationship, which is rubbish because it's also not wanting to put bf on tenancy or tell benefits.
So not properly living together officially, but he is there 6-7 days a week, she made it clear bf doesn't pay rent, I can't believe that, yes he works.
Engaged but no marriage I can't see that happening, and then went and had a baby together.
And he uses the place to have his kids over when it's his turn which he got custody to have contact with, so it's all pretty good for him I'd say!

Lieblingsessen · 01/10/2023 23:59

@applecakes4

"I am better being single and just co-parenting with him."

Yes, absolutely.

It's taken awhile but finally you have appeared to see the light! He can wait in his car for you to come out for him to take you to the baby connected appointments. Maybe even attend the birth if you decide you want him to. But you should no longer 'let him in' and should build your life and home around just you and your child.

DreamTheMoors · 01/10/2023 23:58

You don’t have to give him a key if you don’t want to. Don’t let him bully you into it. Tell him you simply don’t want anyone else to have a key and to stop bloody going on about it.

People are being disrespectful and judgmental and rude - don’t give them a second thought.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 01/10/2023 23:56

I thought maybe having a child together would change him and his actions towards me.

Yeah, this doesn't ever happen. This is why women are warned not to fall pregnant to feckless men, every single day.

In terms of him being a father, he has taken me to all my appointments and has offered to help towards the costs of buying baby to things.

Oh wow, father of the year "offering to help", you must be so grateful that a father is "offering to help" pay for his own child. Dear Lord.

Pinkglobelamp · 01/10/2023 23:55

AlltheFs · 01/10/2023 23:39

What an appalling thing to do to a child. The pair of you should be thoroughly ashamed to have created this situation deliberately. What a car crash of a life before they are even born.

You both sound as awful as each other. Dysfunctional and toxic. What a delightful environment, and how to not model normal relationships and behaviours.

It’s marginally excusable in a teenager, absolutely reprehensible in a grown adult.

There's no need to speak like that. OP is pregnant and in need of support, not assumptions and judgement.
I'm sure she's a loving mother and her child will be happy. (She might need some support in realising she really does deserve better and can set some boundaries to look after her and her baby' s needs, though!)

GirlOfTudor · 01/10/2023 23:53

I've just read your updates... you're definitely his side chick. He makes you sit outside in the car instead of popping in to his house and you had to spend money on hotels to visit him when you moved away. This is insane. I'm even more convinced that you're the side chick now.

GirlOfTudor · 01/10/2023 23:41

Wait, you're pregnant with his baby and you don't live with him, haven't been to his house in years and don't want him to have a key to your house?!?! You were in a desperate situation years ago and he refused to let you live with him?! You're his side chick.

applecakes4 · 01/10/2023 23:39

I am just as confused as everyone else on this thread.

His reasoning, thinking and behaviour has puzzled me for years.

We have been together 10 years.
We started trying for a baby pretty much straight away.

The relationship was perfect up until about the 5 year mark.

I never got pregnant in all those years and I genuinely believed I would never become a mothers
My fertility tests were normal and I was diagnosed with "unexplained fertility".

We both really wanted a child, I felt as if I had invested too much to walk away and plus with being in my 30s I really didnt think I would meet anyone, let alone have a child.

He was the only feasible option.

When I fell pregnant I was just so happy and grateful to be given a chance to be a mother.
I literally couldn't believe it when I saw those pink lines and I still can't believe it now.

I thought maybe having a child together would change him and his actions towards me.

In terms of him being a father, he has taken me to all my appointments and has offered to help towards the costs of buying baby to things.

I am better being single and just co parenting with him.

OP posts:
AlltheFs · 01/10/2023 23:39

What an appalling thing to do to a child. The pair of you should be thoroughly ashamed to have created this situation deliberately. What a car crash of a life before they are even born.

You both sound as awful as each other. Dysfunctional and toxic. What a delightful environment, and how to not model normal relationships and behaviours.

It’s marginally excusable in a teenager, absolutely reprehensible in a grown adult.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 01/10/2023 23:39

Oh goodness my mind is wondering why you're not allowed in his house:

  1. Hoarder/lives in squalor
  2. Serial killer and uses his house to dismember the bodies
  3. Child abductor and has children chained up inside

Oh goodness, either way, continue to deny him a key to yours, and additionally, I would no longer let him sleep over while you're pregnant. If you're struggling to sleep because of him then tell him no or just don't let him in, he's no key after all! You NEED your sleep for energy to get through labour...

Lieblingsessen · 01/10/2023 23:32

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 01/10/2023 22:59

What's your plan for when baby arrives? You'll need help and support- him or someone else?

Ha ha. Haven't you seen, or read about it on this site that you can be a single parent without living with the father. A lot of us did it and will continue to do it.

Not everyone lives the perfect mumsnet life of partner, kids, well paid jobs and lovely house in desirable neighbourhood.

OP, having read your updates, you should not only not give him a key to your house, you should deny him access to your home also.

You are not allowed in his house, so tell him he is no longer welcome in yours. Don't waste anymore of your life with him. Instead concentrate on the last stages of your pregnancy and prepare to welcome your baby which I'm sure will be showered with love from you and others around you. You will cope by yourself as many women have done.

If he wants a relationship with his child let him, but it doesn't mean he has a right to to any romantic relationship with you ever again.

cakecoffeecakecoffee · 01/10/2023 23:31

If you were wanting to be a single parent then I’d get why you’re having the baby.

But surely you can see that it’s a really unhealthy dynamic to raise a child in.

seriously, end it now and at least raise the child with clear boundaries on the relationship.

Isittimeformynapyet · 01/10/2023 23:17

applecakes4 · 01/10/2023 21:51

When we first began a relationship I would visit his house lot.

Yeah he defo lives alone.

When he needs to go to his place he will just leave me outside to sit in the car.

Even when I temporarily moved of of the area and would visit him, I would have to book hotels. He clearly does not want me in his place.

It is a very strange situation but I am getting fed up of him always demanding to come over.

Is he a hoarder? Or lives like a pig and is ashamed of his place? Might it smell of dead bodies?

Making you wait in the car makes me SO curious 🤔

CountessKathleen · 01/10/2023 23:14

applecakes4 · 01/10/2023 22:25

I'm not really understanding the comments about my pregnancy.

This baby is very loved and wanted and will always come first.

Loads of single women use sperm donors is that disgraceful too?
Why am I any different for wanting a child?

At least I didn't go out and have one night stand with some random guy.

I am not a bad person and have just as much love to offer a child much as the next person.

A ONS would suggest better judgement than this semi-detached mess. Are you planning for this man who lets you sit in the car outside his house rather than enter, doesn’t respect your boundaries, and whom you don’t trust enough to give a key to to be on your baby’s birth certificate? If you don’t trust him with a key, will you trust him to look after your baby?

AFieldGuideToTrees · 01/10/2023 23:07

OP, I understand your need for a baby.

But why does this man have to appear in your life other than as father to the baby?

The whole set up is weird and you don't want him around, so dump him, be stronger this time, don't give in to the pleadings of someone you don't want in your home.

Definitely don't give him a key.

It's so unfair on your child to bring them into this relationship. It will affect them from the beginning.

crumblingschools · 01/10/2023 23:05

Why did you think he would be a good father?

OhComeOnFFS · 01/10/2023 23:02

He wasted so many years of my life.

Don't let him waste another minute of your life.

When he's at your house, does he contribute towards food and bills?

Swipe left for the next trending thread