Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do I just suck this up? Building costs

36 replies

norma1980 · 01/10/2023 13:41

Hi

2 brothers applied for planning permission for 2 houses on same site next door to each other.

Each house was to be built by each brother as their home.

Permission for both houses needs to implemented very soon or it will expire and may not be granted again so needs to be implemented.

We're going to implement and satisfy pre commencement conditions now so don't lose permission.

It's costing us £5k to do this - minimum works being carried out.

Our works implement the permission for bother houses so we're also saving the brothers house from expiring.

He's not paying a penny.

Difficult because builder will only be pouring the corners of the garage for our house (that's all we're doing to implement permission) so it's on our site but basically implementing brothers house.

I'm pissed off. Not sure house else to work it. He's intending to build out so he is benefitting as well.

I just know if it was him spending £5k he'd ask for a contribution and make a big scene he has before.

My husband is scared of brother and won't raise it.

I'm not well off this £5k is coming from savings.

Do I just need to suck this up - that it's fair brother not contributing despite benefitting from our works? Any other way we can do this please?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
norma1980 · 02/10/2023 10:53

Good point @TiredandLate I just need to get over this.

OP posts:
TiredandLate · 02/10/2023 10:48

You can't have it all ways, you are doing this for your benefit, and upset that it benefits the brother too. The cost to you to increase the value of the land is £5k. If this is important to you, for the inheritance, then do it. Forget what the brother is or isn't doing. Weigh up whether the £5k spent now will give you a good return in the long run. If you'd happily lose the value on the land to spite the brother then do that.

norma1980 · 02/10/2023 10:42

@Oooooooooooo1 yes the brother's idea. No contract and no discussion. Tried to get permission varied for one of the houses (which would've meant each house then effectively had own permission) but planners said no. Any variation would need to cover both houses.

OP posts:
Oooooooooooo1 · 02/10/2023 09:52

The whole thing is ill thought out. Did you not have a contract agreed? Utter madness
Was this initially the brothers idea?

norma1980 · 02/10/2023 09:46

@smartiesnskittles one of the planning conditions is that the plot is divided in 2 with a hedge so that's what we would intend and we will protect the plot but ultimately he'll have an empty field next to him for his use.

It's not that we can't afford £5k but if it's a wasted cost then prefer not to spend it.

Just wish DH would have a discussion with brother about this. If brother intending to build his house then better he implements permission. Brother lives in a caravan at present so at some point he'll need to move. I'd contribute obviously to getting any of the brothers foundations poured (as implementation benefits us also) but feels unfair that we're getting hit with whole cost of this especially as not intending to build out.

OP posts:
smartiesnskittles · 02/10/2023 02:02

Surely the brother will start the work not wanting planning to expire? And if he's sneaky enough to twist your arm into paying for it, be careful he doesn't steal your land. Added to his as a garden for years, unused by you could give him rights. Fence it off and lay out the planned house foundation etc.

ManyMaybes · 01/10/2023 21:59

If your plot will become his garden is it even worth much then? Why doesn’t he just buy it off you?

How old are you? Why are you so worried about children’s inheritance? How old are your kids? If they are adults maybe just give them the land and let them figure it out.

But to be honest if you re concerned about stumping up £5k you should be thinking about your own finances before your children’s inheritance as it sounds like you don’t have much financial flexibility. Do you have sufficient pensions?

norma1980 · 01/10/2023 21:46

@lljkk other way around. We're not building our house but he is building his house so our plot will likely become his garden

OP posts:
lljkk · 01/10/2023 20:36

So their plot becomes your large patio? Not all bad, maybe?

norma1980 · 01/10/2023 20:19

Hi @LIZS it's a permission for 2 houses. No occupational restrictions or other restrictions. It was borderline passed before hence not confident would be passed again.

I suppose I thought that as the brother is intending to build out and we're not it would've made sense for him to incur the £5k as (as others have said) this will be taken off the total build cost and so if he's intending to build the house it won't go to waste but with me it will

OP posts:
LIZS · 01/10/2023 17:57

If pp were that exceptional , are you sure you could freely sell it on for profit or is it tied to a specific use ie agricultural work or family which would seriously limit its market.

norma1980 · 01/10/2023 17:47

Hi thanks everyone for making it make sense -

yes it's true that the £5k would go off the build should the house ever be built out.

I'll just suck it up - I have to. Land is for kids.

The brother was very unfair on another matter so I'm not keen on him hence i don't want to live next door.

We relied on an exception under planning policy to get permission and wouldn't be granted permission again as exception doesn't exist now.

Thanks everyone appreciate it can sleep easier

OP posts:
Hufflepods · 01/10/2023 17:45

It’s incredibly unlikely that planning permission would be refused for the exact same proposal which has already been approved.

LIZS · 01/10/2023 17:44

But it is only worth the extra if you can sell it. If both dwellings are planned for a single plot and you do not get along with the co-owner, how likely is it you can split it to sell. If pp was granted once, it is unlikely it would not be again, even on greenbelt under current planning policy.

norma1980 · 01/10/2023 17:41

The value of the land will go up by £40k with planning permission implemented on land. Its for kids inheritance. Though if I died tomorrow I think my husband would built the house.

It's a house in countryside so very difficult to get permission for a house in countryside so if let permission expire unlikely get permission for house on same site and value of land will decrease

OP posts:
GabriellaMontez · 01/10/2023 16:57

If you're not planning to build or sell, what are you planning?

smartiesnskittles · 01/10/2023 16:54

Just let planning permission expire.

Hufflepods · 01/10/2023 15:11

I honestly don’t get your reasoning. If you don’t plan to build why does it matter if the planning permission lapses? Why start work on the ground to continue the planning when you don’t need it?
You can just apply for the lapsed planning when you need it.

The brother who wants to build can either start doing it before his planning permission has expired or deal with the consequences.

If two people bought two separate plots and applied for planning they shouldn’t be linked in any way.

anqldbjo · 01/10/2023 15:08

norma1980 · 01/10/2023 13:57

Hi @anqldbjo - no I'm not intending to build our house out. Brother is intending to build his whole house out and live there.

We could've waited to see if they started commencement works first (and we would've offered half) but didn't want to risk losing permission so we've just got on with it. Brother knows and has been consulted.

So why are you bothered if the permission expires if you're not intending to build? Seems stupid to pay for something you don't intend to use.

fridaynight1 · 01/10/2023 15:02

If you aren’t ever planning on building a house on the plot, why are you putting foundations in?
Seems a great way of throwing good money at nothing.
Keep it in the bank.

WithManyTot · 01/10/2023 14:59

By making a start you are preserving your own planning permission. By pouring your corners, you are making £5K of progress against the eventual final build cost of the house. Your brother is making no progress on his build by you laying corners.

You could ask your brother to pour his pads too, but he doesn't have to. You could let PP expire and re-apply for just one house, if you fancy the risk.

I'd just suck it up, pour your pads and sleep easy....

inloveandmarried · 01/10/2023 14:57

I completely understand your frustration.

You both applied for planning as a whole (both sites) and it was granted.

It's about to lapse which means you will then have to reapply unless you are seen to be starting works.

At this point the permission is indefinite as I understand.

Your frustration is that you've had to fund the starting of works to secure planning doesn't lapse. The other brother hasn't bothered and would have let it lapse.

You have inadvertently have benefited the brother who now has open ended planning on his portion of the plot.

I think although this could have been done differently, but you haven't actually paid out any more that you'd have to anyway. It's just the timing has forced you to pay out sooner.

As you are only laying partial concrete foundations on your side he's not getting more from you than extended permission.

I think, although it's annoying when someone should step up, in this case he's inadvertently benefitted.

You'd need to do this work to secure your planning anyway and it's a cost you'll not have to pay out for again. Whereas he'll also have to pay to have foundations laid when his time comes.

The reality is you've saved him having to take this back to planning. I hope he'll be at least saying thank you!

Sparehair · 01/10/2023 14:55

This sounds like a nightmare. Is this a case of the brothers jointly inheriting the plot which is why you went for joint planning permission ? If so I would let the pp lapse and then legally split the plot so that they own half each rather than jointly owning all of it. Otherwise if you don’t intend to build yours up it’s basically worthless.

smallshinybutton · 01/10/2023 14:51

norma1980 · 01/10/2023 13:53

@smallshinybutton - husband won't sell plot.

Leave it to husband to deal with then

AgentProvocateur · 01/10/2023 14:43

So you’ve had pp for 5 years and Don’t intend to build? Are you planning to sell the plot with pp? If not, just let it lapse.