Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Irritated that ExH gf wants to meet me to discuss 'parenting' before meeting kids

605 replies

EmsHugs · 01/10/2023 12:56

Ex and I have been separated for 18 months. We have 2 kids 3 & 7. Was a bit on/off for first few months of seperation. We drifted apart but have never started divorce proceedings, he will still come stay over when looking after kids if I'm on night out etc. Amicable.
He told me he was dating at the start if the year which was a but if a gut punch but I just read that to be snagging about and hooking up (fair enough, lack of sex was one of his reasons for splitting) however it turns out he has been seeing someone for 4'5 months. At the drop off this morning, he had said she would like to meet the kids but feels that given their age, she should meet me first so that I can see who it is they are spending time with. He gave me a letter from her that basically reads like a CV. It has got me properly riled up and I'm not sure why, feels a bit like she is trying too hard to be nice and certainly too soon to 'co-parent'.

Amongst other things she wants to know:
My parenting 'non-nos'
Their ideal bedtime routine
What activities I would prefer she didn't do etc
My preferred methods of discipline
She wrote she wants to ensure consistency but frankly I think this is all OTT for someone who he has only been seeing for 5 months. Plus how about asking their father who was pretty hands on.

I text him and asked him when he was planning to introduce them and he said he was going to do it within the next few weeks on a day out Pumpkin picking and then the plan was to do an over night and hopefully then they would all go to the lapland santa thing he had booked for him and the kids at the start of December. Seems like he has had this planned for a while.
A bit of social media snooping shows they have been a thing officially since April but he has been liking her pictures for over a year. He said they met online over a year ago and have been messaging for ages but they only started dating 6 months later. Is that not a bit weird?

FYI has no kids, seems never to have been married. Not sure if Ex and kids are a nice wee ready made family for her.

Would like to know:
YABU - she is respecting you as a mother and doing best by the kids, meet her and be the bigger person and maintain the somewhat good relationship you have with the Ex

YANBU -I'd be pissed off and tell her and Ex it is a bit soon.she is over stepping

OP posts:
aSofaNearYou · 03/10/2023 11:29

@Panaa I've seen plenty of women on here insisting they must meet the new GF before they meet the kids, and planning on laying out a lot of rules when they do so. When challenged they often say "how else am I meant to tell her how I expect the children to be cared for?"

I don't agree with those people but it is very common, on MN at least. This is a consequence - there are people out there giving prospective step parents the impression that this is what they want and expect.

Panaa · 03/10/2023 11:20

aSofaNearYou · 03/10/2023 10:16

The majority are women in here. Can anyone come forward please and give me a single example of the reverse situation where an ex husband has had a letter and invitation to coffee from mum’s new friend Steve - just wanting to make sure Dave is happy with him and they can talk about how Steve should parent Dave’s three year old daughter? Anyone? Because my own EXH would have lost his shit if I had done that.

No, but I can also think of many examples of mum's demanding to meet their ex's new partners, and lay down lots of rules with the expectation that the new GF will be providing lots of hands on care. I don't see that in reverse.

It works both ways. People are trying very hard to deny that here but it does. Yes the GFs approach was OTT - but she's only mirroring exactly what many mothers on forums exactly like this one genuinely so expect and demand of new partners.

Expecting loads of hands on care right off the bat doesn't happen at all in my experience.

At the start most mums struggle with the new girlfriend doing any of the mammy work and definitely don't demand it at all. Most mums want a casual, gradual approach...and I know with my friends etc they've been upset the first time they heard a new woman tucked their kids into bed or comforted them when they fell etc.

Later on, once the mother has got used to it and is over the introduction then if the woman is in the childs life properly and all dads access time is when the woman is there then that tends to be when the rules come in.

Panaa · 03/10/2023 11:19

GilbertMarkham · 03/10/2023 11:12

*Moving in together after a year - Normal and healthy.

Stepping into 'stepmum' role after a year - Can be normal and healthy and generally happens gradually*

Not sure where the arbitrary year is coming from, but just to point out - a year is not a remotely long time in terms of a child coming to terms with the disintegration of their original family unit, their parent having a new partner, and that partner moving into their home/their space and being inescapable. The reality is that if they had any true choice, they'd probably prefer they didn't move in.

A year is also not long enough to properly get to know someone whom you're not even living with full-time. As this board shows over and over again.

No wonder kids have so many issues when their parents think times scales like these are reasonable.

Edited

I just used a year to provide an example of how time generally makes the difference between whether something is healthy or batshit.

I said can be normal and healthy, not that it always is, and also that it generally happens gradually, and not the way this woman seems to see it which very much comes across as "I am a stepmum now".

My main point being that people think the woman is doing a good thing......which I would agree with IF this was further down the line......but doing it from day 1 is batshit and overstepping.

NosyJosie · 03/10/2023 11:14

@GilbertMarkham - I do have skin in the game and here’s how it went which is why I am very sceptical of this situation all round.

Immediately after we split up, she was introduced out of the home as a friend. Then the popping in and going for walks began

This takes us to roughly the point OP is at right now or will be in a few weeks.

Three months after he moved out he asked her to drop the children back to me.
She pushed for this as she “wanted to be part of his whole life”
He pushed for this because he thought she was amazing and such a good person (in the care profession)
Meanwhile my kids are sleeping in my bed every night for nearly a year trying to come to terms with their dad being gone.

Let me pause here to highlight the last point. Their dad was chaotic. Trying to get divorced, moving house, accommodating a new relationship, work - even if he saw the kids, it was rarely alone without her and it was all Disneyland and Facebook posts but he just wasn’t truly present.

With her quickly being referred to as stepmum and being in charge of the bulk of the parenting, often without him being there, things quickly turned sour and I’d be getting texts from her about things I should do different or hadn’t done to her expectations. Read that again.

Meanwhile, when I introduced someone a full two years after we split, the kids would get interrogated about the most minute details about this man.

At no point through all this did I slag off the dad or her to the kids. She’s welcome to him. I played nice at the door drops, I tried to smooth waters when the kids were angry at him or her. Or just the situation in general. Sadly, in the process of getting her shoehorned into their lives, they were not able to be as considerate and have on several occasions voiced to the kids that I did this or didn’t do that.

Roll on to my kids being teens, they have a shitty and volatile relationship with their dad, don’t fully trust her or him as they are not consistent, and sadly one of them put two and two together and worked out that their relationship started as an affair. I don’t know if one of their friends told them or if they just did the maths. I got asked about this in the car - great. One of the comments leading up to the big question was “she just got introduced and it all happened so fast”. Again, left to me to manage those emotions as any pushback to my ex and the step mum is met with narcissistic ridicule and gaslighting.

In a separate about death where my kids asked what happens if I died, I asked them as part of that conversation what they thought would happen if their dad died. I am honestly a little shocked as I thought they were closer after all these years but they both laughed and replied that “she’s off”.

There is zero doubt that my ex has used the stepmum responsibilities as a means to and control his relationship with her at various points of the relationship. It is also important for him and many other men to “tick the boxes” and show the world their success as a man. Married by 30, millionaire by 35 etc etc. This ramps up even more if the man in question is a narcissist which I am not saying the OP’s ex is. But he is a man.

OP you must be exhausted from this thread and I wish you nothing but the best as you navigate the way forward. Be the constant, be the light, and don’t forget yourself in all this.

GilbertMarkham · 03/10/2023 11:13

The fact that the childrens father isn't even aware she's approached OP too

I didn't realise that at all, I thought the Dad passed the letter to op.

That's even worse.

GilbertMarkham · 03/10/2023 11:12

*Moving in together after a year - Normal and healthy.

Stepping into 'stepmum' role after a year - Can be normal and healthy and generally happens gradually*

Not sure where the arbitrary year is coming from, but just to point out - a year is not a remotely long time in terms of a child coming to terms with the disintegration of their original family unit, their parent having a new partner, and that partner moving into their home/their space and being inescapable. The reality is that if they had any true choice, they'd probably prefer they didn't move in.

A year is also not long enough to properly get to know someone whom you're not even living with full-time. As this board shows over and over again.

No wonder kids have so many issues when their parents think times scales like these are reasonable.

DeeCeeCherry · 03/10/2023 11:10

GilbertMarkham·

She seems sensible, calm, experienced, responsible..

No she fkg doesn't

She's dating a still legally married Dad of young kids who's been separated less than 18 months for 20 weeks max. (!!!!) and she's going on like this. She's lost the plot, and seems to be in good company with their Dad ATM

Exactly. Posters falling over themselves to approve of her ridiculous actions and put OP in the wrong, are either just rushing to be part of the majority consensus or overly impressed that girlfriend is a headteacher. I saw her described as 'Stepmum' somewhere upthread FFS. & she's been around for mere months yet already talking about 'parenting?!'

The fact that the childrens father isn't even aware she's approached OP too, she's just gone ahead and done this off her own bat. Talk about speedy & needy🚩🚩🚩

GilbertMarkham · 03/10/2023 11:04

AliceOlive · 03/10/2023 10:28

Their parents aren't even divorced.

Wait what?! I missed that rather key point.

Ex and I have been separated for 18 months. We have 2 kids 3 & 7. Was a bit on/off for first few months of seperation. We drifted apart but have never started divorce proceedings

The thread title is misleading.

This is very early days for a 3 and 7 year old whose parents have split up, and incredibly early days re the Dad's new relationship of 5 months or less. These people seem to be in an incredible rush/getting carried away; and really not prioritising the kids.

People think she's good for contacting op about looking after and interacting with and disciplining (!) these kids .... If she was "good" she wouldn't be meeting them, let alone planning on going on family type days out and trips away with them from 4/5 months in.

The Dad's head is up his arse for doing this too.

GilbertMarkham · 03/10/2023 10:57

She seems sensible, calm, experienced, responsible..

No she fkg doesn't.

She's dating a still legally married Dad of young kids who's been separated less than 18 months for 20 weeks max. (!!!!) and she's going on like this.
She's lost the plot, and seems to be in good company with their Dad ATM.

And I say that as someone who dated a man with kids in my 30s (when I had none).

Aside from their accelerated "timetable", she can ask their Dad, her boyfriend, all this stuff.

Does the op have special woman's powers that he doesn't or something. She says he's a good Dad.

GrannyHelen1 · 03/10/2023 10:48

It sounds as though she's trying to be considerate, but is making rather heavy weather of it all, and assuming a step-mum role somewhat prematurely. I can absolutely see why it's grinding your gears a bit. Why not tell her, as casually as possible, to relax, and leave the parenting details to your ex, as her role will simply be that of a kind friend?

Panaa · 03/10/2023 10:45

GilbertMarkham · 03/10/2023 10:04

The majority are women in here. Can anyone come forward please and give me a single example of the reverse situation where an ex husband has had a letter and invitation to coffee from mum’s new friend Steve - just wanting to make sure Dave is happy with him and they can talk about how Steve should parent Dave’s three year old daughter? Anyone? Because my own EXH would have lost his shit if I had done that.

Exactly, it's bizarre.

It's totally ott.

It's also quite chauvanist - because it suggests the male parent can't parent on his own and guide his partner where appropriate. It's "women's stuff" that she needs to discuss with the mother. Why? He's the kids parent too. A supposedly equal parent, why does she need to be having a stewards enquiry with the mother, whom she doesn't even know.

In general this woman sounds invested within a 5 month relationship with a not even divorced Dad to a level.that does not suggest good, sound sense and moderation.

The Dad should also not be introducing her this early ..... Very poor judgement on his part. And it's not even a casual introduction; it's a rapidly ramping up one with activities usually done by families.

I have to say that personally I wouldn't mind the chauvinist attitude, with my ex anyway because he is pretty shit.

And I would actually appreciate being asked, but NOT before she met the kids or before they had got used to her being around.

Before she met them or as they got used to her being around I'd be very happy if she asked was there any major no nos in regards to treats/food etc.

But discipline/bedtime etc....no way. I would appreciate that conversation a bit down the line though.

As with most things there's a point where something tends to be normal and ok but there's a point where things are batshit and overstepping.

Saying I love you after a few months - Normal and healthy
Saying I love you after 2 days - Abnormal, most likely lovebombing.

Moving in together after a year - Normal and healthy
Moving in together after a week - Abnormal, extremely risky

Stepping into 'stepmum' role after a year - Can be normal and healthy and generally happens gradually, However some will still be 'detached' from that role at that point.
Stepping into 'stepmum' role before even meeting the kids - Abnormal, risky

AliceOlive · 03/10/2023 10:28

Their parents aren't even divorced.

Wait what?! I missed that rather key point.

GilbertMarkham · 03/10/2023 10:19

can you imagine a man writing a letter like this to another man, assuming he would immediately take over parenting for his new girlfriend’s children?

He would be presumed to be a control freak. He'd be presumed to be domineering. And inappropriate.

In a woman, this isn't much better, it's inappropriate. As I said, the kindest possible explanation would be she's neurodiverse, but I don't even think it's that.

A half way well adjusted women in this position would take it very very slowly and easily with the introduction to the children, and take her cue from their Dad, and not contact the Mum unless the Mum reached out.
But then a halfway well adjusted woman would probably not being dating a still married man, only 14 (?) months separated, with small kids, or at the very least would not be going along with an introduction at only 5 months in.

Her apparent desperation to be the "best girlfriend ever" and show herself to be the best potential step Mum ever, and probably to create a blended family within a similarly accelerated timescale (if she's in her 30s, she may be affected by the clock ticking) .. is written all over this.

It is the "ex" husbands responsibility to manage this, and he's not exactly doing a good job.

aSofaNearYou · 03/10/2023 10:16

The majority are women in here. Can anyone come forward please and give me a single example of the reverse situation where an ex husband has had a letter and invitation to coffee from mum’s new friend Steve - just wanting to make sure Dave is happy with him and they can talk about how Steve should parent Dave’s three year old daughter? Anyone? Because my own EXH would have lost his shit if I had done that.

No, but I can also think of many examples of mum's demanding to meet their ex's new partners, and lay down lots of rules with the expectation that the new GF will be providing lots of hands on care. I don't see that in reverse.

It works both ways. People are trying very hard to deny that here but it does. Yes the GFs approach was OTT - but she's only mirroring exactly what many mothers on forums exactly like this one genuinely so expect and demand of new partners.

GilbertMarkham · 03/10/2023 10:11

The accusations of jealousy from the second wives etc on here are totally off the mark and rather abhorrent.

I'm not a "first wife", I have no skin in this game and this whole situation is, to me, fucked up.

Both the timing of the introduction and the gf's behaviour.

They are clearly deep in the honeymoon stage (and the gf seems incredibly heavily invested) and are thinking of noone but themselves. Not these young kids whose family broke up 18 months ago (with to'ing and fro'ing by their parents within that period too). Their parents aren't even divorced. As I said, most of the condiments in my fridge are a lot older than the Dad's new relationship.
The reality of being in a relationship with a parent, especially when you are not a parent yourself, can be very different and very much more challenging (and very much more potentially relationship sinking) than people think.

This is not school. It's not a teacher, pupil relationship.

She sounds like she's going at it like she's in her profession; can't even realise it's completely different.

GilbertMarkham · 03/10/2023 10:04

The majority are women in here. Can anyone come forward please and give me a single example of the reverse situation where an ex husband has had a letter and invitation to coffee from mum’s new friend Steve - just wanting to make sure Dave is happy with him and they can talk about how Steve should parent Dave’s three year old daughter? Anyone? Because my own EXH would have lost his shit if I had done that.

Exactly, it's bizarre.

It's totally ott.

It's also quite chauvanist - because it suggests the male parent can't parent on his own and guide his partner where appropriate. It's "women's stuff" that she needs to discuss with the mother. Why? He's the kids parent too. A supposedly equal parent, why does she need to be having a stewards enquiry with the mother, whom she doesn't even know.

In general this woman sounds invested within a 5 month relationship with a not even divorced Dad to a level.that does not suggest good, sound sense and moderation.

The Dad should also not be introducing her this early ..... Very poor judgement on his part. And it's not even a casual introduction; it's a rapidly ramping up one with activities usually done by families.

Panaa · 03/10/2023 10:02

Justrolledmyeyesoutloud · 03/10/2023 04:11

Different strokes for different folks eh? As a possible future step parent she will be fucked anyway.
Op needs to tell her ex if she feels the new gf is oversteppping. Nice to be labelled a gaslighter for saying how l would deal with this!

Plenty of stepmums get on well with the mums, this whole 'stepmums are fucked anyway' is mumsnet bullshit that people seem to say so that the mum is always made to be unreasonable even when her requests are perfectly reasonable.

I got on very well with my exes girlfriend despite her being introduced after a week. I wouldn't have called her a stepmum because she didn't try to get that close at all. There were some hiccups at the start such as when I found out she was putting my kids on her snapchat story etc. but those issues were sorted quickly.

I haven't met my exes current girlfriend but I like her from what I've heard. Their dad has very little contact now and would have even less if it wasn't for this girlfriend because I don't like him being around my youngest alone, and my child doesn't want to be either (the girlfriend will tell him to stop when he's annoying her or shouting at her etc). I know she does stuff like give my youngest child energy drinks which I wouldn't do, but I just leave her to it as it's rare and I appreciate the rest of the stuff she does for the kids when she's with them.

By the sounds of it they are close to splitting up......after living together for less than a year, apparently they were talking about marriage recently....which just shows why it is so important to take things slowly and not become a new mother figure straight away, because there are no guarantees that the relationship will last.

I said there seems to be collective gaslighting, which you certainly seem to be part of. You said the OP had to put her personal feelings aside, making out that it was her 'personal feelings' that made her feel weird about this, which isn't true. A girlfriend acting as stepmum instantly is odd....but you're trying to make the OP think that her reaction is the odd thing, that's gaslighting.

I agree that she should her ex if she feels that way, but the collective gaslighting will make that harder because she will doubt her reaction.

AliceOlive · 03/10/2023 10:01

Deargodletitgo · 03/10/2023 09:52

This reminds me of my DP and his ex wife, she was fine thinking he was off looking for a shag because she felt that was why their marriage ended (her lack of interest in intimacy). When it was apparent we actually have a proper full on relationship, and I met the kids at 6 months, her nose was put out of joint. It's jealously, it's somewhat understandable, but it doesn't make it the new woman's fault.

I experienced that once, and it prevented the relationship from moving forward. But you know, the men often encourage the jealousy.

Like @NosyJosie wrote, can you imagine a man writing a letter like this to another man, assuming he would immediately take over parenting for his new girlfriend’s children?

AliceOlive · 03/10/2023 09:56

T1Dmama · 03/10/2023 08:43

I think it’s kind of nice… my friends ex was seeing someone and she was so upset when the GF straightened her little girls lovely curly hair.This is your opportunity to tell her what things you want saved for you to do the first time.
I think it’s so important that you at least try to get along, you want her to be nice to the kids and it makes communication easier if you can text her occasionally too.
you might want to ask her for example to return school uniform Sunday nights washes and dried if he’s had them since Friday. (So she can remind him to do that!) my friend used to get so wound up that her kids came home Monday night with dirty uniform that she then had to wash and dry and iron for Wednesday as well as working etc

This is so messed up on multiple levels. I never once had to remind my now husband to parent or care for his son. Remind him to wash clothes his own child needs for school? If he can’t manage that he doesn’t have space in his life or brain for another person.

NosyJosie · 03/10/2023 09:54

So many opinions here but there are some glaring things we have not discussed:

  1. What happens is OP does not approve or this first meeting goes tits up?
  2. Regardless of which ‘side’ you are on, nobody is talking about the sheer confusion any child would feel with a new person coming in hot like this. Even done in the most “correct” way, I am not sure EXH has even remotely considered his kids might not be as enthusiastic about this new person while they are getting used to mummy and daddy not being together.
  3. The majority are women in here. Can anyone come forward please and give me a single example of the reverse situation where an ex husband has had a letter and invitation to coffee from mum’s new friend Steve - just wanting to make sure Dave is happy with him and they can talk about how Steve should parent Dave’s three year old daughter? Anyone? Because my own EXH would have lost his shit if I had done that.
Deargodletitgo · 03/10/2023 09:52

This reminds me of my DP and his ex wife, she was fine thinking he was off looking for a shag because she felt that was why their marriage ended (her lack of interest in intimacy). When it was apparent we actually have a proper full on relationship, and I met the kids at 6 months, her nose was put out of joint. It's jealously, it's somewhat understandable, but it doesn't make it the new woman's fault.

Panaa · 03/10/2023 09:40

ensayers · 03/10/2023 03:17

She is trying to set up a civil and amicable arrangement and you are looking for an excuse why you shouldn't meet her part way

No she isn't.

And if she was looking for an 'excuse' then she already has a very valid one, because every single expert on how to introduce kids to new girlfriends/boyfriends would tell you that it should be slow and gradual and don't have the new gf/bf acting like a parent straight away, for lots of reasons.

Panaa · 03/10/2023 09:37

@Mamanyt
I'm shocked at the number of responses saying that she is over-stepping. It seems to me that she is trying very hard NOT to overstep here.

She seems to be, but has still massively overstepped, more so than most new girlfriends, because before she has even met the kids she is acting like she's their stepmum who needs to be quickly got up to speed on how to parent the kids.

Now if she'd wrote the same later saying she will keep it all friendly and casual until they get used to her and she's in their life more but after that if she was more involved she'd love to know everything about their routines, discipline etc so she handled it the same way as the parents.... then that would be absolutely perfect, but to be talking about bedtime and discipline straight away is hugely overstepping even if her intention was to not overstep.

T1Dmama · 03/10/2023 08:43

I think it’s kind of nice… my friends ex was seeing someone and she was so upset when the GF straightened her little girls lovely curly hair.This is your opportunity to tell her what things you want saved for you to do the first time.
I think it’s so important that you at least try to get along, you want her to be nice to the kids and it makes communication easier if you can text her occasionally too.
you might want to ask her for example to return school uniform Sunday nights washes and dried if he’s had them since Friday. (So she can remind him to do that!) my friend used to get so wound up that her kids came home Monday night with dirty uniform that she then had to wash and dry and iron for Wednesday as well as working etc

MargotBamborough · 03/10/2023 07:07

EmsHugs · 02/10/2023 21:54

Please do not post a response unless you have read all my posts.
My exH is an excellent parent and is not being weak to the Gf.
The GF does not have an agenda but just has not benefitted from me finding out about her and getting a letter from her on the same day.
I didn't send the long letter it was more a draft/rant
I have drafted a shorter second response and will likely send that.
I wish to meet the person who will be spending tike particularly with my 3 year old.
One DD's friends goes tot he school she teaches at and apparently she is great and very well liked by kids and parents.
Thank you to those who have responded constructively
Some of you are bat shit crazy I am afraid.

OP it sounds like this situation is pretty hard for you.

It was wrong of your ex to spring this on you at the same time he told you he has a new partner, before you'd had time to get used to the idea that he has someone else in his life now. But it is what it is.

I think that of all the people your ex could have chosen to partner up with, he could have done an awful lot worse than a teacher who is liked by kids and also respects your boundaries as the children's mother. This has the potential to be a really positive thing for all of you.

Please don't worry that she will be better at it than you. She's a teacher, apparently a good one, but she's not their mum. You are. You will always be their mum and they love you. It will be a good thing for them if they like her too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread