Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Irritated that ExH gf wants to meet me to discuss 'parenting' before meeting kids

605 replies

EmsHugs · 01/10/2023 12:56

Ex and I have been separated for 18 months. We have 2 kids 3 & 7. Was a bit on/off for first few months of seperation. We drifted apart but have never started divorce proceedings, he will still come stay over when looking after kids if I'm on night out etc. Amicable.
He told me he was dating at the start if the year which was a but if a gut punch but I just read that to be snagging about and hooking up (fair enough, lack of sex was one of his reasons for splitting) however it turns out he has been seeing someone for 4'5 months. At the drop off this morning, he had said she would like to meet the kids but feels that given their age, she should meet me first so that I can see who it is they are spending time with. He gave me a letter from her that basically reads like a CV. It has got me properly riled up and I'm not sure why, feels a bit like she is trying too hard to be nice and certainly too soon to 'co-parent'.

Amongst other things she wants to know:
My parenting 'non-nos'
Their ideal bedtime routine
What activities I would prefer she didn't do etc
My preferred methods of discipline
She wrote she wants to ensure consistency but frankly I think this is all OTT for someone who he has only been seeing for 5 months. Plus how about asking their father who was pretty hands on.

I text him and asked him when he was planning to introduce them and he said he was going to do it within the next few weeks on a day out Pumpkin picking and then the plan was to do an over night and hopefully then they would all go to the lapland santa thing he had booked for him and the kids at the start of December. Seems like he has had this planned for a while.
A bit of social media snooping shows they have been a thing officially since April but he has been liking her pictures for over a year. He said they met online over a year ago and have been messaging for ages but they only started dating 6 months later. Is that not a bit weird?

FYI has no kids, seems never to have been married. Not sure if Ex and kids are a nice wee ready made family for her.

Would like to know:
YABU - she is respecting you as a mother and doing best by the kids, meet her and be the bigger person and maintain the somewhat good relationship you have with the Ex

YANBU -I'd be pissed off and tell her and Ex it is a bit soon.she is over stepping

OP posts:
Crumpleton · 01/10/2023 16:01

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 01/10/2023 14:52

this OP... reserve judgment as its always better to be on good terms if possible.

Agree with these posters...

While I also agree that you're not wanting them to share a bed with your DD's, maybe the GF wouldn't want to do that either.

As for activities together they're going to happen and it would be a bit strange if your Ex's GF sat there and literally said and did nothing with your DD's so from that point I can understand her, you may have a different view to him for whatever reason, some blokes can be a bit "yeah yeah that's fine". He could have just told the GF not to bother and to do as she sees fit.

Possibly, although not on you're mind just yet but in the future you will meet someone and will introduce the new BF into your girls lives and would hope that your Ex H would be as happy for him to play a part in their lives to.

BoohooWoohoo · 01/10/2023 15:58

In your shoes I'd be concerned that ex expected your serious future partners to do the same as his partner is doing with you.
It sounds like she is worried about you being mad at her when she makes a mistake because she didn't know your opinions on stuff like painting dc's nails or curling their hair. Until you have proof otherwise I'd assume that she has good intentions although I would find it very intense.

CapEBarra · 01/10/2023 15:57

Given your children are going to meet her, and perhaps in the future live with her and your ex for at least part of the time, and she may well become a significant part of their lives, what do you want for your children? Because that’s what you need to focus on - not your anger or angst. How can you arrange things that benefit your children the most?

It’s in their best interests that she understands your values and approaches, so that she can work with you and your ex to provide a stable, well structured, and supportive environment for them, and so that she doesn’t overstep the mark because she hasn’t been told not to do it.

You want your children to be happy and to feel safe with your ex and his girlfriend, however much you don’t like it, and you want a cordial relationship with them both so that if you need them for anything - swapping days/looking after one kid while you take the other to the emergency dentist/swanning off to the Seychelles with your future boyfriend, Keanu Reeves , etc. then help is available without fuss or argument. I’m not saying you need to be best mates or anything, but it would be better for the kids if you started to see her as an ally rather than an adversary. I think you have a great opportunity here, and you should put your hurt aside and grab it.

Sunshinenrain · 01/10/2023 15:57

YABU
She sounds lovely and is making a point of respecting you and your boundaries.

Most new partners wouldn’t give a shit about the ex and would just do what their new partner wants.
But she’s gone out of her way to go over exDH’s head, just to do what you want and not just what he wants.

I think you are very fortunate to have someone like this in your kids life, instead of someone who doesn’t respect you or your boundaries and doesn’t care about the kids.

You are upset because you thought you and DH were on and off (and potentially getting back together?) whereas in his mind you were done ages ago and just had sex every now and then but he physically and emotionally moved on.

I can completely see why you are hurt but you need to separate your anger/jealousy of this relationship vs doing the right thing for your kids.

Hopefully this relationship is going to be long term, as I don’t think you’d get this lucky if he met someone else.

BetterWithPockets · 01/10/2023 15:55

Feliciacat · 01/10/2023 15:45

Hey @EmsHugs. I feel like YANBU as a general statement. It’s true that new gf is being respectful and is wanting to put the children first by being consistent. That’s actually great. However, you’re still not being unreasonable to feel riled up by the situation.

It sounds like you perhaps still hold a candle for exDH? This is particularly understandable given that (from your first post) you are separated but not divorced. Were you hoping that you might get back together given that you hadn’t divorced? I think I would be hopeful in your situation.

From what you said about being surprised that he had been just dating one person, it sounds like you hoped any others he was seeing were ‘just for sex’ and not too serious. I would absolutely feel hurt myself if I found out that a recent ex was serious about someone else. It’s happened to me actually! I rationalised that it was just sex but when she got moved in the week after I moved out then it was hurtful.

I imagine (but only you would know) that this other woman meeting your children and becoming effectively a step parent is really solidifying the idea that your marriage with exDH is over and won’t be getting back on track. That’s a lot to process! I don’t think it’s as simple as you feeling like she’s overstepping the mark; I bet it’s setting thoughts about your relationship in motion that you had hoped weren’t justified.

I’m sorry you’re going through this. Breakups always hurt; even if they were the right choice. Look after yourself and maybe see this new chapter as a chance to focus on you. A lot of women actually enjoy the respite that step parents can bring! At least this new gf sounds respectful to you. Change is hard but I think there’s a lot of promise in the situation if you can get through the hard times that are brewing.

Also: this!

Namerequired · 01/10/2023 15:52

She is trying really hard, too hard tbh, but I think it’s coming from the right place albeit naive. There has to be allowances made for her not being a parent, she hasn’t a clue what she’s getting into.
You don’t sound over him tbh. It sounds like you still see yous as a family, just that he’s living separately and having sex elsewhere. But actually he’s building a family elsewhere and you need to get your head around it.
He told you he was dating, and now he’s told you before introducing his partner to the children. That’s the most he could be expected to do, he didn’t need to keep you updated every step, why would he? They are both trying to be kind and decent and do the right thing.

BetterWithPockets · 01/10/2023 15:51

Oh, OP. This is a hard one, and I say that as a mum, a step mum and a former teacher. I genuinely think she is trying to do right by your children. I also genuinely think that you don’t have to meet her if you don’t want — you shouldn’t feel pressurised into it. However, if she’s going to be in your ExDH’s life (and therefore your DC’s life) for a while, you may end up having to interact with her. That’s very different from meeting her, 1:1, though, and I really really really don’t think that’s necessary — especially if you’re not keen. I also think though that some of your parenting no-nos, and I’m trying to say this gently, are about her not your children. What do you realistically expect her to do if your DC wants to come into the bed of the middle of the night? Get up and sleep elsewhere? My youngest DSS used to come into bed with his Dad and me; it didn’t mean he thought of me as his mum. It just meant he wanted comfort from his dad, and I happened to be there… I get that it’s hard but that bit isn’t up to you. And it may feel/be too soon but if she’s a part of your ex’s life, she’ll be a part of your DC’s life too. And difficult as it may be, there’s nothing you can do about that. BUT you will always be their mum and NOTHING she will do will take away from that. So please try not to feel threatened by her. I’ve been in my DSS’s lives for over ten years now and I love them both dearly — but I’m not and never will be their mum. I know that and so do they and so does their mum. It’s hard, I know, but I genuinely think she’s trying to do right by them…

Mischance · 01/10/2023 15:50

Your emotions and insecurities are normal: feeling that she might do a better job than you; having to let go of the remote possibility that you and OH might amicably get together again etc.

This new woman is not wanting to be the children's Mum - she is wanting to be sure that she gets things right for the children when she (inevitably) has contact with them; and wanting to try and reassure you.

I think that is all positive, and you perhaps need to work on your feelings so that you can begin to see that. Not easy, I know.

Doyoumind · 01/10/2023 15:50

*being

Hygeelady · 01/10/2023 15:49

I think you're being very unreasonable. You must remember that it's about the children. And it sounds like you still have feelings for him, jealous of this woman. I can totally see how it would be really difficult to accept a new women sharing the parenting, if course you didn't want that but when you split up it was inevitable at some stage. They both sound very reasonable to me and you should thank them for that, so many parents cannot do this. You say it's sprung on you, but really it wasn't your business who he was with or in a relationship with if it didn't affect the children, so he's told you when it was going to affect the children. She sounds lovely and very respectful that you are the mother, not her. I really think you need to let this go and try to get along, choose your battles wisely because there are likely to be many along the way...

Doyoumind · 01/10/2023 15:49

After your update with her response I'm still saying YANBU as I did at the start of the thread.

She hasn't even met the children yet. She's getting way ahead of herself in a way I don't interpret as lovely at all. She's not bring respectful as she's inserting herself into a parenting role for children she doesn't even know.

How about meeting them and getting to know them as their dad's girlfriend before getting enmeshed in their lives?

OrangesLemonsLimes · 01/10/2023 15:49

She sounds intense but I think she’s fundamentally a good egg.

He probably should have told you about her existence before the I-want-her-to-meet-the-children conversation, but that’s not her fault. Don’t let his failure to do things properly spoil your relationship with her, a relationship which could be mutually-respectful and cordial by the sounds of it.

notacooldad · 01/10/2023 15:48

She’s not a relative or a friend. She’s a woman their dad is shagging
She isn't some that the dad has just bumped into in Greggs either.
She's been around a while, longer than OP thinks, I'm sure.

( i have known at least two different friends that have gone from dating to marriage and separation quicker than these two have ' officially' been together!!)

EmsHugs · 01/10/2023 15:47

Thanks for reassuring me everyone that I'm not being unreasonable to a point.
As I said I didn't find being a mum easy with the first, soft play etc. Was all very tedious to me. The second DC was a surprise and PND followed soon after all during COVID.
There is a teeny wee voice in my head that is probably scared she will be better at dealing with my children than I am. Like I said my ExH is a bit of a soft touch, so they adore him. Everytime DS is handed back to me, he throws a tantrum and if I do anything DD doesn't like she hates me and wishes she was with Daddy or Granny.
ExH was always better at being a parent and going to the parties and activities, especially as I have spent the last 2 years playing catch up with my career.
I like my children but can't really be bothered with other people's so someone who has literally chosen to work with them and plays an active role in the life of her friends' children seems wild to me. All my issues I know but as soon as I open that dialogue and say yes to that relationship, that could be it. However if I say no, I run such a risk or pissing off my ExH, MiL etc and all the people who I very much need in my life to care for children and work.

OP posts:
Feliciacat · 01/10/2023 15:45

EmsHugs · 01/10/2023 15:11

I'm just split on it. Yes angry I'm only being told about her in the same sentence as meeting the children. Also slightly annoyed as he said he was dating but I presumed multiple not just one . I did think we might reconcile at beginning but happier now we are not together (albeit bloody hard working FT and being a single mum).
Perhaps I am putting my own issues on this, motherhood did not come naturally to me, so I guess the fact he is now with someone so could focused puts me a little on edge incase she does end up a better parent than I. These are my issues I know.
I suppose I am a little sad that we were still doing things as a family fir the sake of the kids but with a new Gf, that will likely have to stop.

Her letter and message however just came across as a little patronising. Speaking to a teacher friend, she said that, it will be as she said our her comfort zone being in a home/intimate setting with children she doesn't know that well.

Very very stupidly she also is very similar in colouring and features to our nanny. I had PND after our 2nd and for a while accused ExH of fancying the nanny. That is me just being 100% stupid now.

It has just thrown my lovely relaxing Sunday for a loop

Hey @EmsHugs. I feel like YANBU as a general statement. It’s true that new gf is being respectful and is wanting to put the children first by being consistent. That’s actually great. However, you’re still not being unreasonable to feel riled up by the situation.

It sounds like you perhaps still hold a candle for exDH? This is particularly understandable given that (from your first post) you are separated but not divorced. Were you hoping that you might get back together given that you hadn’t divorced? I think I would be hopeful in your situation.

From what you said about being surprised that he had been just dating one person, it sounds like you hoped any others he was seeing were ‘just for sex’ and not too serious. I would absolutely feel hurt myself if I found out that a recent ex was serious about someone else. It’s happened to me actually! I rationalised that it was just sex but when she got moved in the week after I moved out then it was hurtful.

I imagine (but only you would know) that this other woman meeting your children and becoming effectively a step parent is really solidifying the idea that your marriage with exDH is over and won’t be getting back on track. That’s a lot to process! I don’t think it’s as simple as you feeling like she’s overstepping the mark; I bet it’s setting thoughts about your relationship in motion that you had hoped weren’t justified.

I’m sorry you’re going through this. Breakups always hurt; even if they were the right choice. Look after yourself and maybe see this new chapter as a chance to focus on you. A lot of women actually enjoy the respite that step parents can bring! At least this new gf sounds respectful to you. Change is hard but I think there’s a lot of promise in the situation if you can get through the hard times that are brewing.

NnarcissaMalfoy · 01/10/2023 15:40

OP this is a very painful situation as the split is quite fresh, I don't disagree with pp that she sounds nice/keen to do the right thing but the 'teacherishness' of her messages would also bother me in your shoes. Rest assured your children will NEVER prefer her to you, no matter how great she is with kids. They know who their mum is. Hugs to you- this news is so fresh (and difficult to reconcile with what you thought was going on ie ex only casually dating) it will take a while to process, don't judge yourself for any of your thoughts and feelings as they all sound normal and understandable to me.

Hibiscrubbed · 01/10/2023 15:39

I’d find it unsettling because it’s still really early on in their relationship, as far as you’re aware, she’s quite intense and extremely earnest. It’s just a bit much, all at once. Especially if you’ve still been doing things as a family and he’s been staying over.

Luckydip1 · 01/10/2023 15:37

YABU

EmsHugs · 01/10/2023 15:36

No formal custody arrangement as I was still on gardening leave when we split. Have been promoted since then and childcare and allocation can vary very much week to week based on both our jobs which are non 9-5. The nanny and my MIL fill in any gaps or issues.
We had just renewed our mortgage when we split (terrible timing) so decided to just stay married for 2 more years until.mortgage was up for renewal, when we agreed we would sell the house and split it 50/50. As I said it has all been for the most part very amicable.
I suppose I have compartmentalised everything and was quite happy with the status quo, had my family life, my house &job without needing to meet the emotional needs etc of a husband. Ideal really.

The letter was a surprise and as I said I felt the tone quite condescending. I do suppose she means well and it may be her professional background coming into play too but it just threw me.

Also nit knowing my exH has been emotionally close with someone for a year and me having no idea is a surprise.

The tone of a letter can vary from reader to reader but she comes across as very serious and by the book which is neither of our styles so I'm curious how having her in our lives will play out. MIL has met her and say she is 'lovely' which suggests ExH is taking this rather seriously as I was the only other gf she has met (and that was after we had been together for over a year, albeit 19 years ago). I suppose things move quicker at this stage. We were together for 9 years before he proposed and 3 years before he even put me on the car insurance or gave me a key to his flat, so this is so quick for him.

OP posts:
Waitingfortheconferencehosttojoin · 01/10/2023 15:36

She and your ex have been together a lot longer than 5 months. Probably for most of the time he’s been liking her Facebook posts.

SummerDayz63 · 01/10/2023 15:34

Can’t edit, just seen your update. She’s actually coming across really well to me. Try and take your emotions out and look at it from a neutral perspective.

UsingChangeofName · 01/10/2023 15:34

Yes angry I'm only being told about her in the same sentence as meeting the children

But, presumably your dh is now at a point where it looks as if this is going to be a longer term relationship. So she is going to be about, when he has the dc, and mentioned in conversation sometimes. There has been no reason to mention her to you at the start of any relationship as at that point, one has no idea if, or how it will develop. This really isn't a bad thing.

Also slightly annoyed as he said he was dating but I presumed multiple not just one
Again, potentially he was to begin with, but now he has found someone with whom he is going to settle into a longer term relationship.

a) it was only your presumption that he was dating multiple people
b) it really isn't any of your business if you have split up
c) neither of them would have known that this might develop into a longer term relationship when they first dated..... you have to sort of 'clcik' with someone for that to happen. It could have been the first person he saw, or it could have been the 50th - you don't really know until you find someone you click with.

I agree with @Fabshab . You are confusing your own issues with this, and the fact you have split, without really accepting you have split, with any issues over the other woman trying her best to work with you on what can often be a really difficult relationship.

Elfandwellbeing · 01/10/2023 15:32

I would thank her for the introduction, and say that there is no expectation for her co parent my children. I can see what you mean she has assumed she that as bed fellow to your ex has a role towards your children when in fact she the gf of their dad, that’s it atm. I don’t agree she is trying to be nice, as far as parenting goes, she should wait to be introduced and not be taking the lead, that is the role of parents.

SummerDayz63 · 01/10/2023 15:31

Honestly OP, I think This relationship is a lot older than 6 months. I’d imagine they’ve been ‘dating’ a lot longer and been ‘official’ for 6 months…

I think it’s good she wants to meet you. I met my ex new girlfriend before she met my kids. We get on great.

The dos and donts are a bit weird… I mean she’s dads girlfriend so surely he is there to parent so she doesn’t actually need to. Surely he understands their bedtime routine etc and if she wants to know these things she can ask him! I’d try and give her the benefit of the doubt but doesn’t come across as great and I’d just maybe go with a loose id like Dad to be in charge of parenting when they are with him…

Ladyj84 · 01/10/2023 15:31

Well I think that's amazing she actually want to try and get it right for your children and is asking you as the mum. I think that's so respectful tbh and your over thinking