Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why some on MN insist on othering only children

66 replies

JaneBirkenstocks · 01/10/2023 09:21

As though they are peculiar. When they're just regular humans who happen not to have a sibling/s.

Since I joined MN when DD (now 18) was a toddler there have been numerous threads asking if onlies are lonely, selfish or bored. More difficult to parent, to teach to share, to socialise.

I've never come across a thread asking what it's like to be the 3rd child in a family of 4. It was fine in case anyone's wondering.

OP posts:
BelindaBears · 01/10/2023 10:32

It’s not just MN, society others only children and their parents too. Hopefully as they become more common people might get over themselves and recognise that families with one child are just as valid.

Gettingbysomehow · 01/10/2023 10:31

It was the same 40 years ago. I was always being asked when I'd have the 2nd. My DS is 40 and has no interest whatsoever in having a sibling, never has. He knows he will inherit everything.

FloorWipes · 01/10/2023 10:31

Obviously everyone has their own experiences of their childhood and their own explanations for those. Overall the research shows there is no problem being an only child. I agree with you OP in the sense that for something that research shows to be not particularly consequential, the focus is really disproportionate. People are clearly insecure about it and I think that’s because it’s tied to a lot of cultural values, beliefs and stereotyping. We’ve already seen a that on this thread.

Fabshab · 01/10/2023 10:31

I’ve never seen them othered

Even in your examples, of course people will ask. As some people want to know when making decisions around adding to their family

Beezknees · 01/10/2023 10:29

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 01/10/2023 09:57

I'm an only child and now have 6 children myself (+ 3 step) but I find only children quite annoying.

The ones I know (still children at the moment) think they're sooo grown up, drinking coffees, and wanting to be involved in the adults' conversations and it's very irritating. Also, they seem to get so much input into their parents' decisions.

Just go and play, you're a child!

Sounds like you're the annoying one.

KajsaKavat · 01/10/2023 10:25

I think because a lot of us had experiences when our DCs were younger with “selfish” and very inconsiderate behaviour from only children which shocked us into thinking they can’t possibly ever learn…

the friends of mine who did choose to have just one did end up with a very independent and helpful person in the household to a degree that one of several sibling didn’t normally do it a not all bad I think

6strings1song · 01/10/2023 10:22

I think the way only children are treated by families varies as much as the way siblings are treated within families. Also depending on sibling age gaps, then older siblings can essentially be only children for quite a long time. Longer age gaps seem more common now (due to cost of living) and the standard 2-3 year gap seems to be extending to 5-6 years.

My DH is a "sort of" only, he has step/half siblings, but didn't live with them. As far as I can tell, he was sort of benignly ignored throughout his childhood and certainly not spoiled. Infact, he often felt he was unable to ask for what he truly wanted (birthdays/Christmas) as there was this unspoken feeling of being a financial burden (he wasn't...there was plenty of money). He was just expected to fit in with whatever the adults were doing and tagged along with very little attention placed upon him. There wasn't any sort of "let's do this activity because little DH would love to experience that". 😕I would say this experience is sadly probably just as common as the "spoiled only" claptrap trotted out on MN.

DH is keen to for us to have more than one DC because of his experiences and tbh I don't blame him.

CountessKathleen · 01/10/2023 10:21

I think part of the minor obsession with it on Mn is that such a significant proportion of posters are misanthropic, socially anxious or socially awkward, and struggle with friendships in general — I see regular references to ‘friends coming and going’ but ‘siblings will always be there’, which I think bespeaks a particular attitude to friendships as difficult, unachievable or unsustainable.

Bluntly, a lot of Mners don’t have many/any friends and struggle with loneliness, and as a consequence don’t have confidence that their child will be able to make and keep a good sustaining circle of friends, thereby fuelling paranoid fears their child will be ‘alone in the world’ once their parents die.

And maybe they’re not wrong, if they’re modelling their attitude to friendships to their child.

WandaWonder · 01/10/2023 10:21

I have an only child by choice and I only think of it when a topic comes up talking about it, nothing anyone can say changes the fact I won't have another child

I am 100% fine with what people say as it is on them not me, I have no desire to have any more children so why would their opinion change that? It works for us so it is what it is

thecatsthecats · 01/10/2023 10:13

It may your perception of having an only that they get othered more than other kids, but I can assure you that people are just mindless twats who flap on about anything regardless of your child's sibling status.

My unborn son is a rapist waiting to happen according to some. He's a footballer in the making because he kicks (girl fetuses presumably expected to remain motionless, then?). It's great I'm having a boy because girls are cliquey and bitchy. It's great I'm having a boy because girls scream the house down.

He's likely to be an only too, so they'll add in their little rules about that too...

I don't know who my boy is yet. His strongest opinions are about music with a particular beat, and me dropping hot tea down my throat onto his feet.

I can't help but notice that it's the dull and hard of thinking who come out with the blandest tripe about who he'll be.

Kitcaterpillar · 01/10/2023 10:13

It is weird, as if other children aren't all strange and messy too. Only children may well have collective quirks (I'm not convinced) but my husband is the fabled eldest son and that hasn't exactly imbued him with a humble and generous spirit.

CarrotJanice · 01/10/2023 10:12

As an only, I think there's many more only children now compared to when I was a kid. Largely due to finances, house size and mothers in general being older these days. In the eighties my mum was one of the older mums at school, and she had me at 25!
Also relationships and family dynamics are different. There's more people (cough dads) in my child's
class who have remarried and have new families. Who wants to have 2/3 children with your new wife when you have 2/3 children already to support?
I think how we expect children to behave has also changed. There's less parents sending children to play 'out the front' as in my day, and in those days I think having a sibling was a massive plus for the parents, so they could protect the other one. Maybe this is just my rough upbringing though Wink

As with everything, context is all. I was an only child to a broke, single mother with no contact with my father. An only child with two well off parents would find it a completely different experience. Also if my mum had remarried, or gone on to have other children, I wouldn't be the same person I was today.
When I was a kid it was quite unusual to be both an only child and have an absent dad. People used to comment on the latter far far more. I've had people make only child quips but less do so when they realise I'm not the 'two parents, showered in praise' kid. I was however awkward and loved chatting to grown ups, drank coffee aged 8 and love old people. That's just personality though, I know many kids who are old souls, not all are only children!

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 01/10/2023 10:09

bookworm14 · 01/10/2023 10:05

Congratulations - you’ve just conclusively proved the premise of this thread.

Would you stereotype literally any other group of people in this way?

I'm simply stating my own experiences of only children.

I'm an only child myself and was ridiculously indulged as a child (finances permitting) and was probably the exact only child stereotype.

JaneBirkenstocks · 01/10/2023 10:05

Seems weird to get upset about this so far along the road

I'm not in the least bit upset, just curious so have started a conversation on it.

Things like learning to share obviously doesn't come up with 2/3/4 children as you presume they will have to learn at home, where they learn to a degree that they are not the centre of everyone's universe

As a former reception teacher, I can assure you that not all siblings learn to share at home!

OP posts:
bookworm14 · 01/10/2023 10:05

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 01/10/2023 09:57

I'm an only child and now have 6 children myself (+ 3 step) but I find only children quite annoying.

The ones I know (still children at the moment) think they're sooo grown up, drinking coffees, and wanting to be involved in the adults' conversations and it's very irritating. Also, they seem to get so much input into their parents' decisions.

Just go and play, you're a child!

Congratulations - you’ve just conclusively proved the premise of this thread.

Would you stereotype literally any other group of people in this way?

FloorWipes · 01/10/2023 10:05

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 01/10/2023 10:03

@SoIinvictus what does QED mean?

It means that you’ve demonstrated exactly what OP is talking about.

FloorWipes · 01/10/2023 10:04

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 01/10/2023 09:57

I'm an only child and now have 6 children myself (+ 3 step) but I find only children quite annoying.

The ones I know (still children at the moment) think they're sooo grown up, drinking coffees, and wanting to be involved in the adults' conversations and it's very irritating. Also, they seem to get so much input into their parents' decisions.

Just go and play, you're a child!

This reflects on you, not the children.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 01/10/2023 10:03

@SoIinvictus what does QED mean?

SoIinvictus · 01/10/2023 10:01

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 01/10/2023 09:57

I'm an only child and now have 6 children myself (+ 3 step) but I find only children quite annoying.

The ones I know (still children at the moment) think they're sooo grown up, drinking coffees, and wanting to be involved in the adults' conversations and it's very irritating. Also, they seem to get so much input into their parents' decisions.

Just go and play, you're a child!

QED.

Thingamebobwotsit · 01/10/2023 10:01

To be honest it isn't just MN. As an only people always saw fit to comment on my lack of siblings growing up and an automatic assumption that you were spoiled (not likely in a poor family with both parents having severe MH/alcohol issues) and that you must be lonely. It came from everywhere, grandparents, friends and new people I met. Used to make me feel like it was my fault for not having siblings. Other only children I know, as adults, also describe this and some even disparage themselves saying they can't cope with x, y or z because they were only children/spoilt etc

At the end of the day it is just a life experience like any other life experience. No worse. No better. Better to not comment on it in my book. And for all my difficulties with my parents growing up, I often thank my lucky stars there wasn't also a sibling to add to the mix. My Mother wouldn't have coped and it would have been even worse.

SoIinvictus · 01/10/2023 10:00

Because their minds are so unable to process that people make different choices, or have different lives.

Anything not done exactly the way they do it is wrong.

It's sad really.

I am the only daughter of an only son and have an only daughter.

We aren't lonely. We aren't social misfits. We didn't spend our childhoods begging for siblings. We don't spend every waking hour wondering and worrying who will wipe our arses when we get old.

Dp is the youngest of 6. I've known him since 1997 and I don't think there has ever been a time in those years that all 6 have been talking to each other, or there isn't some sort of backbiting and fighting going on over money, or that Gran talks about X more than she ever mentions Y ad infinitum. Yet to outsiders, they all bang on about what a united family they are. It's laughable really.

Obviously, as I'm not thick, I don't automatically assume that all large families are like that. Which is what the "oooh you must be lonely" idiots do.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 01/10/2023 09:57

I'm an only child and now have 6 children myself (+ 3 step) but I find only children quite annoying.

The ones I know (still children at the moment) think they're sooo grown up, drinking coffees, and wanting to be involved in the adults' conversations and it's very irritating. Also, they seem to get so much input into their parents' decisions.

Just go and play, you're a child!

AnnaMagnani · 01/10/2023 09:55

It's not just on Mumsnet!

Growing up as an only child, I would get adults asking me all the time 'Are you spoilt?' I mean WTF question is that to ask of a child.

Only children have different experiences but then so do sibling groups. My parents were able to spend more money on me as they only had one, however this was peanuts in comparison to my peer group. They gave me more undivided attention, however this wasn't always a good thing.

Every set of child and parents is different, not all parents are good at parenting, not all siblings like each other, not every only child is happy. Everyone makes the best of their own situation.

ToadOnTheHill · 01/10/2023 09:54

I think I've had both experiences. I lived with a sibling til I was 9, then lived as an only until I move out.

My sibling and I played but fought a lot. But xmas was always amazing as there was a houseful of us bio and step siblings. Five bikes, five lots of new shoes, late games.

As adults, i get on so well with the step siblings, sending odd texts, a group chat, meeting up. Its lovely.

But my bio sibling has basically cut us all off, gives the narrative noone bothers with them, which simply isnt true, we have the texts to show how weve all tried seperately.

I loved being a teenage only. I didnt even realise wasi was one really until Mumsnet only child treads, it hadnt occured to me.

Beezknees · 01/10/2023 09:53

Because they clearly lack imagination and can't seem to grasp that every individual is different.