Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why some on MN insist on othering only children

66 replies

JaneBirkenstocks · 01/10/2023 09:21

As though they are peculiar. When they're just regular humans who happen not to have a sibling/s.

Since I joined MN when DD (now 18) was a toddler there have been numerous threads asking if onlies are lonely, selfish or bored. More difficult to parent, to teach to share, to socialise.

I've never come across a thread asking what it's like to be the 3rd child in a family of 4. It was fine in case anyone's wondering.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PaprikaPlease · 01/10/2023 23:31

People spend most of their time on mumsnet (or anywhere on the internet really) justifying their life choices as it makes them feel better about themselves. I’ve done this at times!

People like to feel they’ve done ‘the right thing’ and will fight to the death to defend their choice - in this case, the choice to have more than one child.

Parents of only kids are just as nutty if it helps. There was a thread here recently about parents stopping at one to give them a good life and help them with their driving lessons. Everyone kept going on about driving lessons. It was wild.

wingingit1987 · 01/10/2023 23:27

Ducksurprise · 01/10/2023 11:38

I have six, and have all the opposite 'othering' how they must never have one on one time, everything must be a struggle, why didn't we buy a telly etc.

It's just talk, I like my decisions

We have 5. People make all sorts of assumptions- that we must be skint, that we must be in benefits, that we must never have time for them all, that I must be overwhelmed.

nothing could be further from the truth.

RosesAndHellebores · 01/10/2023 23:20

I'm an only child. My mother was an only child.

My mother's parents wanted her and sadly could have no more after a birth that nearly killed my grandmother in 1936. My mother was adored and was indulged materially. My mother even at 87 can be a spoilt brat.

I was an accident. My mother didn't want any children. I was indulged materially but certainly not adored.

My family has money. We'd have been materially indulged whether we had siblings or not. Neither of us are selfish and both are generous.

DH is one of three. Money was tight. I'd say his sisters were jolly spoilt, one whinges a lot and neither like work.

It used to worry me that I'd bear sole responsibility for my mother as an only and this was one of the principle reasons I wanted more than one child (and also because the sparky comment ts about being an only used to hurt me). In actual fact, my DH does too because his sisters live abroad and wouldn't put themselves out for their mother - well one not much and one not a bit. That was an eye opener.

Fortunately dd and ds are quite close.

Thepeopleversuswork · 01/10/2023 22:58

If I was to say that having six kids (and adding three steps to the mix) was spectacularly selfish and irresponsible, making your children significantly worse off than you were because financial and parental resources are spread much thinner you probably wouldn’t like it.

This... you come on a thread and cheerfully admit you have six children and three step children and have the front to say you find only children selfish and annoying.

The lack of self-awareness would be hilarious if it wasn't so bigoted.

Kemper · 01/10/2023 22:51

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 01/10/2023 10:09

I'm simply stating my own experiences of only children.

I'm an only child myself and was ridiculously indulged as a child (finances permitting) and was probably the exact only child stereotype.

If I was to say that having six kids (and adding three steps to the mix) was spectacularly selfish and irresponsible, making your children significantly worse off than you were because financial and parental resources are spread much thinner you probably wouldn’t like it.

Thepeopleversuswork · 01/10/2023 22:31

To be fair I don't think Mumsnet is particularly bad for this... there are indeed lots of threads on here about this but most of the posters seem to recognise it's a stupid premise that only children are all lonely/selfish/badly behaved.

It's definitely a widely-held prejudice in wider society though (which MN broadly reflects). I think a lot of it is just a hangover from a pre contraception era where more children died in infancy, religion was more dominant and there was a general assumption that women would have as many children as they can afford.

Only children were unusual in these days and therefore people would question the rationale for stopping at one.

I've never seen any credible data to suggest that only children are automatically more lonely or badly behaved or anything else than children who have siblings. I think it's a combination of people being naturally prurient and nosy and imposing silly old wives tales onto this. With a nice big helping of anecdata, usually.

I think any blanket assumption that children are anything purely based on the number of siblings in the family or their position in the sequence is moronic and I treat it with the contempt it deserves.

JaneBirkenstocks · 01/10/2023 22:21

No! I didn't think you were being an arse 🙂It's a term I've never come across before and was eager to look it up.

OP posts:
WimpoleHat · 01/10/2023 20:49

Sorry - my DH is an economist, so it’s something we throw around a lot (wasn’t trying to be an arse 🤣). I suppose I do feel “othered” if I think about on those terms; people do assume a wider family and so that quite often requires an explanation, even at my age. Anything that sets you up as being out of the ordinary or different “others” you, surely?

JaneBirkenstocks · 01/10/2023 19:03

But it doesn't "other" you. And that was the point of the thread.

<off to Google diminishing marginal utility>

OP posts:
WimpoleHat · 01/10/2023 15:52

A SAHP with 3 dc might have more time than a full time WFH parent.

Quite possibly. But that’s not the point is it? That same SAHP would have a lot more time for each child than s/he does for three. However rich or poor you are, you will have fewer resources per child if you have more children. This may not be something that turns out to be significant (diminishing marginal utility and all that), but it is the fact of the matter. Same with elderly parents. Someone’s siblings may or may not help them; the parents may or may not need care. But the fact of the matter is that that burden was destined to be mine if it arose just because of the fact that I have no siblings.

Absolutely - you can’t guarantee that siblings will have a great sibling relationship. You can’t guarantee that your sibling will step up to take an equal share of parental care. But - as an only child myself - I am guaranteed not to have that help or those relationships. That’s a certainty.

JaneBirkenstocks · 01/10/2023 13:39

I think because a lot of us had experiences when our DCs were younger with “selfish” and very inconsiderate behaviour from only children which shocked us into thinking they can’t possibly ever learn

I doubt it. I think you had just as many unpleasant encounters with children with siblings.

OP posts:
Ilovelurchers · 01/10/2023 11:54

I do think it's worth remembering that having any children, even just the one, is one of the most selfish things you can do, and bad for the planet. (I did it myself - I am a mom to one and lost one other wanted pregnancy - but I make no denial it was selfish. My daughter is the best thing in my life by a million miles. But she at least doubles my lifetime carbon footprint if you think about it - and that's before she even thinks about having kids herself...

So perhaps, rather than asking adults why they have chosen no children or only one, in time we will become more used to asking, why did you decide to have children? Or why did you have more than one? Seeing these as the more questionable choices. Which they are, ethically speaking, on an already over-crowded planet.

That isn't a dig at anyone - I wouldn't criticise anyone for having a lot of kids any more than I would criticise them for driving or eating meat, or any other of the things we all do that are slowly destroying the planet.

But also I have total respect for all of those who selflessly forgo these pleasures for the good of others.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 01/10/2023 11:41

@Ducksurprise I have 6 too. I get the TV thing all the time. It bugs my partner because he's not my children's dad so I think it forces him to think of my ex husband and I having sex.

noticetomarry · 01/10/2023 11:40

Beginningless · 01/10/2023 09:35

I also think people discuss their views on it here because it’s anonymous, the fact they don’t express them in RL doesn’t mean they don’t have them.

Agree

Ducksurprise · 01/10/2023 11:38

I have six, and have all the opposite 'othering' how they must never have one on one time, everything must be a struggle, why didn't we buy a telly etc.

It's just talk, I like my decisions

FallingFeathers · 01/10/2023 11:34

I think it's just like the interest in twins. It's a fairly uncommon family dynamic to grow up in so attracts peoples interest. (Albeit both more common now than they used to be)

CrunchyCarrot · 01/10/2023 11:31

I'm an only (grew up without a dad around and it was very unusual in those days to be in that situation). I was never bored, was always finding ways to amuse myself. Not lonely, because I kept myself occupied. Have often heard the 'you're an only so you must be spoiled' line. No I wasn't. Often neighbouring kids from large families had more things and got whatever they wanted! I didn't.

I'm good at making friends - I think that's down to one's personality, not whether or not you have siblings. Sharing? Yeah not good at that, I have had to learn! Did I think I was 'very grown up'? No! I was a very late bloomer, actually!

My DP is also an only, but had both parents around. He too has many friends but like me is very good at entertaining himself. We both like a lot of 'alone' time.

Honestly I think it's because we are a minority group that we get these sorts of comments made. I bet people in Communist China who were allowed only one child don't say those things!

thecatsthecats · 01/10/2023 10:47

6strings1song · 01/10/2023 10:22

I think the way only children are treated by families varies as much as the way siblings are treated within families. Also depending on sibling age gaps, then older siblings can essentially be only children for quite a long time. Longer age gaps seem more common now (due to cost of living) and the standard 2-3 year gap seems to be extending to 5-6 years.

My DH is a "sort of" only, he has step/half siblings, but didn't live with them. As far as I can tell, he was sort of benignly ignored throughout his childhood and certainly not spoiled. Infact, he often felt he was unable to ask for what he truly wanted (birthdays/Christmas) as there was this unspoken feeling of being a financial burden (he wasn't...there was plenty of money). He was just expected to fit in with whatever the adults were doing and tagged along with very little attention placed upon him. There wasn't any sort of "let's do this activity because little DH would love to experience that". 😕I would say this experience is sadly probably just as common as the "spoiled only" claptrap trotted out on MN.

DH is keen to for us to have more than one DC because of his experiences and tbh I don't blame him.

As a youngest of four, this certainly resonates with me, especially with my older siblings trotting out "spoilt youngest" claptrap.

I had no choice but to follow on (happily, I might add), with a lifestyle planned for them. I was a toddler running around trying to stop the teens fighting with their parents. I kept shtum about my troubles because everyone else was being loud about theirs.

And most annoying of all, as a well-behaved and high-performing child who never gave any trouble, I had to live with a lot of strict rules invented for the sake of my troublesome older siblings!

5128gap · 01/10/2023 10:42

I'm an only child. I don't see it as othering children, more wanting opinions on a decision to have just one, or reassurance and advice on avoiding pitfalls if you have made a decision, or have no choice in the matter.
Only children do have a specific childhood experience that some find positive while others do not. I think its understandable that people who have a choice would want to canvas some opinions before making a decision that is quite a big deal in a child's life.

BlackcatsAndPumpkins · 01/10/2023 10:42

The same limited thinking applies to those who home educate.
Like your child never comes into contact with anyone else.

MoiraRosesBaybay · 01/10/2023 10:40

I’m an only and have noticed a lot of unpleasant attitude from other adults about only children, especially teachers. I’d often hear comments in the staff room like ‘well he is an only child so that’s to be expected’.
But I think that as it’s become more common (I was the only only I knew) and they are seen as less of an oddity.

FloorWipes · 01/10/2023 10:40

It’s all G. Stanley Hall’s fault.

Didn't know this. It's fascinting how often bad science catches on and lingers!

Tourmalines · 01/10/2023 10:37

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 01/10/2023 09:57

I'm an only child and now have 6 children myself (+ 3 step) but I find only children quite annoying.

The ones I know (still children at the moment) think they're sooo grown up, drinking coffees, and wanting to be involved in the adults' conversations and it's very irritating. Also, they seem to get so much input into their parents' decisions.

Just go and play, you're a child!

Wow, poor only children hey! What a nasty post.

UkeleleUnicycle · 01/10/2023 10:36

Othered is a bit strong OP!

AlienatedChildGrown · 01/10/2023 10:35

It’s all G. Stanley Hall’s fault.

He decided/theorised that being an only child was “a disease in itself. Created a boatload of stereotypes. It got popularised. More stereotypes added.

None of it holds up to scrutiny. Studies show onlies do as well as kids with siblings. Perhaps even a little better in a couple of areas.

The stereotype continues.

You can start (figuratively) whacking people around the chops with print outs of the studies. This will cost you money, to access, print, and print again after you’ve done some (figurative) whacking making wear and tear an issue. God knows they’ll never get worn out from being read, people don’t like to read piles of things that disprove their long held “makes me feel good about my own superior choices” beliefs.

Or !

Just shrug it off. Smile and nod. Move on. By the time your smallie is big the majority of the mummy wars topics are relegated to a dim and distant past you can barely remember (all hail the brain fog of peri menopause) , and don’t understand why you got sucked into it anyway.