Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For telling my friend to be careful with the language she uses around her daughter?

77 replies

Lolabear38 · 01/10/2023 04:37

A good friend I’ve known for 20+ years.
Friend has been recovering from anorexia for the last 10 years but has seemingly replaced the anorexia with obsessive exercise and counting macros - it’s all she can talk about and she will prioritise exercise over everything, going to the gym for hours a day. She also won’t eat certain foods if they’re over macros and is absolutely rigid about it.

Friend has 3 daughters - eldest one of whom will constantly be snacking or asking for snacks. I.e if there is a plate of biscuits she’ll eat until every one is gone, regardless of how many there are. She will ask for snacks when she can’t possibly still be hungry etc. Friend speaks to her in what I think is a really inappropriate way - e.g ‘you can’t still be hungry, you’re so greedy’, ‘put that cake down, you guts!’ And on one occasion ‘that’s not for you, put it down, fatty’. Her daughter is 7 and not overweight in the slightest though I would say she maybe has issues or potential issues with food. Friend doesn’t talk to her other two dd’s like this though from what I’ve seen they tend to be quite happy to have one biscuit/ snack then go off to play.

Anyway, the other day we were all out and went to get ice creams. All the kids had one but when it was her eldest’s turn to say what she wanted she asked for a double scoop ice cream and friend replied with ‘I might have known you’d be the one to ask for extra, of course one scoop wouldn’t be enough for you, greedy guts’. This was said quite unkindly. As we walked I said to her that I thought as parents of girls (and actually girls or boys, but as we are both girl parents this is the language I used) it’s really important to think about the language we use around our daughters and think about how it affects body image etc, and maybe think about how she speaks to her eldest when it comes to food rather than talking in a way which might make her feel ashamed or build a bad relationship around food or eating. Friend went absolutely crazy at me, telling me I was way out of line to talk to her like that, it’s up to her how she talks to her own kids (true) and she would never dream of having a go at me about how I raised my own kids. Since then we’ve not spoken at all, I sent a message saying I was sorry if she was upset by what I’d said and that wasn’t my intention. She’s ignored it. Was I out of line? To be honest, every time I hear her talk to her dd in that way it makes me wince a bit and feel so upset for her daughter, I can’t bring myself to say to her I didn’t mean it because I really did. What do you think?

OP posts:
Pepperama · 01/10/2023 04:59

You’ve clearly hit a nerve. Problem is that if she’s got such food issues herself then she’ll be in total denial. And it’s common with addictive disorders that people would rather cut off friends and family than be challenged about their problems

still think you did the right thing for the girl and hope the mum comes round in the end

Indoorcatmum · 01/10/2023 04:42

You did the right thing. She is being verbally abusive to her child.

She probably won't change, but at least you have acted with integrity and not just stood silently by.

I wouldn't have apologised, she needs the reality check.
Her daughter will despise her when she's older and will probably have food issues for life.

Anorexia is a terrible disease, but you have a responsibility and a parent not to put those issues onto your child.