Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for being upset nobody complimented my child while other kids were complimented?

292 replies

HelloHilda · 30/09/2023 22:09

Basically, I went to a wedding today with my husband and took our daughter too. She's 7 and sat at the table with us at the reception. There were a few other cousins/relatives her age around the table with their parents (people from my husband's side of the family), and then my husband's sister came over and started talking and being friendly. She lives abroad, so hasn't seen everyone in years.

Anyway, she started complimenting the other children, telling them they have lovely dresses, lovely hairstyles, that they look beautiful. Telling the parents stuff like the kids are gorgeous, have lovely faces, are a credit to the family, etc... She was asking all sorts of questions, like where they bought the outfits, how school's going, stuff like that.

She didn't say one word to my daughter, who she is related to. In the middle of praising these other kids, she literally looked at my daughter and had an unimpressed look on her face, like my child isn't as pretty as the others, then continued talking to the other kids. She noticed me giving her a dirty look/suspicious look, and then put on a fake grin and told me my daughter had a nice bracelet.

I admit my daughter isn't that good looking, but she's not ugly and wears nice clothes and has nice natural blonde hair. It's not nice to exclude her like this. You might think I'm overreacting, but I know for a fact this woman is superficial and critical of appearances because she lived with me and my husband for a while about 10 years ago, and she literally couldn't watch a movie without saying something nasty as the actors' appearances, if she found them ugly or aging. She'd say the same thing about child actors.

She obviously thinks my child is ugly.

OP posts:
SpongeBobJudgeyPants · 03/10/2023 10:03

@HelloHilda I think some people are missing the point on here. I agree, SIL doesn't need to compliment your child, but if she is going to compliment everyone else, then this is telling isn't it?! Who does that to a child?! It may be that she is getting at you through your child. Sounds like you need a strategy for the future, and tbh I would be limiting contact with SIL for a number of reasons, when possible.

She sounds like a thoroughly unpleasant person, and it may be a bit of the 'bitch eating crackers' thing going on.
I hate my SIL, I was forced to spend some time with her at the weekend, and I was annoyed by her very presence. Entirely my problem.

She needs to be nice to everyone, or no one. Unfortunately you aren't going to change her, or persuade her, and a word from her brother probably won't work.
A strategy going forward is your best plan. If your DD does notice, you need a child friendly explanation, that doesn't include the very obvious fact that SIL is a bit of a cow. Sympathies. Been there, got the t shirt.

Seaweed42 · 03/10/2023 09:52

This is NOTHING to do with your child's prettiness.

You are attaching the meaning of what happened to the fact that your daughter 'isn't good looking'.

Could this be more to do with the fact that your SIL was more comfortable talking to her own family members and their kids (maybe her sister's kids?) rather than her Brother's kid.

I suspect it's very very little to do with what your child LOOKS like.

Lampzade · 03/10/2023 09:49

Littlewhitecat · 03/10/2023 08:09

Talk about projecting OP - you really need to think about how you think about your daughter and why you are placing so much weight on her looks. The fact so many people on this thread disagree with you should give you some food for thought. It's not that we are all delusional and that somehow you can see the truth and are therefore a better more honest parent. A lot of people on here can see the damage you are doing in your pursuit of being truthful. I wonder what other truths you hold about your DD? Your SIL could be a bitch as well. The two things aren't mutually exclusive, but you can't control her actions. However you can think about how you reacted and why it was so upsetting to you. It's ok for you to honestly tell strangers your DD isn't attractive but by the same turn you expect someone else to lie and compliment her looks. Maybe your SIL thinks exactly the same you do.

This

Shouldistayorshouldi · 03/10/2023 09:37

I applaud OP for recognising that their child might not be a looker. It’s refreshing to hear something other than “my kids are so beautiful” when they’re clearly deluded and biased.

OP she was being a cow regardless, it would just be polite to give her a compliment - even if it wasn’t about her appearance. Horrid woman. I bet the other parents felt mortified too. My daughter attended a hobby 2 weeks ago and the staff were all saying “omg she is gorgeous” and I actually felt mortified that all the other kids and parents weren’t getting such comments.

looks aren’t everything but she sounds awful

Georgeandzippyzoo · 03/10/2023 09:31

I have a feeling that SiL possibly knew exactly what she was doing and continued even when she knew you were watching hing and aware. Probably got a big buzz from it.

This has nothing to do whether your DD is beautiful or not but you seem very down on it, I hope your daughter does not pick up these vibes your giving iff!

SpringingChicken · 03/10/2023 09:27

MariaVT65 · 03/10/2023 08:29

Op I would advise you to be careful about this if you want to continue a close relationship with your daughter.

I don’t look like an instagram model, and although my mother hasn’t explicitly told me that she thinks i’m not good looking, it’s still very clear to me that she doesn’t think i’m beautiful. She even had to be coaxed for hours by my bridesmaid to tell me i looked lovely on my wedding day.

The fact that I don’t look like Angelina Jolie hasn’t impacted my life whatsoever, but my mum’s attitude means we are not close.

Please reframe your thinking. Not directly telling someone that they are not good looking isn’t enough.

‘Op I would advise you to be careful about this if you want to continue a close relationship with your daughter.’

So what exactly do you suggest OP does? She does not think her daughter is pretty. The thought has come into her head. What should she do with that thought other than not act on it? Automatic thoughts are not easy to change. Most people are not ‘pretty’. That’s ok. I am interested in what you think the OP needs to do.

I am not into judging people’s thoughts and feelings. Actions and behaviour yes.

SpringingChicken · 03/10/2023 09:22

People really are going over the top here. It is possible to adore your child whilst accepting that they don’t meet society’s current standards of what is conventionally attractive. And being capable of that level of objectivity does not automatically make someone a bad parent.

I have friends who now laugh at how much they thought their little baby was beautiful and cute when in fact, they were just potato lumps at that time. They still adore their children but laugh at their early newborn ‘blindness’. It means nothing in the context of a loving relationship.

My daughter was pretty beautiful at birth. My son took six months to ‘grow into’ his looks 😂I could see that at the time. They were both still perfect to me.

Most people don’t have supermodel children. And most parents know that, whilst thinking their kids is gorgeous to them. Are parents who don’t think their child is the most stunning in the world, dooming them to an unloved life of emotional neglect? Of course not. Some ridiculous comments here.

Ihaventgottimeforthis · 03/10/2023 09:20

You and your SIL don't like each other, from your post she does sound unpleasant, but why would you seek approval for your daughter from someone like that?
It should be like water off a duck's back.
To me it sounds like you're disappointed your daughter is not 'pretty' in your eyes, so you're extra sensitive about it.
Which makes me very sad for your daughter.
This thread is unpleasant, using your child's appearance as an excuse to essentially moan about your SIL's behaviour.

Janieforever · 03/10/2023 08:39

What an utterly shocking thread. Complaining about this woman finding your daughter ugly , in your own head whilst utterly putting your own kid down so much.

at least the other woman said nothing. You are struggling to keep your horrible vain thoughts to yourself. Your daughter is beautiful. In her own way. Her not talking to her was about you and the fact you’re horrible and nothing to do with your kid

MariaVT65 · 03/10/2023 08:29

HelloHilda · 30/09/2023 22:43

We're not all capable of parental delusion. There's no need to feel sorry for my daughter; she will never know I don't find her pretty. Why would I ever say any of this to her?

Op I would advise you to be careful about this if you want to continue a close relationship with your daughter.

I don’t look like an instagram model, and although my mother hasn’t explicitly told me that she thinks i’m not good looking, it’s still very clear to me that she doesn’t think i’m beautiful. She even had to be coaxed for hours by my bridesmaid to tell me i looked lovely on my wedding day.

The fact that I don’t look like Angelina Jolie hasn’t impacted my life whatsoever, but my mum’s attitude means we are not close.

Please reframe your thinking. Not directly telling someone that they are not good looking isn’t enough.

SeptemberSuns · 03/10/2023 08:21

Quite probably the most batshit thread I'll read this month!

totaldeniallimitation · 03/10/2023 08:19

StephanieSuperpowers · 30/09/2023 22:18

I don't think you should be worrying too much about your SIL. She isn't responsible for creating your child's self esteem. That's your job.

I think this is what you need to focus on, at the end of the day.

Though praising other children and excluding one is really fucking nasty and YANBU for raging about what a nasty arse she is.

Hadjab · 03/10/2023 08:12

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 30/09/2023 23:15

Op isn't a racist just because she thinks her daughters blonde hair is pretty, lots of people tbink blonde hair is pretty (including Beyoncé) and spent a lot of money on highlights

Absolutely nobody accused the OP of being racist, so please don’t even! She is, however, very focused on looks. Because her SIL didn’t compliment her child, she automatically assumes it’s because her child isn’t pretty, rather than assume the SIL just doesn’t like OP or her child.

Littlewhitecat · 03/10/2023 08:09

Talk about projecting OP - you really need to think about how you think about your daughter and why you are placing so much weight on her looks. The fact so many people on this thread disagree with you should give you some food for thought. It's not that we are all delusional and that somehow you can see the truth and are therefore a better more honest parent. A lot of people on here can see the damage you are doing in your pursuit of being truthful. I wonder what other truths you hold about your DD? Your SIL could be a bitch as well. The two things aren't mutually exclusive, but you can't control her actions. However you can think about how you reacted and why it was so upsetting to you. It's ok for you to honestly tell strangers your DD isn't attractive but by the same turn you expect someone else to lie and compliment her looks. Maybe your SIL thinks exactly the same you do.

Utterbunkum · 03/10/2023 07:49

She will absolutely know you don't think she is good looking. Trust me on this. You will tell her in a thousand ways and won't know you are doing it. I was that child and I knew without being told outright. Also, I wasn't stupid. I had access to mirrors and could see the difference between me and my pretty peers. And, of course, my crueller peers wasted no time in telling me. I get being honest with yourself about your child, I really do, but it's not that you acknowledge that your daughter isn't a stunner, it's more that I think it matters to you. If it didn't, you wouldn't care about what the relative said. It obviously bothers you she isn't a looker. Why is it so important?

Ididivfama · 03/10/2023 07:47

Isn’t it because she doesn’t know the others as well so is trying to gee them up? It sounds like she doesn’t get on with you very well.

OuiRagamuffin · 03/10/2023 07:42

StephanieSuperpowers · 30/09/2023 22:18

I don't think you should be worrying too much about your SIL. She isn't responsible for creating your child's self esteem. That's your job.

This is it. Ask your daughter what she thinks about different issues and different options. Listen to her. That is going to raise her self-esteem.

OuiRagamuffin · 03/10/2023 07:39

Some people are very lookist and even people who aren't get swept up in 'the aesthetics' on their wedding day. I don't think you can 'do' anything. But try try try not to let it hurt you. often cut kids grow up looking a bit odd (mcCauley culkin!) and often kids who were kinda ordinary grow up stunning. You often see pictures of hollywood stars and their childhood photos don't give much indication of how gorgeous they're going to become. But, most of us fall in the middle and on a good day, if you hadn't been hurt (and I get that) you'd probably know that. I've two kids and I'd say one is more conventionally attractive than the other, but he has no ability to work within the system that exists. Hates rules, does everything his own way. Life is going to be hard for him.

OnAFrolicOfMyOwn · 03/10/2023 07:23

SpringingChicken · 03/10/2023 05:10

Leaving one child out of a round of compliments at a table, whether it’s about their looks, brains or colour of their napkins, is poor form. Even if the kid doesn’t notice, the parent will. It shows poor social skills, whatever the parameter being used to compliment.

This. She could have found something to praise - 'what a lovely dress' or similar.

MrsRaspberry · 03/10/2023 06:31

You don't even like your SIL so why do you care about her opinion? To be fair you're both so shallow and you probably clash because you're so similar in the importance of appearances. You've said yourself your kid isn't good looking. Lets hope your kid doesn't inherit yours or her aunts views on others based on looks

McIntire · 03/10/2023 05:27

OP, she was mean to miss your DD out but you know from previous experience that she’s shallow so I don’t know why you’re even bothered tbh

Springflower866 · 03/10/2023 05:19

Jesus give this woman a break, you pack of wolfes! She can still love her child and objectively think that they are not the most good looking. We all would wish for the best looking children but if they are not, we still love them and never tell them.

SpringingChicken · 03/10/2023 05:10

Leaving one child out of a round of compliments at a table, whether it’s about their looks, brains or colour of their napkins, is poor form. Even if the kid doesn’t notice, the parent will. It shows poor social skills, whatever the parameter being used to compliment.

SpringingChicken · 03/10/2023 05:06

BabyFireflyx · 01/10/2023 02:21

Makes me think I struck lucky with my kid. She wakes up beautiful, always has, which is more than I can say for myself. I take a little more engineering (full face of make up and I’m alright). DD started out potatoed like all babies. But she went from old man to effortless beauty in months. There's a shine that's all her own and even at 11, I'll catch her in a facial expression and tell her she's beautiful, because she simply is.
I don’t understand if it's a bad genetic mix you accept, those of you saying your kids are plain or y'know "not good looking" or some kind of superiority complex - you vs your kid. Or people meaning that they don't look good and neither does their child.
None of our kids are likely to be world changing models, but jesus. I hope you never say this shit out loud. Self fulfilling prophecy will decimate your child's self esteem.

‘None of our kids are likely to be world changing models, but jesus. I hope you never say this shit out loud.’

I am sure most people don’t. I don’t know why posters are getting so worked up about this.

SpringingChicken · 03/10/2023 05:02

brielliance · 30/09/2023 23:20

? I don't get this.

I guess to you and others like @Festivemoose, physical beauty is a really, really important trait. To me there are more important things.

Objectively I'm pretty ugly (I was called pig nose in school and relatives would always praise my siblings' looks and then look at me and pause awkwardly, etc etc). My DH is conventionally unattractive, and our children inherited both our (lack of) looks. Basically we all look quite piggish and sunken.

Physically, I love EVERY single big and small thing about my DH and my kids. I love their smiles, their hair, their lashes, their cheeks, my DH's odd freakish toes, every single beautiful and weird and wonderful thing about them. In my heart, they are the most beautiful creatures ever.

But according to arbitrary, superficial, external societal standards, are they/we good looking or even average? No. I think it's okay to admit that, just as it's okay to admit maybe your child isn't academic or sporty or etc. I wouldn't tell my child that for sure, but it's OK to admit to yourself.

The "of COURSE you're beautiful sweetheart" message is damaging, because it strongly implies it's not OK to be physically unattractive. I heard this line all my life, usually said after an awkward silence and in very stilted tones from superficial adults (including my vv superficial mum). I used to plan for plastic surgery but I guess after meeting DH I learnt to love my own features, truly :-)

If a child wasn't good at ballet or football, you wouldn't insist they were their whole life! At some point they'd realise the truth and then feel shit they couldn't live up to what you clearly value (ballet/football skill). Instead, you'd focus on emphasising all their other great strengths and traits. My children are brilliant, kind, funny and just wonderful.

Agreed.

I have always been able to be objective about my kids’ looks. I think they are gorgeous now, but when one was little I could see that they didn’t fulfil standard beauty standards. They have both grown to be pretty attractive adults but I retained objectivity when the boy was very young and slightly odd looking. It was no reflection of love at all.

Some of us aren’t blinded by our kids’ looks. That does not mean we don’t adore them. And as you say, there is plenty else to value.

Swipe left for the next trending thread