Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For being really upset my dad bought my sister a home but not me

93 replies

Nostalgicdreamer · 30/09/2023 20:05

My dad retired and decided he wanted to buy my sister (32) and I (35F) our own houses, my property was originally to have a bigger budget as dad was going to put a smaller house/granny flat on the place he bought for me and it would essentially be for him and my family (partner and 3 young kids) eventually, he originally had no intention in moving with us for at least a few years. My place was to be on acreage, we looked and looked and as I had to keep in mind this was to be a forever property and needed to be a property both my family and my father could live happily it was very difficult to find something we could all be happy with let alone put a second dwelling on with council regulations etc. If it was just for us there are so many properties along the way we were looking that would have been perfect for us.

After a year we found a property, dad put down a deposit then someone offered more and they decided to go with them. Dad was pissed off and didn't want to increase his offer.

A couple months later Dad ended up finding a property in a county town 6 hours away from where we were looking to buy, right up to the auction I told my dad repeatedly we did not want to move there and to please not buy the property, he told me he didn't care if I liked it or not he was buying it. The place has nothing that I wanted in a place for my family except the acreage, the house is not big enough for us and theres not enough bedrooms and its hours away from our family/support system, my dad also isn't the type to help with our kids at all. I have chronic pain and can't work and we need our support system, my eldest son also has behavioural issues we are waiting to be diagnosed (suspected adhd) Dads opinion is that he got this place for us and its just too bad if we don't like it and don't want to move there thats our tough luck and we get nothing if we don't want to uproot our family and move all the way there. Dads moved there now.

Its not my money and I know if someone buys a house for you you should be grateful and I kind of felt like an ass right up until my sister tells me dad bought her her house in the suburb she wants to live in, somewhere my dad said there was no way he was buying a place near there, that it was overpriced and not somewhere he wanted her or any future grandchildren living. She never has to worry about him ever wanting to go live with her and he has spent the same amount on her house as he did on the property he bought himself.

Now he worked hard all his life he deserves to live where he wants but I can't help feeling now like its extremely unfair he went and bought my sister a nearly $2m house near the city exactly as she wanted it and where she wanted it and I was expected to move my family where he wants me to, it also massively hurts that he decided my opinion and what I wanted no longer mattered and he was going to just buy what he wanted and if I didnt like it thats just tough! when every property I looked at I tried to have everyones best interests in mind and looked at places with the thought when dad moves in with us will he be happy there. Don't get me wrong I'm happy for my sister however I still think its extremely unfair I ended up with nothing because I don't want to move my family where dad bought but my sister got exactly where and what she wanted and dad sees nothing wrong with any of this.

My sister also has no children or partner, makes more money than my partner does, has enough to go on at least a month or more long European trip each year, goes out regularly and isn't scrimping for money each week so its not like she was in need more for the house than we are.

So AIBU being extremely upset that my dad expects my family just to uproot our lives and leave all support we have to move where he wants us to? to a house we don't like, when he has bought my sister exactly where and what she wanted. Ive tried talking to my dad about it but he doesn't see my point of view he just tells me the kids can room together, its not terrible to have to live away from our other family and thinks Im being very unreasonable, he doesn't understand how what he's done could possibly be unfair.

OP posts:
MILLYmo0se · 01/10/2023 09:20

It will be difficult but stop giving him the satisfaction of discussing it with him ir your sister. Disxussing it isnt going to change anything, he has ourchased his house and you are not moving there. Shut sown any conversation about it immediately with 'we cannot move there, i told you that, i dont want to discuss ut anymore'. He wabts to wear you down and doesnt care that it may affect you relationship with your sister. Dobt entertain any of it, whats done is done, you talking to him wont change any of it, the reality of actually living 6 hours away might.

RoseGoldEagle · 01/10/2023 09:09

I’d be very wary of this if I was your sister, what if he decides he wants that money and sells, or needs to sell to fund care in the future? I would not feel very secure in her position. I completely get why you’re upset, but I think in a weird way your Dad is enjoying it- and enjoying the control it gives him. I would vent those feelings to your partner for a little while, but just live your own life without help from your Dad, you may find it has surprising benefits down the line.

BMW6 · 01/10/2023 08:59

The houses are all in his name, so at any point he could evict your sister if he chose, or you if you did his bidding.

I think he's a controlling bastard TBH. These aren't gifts at all.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 01/10/2023 08:53

Yeah, it's all just further proof of his control.

If he had bought the house in a suitable location and the OP had moved in, he would have used the threat of kicking her out to keep her in line.

I would bet my salary that every time the OP disagreed with him or did something he didn't approve of, he would pull the "This is my house you're living in, you can leave if you don't like it.." line

rookiemere · 01/10/2023 08:51

Technically your DF hasn't bought anyone a house as it's all still in his name.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 01/10/2023 08:50

Mybasilplantispastitsbest · 01/10/2023 08:40

Are you in the states, OP?

Honestly, the best thing I think could ever happen to children brought up in manipulative wealthy homes is to 100% distance yourself from the relationship while you get on with focusing on building your own financial stability. Why will you never be able to buy where you are? Why can’t you staircase/flip/improve a fixer upper yourself?

Honestly, I grew up in an area with a lot of Self-Made Wealthy Parents and their kids are my friends and much of my adult life seems to be listening to ‘and then dad said if he gave that much to Jack/Jane/cousin Jo, then he might do something for me but then I said but wait is that fair and then mum said but then Jack had an issue bla bla bla £€$¥£€$¥£€$¥ etc etc forever and ever’.

Is there really no way you can get out of rental on your own where you want to be? Ever? Even if you don’t get acreage? (If acreage means a shit ton of land, a lot of people want that but don’t get it).

Independence, emotional freedom and the respect that comes from EVERYONE, even yourself when you stand on your own two feet are wonderful things too, with no caring obligations and manipulative emotional roller coasters to go through either.

I agree with this - what can you afford in the area you want to live in?

Forget about wants (acreage etc), what do you actually need? You need a place to live that is commutable for work, near your friends and support network, and large enough for your family. What would that cost - and can you get a mortgage for that?

You've been putting off taking responsibility for buying your own house because your dad has dangled this carrot of having a huge property with "acreage". Well the carrot is gone, so it's time to do it for yourself.

sodthesodoff · 01/10/2023 08:41

I think you have to stop thinking as your dad as a kind and caring parent who puts his children first

He's controlling and bullying and using his money to upset you and probably try to put a wedge between you two too

I notice your sister isn't on the deeds for her house. So it's not the big gesture it sounds like. He's still in control. And she is now under his power. If she does something he doesn't like... well, he owns her house.

Such is his power over you he thought he could force you all to uproot to where he wants to be without complaining.

He has given you an insight into how this 'caring' for him would look like. You being treated like a slave and your opinions and desires totally ignored

Cut him off. He will use his money to manipulate and control you. I'm sure he'll be back with another way to tempt you with money. But it'll come at a cost. And for me it's not worth it.

Sorry you have such a dick for a parent.

Mybasilplantispastitsbest · 01/10/2023 08:40

Are you in the states, OP?

Honestly, the best thing I think could ever happen to children brought up in manipulative wealthy homes is to 100% distance yourself from the relationship while you get on with focusing on building your own financial stability. Why will you never be able to buy where you are? Why can’t you staircase/flip/improve a fixer upper yourself?

Honestly, I grew up in an area with a lot of Self-Made Wealthy Parents and their kids are my friends and much of my adult life seems to be listening to ‘and then dad said if he gave that much to Jack/Jane/cousin Jo, then he might do something for me but then I said but wait is that fair and then mum said but then Jack had an issue bla bla bla £€$¥£€$¥£€$¥ etc etc forever and ever’.

Is there really no way you can get out of rental on your own where you want to be? Ever? Even if you don’t get acreage? (If acreage means a shit ton of land, a lot of people want that but don’t get it).

Independence, emotional freedom and the respect that comes from EVERYONE, even yourself when you stand on your own two feet are wonderful things too, with no caring obligations and manipulative emotional roller coasters to go through either.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 01/10/2023 08:25

Your dad is a controlling bully. Why would you want to live with him? Thanks your lucky stars that you don't have to.

You know he bought that house for your sister out of spite, don't you? He went over and above what he originally said he'd do for her to get back at you for not wanting to move to the house he wanted. Nasty man.

Poppysmom22 · 01/10/2023 08:24

Honestly no matter how hard it is continue being independent done rely on anyone but yourself. Do not let yourself be one dependant on someone who has so little regard for your happiness.

MyCircumference · 01/10/2023 07:58

how were you meant to look after him?

RudsyFarmer · 01/10/2023 07:54

Well if you’re trying to find the positive, not having to care for your dad in old age has to be up there.

Guiltridden12345 · 01/10/2023 07:53

ErinAndTonic · 30/09/2023 20:21

You do sound a little spoilt.

I'd just forget that he ever offered and buy or save up for my own home. And stop being jealous of your sister as you can't change that unfortunately.

These comments make me laugh. This is a classic example of different and unfair treatment - like the prodigal son stories that sell so well - and people go ‘don’t bd jealous, it’s just 2 million’. Ridiculous.

op, I second the narrow escape. Your feelings of upset are totally valid. You’ll need to work through them and stand firm with your dad. He sounds like a bully who threw his toys out when you didn’t do as he asked.

Nostalgicdreamer · 01/10/2023 07:47

@RudsyFarmer
We wanted to stay in our current area and on acreage, dad also eventually wanted to live out his days on acreage and with his grandchildren (was not supposed to be for a few years tho as he had plans to travel around the country with friends) and well wants someone to look after him when hes older. It was going to be a more expensive property than where he was supposedly going to buy for my sister in the beginning, so the deal was that we would look after him in his old age because he was buying my family the more expensive property we were wanting, so my sister wouldn't have any complaints because her inherited house was less than mine because she wouldn't have the added expectation of looking after our dad when he needed it. He has now bought her a property the same price as the one he bought himself.

OP posts:
Newestname002 · 01/10/2023 00:32

@Nostalgicdreamer

You and your partner are absolutely doing the right thing for your family. If he can treat you like this now, trying without any care for you, to make you isolate yourselves from job, hospital, schools/support for your children think how he will treat you if you capitulate and do what he wants. You will have no financial security if he decides he's changed his mind once you've done what he wanted.

Tell your sister to save as much of her salary as she can as there may well come a time when he changes his mind about "her" house too and she'll need to sort out property for herself to which she does have legal title. 🌹

saraclara · 01/10/2023 00:10

You've definitely dodged a bullet. He'd clearly be a nightmare to live with if he has such a complete lack of empathy.or care for anyone else's needs.

Gymnopedie · 01/10/2023 00:08

And, OP, don't take any notice of your sister wanting you to 'just have a look'. It may be that she genuinely thinks it could work out for you, but it could also be that she realises if you don't go she might become default carer.

Surely this sort of manipulation from your father hasn't come out of nowhere. If you moved to the new house your life and everything in it wouldn't be your own. Stay where you are and don't be bullied into anything else.

Emz6103 · 01/10/2023 00:04

ErinAndTonic · 30/09/2023 20:21

You do sound a little spoilt.

I'd just forget that he ever offered and buy or save up for my own home. And stop being jealous of your sister as you can't change that unfortunately.

This ☝️

AliceMcK · 30/09/2023 23:54

Well he’s not bought your sister a house or you, he’s bought himself 2 houses that he’s allowing your sister to live in and another he expects you to live in.

he sounds very controlling, your doing the right thing by not moving.

id stop with the unfair stuff, that just makes you sound like a whiny child. I’d say ok Dad, I appreciate your well meaning in providing somewhere for us all to live without rent, but upheaving my children and DP is just not something we are willing to do as a family. And then just avoid the topic grey rock him and just maintain a relationship with him, if that’s what you want.

Your situation might be unfair, I get it, but wallowing in self pity won’t do you any favours.

Hairyfairy01 · 30/09/2023 23:52

As awful as it is to hear it doesn't appear that your dad has either yours or your families best interests at heart. In fact far from it. What you do with that information is up to you but I wouldn't be eating too much time on what is best for him. Look after yourself and your own family. As hard as it is try not to let the resentment build up between you and your sister, ultimately it's not her fault and she is in a vulnerable position.

BOOTS52PollyPrissyPants · 30/09/2023 23:32

He sounds awful controlling and do not ever think of looking after him in his old age as it will be a nightmare for you and your family and he will drive you demented. He can afford to pay someone to look after him as it sounds like he will be a nightmare.
It is not fair that he bought your sister the house of her dreams in her dream area but will not do the same for you.
Do not say anymore to him once he knows you are disappointed and he should have let you both have a say in the property that was picked and near your support area.
Why does he want you to be the one to look after him, is it because you are kinder and softer and your sister just would not do it.

Horrible situation but do not move there as you will be miserable and maybe he will see sense when he is alone there and lonely.

Baldieheid · 30/09/2023 22:43

Sounds like you're best providing for yourselves and to carry on living where you prefer. You don't owe him anything, he can't throw you out of your current home so stay there. When you inherit his house, you can just chuck it on the market and get rid of it.

If he wants to be cared for in his dotage by you, he'll need to move where YOUR life is.

RudsyFarmer · 30/09/2023 22:41

Why did he have to move in with you in the original arrangement?

AcrossthePond55 · 30/09/2023 22:32

@Nostalgicdreamer

Look at it this way; Yes, owning a home is a great deal of security. But neither of you would own those homes, would you? And Dad could evict you at any time if you pissed him off. Or he could sell them out from under you or leave the houses to a 3rd party when he dies. The only 'benefit' to you in Dad's 'arrangement' would be that you would (I assume) be living there rent free. Or rather, rent free in exchange for 'services' at some point. But is that really worth it considering the financial hold he'd have over you? I say you, but I'm including your sister in this.

I think you need to take a new point of view. You are free, your sister is not. When/If the time comes that your dad needs care you will be able to say 'No, that doesn't work for us' because he has no hold over you. It won't be that way for your sister because dad owns her home. He can say to her "You will be my carer or I will sell that house". Sister has the Sword of Damocles hanging over her head. Dad may have preferred you to be his care-giver, but do you seriously think he won't expect your sister to perform those duties if you refuse?

Canisaysomething · 30/09/2023 22:15

This all sounds really toxic. I imagine you are incredibly disappointed after he made such an original kind and life changing offer that he’s now gone back on. Give him lots of space until you come to terms with the disappointment.