Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child favouritism to the tune of 50k

241 replies

FrillyGoatFluff · 30/09/2023 18:54

Please bear with, there’s some background!

I’m mid-30s, married with one daughter (toddler). I live with my DH and two DSDs (no contact with mum, we are entirely responsible 100%, financially and otherwise).

We paid for our house entirely ourselves, no help from family etc, same with our wedding. Have never asked anyone for a penny.

My half sister (dads daughter) is 21. At uni but lives with BF in her uni city. He works, earns well, lovely guy. She’s nearly finished her degree, looking at great grades and has a solid future plan. They’ve been together 3 years, talk of getting engaged when she graduates. I have no other siblings.

My Nan (dads mum) recently passed away, and dad is talking about selling the family home (he, stepmum and Nan lived together in nans house) and buying somewhere smaller. Would free up about £250k (we’re in the south east). Dad and I live in the same village, which he plans to continue living in. Fab.

However, he recently announced that he’s planning to give my sister £50k, to ‘set her up’ for wedding, house deposit etc.

Now, I love my sister, and honestly do want her to have the money for all of the above but I’m REALLY narky that she’s getting a £50k handout, and I’m getting bugger all. I appreciate it’s his cash to do what he wants with, but actually, it’s not even about the money, it’s genuinely not, it’s the fact that I feel totally second best.

For history, mum chucked my dad out when I was two (affair, he then married her, she was a ballache) and was sporadic with child support - both financial, and emotional. Mum bought me up and it was tough, financially, we were up against it. My sister, however, was a two parent family (three really, my Nan was there too), wanted for nothing - dance classes, drama lessons, foreign school trips, uni paid for - financially, she has been well catered for, and had a much easier time of things. Dad seemed to grow up by the time he had her, I was a bit of a learning curve I think, the training daughter almost.

My dad told my mum about his financial plans the other day (they’re arms-length-friends now, for the sake of my daughter) and she pointedly said ‘don’t forget you have two daughters’ and his response was ‘well yes, but I want to set X up’. With one biological daughter of my own and two DSDs, I cannot imagine for one second treating any of them this differently, I can’t see how he can justify it in his head?

Am I being totally ridiculous? Yes, I absolutely DO have my life together (through pure hard work on my and DH’s part!), should i to just let it go and accept my dad is a total fuckwomble??? I really can’t decide if I’m being a drama queen or not, but we live 500yards apart so I can’t avoid the subject forever!

OP posts:
Mari9999 · 30/09/2023 22:46

@Mindovermatter247
Is it possible that your brother asked for the money and your dad was pleased for once to be in a position to help?

Working class parents are often in a position to do more for younger children, not because of favoritism, but became of income increases over time and having fewer children in the home.

FrillyGoatFluff · 30/09/2023 22:45

AmandasFleckerl · 30/09/2023 22:36

However, he recently announced that he’s planning to give my sister £50k, to ‘set her up’ for wedding, house deposit etc.

You're married and have paid off your house. I don’t think in these circumstances I would begrudge my sibling. At 21 your sister needs the help. Do you need help? It’s your dad’s money to do what he wants with.

House is very much not paid off, still got a big mortgage!

OP posts:
FrillyGoatFluff · 30/09/2023 22:44

Judashascomeintosomemoney · 30/09/2023 22:33

Does your mum have other children or are you likely to inherit 100% of her assets? Is that maybe part of his thinking?

I'm only child on mums side. I think that probably is a part of it, but... and this will sound awful, not really my fault?

So yes, I will inherit from mum, but I am also the sole person responsible for her and stepdad with regards to old age care etc, and, realistically likely to be for dad and stepmum too, given that my sister is 3 hours away (and daft as a brush 😂)

If mum and stepdads family histories are anything to go by care costs will be in their future, so money wise, most of it'll be heading there. I'm not going to able to care for four of them alone without professional help.

OP posts:
loveloveloveme · 30/09/2023 22:43

I have a biological sister.
My mum and dad divorced when we were small.
My dad remarried, she already had a son, then they had a son together when I was 11.
I would go absolutely utterly BALLISTIC if my half and step brother were given 50k each of my Nanas money and my sister and I were given nothing.

Bigcat25 · 30/09/2023 22:43

That's horrible Bartlebum, you deserve much better. I know it doesn't' help, but it's him not you. It a real shame your sisters don't see what he's done

Mindovermatter247 · 30/09/2023 22:37

My dad cashed in his pension early, he has a wife who I get on absolutley fine with, they have 3 kids together, so money was understandably used for them being his kids, he gave my brother like 5k for a car, and also just gifted him a different car. I’ve had nothing. Now I don’t need anything off of him, my mum went mental though, not at him as they don’t really talk. She was super pissed. I am a little miffed not that I didn’t get money but that he gave my brother the money straight out, bearing in mind my brother has a better paying job, he earns 2x more than me, he hardly ever visits him or our siblings, doesn’t bother with birthday, Christmas etc, where as I do.

AmandasFleckerl · 30/09/2023 22:36

However, he recently announced that he’s planning to give my sister £50k, to ‘set her up’ for wedding, house deposit etc.

You're married and have paid off your house. I don’t think in these circumstances I would begrudge my sibling. At 21 your sister needs the help. Do you need help? It’s your dad’s money to do what he wants with.

HellNoBedBug · 30/09/2023 22:35

That really is shit.
If he doesn’t reconsider then you know where you stand and you help neither him nor step mum in the future with any care or anything

Judashascomeintosomemoney · 30/09/2023 22:33

Does your mum have other children or are you likely to inherit 100% of her assets? Is that maybe part of his thinking?

Ramalangadingdong · 30/09/2023 22:30

I haven’t RTFT but if I was your sister I would say something to father because this just isn’t fair. I think you are behaving with real dignity. Some people would fly off the handle. I am glad that you are not doing that. Maintain your calm but have a chat to him, tell him how you feel. What an idiot he is. I hope that he sees sense and that things get resolved in your favour.

I believe you when you say that that this isn’t really about the money because I have a similar experience and know where you are coming from.

EnoughIsay · 30/09/2023 22:19

You were raised in an environment of no support. Your dad did not do his share and your mum struggled. You absorbed all that. You never asked for help.

Your sister is raised in an environment of support - dad behaving, mum supported and even granny chipping in. She can ask for/accept support.

It may be time for you to recallibrate.

Go to dad - say you know there is a spare 50k going. That is great news because you assume it will be shared bewteen you and sister. Could not have come at a better time because you have XXXX that needs attending to.

Tell him that you are happy to accept his help, and happy that he can finally help.

Go to him as an equal to your sister. Go to him assuming the best of him.

See what happens.

Iknowthis1 · 30/09/2023 22:08

Someone (your mum, perhaps) needs to tell him that he's not only jeopardising his relationship with you but potentially causing future conflict between you and your sister. He is being an idiot.

SilverOnToast · 30/09/2023 22:02

So interested in the thoughts on this thread. I agree that it’s not really about the money. My youngest brother has made some monumental fuck ups over the years and my parents have bailed him out time and again. He is a bit older now, and seems to have got his life back on track somewhat. My parents recently gave him a substantial house deposit.

We aren’t especially close, but I really feel nothing but relief that he has had their help over the years, and that they’ve helped him out again. I’ve never had financial help from my family, but I also went to uni when fees were means tested (so basically free as my parents earned nothing back then - my brother didn’t go to uni due to cost), and I’ve been fortunate enough not to have suffered significantly with my mental health.

My brother has had a stream of different jobs and I believe he has always felt less-than. He has had health issues I’ve never needed to contend with. He has also always lived beyond his means because he feels ashamed and buries his head in the sand. All this to say: if my parents feel like he needs more money, that’s their decision and I do think that equitable and equal aren’t always the same thing, especially between siblings with a substantial age gap. I am one of five, and I believe my other siblings feel the same way about our parents’ decision: proud to be financially independent and sad that our brother has had to lean on our parents so significantly, partly due to frivolous spending and partly due to the hand he was dealt.

I do feel like we were never treated unequally in terms of care, love and affection though, and I think this is the key thing. The money given to your sister sounds like it is indicative of a larger imbalance of how you’ve been treated which needs addressing.

M103 · 30/09/2023 22:01

That's awful, you have every right to be upset.

addicteetopawpatrol · 30/09/2023 21:54

Mean

Mari9999 · 30/09/2023 21:52

@JANEY205
I'm not suggesting that OP be happy about the situation. I am suggesting that she make her peace with a situation over which she has no control.

Would you suggest that she nurture anger over a situation where she has no control and no real entitlement? How will that make her life any better?

PortalooSunset · 30/09/2023 21:51

FrillyGoatFluff · 30/09/2023 21:22

She's the only recipient. He wants to help set her up. The other 200 is allocated for renovations, holidays and early retirement for stepmum

Bloody hell. I was hoping I'd misunderstood. I'm sorry.

Sunshinenrain · 30/09/2023 21:50

YANBU

I would hope that he meant he’s giving her £50k to set her up (because she’s not got a house etc yet) but is also giving you £50k to spend on what you want.

I would need to speak to him directly and ask if you’re getting the same as sister and if not why not.
Tell him it’s not fair to have favourites and even if you have you don’t blatantly make it obvious.

I would then tell this to your sister and ask her to have a word.
If she’s the favourite then he might listen to her more.

FarEast · 30/09/2023 21:49

IME (of my father, lol) men can be idiots about this sort of thing. Your father sees you all set up and OK, and because you grew up out of his sight, he didn’t see you struggling and grafting. He thinks “Oh @FrillyGoatFluff is fine. It’s baby half-sister who needs my money.”

He doesn’t think, I love them both, I should give them both a nice present.

They do this with wills as well. It’s carelessness and self-centredness. Good for your mother in reminding him - hopefully she’ll keep on reminding him

Also, me and my siblings find that if we are absolutely straight with our father, he will think twice. But he doesn’t take hints - we have to be quite direct, and appeal to his sense of being the wealthy head of the family ( he is) but wanting everyone to like him. So we present money stuff in a very matter of fact way, about family and his money helping his grandchildren. He likes to be the rich patriarch…

Peanuts2000 · 30/09/2023 21:43

You need to tell him how you feel, even if it's by text or email. I'm sure your nan would have wanted you to have money too.
If he doesn't agree then I would tell him not to contact you again.
I may have missed this but did your nan leave a will? Could it be challenged through a solicitor?
I would be extremely angry at this too, unfortunately your dad has shown his true colours.

Bartlebum · 30/09/2023 21:41

@JANEY205 that's a fair question. And one I ask myself a lot. He was a perfect dad to me for six years. Then he left and started again. I did have counseling for it and she said he wasn't a good dad in the first place. But I feel incomplete without him. And thanks to building the bridge back I have a relationship with one of my sisters that is really close. She comes to see me all the time and helps with the children etc. I'm glad of that. And I know she can't see the injustice as it's just how it's always been. It might not be something you question when you're in your 20s.

I see my dad for the kids birthdays and Xmas, so not too much. He leaves and I don't feel torn apart inside and I don't break down in uncontrollable tears like I used to when I said goodbye to him. It's some kind of progress.

I think the people unsupportive of the OP don't understand..it's really not about money, not at all. It's just that's the only tangible thing, the only thing in black and white that proves you aren't important.

StorminanDcup · 30/09/2023 21:40

You have to address it, you can’t just ignore the fact your dad has essentially cut you out of ANY of his family money. SM will undoubtedly outlive him and all hers will go to SS.

Yes yes people can do what they want with their money but this is next level unbelievable.

if we were talking a small gift of a few grand you could let it go but 50k? That’s a huge sum.

I would address this, just you and him, no one else there and simply say “I am really struggling to understand how you’ve rationalised this in your head, so I need you to explain your rationale because at the moment I am feeling extremely hurt and confused”

listen to what he has to say and then make a decision if this is something you can accept or if it is going to change your relationship permanently

gotomomo · 30/09/2023 21:35

Most families (not mine actually) have examples like this, I know several people often the eldest who seem to be treated very unfavourably in life and death to younger sibling(s) even with step situations being involved. Certainly in dp's family there's a of disparity though you have to just let it go, more to life than money and we have enough

JANEY205 · 30/09/2023 21:33

Mari9999 · 30/09/2023 21:31

@FrillyGoatFluff
Anger over the disposition of money thaYt is not yours only hurts you. If you do not let this go, it will eat at you and not at anyone else.

Your dad, for whatever reason, has probably convinced himself that this the right thing to do. It may even have been something that his mom suggested. If you were married and settled, it may just have been a way of providing for the younger child who is still in school.

As painful as it may be to see him taking a fatherly interest in the child that he actually reared, you are not missing anything that you had any real reason to expect. You will only hurt yourself by nurturing your anger. You would not be at all angry if he had spent all of the money on his new property or other items for himself.

Be grateful that you were able to provide for yourself, that is a blessing. You should not feel cheated because your ability to provide came through your own efforts. That is something for which you should be proud.

You can share your feelings with your dad, but then what are you expecting him to do about those feelings?

This is outrageous! Her dad is a prick and needs telling. Of course she should expect and DESERVES a Dad who treated her how he treats his other child. You may be happy with people treating you like shite compared to others but don’t suggest OP needs to join in.

Lavender14 · 30/09/2023 21:33

I would be honest with your dad and say exactly what you've said here, that you feel hurt that he's making a difference between you both and you can't imagine treating your girls differently. I wouldn't say you want the money etc just that you know what he's planning and you're extremely hurt by his lack of consideration for you.