Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child favouritism to the tune of 50k

241 replies

FrillyGoatFluff · 30/09/2023 18:54

Please bear with, there’s some background!

I’m mid-30s, married with one daughter (toddler). I live with my DH and two DSDs (no contact with mum, we are entirely responsible 100%, financially and otherwise).

We paid for our house entirely ourselves, no help from family etc, same with our wedding. Have never asked anyone for a penny.

My half sister (dads daughter) is 21. At uni but lives with BF in her uni city. He works, earns well, lovely guy. She’s nearly finished her degree, looking at great grades and has a solid future plan. They’ve been together 3 years, talk of getting engaged when she graduates. I have no other siblings.

My Nan (dads mum) recently passed away, and dad is talking about selling the family home (he, stepmum and Nan lived together in nans house) and buying somewhere smaller. Would free up about £250k (we’re in the south east). Dad and I live in the same village, which he plans to continue living in. Fab.

However, he recently announced that he’s planning to give my sister £50k, to ‘set her up’ for wedding, house deposit etc.

Now, I love my sister, and honestly do want her to have the money for all of the above but I’m REALLY narky that she’s getting a £50k handout, and I’m getting bugger all. I appreciate it’s his cash to do what he wants with, but actually, it’s not even about the money, it’s genuinely not, it’s the fact that I feel totally second best.

For history, mum chucked my dad out when I was two (affair, he then married her, she was a ballache) and was sporadic with child support - both financial, and emotional. Mum bought me up and it was tough, financially, we were up against it. My sister, however, was a two parent family (three really, my Nan was there too), wanted for nothing - dance classes, drama lessons, foreign school trips, uni paid for - financially, she has been well catered for, and had a much easier time of things. Dad seemed to grow up by the time he had her, I was a bit of a learning curve I think, the training daughter almost.

My dad told my mum about his financial plans the other day (they’re arms-length-friends now, for the sake of my daughter) and she pointedly said ‘don’t forget you have two daughters’ and his response was ‘well yes, but I want to set X up’. With one biological daughter of my own and two DSDs, I cannot imagine for one second treating any of them this differently, I can’t see how he can justify it in his head?

Am I being totally ridiculous? Yes, I absolutely DO have my life together (through pure hard work on my and DH’s part!), should i to just let it go and accept my dad is a total fuckwomble??? I really can’t decide if I’m being a drama queen or not, but we live 500yards apart so I can’t avoid the subject forever!

OP posts:
Tinkerbyebye · 01/10/2023 09:41

YANBU. It’s not fair and I would be telling your father, calmly, how upset this has made you. It’s a joint nans money, he is choosing to spend on one daughter, when he has two. I would explain that due to him leaving for another woman, and not paying maintenance you had a much tougher childhood than your sister. That he wasn’t there for you, that you may look successful but it’s taken blood sweat and tears and no help from him, and that he is being totally unfair and favourtising your sister. He had two children

tbh I am not sure it’s something I would be able to get over and I would start to withdraw to protect myself

user14699084658 · 01/10/2023 09:29

You have my sympathy OP - we are in a similar situation, but much bigger sums involved!
DH’s siblings and children have been bought houses, cars, weddings, Horses, land and stables for the Horses…while DH and our kids have received nothing!
I expect his parents see it that he can paddle his own canoe financially, and he can, we are lucky to have a very successful business which he works very hard at, but its hard for me to see the low level upset it causes, he very much feels the outsider, the less loved child.
It isn’t about the money, (we have plenty of that) it’s a sure fire way of throwing a grenade into family relationships not treating siblings equally.

Sceptre86 · 01/10/2023 08:06

Honestly if you were in the room why didn't you challenge him? I'd have said my piece and left the house. If you let yourself be taken for a mug that is exactly how people will treat you. I'd be telling lil sis when it comes to childcare for her dad and mum that she can grow up and do it herself. Your dad decided long ago he wasn't responsible for you so why are you for him? Get it together op, if he can't do the same for you he has no place in your life. You are wasting your time on someone who doesn't love you as you do them.

Whatafustercluck · 01/10/2023 08:03

It all sounds dreadfully unfair. However, to play devil's advocate, could it be possible that your dad views the £50k simply.as an advance on her inheritance? So, could he be releasing money a little.early for your sister so he can help her now, but even things up upon his death? It's the only explanation I can think of really. I'm sorry, op. Whichever way it goes, I think you need an honest amd fairly brutal discussion with your dad.

Daffodilwoman · 01/10/2023 08:00

I’m sorry to say this op but it’s quite obvious that you don’t mean much to your father.
He views his child with his new wife as special. As his child. He walked away from you and doesn’t see you the same.
Being a decent person, you cannot comprehend this type of behaviour. Cut him off. You will not be caring for him in his old age his much younger wife will. Neither he or she are your problem. You weren’t his problem in your time of need were you?
You will not change him.
The fact is there are many men like this.
Stop trying to apply laws of decency and fairness to a man who does not live by these rules.
From now on regard him as what he is, someone who got your mother pregnant a long time ago. Otherwise you will drive yourself crazy.

LilyJessie · 01/10/2023 07:38

I feel you in regards to this, I suffer the same issues.
I too feel it is not about the money, it's is about the fact you feel you don't matter.
It's horrible and I'm so sorry. He will be totally oblivious mind. It isn't you, it's him.
X

Cherryana · 01/10/2023 07:30

You need a plan:

  1. Sit down with him, face to face and ask him if he intends to give you 50K as well, as your sister?
(Be clear and not ambiguous).
  1. If no, tell him straight about how this makes you feel unimportant and ignored as a daughter. You have made peace with seeing your sister have money growing up, opportunities to drama and dance lessons, things that you would have loved to do, but as he knows money was a struggle. Now he has a real chance to gift me some of my grandmothers money - it does not make sense.

3.If there is ‘only’ 50K suggest it is split between you and your sister -25K each.

4.If you don’t get anywhere - let your mum send the letter and try and get him to pay now.

5.His actions have ruined many relationships here whether you get any money or not.

FarEast · 01/10/2023 07:26

Say something and don’t let him change this subject. Tell him how hurt you are by this decision and how it will affect your relationship long term.

We found this was what worked with my father. We weren’t asking him for money - we just told him how it made us feel that he was planning to give money to someone else’s child (not even a half-sibling).

AmandasFleckerl · 01/10/2023 06:29

FrillyGoatFluff · 30/09/2023 22:45

House is very much not paid off, still got a big mortgage!

Reading your comment We paid for our house entirely ourselves made me think otherwise. Regardless is this worth a potential rift? My parents have helped both of my brothers with deposits for homes over the last 10 years because of their financial situation after divorce. I don’t feel that I am owed anything because I wasn’t given money too and likewise brother 1 doesn’t feel shortchanged because brother 2 received more money. If you need help tell your father that, rather than just saying it’s not fair. But if you’re ok financially what is the problem?

PivotPivotmakingmargaritas · 01/10/2023 02:16

Agree with a previous poster saying nothing will breed resentment. Say something and don’t let him change this subject. Tell him how hurt you are by this decision and how it will affect your relationship long term. Even go as far as saying if you prioritise one daughter over the other do not turn to me in your old age.

Your dads behaviour is disgusting to you and apparently to your mum while you were a kid so he needs to put up now.

How are you so passive about this?!? I’m raging for you and your family especially your mum

Happiestonthebeach · 01/10/2023 01:56

You have two options: discuss it with him or say nothing- if you choose to say nothing you’re likely to be eaten with resentment so I think it would be sensible to discuss.

if you bring it up- he may give you a reason you’ve not thought of, or suggest splitting more evenly. Or he may confirm he’s thoughtless and insensitive. You can then decide whether that affects your relationship with him accordingly.

Nanaof1 · 01/10/2023 01:51

FrillyGoatFluff · 30/09/2023 22:44

I'm only child on mums side. I think that probably is a part of it, but... and this will sound awful, not really my fault?

So yes, I will inherit from mum, but I am also the sole person responsible for her and stepdad with regards to old age care etc, and, realistically likely to be for dad and stepmum too, given that my sister is 3 hours away (and daft as a brush 😂)

If mum and stepdads family histories are anything to go by care costs will be in their future, so money wise, most of it'll be heading there. I'm not going to able to care for four of them alone without professional help.

I can see you helping take care of DM and SF, as your DM raised you alone and worked very hard to do so. You have a good heart and care, so they are very lucky to have you in their lives. You have no obligation to them but I think you want to make sure you are there for them.

Your NVDF and SM, however, did not raise you, nor have they seemed to ever have your back. Though you are kind and caring, you owe them nothing as they age. Nothing at all. They have shown you their true colors so believe them. Being your NVDF does not equal an obligation on your part. Your sister, who was raised by them can make whatever decisions necessary concerning them.

You cannot be expected to care for four aging adults, if it even comes to that, so you prioritize.

caringcarer · 01/10/2023 01:47

Onthemaintrunkline · 01/10/2023 01:34

I think it’s astonishing that others haven’t had your back in this….firstly your sister, secondly your Mother and thirdly your step-mother, don’t they see the inequality here🤷🏻‍♀️!

This, your sister should have pointed out to your Dad how unfair his plan is.

Nanaof1 · 01/10/2023 01:39

caringcarer · 30/09/2023 19:26

This. If he still gives your sister £50k and not you I'd go NC with him.

So would I.

I bet the SM would have no problem assuming the OP would give time to help care for her DF if he needs it in the future but not expect anything from her own child.
OP--I am sorry that you have been low on the totem pole for your life. I admire you having a relationship with your DF because I would not be able to do it. Ditto for the PP whose own mother treats her so shabbily. It would be NC at all and no help if they need it in the future.

Onthemaintrunkline · 01/10/2023 01:34

I think it’s astonishing that others haven’t had your back in this….firstly your sister, secondly your Mother and thirdly your step-mother, don’t they see the inequality here🤷🏻‍♀️!

Mari9999 · 30/09/2023 23:58

It is so sad that family relationships often end because of money and yet all involved would probably swear on a stack of bibles that it was not transactional and not about the money. But it always ends up being about money, and in this case money that did no belong to any of the actors in this current drama. The money actually belonged to the deceased grandmother, and yet not any of the people currently involved contributed any money towards the payment of grandma's house.

Bored1000 · 30/09/2023 23:40

Maybe let your balsy mother handle it then and stay out of it, she sounds enraged by it all and quite rightly so!
If she can’t convince him to do the right thing, I doubt you would be able to convince him either
Its going to be difficult if he has already promised the money to your sister though and then has to go back on his promise, could your sister potentially fall out with you over this or would she understand

ittakes2 · 30/09/2023 23:33

I'm sorry that's very hurtful.

FrillyGoatFluff · 30/09/2023 23:21

Bored1000 · 30/09/2023 23:16

It does sound unfair, but unfortunately it dosent sound like he sees this

What do you think his response would be if you mentioned this to him?

I think he's probably change the subject very quickly, or parrot out the same line about wanting to get little sis sorted.

He changed the subject when my mum challenged him (and she's much blunter than me!) and that was firmly the end of the conversation.

My mum is livid. She has a letter from him sent via his solicitor when I was about 15, saying he couldn't pay maintenance or repay X amount that was owed because 'as she well knows he has a family to support'. She's going on about delivering him a copy of the letter, saying 'I'll call in this debt now thanks' 😬 she's far more ballsy than I am!

OP posts:
Lieblingsessen · 30/09/2023 23:18

My father had another family and I only had sporadic contact with him over the years. Whenever we spoke, which was mainly by phone, i couldn't bring myself to call him dad, father, or even his name.

That is how much I resented him not being in or interested in my life.

Your father started a new family, and basically cut you adrift. Someone mentioned about the fact that he reared your sister explains how he favours her, and that is to be expected. That view just enrages me no end.

OP you have mentioned about possibly caring for your mum and step dad and your dad and step mum. Why are you even considering that about your father and stepmother, after he has showed you he doesn't care about you? Just why?

You need to back off from him, just as he did to you when you most needed him when you were younger.

Karma needs to bite him on the bum, when he needs help in later years. Your sister can deal with him. If needed just move away, so he gets the message not to come calling.

Bored1000 · 30/09/2023 23:16

It does sound unfair, but unfortunately it dosent sound like he sees this

What do you think his response would be if you mentioned this to him?

SirVixofVixHall · 30/09/2023 23:14

WindowsSmindows · 30/09/2023 19:01

You have to calmly tell him that it is clearly unfair and risks driving a wedge between you and your sister and between you and your father.
Because it does.

I agree. You should tell him what you said in your OP, that you went without a lot growing up, your sister has been far more advantaged, and while you can forgive and understand that to a certain extent, you really couldn’t forgive him playing favourites with your joint Grandmother’s money . It is a horrible thing to do OP. He needs some home truths about his slack parenting when you were growing up.

SunnyLiving · 30/09/2023 22:57

Sorry OP but your dad sounds awful. Not someone I would want in mine or my children’s lives. It’s absolutely not about the money, but about the principle of his second daughter being “worthy” of his inheritance while you and grandkids are left out. I’m so sorry you have to deal with this. 😞

JustAMinutePleass · 30/09/2023 22:51

FrillyGoatFluff · 30/09/2023 22:44

I'm only child on mums side. I think that probably is a part of it, but... and this will sound awful, not really my fault?

So yes, I will inherit from mum, but I am also the sole person responsible for her and stepdad with regards to old age care etc, and, realistically likely to be for dad and stepmum too, given that my sister is 3 hours away (and daft as a brush 😂)

If mum and stepdads family histories are anything to go by care costs will be in their future, so money wise, most of it'll be heading there. I'm not going to able to care for four of them alone without professional help.

Not your problem. Make it clear to your Dad too - the daughter he gives money to is the one who should be the carer (and also the one whose children he should bank on seeing regularly). Cut him off. Encourage your dd not to call him grandpa as he isn’t. He’s a pig.

kamboozled · 30/09/2023 22:50

I'm jealous on your behalf!! Honestly, I'd ask him directly if you're not his biological daughter, because I can see no other reason for this treatment....

Swipe left for the next trending thread