Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child favouritism to the tune of 50k

241 replies

FrillyGoatFluff · 30/09/2023 18:54

Please bear with, there’s some background!

I’m mid-30s, married with one daughter (toddler). I live with my DH and two DSDs (no contact with mum, we are entirely responsible 100%, financially and otherwise).

We paid for our house entirely ourselves, no help from family etc, same with our wedding. Have never asked anyone for a penny.

My half sister (dads daughter) is 21. At uni but lives with BF in her uni city. He works, earns well, lovely guy. She’s nearly finished her degree, looking at great grades and has a solid future plan. They’ve been together 3 years, talk of getting engaged when she graduates. I have no other siblings.

My Nan (dads mum) recently passed away, and dad is talking about selling the family home (he, stepmum and Nan lived together in nans house) and buying somewhere smaller. Would free up about £250k (we’re in the south east). Dad and I live in the same village, which he plans to continue living in. Fab.

However, he recently announced that he’s planning to give my sister £50k, to ‘set her up’ for wedding, house deposit etc.

Now, I love my sister, and honestly do want her to have the money for all of the above but I’m REALLY narky that she’s getting a £50k handout, and I’m getting bugger all. I appreciate it’s his cash to do what he wants with, but actually, it’s not even about the money, it’s genuinely not, it’s the fact that I feel totally second best.

For history, mum chucked my dad out when I was two (affair, he then married her, she was a ballache) and was sporadic with child support - both financial, and emotional. Mum bought me up and it was tough, financially, we were up against it. My sister, however, was a two parent family (three really, my Nan was there too), wanted for nothing - dance classes, drama lessons, foreign school trips, uni paid for - financially, she has been well catered for, and had a much easier time of things. Dad seemed to grow up by the time he had her, I was a bit of a learning curve I think, the training daughter almost.

My dad told my mum about his financial plans the other day (they’re arms-length-friends now, for the sake of my daughter) and she pointedly said ‘don’t forget you have two daughters’ and his response was ‘well yes, but I want to set X up’. With one biological daughter of my own and two DSDs, I cannot imagine for one second treating any of them this differently, I can’t see how he can justify it in his head?

Am I being totally ridiculous? Yes, I absolutely DO have my life together (through pure hard work on my and DH’s part!), should i to just let it go and accept my dad is a total fuckwomble??? I really can’t decide if I’m being a drama queen or not, but we live 500yards apart so I can’t avoid the subject forever!

OP posts:
PoppyTries · 01/10/2023 22:07

FrillyGoatFluff · 01/10/2023 20:39

DBIL has just sent me a vid of dad, stepmum and sis scattering Nan's ashes.

Dad earlier updated me with a text saying they'd all arrived and were drinking wine overlooking the harbour.

I know I am probably just being pissy now, and they're prob doing it to be nice and involve me, but the running commentary is winding me up!

I would be sorely tempted to reply “She was my Nan too. I would have liked to have been there, or at least have been invited, but I suppose I’ve always been a bit of an afterthought to you.”

I’m so sorry you’re having to experience this.

Cgar2018 · 01/10/2023 21:55

Gosh I could have written this too. Wasn’t my parents but my MIL. Sold a BTL property and gave the proceeds to my husband’s brother for deposit on place of his own and my husband got zero. Same sentiment - my husband already owned a house, had a good job etc whereas my BIL dropped out of school and never really had a stable career. Sadly, on confrontation my MIL didn’t understand what she had done wrong. This was five years ago and I’ll never forget what she did.

My mum saw this with my dad’s siblings - the ones that were total screw ups got the additional financial support, so she coined the phrase “he who f*cks up the most, gets the most”. Makes you wonder whether in some families it’s worth working hard if you constantly get bailed out by bank of mum and dad….

GabriellaFaith · 01/10/2023 21:00

I think I'd ask him casually like "did you decide about the £50k?" and if he says yes, have an answer ready like "well that's a weight off my shoulders with the girls driving lessons coming up. Even add in you'd love for your girls to have dance lessons like your sister did because you always felt like you missed out 🙊🤷🏻‍♀️😆

Gagaandgag · 01/10/2023 20:42

I also agree with this approach. Be clear and calm.

If you don’t start the conversation you will hold it within you and it will eat away at you and your relationships. I’m sorry OP, I would feel exactly the same. And I agree it’s not always about the money/value. Best of luck

FrillyGoatFluff · 01/10/2023 20:39

DBIL has just sent me a vid of dad, stepmum and sis scattering Nan's ashes.

Dad earlier updated me with a text saying they'd all arrived and were drinking wine overlooking the harbour.

I know I am probably just being pissy now, and they're prob doing it to be nice and involve me, but the running commentary is winding me up!

OP posts:
AbbeyGailsParty · 01/10/2023 20:18

That’s a horrible thing for your father to do and awful that he can’t see how bad it is.

Playingintheshadow · 01/10/2023 20:13

Mari9999 · 01/10/2023 20:01

@hby9628
If your parents loved you, cared for you as a child, and helped in every way possible to prepare you to become a productive, self sufficient adult, what else do they owe you or any of your siblings? There assets should be theirs to dispose of as they see fit. They worked to earn whatever, and they should be free to leave it all to 1 child or to the local animal shelter if they so choose.

If you are caring for them out of love and concern, that is as it should be. If you are doing out of a desire to get "best child " place in the inheritance pool that is unfortunate.

Another one spectacularly missing the point!!

Playingintheshadow · 01/10/2023 20:11

Viviennemary · 30/09/2023 21:29

Your house is paid off. So he probably thinks you don't need a hand out. I kind of agree with him.

That is so not the point!!

Mari9999 · 01/10/2023 20:01

@hby9628
If your parents loved you, cared for you as a child, and helped in every way possible to prepare you to become a productive, self sufficient adult, what else do they owe you or any of your siblings? There assets should be theirs to dispose of as they see fit. They worked to earn whatever, and they should be free to leave it all to 1 child or to the local animal shelter if they so choose.

If you are caring for them out of love and concern, that is as it should be. If you are doing out of a desire to get "best child " place in the inheritance pool that is unfortunate.

Newbie999 · 01/10/2023 20:00

YANBU!!

if your sister is a decent person she will ask your Dad to make things right or give you half of the bequest
However, if your sister is a shit like mine was when I had a similar situation she will just say “it’s mine”.

your Dad sounds horrible. Your sister should bear your feelings in mind. I would tell them both how you feel!

Reality25 · 01/10/2023 19:55

Ask your sister for justice.

If she refuses, it's time to go scorched earth and ditch them all.

It's times like this where people show their true colours.

Fluffmum · 01/10/2023 19:52

Dreadful behaviour by Dad.

hby9628 · 01/10/2023 19:49

I'm in a similar situation. It's made me confused really as I'm the child who looks after my parent & always checks in on them etc but the shitty sibling gets the hand outs but mine will come when I inherit. Presuming there is something to inherit. I think it's because I'm stable financially & with my relationship so they don't think I need the money & im not desperate for it but it's more about being treated unfairly that upsets me.
I think more than anything it just makes me feel a bit sad.
I don't know the answer. In my case I'm
not going to do anything because I don't want to upset my parent but it doesn't sit right with me & I would never do that to my kids.

Utterknowitall · 01/10/2023 19:40

I haven't rtft but I wonder if the 50k is coming out of her inheritance. For example, if Dad leaves his money to you two girls equally, his Will may state that your dsd has already had 50k. If he predeceases DSM, which is likely, he may still leave half his assets to you on her death.

Mari9999 · 01/10/2023 19:38

@Oldandnonethewiserlol
There is no universal best practices in disposing of your assets other than as you think best Some jurisdictions have laws governing distribution in cases of people who die intestate. In this case the dad is planning to gift his daughter prior to his death so that won't be an issue.

In working class families, parents are often able to do more for younger children simply because their income increases over time and the number of dependent children decreases over time. No one blinks an eye at that situation. How is this any different? The working class dad is finally in a position to do for his youngest that which he was never able to do for his oldest. It is not a matter of favoritism ; it is a matter of placement in line and timing of resource availability.

My cousin has 3 sons ages 32, 29, and 16. He and his wife have done shift work throughout their marriage. They were able to assist their sons with college tuition, but both boys had to work and take out loans to cover the difference.

With 2 dependents college graduates and gainfully employed, he was able to buy the 16 year old a new car for his 16th birthday and will be able to pay his college tuition without the last son having to take out loans. This was not a matter of favoritism. It was a matter of finally being in a position to do for one child that which at the time he ideally would like to have been able to do for all of his children. His older sons are not angry nor do they feel cheated. They realize that they each in turn got however much or little that was in the coffers at the time.

The dad may be thinking that for once, he wants to do all if the things that he was never in a position to do before.

Is that a valid thought for him to have? Who is entitled to say? Is the OP's thought valid ? Who has a right to say?
These 2 people should communicate their feelings to each other (not through intermediaries ) and see if they can reach an understanding.

The only absolute truth in this situation is that neither of these parties contribute any resources towards the payment of grandma's house and as such should not really have expected to benefit in anyway.

Gothambutnotahamster · 01/10/2023 19:35

That's so unfair of your dad Op, but I cant see what you can do about it unfortunately?! Speak to him by all means, but don't get your hopes up that you'll get any sort of satisfactory response. He sounds like a feckless waste of a man IMHO.

Gillypie23 · 01/10/2023 19:27

Absolutely not. Your dad is being totally unfair. You need to talk to him about it. I'd be devastated if my dad did this to me.

mandlerparr · 01/10/2023 19:24

Sounds like he has always been like this towards you and the money thing is just an enormous, blatant sign shouting it for everyone to see. he basically put his lack of feelings and care into every single one of those pennies.
I would guess that he also has a bit of the "this world owes me" attitude most of the time.

AllyArty · 01/10/2023 19:13

It doesn’t sound ok to me and by doing this he is setting up all sorts of family issues. What do you think he would say if you asked him why he’s giving her 50k, and u nothing? Is it possible that he has something set aside for you/your family ? Family life is tough at the best of times and some people are thoughtless and seem to square off an unfair situation because it suits them to financially or emotionally. You are right to be upset.

FarEast · 01/10/2023 19:05

Many parents have a favourite child. They don't like to admit it, but the children know.

NewName122 · 01/10/2023 19:04

She's quite obviously the favourite daughter. Extremely unfair. Your dad sounds awful.

Oldandnonethewiserlol · 01/10/2023 18:56

I have two grown up children, only one of whom has a child. My DS has a professional job and earns a very good salary and has an easy life with his wife and daughter. My DD struggles with money as she does not earn much but works hard and lives within her means.
When we gifted them some money a few years ago when their grandfather passed away, they got EXACTLY the same sum. I would not dream of treating differently.
My MIL in her will left 60% to her daughter (who convinced her to change the will from 50/50 when FIL was alive) and 40% to her son which created a rift in the family and upset my DH who felt and still feels second best.
When my parents passed away some years ago, my 3 sisters and I got exactly the same amount of money.
I would feel upset in your place and would talk to my father about it.

FarEast · 01/10/2023 18:52

ThatsLifeIGuess · 01/10/2023 14:25

But if the Grandmother's estate was left to him, it's up to him to spend it as he see's fit?

It's hard to bring this up without seeming grabby. Afterall, you could assume that the sibling has not asked for a penny.

Which is why I suggest that@FrillyGoatFluff does not in any way ask for some of the money from her grandmother's estate. She just asks her father why he's treating his 2 daughters so differently.

Then she can respond to his answer. But he needs to be asked to think about the consequences of his actions - his thoughtlessness or his obvious favouritism.

I'm advising this because I think sometimes men in this situation are not deliberately or consciously exercising favouritism - they're just thoughtless & irresponsible - I'm giving OP's father the benefit of the doubt that he's never really thought about the impact of his decision on his other daughter. He's looking at his younger DD thinking "Oh, she's just starting out. I'm in a position to help her" - if pushed, I imagine he looks at @FrillyGoatFluff and thinks, "She's well set up & doing OK."

He doesn't realise what this looks like to his elder DD. He needs to know the impact of his proposal on her feelings. She's not asking for the money (at least at first); she's asking about why he loves & cares for her less than for his younger DD.

That might shock this stupid man out of his unthinking cruelty.

LizM66 · 01/10/2023 18:48

This must hurt. But at end of day it is their money. I am cut out totally of parents (substantial) will. My parents kept telling me treated and loved us equally. I kept challenging not due to finances but the bull. Finally admitted "We can't speak to X(sib) as we speak to you as we will lose a child". (My youngest reminded me that my mum always told her could not speak to sibs children like spoke to her What they have given me tho is priceless...a template of how to break the dysfunctional cycle and really work on making sure I change my families narrative. Focus on those who love you unconditionally and not those who cannot/will not change. Do not be bitter

Rachand23 · 01/10/2023 18:40

You need to tell him what you have written here. Unless you do he will go on as blindly as he’s has done all this time. I would also tell your sister and Nan too. This needs to be out in the open or it will just fester and grow into a huge big green monster that will make you ill. If he still wishes to go with this AND your sister accepts this you will seriously need to reconsider your contact with these people, it will be a show of how they value you. Good luck.

Swipe left for the next trending thread