Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thread gallery
12
Livingtothefull · 02/10/2023 16:10

It is often women who have been through pregnancy and childbirth and know what it entails, who are most insistent of the right to an abortion, regardless of whether they have actually had one themselves. That is certainly the case for me.

Several women have posted their own stories on this thread. Here's mine:

At around 26 weeks of pregnancy I started to feel ill, was diagnosed with pre-eclampsia which couldn't be controlled. If the pregnancy had continued both I and DS would be dead. I have never forgotten the terror I felt when I thought I really might die.

Just a few weeks earlier and I might have been facing an abortion to save my life. As it was, one emergency CS later and I was recovering but DS was fighting for his life. He did recover though has severe lifelong physical and learning difficulties. We are good now...but even though he was a much wanted baby and I was in a stable personal and family situation, the whole experience taxed my mental health to the limit. It would probably have been too much for a more vulnerable mother - and the idea of her being unwillingly pregnant doesn't bear thinking about.

It is in my view immoral for any so called 'pro-lifer' to demand that any woman should be denied an abortion and risk having to go through experiences like these. It is just too much to demand of any other human being. But then these people don't see women as human beings do they?

YokoOnosBigHat · 02/10/2023 12:10

Oh my God @SchoolQuestionnaire that would be laughable if it wasn't so fucking awful. So what, foetuses have rights if the woman wants to get rid of them, but not if they don't? Making it ever-clearer that it's not about "babies", it's about women. And hating women.

Livingtothefull · 02/10/2023 11:12

GilbertMarkham · 02/10/2023 10:42

He, he, he ..... Father.

Why male?

Because we've lived in a male dominated society, because men had the power?

Apparently man is made in the image of God.

But we know that y chromosomes only have the information necessary to turn a fetus male, everything else - every single instruction is on the X chromosome, the female chromosome. This is why males will suffer eg haemophiliac or types of muscular dystrophy, but not females - who have two x chromosomes to make up for faults on one.

Males also have nipples because the prototype, original fetus is female.

So why is god male?

Also, how also can a woman, with womb, ovaries and vagina - be made after a man who has the corresponding eg reproductive organs?? So it was figured out how to build reproduction into a human male, and how it would work perfectly with a corresponding human (female) without creating the female?

Or was he not a man like he is now, did he have no sexual organs?

Or was the blueprint for the female made at the same time but for inexplicable reasons held back and not released with human male 1.1? No, because we are told females were made from a man's rib bone, and after him -to give him company.

Except that's not physically possible - with two creatures - animals - with corresponding reproductive organs.

A narrative invented and written by men, for men.

Edited

Indeed. These views date from a time when it really was believed that women were just incubators for human life; that the father provided the seed and the mother just the soil where he chose to 'plant' his children.

This was from a time before discovery of the ovaries and the reality that a child has the genetic inheritance of both parents. But some peoples' views have never caught up.

The 'pro-life' anti abortion arguments derive from male hostility towards, and contempt for, women. It is not even about the best interests of the child (we already know they don't care about the mother) it is about claiming ownership of their genetic 'property'. Whether they like it or not, anti-abortion campaigners are misogynists.

Insommmmnia · 02/10/2023 11:11

For the avoidance of doubt; the Bible is silent on the subject of abortion. And this despite the fact it has always been practised, since ancient times.

Exactly

Abortion was practiced at the time various parts of the bible were written. However, unlike many other parts of life the Bible does dictate, it doesn't mention abortion. Therefore to me, it makes sense that Christianity is actually pro choice

The bible doesn't dictate that abortions should occur in certain circumstances, it doesn't dictate that abortions shouldn't occur in certain circumstances it leaves it up to the free choice of the individual. You can't really get any more pro choice than that.

And whether or not the bible was pro choice, pro life, forced birth or anything inbetween is highly irrelevant. As I don't feel laws should be based on one religion over another or no religion at all. And I notice @Babochan88 neatly skipped the questions about how they would feel if other people's religious beliefs were forced upon them through law. I have a feeling they would not be quite so happy about that.

It takes an incredible amount of arrogance to believe that your one interpretation of the bible and religion is the only one that could possibly be correct. An amount of arrogance that is actually discussed and condemned in the bible (unlike abortion)

Perhaps @Babochan88 should pay a little more attention to things like this:

Everyone who is arrogant in heart is an abomination to the Lord; be assured, he will not go unpunished

Or this

I will put an end to the pomp of the arrogant, and lay low the pompous pride of the ruthless.

Rather than thinking the deaths of millions of women is justifiable because boys might be born from their deaths.

SerafinasGoose · 02/10/2023 11:09

Passepartoute · 02/10/2023 09:17

For those that have had abortions, please know that you’re loved more than you could ever imagine by God. Whether you believe it or not he loves you an infinite amount. If you have a second shoot him up a prayer he’s always listening and desperate for you to speak to him - he’s your father who made you and watched over you from womb till now and absolutely delights in you.

I wish I understood people who believe in this. How does such an infinitely loving and omnipotent being allow babies to develop without lungs so that, if they survive birth, they will simply suffocate and die? And, if it does, how does it then proclaim that it is wrong to prevent that suffering? I've never yet seen an explanation that remotely works.

I've been following this thread, but as yet haven't commented.

You won't receive an explanation, because it is not rational. A 'pro-life' stance is curiously anti-life when it comes to the fundamental human rights of women.

When our rights are viewed to be in direct conflict with another vulnerable group (or a group that isn't necessarily vulnerable but paints itself as such, which of course is another argument) - women always lose. The lives of women matter less than the lives of others. And, despite the fact that sex is a clearly defined characteristic under the 2010 Equality Act, and that hate speech and verbally articulated prejudice against all other charactersitics is defined as a criminal offence, misogyny is not a hate crime. This tells us everything we need to know about the way society views us. It tells us why feminism and women's rights movements are not obsolete, but are more necessary now than they have perhaps been for a century past. The pushback, horrible prejudice and silencing tactics used against such women's protests - or even under-the-radar meetings - are evidence enough that little has changed and we've even gone backwards by a significant margin since the second wave.

There are many Christians on this thread who don't talk in the misogynist terms of assuming complete bodily autonomy on behalf of other human beings. This is the religion which persecuted women for witchcraft. And amongst the many groups of women, aside from those who ere older or independent, some of those who came in for the worst of it were herbalists, faith healers and - you guessed it - midwives.

Why would I, a pagan, for one moment accept a Christian rule of law over my own bodily autonomy? They've been doing this to women for quite long enough. Women on the other side of the Atlantic have my heartfelt sympathy and solidatarity. That such a thing could be happening to them, in a supposedly civilized, developed nation in 2023, defies all reason and compassion altogether.

GilbertMarkham · 02/10/2023 10:42

He, he, he ..... Father.

Why male?

Because we've lived in a male dominated society, because men had the power?

Apparently man is made in the image of God.

But we know that y chromosomes only have the information necessary to turn a fetus male, everything else - every single instruction is on the X chromosome, the female chromosome. This is why males will suffer eg haemophiliac or types of muscular dystrophy, but not females - who have two x chromosomes to make up for faults on one.

Males also have nipples because the prototype, original fetus is female.

So why is god male?

Also, how also can a woman, with womb, ovaries and vagina - be made after a man who has the corresponding eg reproductive organs?? So it was figured out how to build reproduction into a human male, and how it would work perfectly with a corresponding human (female) without creating the female?

Or was he not a man like he is now, did he have no sexual organs?

Or was the blueprint for the female made at the same time but for inexplicable reasons held back and not released with human male 1.1? No, because we are told females were made from a man's rib bone, and after him -to give him company.

Except that's not physically possible - with two creatures - animals - with corresponding reproductive organs.

A narrative invented and written by men, for men.

Passepartoute · 02/10/2023 09:17

For those that have had abortions, please know that you’re loved more than you could ever imagine by God. Whether you believe it or not he loves you an infinite amount. If you have a second shoot him up a prayer he’s always listening and desperate for you to speak to him - he’s your father who made you and watched over you from womb till now and absolutely delights in you.

I wish I understood people who believe in this. How does such an infinitely loving and omnipotent being allow babies to develop without lungs so that, if they survive birth, they will simply suffocate and die? And, if it does, how does it then proclaim that it is wrong to prevent that suffering? I've never yet seen an explanation that remotely works.

Pemba · 02/10/2023 09:12

Obviously it's a bloke. From the USA too I'm guessing, due to some of the references given. He could at least be honest.

pointythings · 02/10/2023 08:57

Brefugee · 02/10/2023 07:50

Sorry to harp on but I wanted to come back yo this.

I believe people holding these views (everything Babochan88 posted in this thread) are terrible. And we must be protected from these views affecting us, the non-religious, those of other faiths, those not of this abhorrent, hypocritical fundie-"Christianity"

I agree completely. If you hold views like these, you lack whatever it is that makes the rest of us human. Unfortunately that lack also comes with a total lack of insight.

Livingtothefull · 02/10/2023 08:20

Babochan88 · 01/10/2023 14:24

Respectfully, I purposely ignored your question because I don’t need to disclose my personal life on the internet. my personal circumstances have no baring on this discussion, neither do yours.

This is just a discussion, we don’t need to make things personal.

However I understand it’s brought up many difficult feelings for people which I’m sorry about. The topic of abortion is hard and complicated and challenging and difficult. I do understand that every situation is difficult and needs its own particular wisdom.

I'm afraid this does read as a total copout. Of course you are not obliged to share personal information; however, your silence will cause readers to draw their own conclusions. On the subject of abortion, personal circumstances are everything, because the implications of it - and of banning it - can only be understood at a personal level. Many posters here have shared their sensitive personal experiences to illustrate why abortion rights are utterly critical.

To deny them leads to evil being done in the name of good. Several posters on here have explained how denying abortion rights lead to increased human suffering and indeed, deaths. But at least the self-styled 'pro-lifers' get to feel good about themselves; which is something I suppose because it is probably the only benefit for overall human happiness.

'I can proudly say I am a Christian'.

Such an odd turn of phrase. I identify as a Christian and it doesn't occur to me to be proud of it. For the avoidance of doubt; the Bible is silent on the subject of abortion. And this despite the fact it has always been practised, since ancient times.

GodDammitCecil · 02/10/2023 08:03

And to hitch a ride on the implication of infertility to try to get out of answering that question - what an utter piece of work.

I was asking because he is clearly a man, and that’s why the answer is ‘no’, he can’t get pregnant.

Brefugee · 02/10/2023 07:50

Babochan88 · 01/10/2023 22:00

I understand that you think I’m terrible (I promise you I’m not) but surely you know that you should never ask someone such a question???

Sorry to harp on but I wanted to come back yo this.

I believe people holding these views (everything Babochan88 posted in this thread) are terrible. And we must be protected from these views affecting us, the non-religious, those of other faiths, those not of this abhorrent, hypocritical fundie-"Christianity"

RampantIvy · 02/10/2023 07:21

For any other questions you have my answer is always that unborn babies are human and have the right to life.

As do women.

GodDammitCecil · 02/10/2023 07:05

The astounding manly arrogance it takes to come on here and tell women they are worthless never ceases to stun me.

’Twas ever thus.

We do see right through it, though.

This is the Handmaids Tale in real-time
Brefugee · 02/10/2023 06:52

The Bible uses literal and figurative language

Translation: when it suits my narrative I insist on the badly translated misogynistic book. When it doesn't I twist the words and meanings until they do.

The astounding manly arrogance it takes to come on here and tell women they are worthless never ceases to stun me.

I'm with Mrs P Terry. The unforgiving god that I don't believe in, should she turn out to be real won't judge me harshly. My actions are more "Christian" than many actual "Christians"

Brefugee · 02/10/2023 06:34

Christians should never judge anyone - That is condemning someone as bad awful etc.

So what is it when you call women who have had abortions "murderers"? That is ultimate judgyness

MrsTerryPratchett · 02/10/2023 00:54

If my posts have triggered and upset which I know they have…abortion is a tough topic…I apologise and genuinely wish peace for you.

The best apology is not to do it again. On behalf of the women I know who have variously had to have abortions because an ectopic would have killed them, the much-wanted baby was going to be born dead, they were in an abusive relationship and the only way to separate and never see the father again was to end the pregnancy... do not advocate to remove women's rights. By all means feel the way you do about your own body. Leave ours alone.

GodDammitCecil · 02/10/2023 00:54

You’re funny!

Babochan88 · 02/10/2023 00:46

I think it’s best I bow out here and stop replying to messages. For any other questions you have my answer is always that unborn babies are human and have the right to life.

For those that have had abortions, please know that you’re loved more than you could ever imagine by God. Whether you believe it or not he loves you an infinite amount. If you have a second shoot him up a prayer he’s always listening and desperate for you to speak to him - he’s your father who made you and watched over you from womb till now and absolutely delights in you.

If my posts have triggered and upset which I know they have…abortion is a tough topic…I apologise and genuinely wish peace for you.

always happy to speak to anyone over private messages but will stop posting on this thread now. I’m sure op and most of you are sick of me 😭😂

MrsTerryPratchett · 02/10/2023 00:44

Because one day we will all have to give an account for everything we’ve done on Earth. I love you enough to speak truth.

I won't.

But even if you're right (you're not) if I had to account for myself I would expect God to be on the side of women, what with having created the world with women being the only ones able to produce life. I think she'd be pretty keen on women.

I've just spent some time in a more sensible place. A lovely mixture of animism and Buddhism. So much less vehemently anti-women.

Catsmere · 02/10/2023 00:39

@Babochan88 Why is the foetus' potential life more important than the established life of the woman or girl being forced to give birth to it?

Oh, of course, as @Insommmmnia said, the foetus might be male, after all. Women and girls only exist to breed and raise males and if we fail at that, well, we were obviously defective anyway.

GodDammitCecil · 02/10/2023 00:39

@Passepartoute - he’s already said that yes, she should.

As I say, it’s pointless even having this discussion with someone who doesn’t have the physical equipment to even get pregnant.

It’s totally theoretical to them.

Passepartoute · 02/10/2023 00:30

Another scenario for you, @Babochan88. Should a 10 year old who is pregnant as a result of rape be forced to carry on with the pregnancy and give birth, even though that may cause irreparable damage to her mental and physical health? Does a Christian god really demand that sort of suffering from young girls?

Passepartoute · 02/10/2023 00:26

Babochan88 · 02/10/2023 00:09

An argument often used against the pro life stance on abortion is “What about when the life of the mother is at risk?”

Dr. Landrum Shettles, a pioneer in the field of in vitro fertilization, wrote, “Less than 1 percent of all abortions are performed to save the mother’s life”

Over 1,000 OB-GYNs and maternal healthcare experts signed a statement in 2012, saying, in part, “As experienced practitioners and researchers in obstetrics and gynaecology, we affirm that direct abortion—the purposeful destruction of the unborn child—is not medically necessary to save the life of a woman”

in 2019, “medical leaders representing more than 30,000 doctors said intentionally killing a late-term unborn baby in an abortion is never necessary to save a mother’s life”

So is this a utilitarian argument, then? Because less than 1% of abortions are allegedly performed to save the mother's life, it's OK to let those mothers die when they could be saved?

No reputable doctor can claim that abortion is never necessary to save the life of a mother. You only have to look at Savita Halappanavar's case to see that that is manifestly not true.