Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thread gallery
12
Tistheseason17 · 01/10/2023 09:32

Pro choice here - always will be.
The disgrace of those who are pro life but do nothing to protect that life from guns. School shootings daily in US.

LakieLady · 01/10/2023 09:26

This is so bloody depressing. I'm old, old enough to remember the days when abortion was illegal in the UK. My DM, who had been a nurse, was delighted when it was legalised here, because she had nursed women through to aftermath of botched back-street abortions and DIY attempts to terminate a pregnancy. Some of them died.

Desperate women will always try to end pregnancies, regardless of what the law says. Ffs, let them do it safely.

I also find it bizarre that so much of the US is anti-choice, but determined to allow people to carry deadly weapons. They'd rather protect foetuses than actual living, breathing people.

FrancescaContini · 01/10/2023 09:24

Not RTFT but skimmed the article: what a very nasty little man.

CostelloJones · 01/10/2023 09:23

*by labelling it as evil

CostelloJones · 01/10/2023 09:21

I know someone who was told at a scan that their baby had not developed any kidneys or lungs. They left it a few weeks and had another scan to see if it was somehow wrong. It wasn’t.

she had to choice to terminate for medical reasons and end a very wanted pregnancy, or give birth to the baby (if they survived) and essentially watch them die painfully. I know what I would have done.

I think it’s a choice a lot of people don’t want to make but have to.

by disregarding it as evil, immoral etc… you are completely disregarding the emotional weight these decisions carry at any point in a pregnancy. It’s not a choice anyone makes lightly.

I think people don’t realise the impact bans will have for people in already terrible situations.

Passepartoute · 01/10/2023 09:21

Siameasy · 30/09/2023 19:24

I think that’s pretty dismissive. The fetus is alive and can move around. Google a 10 week fetus and you’ll see it’s a baby, just small. Funny how when a baby is unwanted it’s suddenly ok to be dismissive about killing it. Also funny how no one ever reacts to a positive pregnancy test by saying “we’re expecting a collection of cells”. That’s because you know full well it’s a baby.
The pro-abortionists language is like that of the trans lobby and their top surgery bottom surgery nonsense, deliberately obfuscating. Just call things what they are.

And funny how, in the US, people will go to this sort of trouble to prevent abortion whilst apparently being relaxed about children killed by guns. In Texas, whilst they tighten up anti abortion laws they have been busy progressively relaxing gun laws, with the result that an average of 450 children per year are killed by guns. To say nothing, of course. of the approximately 4000 adults killed by guns.

Apparently life before birth is precious in Texas. Afterwards, not so much.

Passepartoute · 01/10/2023 09:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

So is it OK to refuse abortion to a woman who will die if forced to go through with the pregnancy and birth? Or where, if the baby is born, it will have at best a short life in agony before dying?

DrBlackbird · 01/10/2023 09:10

CantFindTheBeat · 01/10/2023 08:08

Ok @Babochan88

If you are arbitrary about your decisions?

What would you suggest happen in these circumstances, @Babochan88?

Woman who has been raped
14 year old girl with no family support
Woman with mental health problems who would be suicidal if pregnancy continued

100% agree with @Thelnebriati on this This is how you can tell it's not about abortion, it's about controlling women. If it was about reducing abortion, they'd be in favour of contraception, woman's rights and sex ed. But they aren't.

And to the list above, we add:
Woman who’s life is at risk / women who will die by continuing the pregnancy
The foetus with catastrophic abnormalities

And when the anti-abortioners continue to screech ‘abortion is wrong’ and ‘abortions must be illegal’, we understand how profoundly anti-life and anti-women these people are. Making abortion illegal and preventing women from having control over their reproductive rights has always been about hating women to the point of being fine with an agonising death in child birth and/or feeling fine with condemning the life of a child to misery.

The very essence of totalitarian control is control over another’s physical body and absolutely nothing else. Aunt Lydia is alive and well.

Locutus2000 · 01/10/2023 09:10

Babochan88 · 01/10/2023 08:33

Completely reductionist.

Yes because, pro lifers don’t also care about people in poverty, sexual violence, in care, abuse, trafficked etc… ??

Of course they do, they’re just doing the work rather than stating their political/religious or ethical leanings !!

Whether or not abortion is eliminated, people will always fight for babies to live and not just live, but to thrive and live happy and safe lives. At every stage of the journey pro lifers are working hard.

Nah, pro-birthers are usually in step with other right wingers in opposing state aid and support in favour of picking and choosing who they think deserves support.

Most couldn't give a fuck about anything post-birth. If they really cared then they wouldn't try and restrict a woman's fundamental right not to bring a baybee into a chaotic, miserable life.

pointythings · 01/10/2023 09:08

@Babochan88 should a woman be forced to carry a pregnancy to term knowing that her baby will die at or immediately after birth because they have a condition incompatible with life?

Iam4eels · 01/10/2023 09:00

AlwaysPrettyOnTheInside · 01/10/2023 08:16

I didn't know abortions could be born alive. That is horrific. The op is right.

I've never thought about it in depth, having never been in the position to need one and then when coming off contraception to ttc, starting early meno about a year after 🙄

What happened to the ones born alive? Were they left to die naturally? Were they given medication to kill them?

It doesn't happen. In late term abortions, medication is given to stop the heart precisely to prevent this scenario and they check for lack of heartbeat. In the ONS official report it not only given figures, it also details methods used and in all cases the fetal heartbeat is stopped before progressing to the next stage.

In the UK the vast majority of abortions take place within the first trimester with only around 1% occurring around 20 weeks (which would coincide the anomaly scan that takes place at 18-22 weeks). 0.01% of abortions takes place after 24wks (around 240 a year) and all are done on serious medical grounds. The vast, vast majority of women are terminating their pregnancies at a stage where there is no possibility of a heartbeat outside of the woman's body and for the ones terminating at later stages there are medical reasons for doing so and steps are taken to stop the heartbeat first.

Mummyoflittledragon · 01/10/2023 08:57

@Babochan88

If the mum doesn’t want the child, should she be pushed into keeping it for a while to make sure?

If not, what about the fourth trimester? What about the mental health of an unwanted child?

MoreCraicPlease · 01/10/2023 08:55

Interesting posters on this thread.. Welcome to MN.

Texas is now the home to some huge west coast firms like Tesla, Hewlett Parkard, Oracle. Others have gone to Florida who is now right wing.

They’re literally telling their female staff they are unimportant and don’t deserve female health services. It’s not just the right to abortion: there is a ripple effect in all areas including early pregnancy care and contraception.

Totaly · 01/10/2023 08:48

Luckily I live in a country that has recently made it easier to access abortion (not the UK).

We are probably in the same place!

Having teen daughters I am delighted they have a choice. Previously they needed to travel for abortions, who travelled? Those with money.

Banning abortion only affects the poor who can’t afford an abortion and can’t afford the travel.

We don’t need more poverty.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 01/10/2023 08:46

Babochan88 · 01/10/2023 08:11

In all these cases the baby must be delivered and support and help given to both woman and baby. They don’t have to raise the child. But yes, the life should be spared.

Where are all these adoptive and foster parents going to come from?

Echobelly · 01/10/2023 08:36

I think a big point here is, I, personally would not want to birth a child who medical professionals have told me has a condition that is incompatible with life and will die outside the womb. I feel it's unfair to create that suffering and to be honest I wouldn't wish to experience that trauma.

However I would never, ever, force another woman in the same position to abort that child. Maybe she thinks a miracle will happen, maybe she thinks it is the will of God and she will see it through, or she just wants to hold the child. And I totally support any woman to do this. No opponent of forced birth wants forced abortion, yet the other side wants to force cruel outcomes, even to the point in America that children will be be left without their mothers because mums will die from totally preventable causes due to these abortion bans.

And they are bans, states have often made 'exceptions' for rape or danger to the mother unusable and hospital lawyers have told obstetricians not to act because they could still be open to prosecution. Look up Jessica Valenti, Abortion Every Day - she is a reputable journalist dedicating herself up reporting the consequences of abortion bans.

Babochan88 · 01/10/2023 08:33

ChaToilLeam · 01/10/2023 08:18

The forced birthers certainly are out in force today.

I’m beyond the age of having to worry about this for myself but for every woman and girl facing unwanted pregnancy, I will continue to fight for your right to CHOOSE.

We are not idiots who do not know what is involved in an abortion. Pregnancy and childbirth are profoundly life changing and no woman or girl should be made to go through it against her will.

If you want to reduce the number of abortions, campaign for free contraception, campaign for more support for women in poverty. Campaign for refuges for women and girls subject to sexual violence. But you will not eliminate abortion. You might eliminate safe abortion, and if you think that is a victory, do not even dare to think yourself “pro-life”.

Completely reductionist.

Yes because, pro lifers don’t also care about people in poverty, sexual violence, in care, abuse, trafficked etc… ??

Of course they do, they’re just doing the work rather than stating their political/religious or ethical leanings !!

Whether or not abortion is eliminated, people will always fight for babies to live and not just live, but to thrive and live happy and safe lives. At every stage of the journey pro lifers are working hard.

GodDammitCecil · 01/10/2023 08:26

Sadly for you @Babochan88 - whether legal or illegal- abortion will always exist. Always.

If a women does not want to be pregnant, she will ensure that happens.

Babochan88 · 01/10/2023 08:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

It’s interesting how the use of language is used to create space and take away responsibility. You can call it a foetus, a clump of cells, an embryo, a baby (all are right descriptions) but it still - if everything goes to plan- should develop into a baby.

Regardless of what week it’s at, it should still be protected. Yes, we are truly crazy for wanting to fight for people to live - how awful of us.

Murder should never be a choice that people have. Whether inside the body or out.

Crapsummer2023 · 01/10/2023 08:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

GodDammitCecil · 01/10/2023 08:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I don’t believe in the sanctity of life (I eat meat, swat flies, etc), so your sort of talk has zero impact on me, and many like me.

Luckily I live in a country that has recently made it easier to access abortion (not the UK).

The US is very backward in so many ways.

ChaToilLeam · 01/10/2023 08:18

The forced birthers certainly are out in force today.

I’m beyond the age of having to worry about this for myself but for every woman and girl facing unwanted pregnancy, I will continue to fight for your right to CHOOSE.

We are not idiots who do not know what is involved in an abortion. Pregnancy and childbirth are profoundly life changing and no woman or girl should be made to go through it against her will.

If you want to reduce the number of abortions, campaign for free contraception, campaign for more support for women in poverty. Campaign for refuges for women and girls subject to sexual violence. But you will not eliminate abortion. You might eliminate safe abortion, and if you think that is a victory, do not even dare to think yourself “pro-life”.

AlwaysPrettyOnTheInside · 01/10/2023 08:16

Rightsraptor · 30/09/2023 19:39

I've performed abortions, @BiscuitsandPuffin, they were generally around 20-22 weeks and the procedures were not anything to be horrified at. I'm wondering which country you are in or if the articles you read don't relate to modern methods in the developed world?

We did medical terminations by administering meds to 'ripen' the cervix and then to start/augment contractions - an induction really, which many women go through, albeit with the expectation of a live baby at the end. The expectation in abortions was that the fetus would dead at delivery but sometimes it was not. If not, it was removed from the parents' sight and hearing into another room. They all had the choice whether or not to see and/or hold their infant.

These were carried out for gross fetal abnormality or to save the mother's life. Any 'horror' was around emotional issues, such as the woman being seriously compromised and having no choice but to end the pregnancy, which may have been much wanted, ditto for the seriously malformed fetus.

I didn't know abortions could be born alive. That is horrific. The op is right.

I've never thought about it in depth, having never been in the position to need one and then when coming off contraception to ttc, starting early meno about a year after 🙄

What happened to the ones born alive? Were they left to die naturally? Were they given medication to kill them?

CantFindTheBeat · 01/10/2023 08:15

Babochan88 · 01/10/2023 08:11

In all these cases the baby must be delivered and support and help given to both woman and baby. They don’t have to raise the child. But yes, the life should be spared.

You're talking in 'musts and shoulds '.

Be specific. What needs to happen, and how?

Babochan88 · 01/10/2023 08:11

In all these cases the baby must be delivered and support and help given to both woman and baby. They don’t have to raise the child. But yes, the life should be spared.