Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thread gallery
12
Ilikeviognier · 01/10/2023 10:54

UP

Ilikeviognier · 01/10/2023 10:54

(Ended yo with us losing) - sorry typo.

Ilikeviognier · 01/10/2023 10:53

@Babochan88 or what about my situation, where the baby who had a condition incompatible with life was one of a twin, and their existence was endangering the life of their healthy sibling, which may have potentially ended up it’s us losing them both had we not acted?

i doubt you have been faced with this kind of terrible choice yourself, otherwise you’d not be quite as flippant with your views here, believe me.

Passepartoute · 01/10/2023 10:45

Babochan88 · 01/10/2023 10:29

I understand we have different view points but surely you know the answer to your question is no.

Sadly the pro-life states don't seem to agree with you. As reported in the link given above, "women across the US have been increasingly subjected to surveillance, arrest and charges for abortions, stillbirths and other actions that police claimed “endangered” their fetuses, with routine healthcare decisions and pregnancy outcomes treated as crimes."

FrangipaniBlue · 01/10/2023 10:45

BiscuitsandPuffin · 30/09/2023 18:56

To be fair, I recently found out what actually happens during an abortion, and I am horrified. I think we should all have open and transparent information about exactly what is happening and how the procedure is done because it is physically impossible to give informed consent without this information, it's disgraceful that they fluff over the truth and treat us like children when we're literally making life or death decisions. While I think this lawyer is going too far, I understand now why they feel so strongly about it.

Edited

NOBODY needs to know the details of what happens during an abortion other than the woman undergoing the procedure.

It is her and her alone who makes an informed consent decision.

Not one other single person has a say.

I'm horrified that you even think this.

Passepartoute · 01/10/2023 10:41

Babochan88 · 01/10/2023 10:27

Yes

Is that still the case if the baby's condition is such that their life will be short but agonising?

SerendipityJane · 01/10/2023 10:41

Exasperatednow · 01/10/2023 10:35

My neice recently moved away from Texas for this reason.

US military will also transfer personnel affected. And reduce funding to states that have similar laws making them even poorer than they are now.

Passepartoute · 01/10/2023 10:40

Babochan88 · 01/10/2023 10:35

I’m not in the area of mental health legislation to give you an answer abut the strategic and structural implementation of pregnancies.

Just like I can’t tell you how we solve the national debt to take care of babies being born to women wanting abortions. I’m sure there are many qualified people to answer these questions. But one thing I do know is that the answer isn’t murdering babies

That really is a cop-out. You claimed that the suicidal woman could be supported to continue the pregnancy. You can't just shrug your shoulders and say you have no idea how that could be achieved.

The reality must be, mustn't it, that if a woman in that situation is absolutely determined to commit suicide, she can only be kept alive and made to continue the pregnancy by sectioning her and having a watch kept on her night and day? Is it acceptable in those circumstances to force the woman to continue with her pregnancy even though it will irreversibly ruin her mental health?

Passepartoute · 01/10/2023 10:35

Babochan88 · 01/10/2023 10:29

I understand we have different view points but surely you know the answer to your question is no.

Can you explain why? If a foetus has a right to life, why do you say we have to protect that right only in relation to abortion and not anything else?

Exasperatednow · 01/10/2023 10:35

My neice recently moved away from Texas for this reason.

Babochan88 · 01/10/2023 10:35

Passepartoute · 01/10/2023 10:19

How does that work in the case of the hypothesis given of the woman who is suicidal as a result of the pregnancy? Are you proposing to section the woman while she goes through the pregnancy to prevent her committing suicide? What happens for the rest of her life when her mental health has been shot to hell?

I’m not in the area of mental health legislation to give you an answer abut the strategic and structural implementation of pregnancies.

Just like I can’t tell you how we solve the national debt to take care of babies being born to women wanting abortions. I’m sure there are many qualified people to answer these questions. But one thing I do know is that the answer isn’t murdering babies

Babochan88 · 01/10/2023 10:29

Passepartoute · 01/10/2023 10:23

So what do you suggest we should do about miscarriages? If foetuses are to have the same status as babies who have been born, should we be holding an inquest for every single miscarriage? Should we be making the mothers liable for not looking after their health adequately or even changing them with murder or manslaughter? It would be really helpful to know how far you take this argument.

I understand we have different view points but surely you know the answer to your question is no.

SerendipityJane · 01/10/2023 10:29

Passepartoute · 01/10/2023 10:23

So what do you suggest we should do about miscarriages? If foetuses are to have the same status as babies who have been born, should we be holding an inquest for every single miscarriage? Should we be making the mothers liable for not looking after their health adequately or even changing them with murder or manslaughter? It would be really helpful to know how far you take this argument.

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/apr/03/pregnancy-birth-murder-charge-kelsey-carpenter-san-diego

She lost her child in a home birth. Prosecutors charged her with murder

The medical examiner ruled the death of Kelsey Carpenter’s baby an accident – yet she faces life in prison: ‘I mourn every day’

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/apr/03/pregnancy-birth-murder-charge-kelsey-carpenter-san-diego

Babochan88 · 01/10/2023 10:27

pointythings · 01/10/2023 09:08

@Babochan88 should a woman be forced to carry a pregnancy to term knowing that her baby will die at or immediately after birth because they have a condition incompatible with life?

Yes

Passepartoute · 01/10/2023 10:23

Babochan88 · 01/10/2023 08:22

It’s interesting how the use of language is used to create space and take away responsibility. You can call it a foetus, a clump of cells, an embryo, a baby (all are right descriptions) but it still - if everything goes to plan- should develop into a baby.

Regardless of what week it’s at, it should still be protected. Yes, we are truly crazy for wanting to fight for people to live - how awful of us.

Murder should never be a choice that people have. Whether inside the body or out.

So what do you suggest we should do about miscarriages? If foetuses are to have the same status as babies who have been born, should we be holding an inquest for every single miscarriage? Should we be making the mothers liable for not looking after their health adequately or even changing them with murder or manslaughter? It would be really helpful to know how far you take this argument.

Passepartoute · 01/10/2023 10:19

Babochan88 · 01/10/2023 08:11

In all these cases the baby must be delivered and support and help given to both woman and baby. They don’t have to raise the child. But yes, the life should be spared.

How does that work in the case of the hypothesis given of the woman who is suicidal as a result of the pregnancy? Are you proposing to section the woman while she goes through the pregnancy to prevent her committing suicide? What happens for the rest of her life when her mental health has been shot to hell?

Isitsixoclockalready · 01/10/2023 10:18

Tistheseason17 · 01/10/2023 09:32

Pro choice here - always will be.
The disgrace of those who are pro life but do nothing to protect that life from guns. School shootings daily in US.

I have to say that I do find the fervour over pro life at any cost but at the same time a fervour over the right to bear arms when there are so many tragic shootings each year to be a really strange and morally compromising attitude. I do agree with others that it's such a blinkered approach - I really don't think that there seems to be so much of a compassion as a zealotry. There is literally no-one who would want to have an abortion, given any other option. It's not a lifestyle choice - it's a very sad and emotive situation to end up in. Ultimately the woman has to have the choice - it is their decision and it anyone imagines that it's an easy one to take, they would be very misguided.

VesperLynne · 01/10/2023 10:08

Rightsraptor ...........................sorry, but I know exactly what goes on and it is horrific, which is one of the main reasons I steered well clear of Obs and Gynae and concentrated on Emergency and Intensive Care medicine.

itsmeafterall · 01/10/2023 09:48

Rightsraptor · 30/09/2023 19:39

I've performed abortions, @BiscuitsandPuffin, they were generally around 20-22 weeks and the procedures were not anything to be horrified at. I'm wondering which country you are in or if the articles you read don't relate to modern methods in the developed world?

We did medical terminations by administering meds to 'ripen' the cervix and then to start/augment contractions - an induction really, which many women go through, albeit with the expectation of a live baby at the end. The expectation in abortions was that the fetus would dead at delivery but sometimes it was not. If not, it was removed from the parents' sight and hearing into another room. They all had the choice whether or not to see and/or hold their infant.

These were carried out for gross fetal abnormality or to save the mother's life. Any 'horror' was around emotional issues, such as the woman being seriously compromised and having no choice but to end the pregnancy, which may have been much wanted, ditto for the seriously malformed fetus.

Can I just say Thankyou for your compassion and professionalism in doing what must be a horrendously difficult procedure for women who really have no other choice.

My hat off to you and my heart goes out to you too. It must be so unspeakably hard.

I have known a couple of women who had to go through this and the dignity and compassion they were treated with helped to lessen the trauma and heartbreak.

And I'm raging for the women across the world who are being controlled and abused by men who are so small of mind (and penis? 😬) and feel they have to exert power over others. Pathetic specimens.

And @BiscuitsandPuffin yes the reality is grim, but the alternative is much grimmer. Women need the right to choose. And if that means not discussing the actual procedure details then that's fine too. When I had surgery I really did not want to know the gory details of cuts and bones being sawn through. It wasn't necessary, and increased my anxiety in an already stressful situation for something that needed to be done. Abortion is no different, we don't need to know the exact ins and outs for the surgical options, unless we want to.

Women's bodies, women choice. Always.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 01/10/2023 09:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Laws are changing because they want to control women, they don’t care about babies. In the very same state they are arguing that this viable foetus doesn’t have rights.

https://www.texastribune.org/2023/08/11/texas-prison-lawsuit-fetal-rights/

You’d think the pro forced birth lobby would be all over this but there’s not a peep. They are a bunch of hypocrites.

Prisoners work outdoors at the Dr. Lane Murray Unit, a women's prison that's part of the Texas Department of Criminal Justice.

A prison guard says she was forced to stay at her post during labor pains. Texas is fighting compensation for her stillbirth.

The seven-months-pregnant officer reported contraction-like pains at work, but said she wasn’t allowed to leave for hours. The anti-abortion state is fighting her lawsuit, in part by saying her fetus didn’t clearly have rights.

https://www.texastribune.org/2023/08/11/texas-prison-lawsuit-fetal-rights/

Iam4eels · 01/10/2023 09:37

DrBlackbird · 01/10/2023 09:32

I think people don’t realise the impact bans will have for people in already terrible situations I’d refute this and say they absolutely do know.

They know, they just don't care. If a woman dies or is seriously unwell due to infection or left with life-changing injuries then they consider this her just desserts because their motto is "you made your bed, now lie in it".

They view pregnancy, and all the possible outcomes of it, as a punishment for daring to have sex or for tempting a man into having sex with you.

It has absolutely nothing to do with protecting innocent little babies and nothing to do with the sanctity of life. It's all about controlling women and keeping them in what these people view as "their place".

DrBlackbird · 01/10/2023 09:36

Iam4eels · 01/10/2023 09:32

Woman who has been raped
14 year old girl with no family support
Woman with mental health problems who would be suicidal if pregnancy continued

And to the list above, we add:
Woman who’s life is at risk / women who will die by continuing the pregnancy
The foetus with catastrophic abnormalities

And to add further to the list:

  • woman in an abusive relationship whose partner uses pregnancy as a means of keeping her tied to him

  • woman with severe cognitive impairments who is used by a man she knows, is emotionally distressed at being pregnant and unable to care for a child

  • 11 year old girl being sexually abused by a male relative

  • mother of three who cannot support another child emotionally or financially

  • woman who finds out she has cancer and the treatment is not compatible with pregnancy

Should they all be denied an abortion?

Yes, apparently they should according to the likes of @Babochan88 and other misogynistic anti-abortioners.

This is the Handmaids Tale in real-time
DrBlackbird · 01/10/2023 09:32

I think people don’t realise the impact bans will have for people in already terrible situations I’d refute this and say they absolutely do know.

Iam4eels · 01/10/2023 09:32

Woman who has been raped
14 year old girl with no family support
Woman with mental health problems who would be suicidal if pregnancy continued

And to the list above, we add:
Woman who’s life is at risk / women who will die by continuing the pregnancy
The foetus with catastrophic abnormalities

And to add further to the list:

  • woman in an abusive relationship whose partner uses pregnancy as a means of keeping her tied to him

  • woman with severe cognitive impairments who is used by a man she knows, is emotionally distressed at being pregnant and unable to care for a child

  • 11 year old girl being sexually abused by a male relative

  • mother of three who cannot support another child emotionally or financially

  • woman who finds out she has cancer and the treatment is not compatible with pregnancy

Should they all be denied an abortion?

Swipe left for the next trending thread