Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not let another baby take toys from my own?

39 replies

Takemetothelakes45 · 30/09/2023 13:21

I’m not passionate either way just a FTM looking for the general consensus.

I take my DC (8month)to alot of baby groups with a mix of ages. There’s one child in particularly who also attends a few (around 10 month I think) That can crawl and move and who snatches toys from other babies cos well, they’re a baby too and I get that. The mother herself is very vocal about aww X coming for that, don’t let them take this, oh have they just snatched that how rude etc.

So when they approach my own DC and tries to take things from there hands, I say ‘aww (DC) is playing with this one, how about we play with this instead’ and with hand her another toy, while helping my DC hold onto what she has. I noticed after a few times the other mother looked a bit put out by this, despite her asking others to make sure she doesn’t steal. I also noticed most of the other mothers let them take whatever from their own DCs. This just an example but this obviously happens a lot at these groups with lots of new toys available.

So I think really I’m not sure what the social norm is? As I said they are just young babies but I assumed gentle encouragement to not snatch toys (at the mother’s request as well) was surely a good thing? Also to try to encourage my own DC to not be a snatcher when they get to moving about?

But ready to be humbled either way 😅

YABU - there a baby let them have what they want manners come later
YANBU - start the basis of sharing and manners as young as possible for all parties involved!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Fabshab · 01/10/2023 15:06

YABU

they're babies, babies usually play with everyone’s toys at some point

this is your first isn’t it p

Goldbar · 01/10/2023 14:57

RunningOnHope · 30/09/2023 22:11

But they learn so much, continually. A 10 month old is learning the very foundations of social interaction, they are learning things that are repeated to them often, they are learning to recognise and respond to tone of voice, facial expressions, patterns of events...

It is worth investing in babies, toddlers don't appear out of nowhere.

I know, but I really can't be doing with all this "standing up for MY baby" and "protecting MY child" shit when we're talking about tiny, tiny little people. The most important thing is to make sure all the babies are happy and safe and interacting nicely, not to territorially guard your baby and whatever toy they're playing with.

And it's not nice to snatch, but it's also not nice to hog or exclude and it's nice to share. A child who has waited patiently for a toy and eventually runs out of patience and cuts in is not necessarily in the wrong. So there's a balance in everything and I'm not sure making long speeches they don't understand at babies and toddlers is helpful. Far better just to promote them all playing harmoniously rather than focus on the rights and wrongs of it.

Lavender14 · 01/10/2023 11:01

Wibblywobblylikejelly · 30/09/2023 22:14

Investing in your own kid sure. But I wouldn't bother wasting the time with other kids.

But you're teaching your child that firstly they don't need to give away things they're using, they're allowed to have boundaries and ask others to respect those boundaries and to share in a fair way. So you are investing in your child by modelling those positive interactions for them so by the time they get to toddlerhood, hopefully you've already built those foundations.

Snowonthebeachx · 30/09/2023 22:54

You are in the right but I think you are overthinking this. Maybe the Mum had just had a shit night or a stressful morning and didn't have the energy to be constantly stopping her baby snatching. I'm sure she didn't think you were doing anything wrong she was maybe feeling a bit meh and judged?

On Mumsnet everyone's children always behave perfectly but in the real world sometimes they snatch even when they've been told not to. Especially little babies who have no concept of ownership. I don't think there's anything wrong with laying the groundwork for understanding not to snatch but I do feel you need to chill out a little bit.

RudsyFarmer · 30/09/2023 22:50

I have no idea about social norms but i do remember my toddler shoving smaller kids off of his walker at these groups and it being really embarrassing when the other kids cried 🥴

CowboyJoanna · 30/09/2023 22:46

YANBU

Feels like a lot of mums are dragging their kids up nowadays, the norm is to steal and bully, like a bloody kid eat kid world now Sad

ChestnutShell3 · 30/09/2023 22:36

At a baby group once, my baby DD wouldn’t let another baby take her toy, the mum came over and said “come on DS, she doesn’t want to share”.
That’s right, she as an adult was passive aggressive towards my DD, a baby. I just laughed at her because I couldn’t believe it.

So long as you’re not doing that, OP, you’re fine.

fearfuloffluff · 30/09/2023 22:36

You're in the right, though I think words like 'steal' and 'snatch' are a slightly dramatic way of describing it.

It's worth bearing in mind that sometimes mums at these groups are struggling, depressed, exhausted, might be living in bleak conditions, didn't get shown the right way themselves when young - I know that sounds condescending but it's true.

You need to be careful not to make it look like you're saying to a struggling mother 'oh look, you're shit and your baby's a tyrant' because they might be doing their best and absolutely exhausted.

RunningOnHope · 30/09/2023 22:23

Wibblywobblylikejelly · 30/09/2023 22:14

Investing in your own kid sure. But I wouldn't bother wasting the time with other kids.

Yeah, I'm talking about your own kid - they are learning from your response, if you make a habit of responding with kind assertiveness each time, and in a couple of years, they'll be able to do the same for themselves.

Givemepickles · 30/09/2023 22:18

This is so OTT. They are babies not 3 year olds. I've never seen a baby care about a toy being taken. They don't even notice. They have no idea what's going on let alone concepts like sharing. Chill out everyone.

Wibblywobblylikejelly · 30/09/2023 22:14

RunningOnHope · 30/09/2023 22:11

But they learn so much, continually. A 10 month old is learning the very foundations of social interaction, they are learning things that are repeated to them often, they are learning to recognise and respond to tone of voice, facial expressions, patterns of events...

It is worth investing in babies, toddlers don't appear out of nowhere.

Investing in your own kid sure. But I wouldn't bother wasting the time with other kids.

RunningOnHope · 30/09/2023 22:11

Goldbar · 30/09/2023 22:04

I agree for toddlers but these are just babies. I'd feel a bit crazy saying that to a 10 month old.

But they learn so much, continually. A 10 month old is learning the very foundations of social interaction, they are learning things that are repeated to them often, they are learning to recognise and respond to tone of voice, facial expressions, patterns of events...

It is worth investing in babies, toddlers don't appear out of nowhere.

Goldbar · 30/09/2023 22:04

Lavender14 · 30/09/2023 21:43

'Oh you like this toy? Dc is playing with it just now but you can play with it when they've finished. '
That way your child learns to share when they're finished and the other child learns not to snatch.

Really I wouldn't care about the other mum because why she isn't actively teaching her child not to snatch is beyond me.

I agree for toddlers but these are just babies. I'd feel a bit crazy saying that to a 10 month old.

Lavender14 · 30/09/2023 21:43

'Oh you like this toy? Dc is playing with it just now but you can play with it when they've finished. '
That way your child learns to share when they're finished and the other child learns not to snatch.

Really I wouldn't care about the other mum because why she isn't actively teaching her child not to snatch is beyond me.

Goldbar · 30/09/2023 21:40

It would depend how keen on the toy my baby was. Sometimes my DC isn't bothered and is more curious about the baby doing the snatching. Sometimes, my DC wants that toy and will take it back from the 'snatcher' baby. Sometimes it's my DC doing the snatching. Generally, I just distract/find another toy for one of the babies. I find that babies aren't really possessive/obsessed with things in the way toddlers are... that seems to come later.

Tbh I don't view it as protecting 'my' baby but just as helping all the babies play nicely together. I'll still intervene when I'm next to babies that aren't mine and one baby moves to poke another baby in the eye or push them, as well as taking toys. It just makes sense to keep all the babies in the group safe and happy if you can. Yes, the mum should intervene, but babies can be fast movers and us mums are big and lumbering in comparison so the correct mum isn't always going to get there in time.

RunningOnHope · 30/09/2023 20:05

YANBU. You've got it spot on, keep it up. Your kid will, by watching you, instinctively get how to do kind assertiveness, rather than defaulting to passivity or aggression.

Olika · 30/09/2023 17:30

You are doing great job

Dacadactyl · 30/09/2023 17:22

I always stopped other kids snatching off my children at playgroups.

AlwaysFoldingWashing · 30/09/2023 17:16

I would be doing exactly the same as you are doing. It's up to the other mum to be on top of that but if she isn't then I think you are handling it really well.

BannedfromChristmas · 30/09/2023 17:06

God babies are feral snatchy critters, you have to watch them all. I think you re being completely fair OP. You are al teaching your baby that it's okay for her to keep the toy that she has and not have to hand it over because someone else wants it.

Kinsters · 30/09/2023 16:32

If it was an activity the baby was supposed to be doing with whatever they had then I'd make sure they kept hold of it. If it was just a toy I'd be led by them. If they weren't unhappy at the toy being taken and we're ok with being given something else then I'd leave it at that (maybe say to the child who took the toy, if they were older, give something else to the baby if you want what they have). Of course if they were unhappy I'd help them to keep hold of it.

UncleHerbie · 30/09/2023 16:27

IronicElf · 30/09/2023 16:12

I think you're doing a grand job there. It's not just the other baby who needs to learn manners IMO.

It seems insignificant as a one off, but who knows which moment a child learns to share, or that they never have to. Infancy and toddlerhood are invisible foundations to personality and social integration but there have to be rules and consequences, as there sure as heck will be if children never learn how to behave in society.

I moved to a new area when my DDs were preschoolers and looked for new groups to take them to - I'd already done it once so I knew the atmosphere I was looking for - and went to a nearby village group. There was one of those little tykes car thingies. My daughter (2ish) had just climbed in and was pootling around. A boy about a year older opened the door, grabbed her arm and tried to yank her out.

His mother (one of the organisers, of course) coo'd at her son and said 'oh yes, he does love that car' and gave me a pointed stare. My daughter prised his fingers off, closed the door and sped off at high speed across the hall. I called out something saccharine like 'Darling another five minutes then let someone else have a turn' then turned to the mother and commented on how groups like this help children learn turn-taking and other skills. I already hadn't felt particularly welcome, wasn't going to go back and had nothing to lose by suggesting that her son's manners needed addressing.

The boy followed DD around and tried taking everything she picked up, but I wandered around after her, telling her it was OK to play with the toy and she was allowed a turn and thwarting him

Well done, BabyIronicElf. Teach them the right way before they know there’s a wrong way 👏

LolaSmiles · 30/09/2023 16:20

Crikey, they're babies. If toddlers, I'd agree with you completely. But this is overkill
It's overkill to allow your child to enjoy the toy they're playing with instead of handing it over to the first kid that snatches it off them?

Allowing snatching and doing the sort of forced sharing of handing toys over the second another child wants it doesn't teach sharing. It teaches a mixture of "other people can take what they want off me/can demand I give them what they want" and "obviously I must be allowed to snatch and demand other people give me what I want straight away".
Obviously older babies and young toddlers don't have those words, but that's the pattern of behaviour that's being set.

IronicElf · 30/09/2023 16:12

I think you're doing a grand job there. It's not just the other baby who needs to learn manners IMO.

It seems insignificant as a one off, but who knows which moment a child learns to share, or that they never have to. Infancy and toddlerhood are invisible foundations to personality and social integration but there have to be rules and consequences, as there sure as heck will be if children never learn how to behave in society.

I moved to a new area when my DDs were preschoolers and looked for new groups to take them to - I'd already done it once so I knew the atmosphere I was looking for - and went to a nearby village group. There was one of those little tykes car thingies. My daughter (2ish) had just climbed in and was pootling around. A boy about a year older opened the door, grabbed her arm and tried to yank her out.

His mother (one of the organisers, of course) coo'd at her son and said 'oh yes, he does love that car' and gave me a pointed stare. My daughter prised his fingers off, closed the door and sped off at high speed across the hall. I called out something saccharine like 'Darling another five minutes then let someone else have a turn' then turned to the mother and commented on how groups like this help children learn turn-taking and other skills. I already hadn't felt particularly welcome, wasn't going to go back and had nothing to lose by suggesting that her son's manners needed addressing.

The boy followed DD around and tried taking everything she picked up, but I wandered around after her, telling her it was OK to play with the toy and she was allowed a turn and thwarting him

JMSA · 30/09/2023 15:35

Crikey, they're babies. If toddlers, I'd agree with you completely. But this is overkill.

Swipe left for the next trending thread