Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think the disabled are the next target?

384 replies

Locutus2000 · 30/09/2023 13:14

The Guardian

Though Jeremy Hunt said the government was “not in a position” to contemplate a decrease in tax immediately, he said the welfare budget could be hit further down the line to foot the bill.

He told the Times that 100,000 people a year were “moving off work into benefits without any obligation to look for work” – a sign he said showed the system was not working.

The welfare system had to be a “mix of carrot and stick”, with more assistance required to help people find work, given there was “no shortage of jobs”, he added."

Funny how 'carrot and stick' always equates to 'more stick'.

UK welfare budget could be cut to pave way for tax cuts, says Jeremy Hunt

Chancellor says system has to be ‘mix of carrot and stick’ with more assistance to help people find jobs

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/sep/30/uk-welfare-budget-could-be-cut-to-pave-way-for-tax-cuts-says-jeremy-hunt

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
WrongSwanson · 30/09/2023 18:26

Froodwithatowel · 30/09/2023 15:09

'The disabled' are always talked about as one homogenous lump.

There are those with profound disabilities who need full time care and for whom having to turn up for interviews at intervals to prove they haven't miraculously recovered enough to work is insane.

There are those with moderate to significant difficulties who with the right programme and support would love to work in the way that they are able.

There are those who would bloody love to work or try very hard to work as best they can with disabilities, particularly chronic illnesses, but are permanently walloped by the government pushed demands around attendance and sick days. You can't have it both ways, to push for attendance and disciplinaries against those who can't make their body be sufficiently normal and expect them to stay in the work force.

There are the disabled who are reliant on carers because of their degree of physical difficulty, who are not ill or unqualified, a colleague of mine has a post grad degree and is excellent in her field. She has to strictly limit her hours as if she works too much she loses her carers and could never earn enough to pay for the 24 hour support she needs due to not being independently mobile.

And so on and so on.

A lot of these aren't people with the time or confidence to play the system, are scared of the system, and many won't even try to see what they might be entitled to. And yes, there are some who are confident and are good at the system and are getting the support that many of those above would love to have.

A whole raft of joined up thinking and approaches are needed, but it's not going to be cheap or time saving, or electorally popular.

And let's not forget all the disabled people who do work too.

It frustrates me on this thread that so many assume disabled people don't work. I am disabled and a higher rate tax payer.

I know I am very lucky to have a supportive employer and husband, and I wish everyone did. But I think it's really frustrating to read assumptions that disabled people aren't in work. Some of us work incredibly hard, and some I am sure would love to be able to.

Secondwindplease · 30/09/2023 18:26

Noicant · 30/09/2023 18:24

Pensioners have very limited opportunities to increase their income though. Younger people have more opportunities to build skills and improve their financial circumstances.

I understand what you’re saying, but pensioners did have an opportunity to increase their income in retirement before they retired.

Noicant · 30/09/2023 18:24

Pensioners have very limited opportunities to increase their income though. Younger people have more opportunities to build skills and improve their financial circumstances.

TheThinkingGoblin · 30/09/2023 18:23

Zebedee55 · 30/09/2023 18:10

Why go pensioners need to get less?

Do we also need to pay less UC, less in top ups, less in childcare vouchers etc?

If you mean an "across the board" reduction, in top ups, benefits etc. then that's probably another subject.

If you don't understand how demographics in the UK work I cannot help you.

Sending more and more tax revenue to an increasing (and unproductive) amount of the UK population, while the population that funds this is shrinking (and sicker)....

Well, lets just say this only ends one way:

Standard of living in the UK sinks

Sidebeforeself · 30/09/2023 18:20

Really? I’m sure my struggling pensioner parents would have been very interested to hear how well off they were

TheThinkingGoblin · 30/09/2023 18:14

Sidebeforeself · 30/09/2023 18:07

I think this is much more nuanced than an “evil Tories” issue ( not that I have any time for this lot). We have a very narrow view of disability and health issues I think and the solution lies in a comprehensive mix of changes in employer attitudes, better illness prevention, better in work support, more recognition of the value of carers, shorter waiting lists etc etc. No party is going to crack that quickly.

I also think we have a narrow view of “pensioners” and a lot of the rhetoric is about the triple lock being purely a vote chasing policy. It may well be, but the number of people of pensionable age living in poverty and relative isolation will only grow given our current demographic…and then when you add that to the issues I listed above it is clear to see that taxation policies will only scratch the surface

Sorry to be a misery on a Saturday night!

Pensioner "poverty" is 16%

Child poverty is 27%

You know the economy is completely unbalanced when working people have lower incomes and higher poverty levels than pensioners do.

The "view" of UK folks about just how much damage the pensioners are causing has reached absurd level.

One thing people fail to understand:

The more money you end to pensioners every year, the poorer the country actually gets.

People want to know why schools and hospitals are crumbling?

Why local authorities are broke?

Its because more and more tax revenue is being sent to the pensioners (pensions, healthcare, social care etc) to the detriment of the country as a whole.

In a "normal" country this would never happen. But because of our FPTP electoral system, we have become trapped inside a situation were the Tories give more and more bungs to their voting demographic to stay in power (even though they have less than 40% of the national vote)

This farce needs to be called out.

Oliotya · 30/09/2023 18:13

Zebedee55 · 30/09/2023 17:26

Sorry...I worked and "paid for" the pensions for my parents, and grandparents. That's the system.

We, generally, also had houses and kids to support. And that was the system.

Today's working generation didn't invent the way it works.🙄

The "system" has changed and will have to change more. Sorry if you don't like it, but you can't squeeze blood from stones.

Babyroobs · 30/09/2023 18:11

ruby1957 · 30/09/2023 18:08

I agree - so many do not understand how the state pension works.

The state pension is TAXED if it goes to anyone with an income above the personal allowance - which would include those millionaires.

Pensioners have often worked for 40 years plus and paid taxes and NI - they deserve their payment
.

Those on pension credit with the freebies have probably not paid in as much or indeed anything.

There are an awful lot of people who have not paid anything or very little in. pension credit is even doled out to people who have been abroad for years and barely worked in the UK. In the past few weeks in my job role I have had a case where a man was working in Australia and Germany for years, came back to the UK and immediately was able to claim pension credits as had nothing to live on. Another been in South Africa for years and come to live with her son - was a Uk citizen but no state pension so could claim full pension credit and a man from India who had come to live with his family, has never worked here and able to claim pension credit. they can also claim disability benefits once they have lived here for 2 out of the past 3 years despite never paying in.

Zebedee55 · 30/09/2023 18:10

BIossomtoes · 30/09/2023 18:09

Oh Lord, somebody’s summoned the perpetual ageist, anti pensioner poster from somewhere. Watch the thread turn into an age bashing fest.

'Twas ever thus lol 🙄

Zebedee55 · 30/09/2023 18:10

TheThinkingGoblin · 30/09/2023 18:00

The "solution" is simple.

You focus on changes that increase productivity in a beneficial way.

  1. Childcare (more women work)
  2. Better Education (more skills)
  3. Better healthcare (this one is a bit trickier)

If you want to "grow" the UK economy and make it more sustainable, that is how to do it.

I haven't mentioned housing of transport because that is a different issue (NIMBY related) which will be difficult to solve.

But this means, you have to make use of the resources available (financial) in a more targeted way.

So pensioners need to get less. There is no way around that now.

Why go pensioners need to get less?

Do we also need to pay less UC, less in top ups, less in childcare vouchers etc?

If you mean an "across the board" reduction, in top ups, benefits etc. then that's probably another subject.

BIossomtoes · 30/09/2023 18:09

Oh Lord, somebody’s summoned the perpetual ageist, anti pensioner poster from somewhere. Watch the thread turn into an age bashing fest.

ruby1957 · 30/09/2023 18:08

Zebedee55 · 30/09/2023 17:13

The working population always paid for the generation above with pensions. That's how it works. You seem to not understand either the system or disability.🙄

I agree - so many do not understand how the state pension works.

The state pension is TAXED if it goes to anyone with an income above the personal allowance - which would include those millionaires.

Pensioners have often worked for 40 years plus and paid taxes and NI - they deserve their payment
.

Those on pension credit with the freebies have probably not paid in as much or indeed anything.

Sidebeforeself · 30/09/2023 18:07

I think this is much more nuanced than an “evil Tories” issue ( not that I have any time for this lot). We have a very narrow view of disability and health issues I think and the solution lies in a comprehensive mix of changes in employer attitudes, better illness prevention, better in work support, more recognition of the value of carers, shorter waiting lists etc etc. No party is going to crack that quickly.

I also think we have a narrow view of “pensioners” and a lot of the rhetoric is about the triple lock being purely a vote chasing policy. It may well be, but the number of people of pensionable age living in poverty and relative isolation will only grow given our current demographic…and then when you add that to the issues I listed above it is clear to see that taxation policies will only scratch the surface

Sorry to be a misery on a Saturday night!

Sirzy · 30/09/2023 18:05

If we want more people to work we first need to put better resources into supporting people with disabilities in the work place. Not just box ticking but actual proper personalised support.

many disabled people want to work but the system doesn’t let them.

TheThinkingGoblin · 30/09/2023 18:00

Noicant · 30/09/2023 17:54

It’s unsustainable to have 2.5 million people permanently out of work due to illness an ageing population, just under 30 million working (22.5 million working full time) out of a population of 67 million. It doesn’t add up when only a third of the population is working full time.

I think it gets past the point of whether it’s moral or not to shove people into jobs and becomes a matter of necessity for tax revenue. The reality is you can’t do much about pensioners or people with severe disabilities but I think anyone who has the potential to do more hours or find some sort of work will be expected to.

The reality is many people who are working part time will be doing it out of necessity due to health or caring obligations and they are often women. I have no idea how the government (any government) would be able to square that circle, going into paid work but having to withdraw unpaid caring work will have other knock on effects.

The "solution" is simple.

You focus on changes that increase productivity in a beneficial way.

  1. Childcare (more women work)
  2. Better Education (more skills)
  3. Better healthcare (this one is a bit trickier)

If you want to "grow" the UK economy and make it more sustainable, that is how to do it.

I haven't mentioned housing of transport because that is a different issue (NIMBY related) which will be difficult to solve.

But this means, you have to make use of the resources available (financial) in a more targeted way.

So pensioners need to get less. There is no way around that now.

Secondwindplease · 30/09/2023 17:59

Ponoka7 · 30/09/2023 17:53

It isn't whataboutery to question targeting those looking after the most vulnerable above other unemployed groups. It makes more sense for someone to work 35 hours and be self sufficient than have LPs of babies overstretching themselves to not save the country any more money because they still need topping up with benefits. When employers complain about not being able to fill jobs, it's those with -20 hours, some are under 15 hours.

In terms of looking after the most vulnerable, the 9 month old of a lone parent is biologically similar to the 9 month old of a family with two working parents. They can go to nursery for 15 hours. They will be fine, perhaps they will even benefit. Meanwhile the parent can work. It’s a modest expectation and it’s really not that much to ask.

And of course lone parents working 15 hours would save the country money. There is the immediate savings in terms of earned income being offset against benefit entitlement, but also the pension contributions, career progression etc that mean the worker will hopefully need less state support in later life.

LakieLady · 30/09/2023 17:58

The govt are going to "consult" about doing away with the work capability assessment and and determining who is too ill to work by their PIP award.

This is complete bollocks, because PIP is about the need of care/assistance/support people need to carry out a narrow range of tasks, while the work capability assessment does what it says on the tin.

I work in welfare rights for a charity that supports people with MH issues. A lot of my clients get awarded LCWRA on the grounds of risk, ie there would be a "substantial risk" to them or someone else if they were required to work or undertake "work-related activity". Some of my clients are so very unwell that they cannot have any social interaction with anyone other than their MH team without having a total meltdown. They only leave the house to go to MH appointments. They would literally rather die than have to meet anyone outside the tiny circle of people that they know and trust. They have to have PIP assessments either over the phone or occasionally at home, with someone from their MH team there to support them through the process, ditto appeal tribunals (around 50% of them don't get PIP at application, and have to appeal).

If the review goes the way we suspect it will, and the "substantial risk" criteria goes, what will happen to these people if they are sanctioned for not doing attending appointments that would tip them into crisis?

Secondwindplease · 30/09/2023 17:54

MrsMarzetti · 30/09/2023 17:46

That all depends on the disability. Some will be of no use to an employer as they will need a lot of short notice sickness leave. My cousin was a teacher un till she was attacked by a pupil ( she had a chair smashed across her back) she loved her job but the pain and she is in means she can only stand or sit for very short periods of time and some days can't get off the floor if she falls onto it. Would you want her as your child's teacher, there for a few days and off for a week ? Not to mention the strong painkillers she takes, most of the time she is so spaced out she is not able to use a kettle, write her name or even to go into the garden alone. What job would you recommened for her ?

Your poor cousin. I’m sure someone will be along to say that pupil had unmet needs and is the true victim, but honestly he/she sounds vicious and cruel, and has no place in a school setting.

Noicant · 30/09/2023 17:54

It’s unsustainable to have 2.5 million people permanently out of work due to illness an ageing population, just under 30 million working (22.5 million working full time) out of a population of 67 million. It doesn’t add up when only a third of the population is working full time.

I think it gets past the point of whether it’s moral or not to shove people into jobs and becomes a matter of necessity for tax revenue. The reality is you can’t do much about pensioners or people with severe disabilities but I think anyone who has the potential to do more hours or find some sort of work will be expected to.

The reality is many people who are working part time will be doing it out of necessity due to health or caring obligations and they are often women. I have no idea how the government (any government) would be able to square that circle, going into paid work but having to withdraw unpaid caring work will have other knock on effects.

Ponoka7 · 30/09/2023 17:53

Babyroobs · 30/09/2023 17:35

Most people don't get paid for 12 months mat leave, they fund themselves if they want to take the last 3 months unpaid. Why should it be different for those on UC ?

It isn't whataboutery to question targeting those looking after the most vulnerable above other unemployed groups. It makes more sense for someone to work 35 hours and be self sufficient than have LPs of babies overstretching themselves to not save the country any more money because they still need topping up with benefits. When employers complain about not being able to fill jobs, it's those with -20 hours, some are under 15 hours.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 30/09/2023 17:52

Assessment

uncomfortablydumb53 · 30/09/2023 17:52

The tories already think the disabled are worthless!
Yes I've been assessed as never being able to work with no need for further assess

ItsJustMeeee · 30/09/2023 17:50

Unfortunately there aren't enough reasonable adjustments in the world to make working a realistic prospect for many disabled people. Employers and voluntary organisations need reliability and people like me can't give them that.

I have schizophrenia. I'd love to work, but my mental health isn't reliable enough for me to hold down a job. Many employers would run a mile from someone like me anyway, thanks to the stigma associated with severe mental illness.

ThreePointOneFourOneFiveNine · 30/09/2023 17:47

The disabled aren't the next target. We have been the target for well over a decade. I suggest you start looking into the numbers of people who have died within six weeks of being declared fit for work.

MrsMarzetti · 30/09/2023 17:46

DoItAgainPlz · 30/09/2023 14:32

Disabled people can still work.

That all depends on the disability. Some will be of no use to an employer as they will need a lot of short notice sickness leave. My cousin was a teacher un till she was attacked by a pupil ( she had a chair smashed across her back) she loved her job but the pain and she is in means she can only stand or sit for very short periods of time and some days can't get off the floor if she falls onto it. Would you want her as your child's teacher, there for a few days and off for a week ? Not to mention the strong painkillers she takes, most of the time she is so spaced out she is not able to use a kettle, write her name or even to go into the garden alone. What job would you recommened for her ?