Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think the disabled are the next target?

384 replies

Locutus2000 · 30/09/2023 13:14

The Guardian

Though Jeremy Hunt said the government was “not in a position” to contemplate a decrease in tax immediately, he said the welfare budget could be hit further down the line to foot the bill.

He told the Times that 100,000 people a year were “moving off work into benefits without any obligation to look for work” – a sign he said showed the system was not working.

The welfare system had to be a “mix of carrot and stick”, with more assistance required to help people find work, given there was “no shortage of jobs”, he added."

Funny how 'carrot and stick' always equates to 'more stick'.

UK welfare budget could be cut to pave way for tax cuts, says Jeremy Hunt

Chancellor says system has to be ‘mix of carrot and stick’ with more assistance to help people find jobs

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/sep/30/uk-welfare-budget-could-be-cut-to-pave-way-for-tax-cuts-says-jeremy-hunt

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Universalsnail · 30/09/2023 21:12

Means tested disability benefits puts disabled people at massive risk of being stuck in abusive situations with no support or money.

BIossomtoes · 30/09/2023 21:10

Secondwindplease · 30/09/2023 21:07

Surely it is true, according to your graph? In every other age category remain is over half of the turnout?

I’m doubting myself now….

Less than 50% for Remain in all three older age groups, ie all over 45. Just goes to show how myths take hold, doesn’t it? I was surprised myself.

Secondwindplease · 30/09/2023 21:07

BIossomtoes · 30/09/2023 21:03

Pensioners are the only age cohort who stated that they would be willing to vote for the whole country to be poorer to achieve Brexit

It’s not true anyway.

Surely it is true, according to your graph? In every other age category remain is over half of the turnout?

I’m doubting myself now….

BIossomtoes · 30/09/2023 21:03

RancidOldHag · 30/09/2023 20:53

Pensioners are the only age cohort who stated that they would be willing to vote for the whole country to be poorer to achieve Brexit

Pensioners are also the cohort who voted remain in 1976, so I'm not sure it's as clear cut as those who see generational division would have us believe.

(Where would we be now if the referendum had been in 1991 instead?)

Pensioners are the only age cohort who stated that they would be willing to vote for the whole country to be poorer to achieve Brexit

It’s not true anyway.

AIBU to think the disabled are the next target?
sadaboutmycat · 30/09/2023 21:01

@DoItAgainPlz that's a very sweeping statement.

Princessandthepea0 · 30/09/2023 20:55

Alstroemeria123 · 30/09/2023 20:46

I’d actually support that if there was another way of being able to register as disabled. And they set the means testing at a sensible level.

I get PIP but arguably don’t need the money (it is welcome, and I spend it entirely on disability-related costs, but I could just about manage without it). However, I do need a couple of specific things it acts as the gateway for. So until or unless there’s another way of accessing those, I’m pretty much stuck with PIP.

I do think this is what will happen soon. Although it has two issues. One the gateway benefits you suggest. Two that tipping point between working and not becomes more unbalanced. For those that may benefit being out of the house especially. I’m not being facetious it’s known that being active and out if you can leads to a more healthy lifestyle.

RancidOldHag · 30/09/2023 20:53

Pensioners are the only age cohort who stated that they would be willing to vote for the whole country to be poorer to achieve Brexit

Pensioners are also the cohort who voted remain in 1976, so I'm not sure it's as clear cut as those who see generational division would have us believe.

(Where would we be now if the referendum had been in 1991 instead?)

Alstroemeria123 · 30/09/2023 20:46

Babyroobs · 30/09/2023 18:51

Unless they start means testing disability benefits.

I’d actually support that if there was another way of being able to register as disabled. And they set the means testing at a sensible level.

I get PIP but arguably don’t need the money (it is welcome, and I spend it entirely on disability-related costs, but I could just about manage without it). However, I do need a couple of specific things it acts as the gateway for. So until or unless there’s another way of accessing those, I’m pretty much stuck with PIP.

Coveescapee · 30/09/2023 20:44

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

They are also the only cohort who had experience both in and out of the EC. Brexit is much more complex than about the economy, I think many older people wanted a financial not political union. All generations are formed by their experiences and none are morally better than any other (unless you count people who fought in the wars who were probably better but unlikely to be still around).

Coveescapee · 30/09/2023 20:38

It's really not an outrageous idea. Many (most) countries have a contributory system where you have to pay in before getting anything out and even then benefits are time limited. That's if they have a benefit system. If you don't want to go down that route this is an alternative.

KnittedCardi · 30/09/2023 20:36

My DM and her husband were wealthy pensioners. Hundreds of thousands in savings, property and pensions. They paid their way for everything. Private health care which they eventually had to give up mid eighties due to premuims being a few thousand a month, yes month. Then they paid for their private nursing homes and live in carers. Then they died of COVID. Good thing, because they had run out of money, and we were in the process of selling their house. All their money was gone. Not so wealthy by the end then.

TheThinkingGoblin · 30/09/2023 20:36

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

DickJagger · 30/09/2023 20:35

hattie43 · 30/09/2023 16:33

Everyone should contribute something in return for benefits if they are able. . I'd advocate some voluntary work for those that may not be able to hold down a job due to LD , ND whatever but they could do a few hours in the community . Maybe cleaning off graffiti , gardening , helping disabled / pensioners with painting , collecting shopping , anything really .

Maybe there could be some sort of house where we stick all these people and they do chores in return for a few quid? We could call it, oh I dunno, a workhouse?

SunL1ghter · 30/09/2023 20:34

Porridgeislife
How is it?

Coveescapee · 30/09/2023 20:28

I think it's abit of a red herring to blame Tory voters, I think Labour would have tried to buy votes in the same way. And also not useful to blame boomers, they acted no differently to his younger generations would in the same position. Eg I have been having conversations with people of my generation 50s since about 2005 saying house prices are too high, they often seemed unable to look ahead and at the wider picture.

girlfriend44 · 30/09/2023 20:22

Voluntary Work is just that Voluntary Work.

Shocking suggestion saying people should be forced to help pensioners and would never Work.

Would you like your mum or dad looked after by someone who was being forced into I wouldn't.

mpsw · 30/09/2023 20:19

Babyroobs · 30/09/2023 20:12

Most of my close circle of friends who are no longer working in their fifties are doing so because of their massive public sector pensions rather than ill health.

That type of pension was phased out back in the 90s. Very few are retiring at 55 on "massive" pensions - though a few exceptionally physical jobs (like military and firefighters) still have an early retirement age.

It's a trade off, isn't it? Back in the 80s (when the last cohort to have had these options) were starting their career, public sector salaries were considerably lower than private sector (and bonuses non-existent). But it was known then that public sector offered better job security and better pensions (something that was well known during Thatcherite reforms), and people made their choices accordingly.

Even later, with public sector pensions reform making them less "massive" they (generally) remained defined benefit. And there's no reason why people who want that type of pension cannot move in to the sector that offers them

TheThinkingGoblin · 30/09/2023 20:18

kirbykirby · 30/09/2023 20:14

Possibly but you could argue that most pensioners will have paid some NI for their pension over many years whereas housing benefit/LHA or the housing element of UC is paid to many people who have never paid into the system or paid very little (and in London this means potentially thousands of pounds rent paid by the taxpayer per month for bog standard housing). HB bill will also go up because more and more people will need to have their rent paid because none of the parties will build social housing.

Bad housing also contributes massively to the cost of healthcare - if landlords are encouraged to buy up all the houses because they can get their mortgages paid by the taxpayer whilst spending minimum on making them habitable (to maximise profits) then this puts massive pressure on the NHS due to things like black mould, poor insulation, unsanitary conditions leading to health problems. They are both connected.

Mostly agree with this but order to shift capital away from property into more productive investments you need a US-style property tac on owners.

How likely is that in the UK?

There are just too many people involved with their hand in the till asking for more.

Its economic rentieriesm run amok.

Porridgeislife · 30/09/2023 20:17

IClaudine · 30/09/2023 20:09

Yes, but that is because of the high house values, not because loads of pensioners have millions sloshing around in their savings accounts?

Does it matter though? Fact is that this is a wealthy pensioner cohort and this is being achieved at the cost of everyone behind them. Wealth distribution is concentrated in this age group like never before since the creation of the welfare state.

ilovesooty · 30/09/2023 20:17

All of us?

I've never voted Conservative.

TheThinkingGoblin · 30/09/2023 20:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Supersimkin2 · 30/09/2023 20:14

Welfare’s growing cos we all die later - old people use 95 per cent of the nhs budget, and most welfare payments are pensions.

But most voters are old.

kirbykirby · 30/09/2023 20:14

TheThinkingGoblin · 30/09/2023 19:43

I agree that HB is an issue but its cost (£26bn) is nowhere near as bad as State Pension (£120bn) and Healthcare (£200bn+).

Possibly but you could argue that most pensioners will have paid some NI for their pension over many years whereas housing benefit/LHA or the housing element of UC is paid to many people who have never paid into the system or paid very little (and in London this means potentially thousands of pounds rent paid by the taxpayer per month for bog standard housing). HB bill will also go up because more and more people will need to have their rent paid because none of the parties will build social housing.

Bad housing also contributes massively to the cost of healthcare - if landlords are encouraged to buy up all the houses because they can get their mortgages paid by the taxpayer whilst spending minimum on making them habitable (to maximise profits) then this puts massive pressure on the NHS due to things like black mould, poor insulation, unsanitary conditions leading to health problems. They are both connected.

Princessandthepea0 · 30/09/2023 20:14

IClaudine · 30/09/2023 20:13

It is etiquette on MN to link to sources that are mentioned in posts. Your response has echoes of the "do your own research" mob.

I don’t really care - you wouldn’t read it anyway. It’s been out months now.