Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think the disabled are the next target?

384 replies

Locutus2000 · 30/09/2023 13:14

The Guardian

Though Jeremy Hunt said the government was “not in a position” to contemplate a decrease in tax immediately, he said the welfare budget could be hit further down the line to foot the bill.

He told the Times that 100,000 people a year were “moving off work into benefits without any obligation to look for work” – a sign he said showed the system was not working.

The welfare system had to be a “mix of carrot and stick”, with more assistance required to help people find work, given there was “no shortage of jobs”, he added."

Funny how 'carrot and stick' always equates to 'more stick'.

UK welfare budget could be cut to pave way for tax cuts, says Jeremy Hunt

Chancellor says system has to be ‘mix of carrot and stick’ with more assistance to help people find jobs

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/sep/30/uk-welfare-budget-could-be-cut-to-pave-way-for-tax-cuts-says-jeremy-hunt

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
loislovesstewie · 01/10/2023 08:14

I worked in the public sector; my pension contributions were invested so that the scheme self funds. Every year I get a statement that tells me how that fund is doing. Can someone explain why the governments of this country did not have the wherewithal/common-sense to do the same? Why ,at no point, did any Chancellor think' oh this needs to be self funding'? MP's are supposed to think of these things. the Chancellor is supposed to be able to manage the economy, no one seems to be blaming them for the mess. Apparently I am responsible because I am over pension age, and as I keep saying I have never voted Tory! FWIW I don't think Labour thought it through either, but they at least haven't governed the country for as long.

NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 01/10/2023 08:02

The majority of the welfare bill is for pension benefits, but of course the Tories will not touch that due to pensioners voting Tory, instead money will be taken from the most vulnerable in our society, to give wealthy people tax breaks. Along with cuts to services, and issues due to lockdown, I feel young people have been totally sacrificed, with no thanks for essentially staying inside for 2 years to protect the elderly. Given how long people live, the future looks very bleak.

Noicant · 01/10/2023 05:15

I think yeah it’s fair to say the elderly use a lot of resource but then whats the alternative? We can’t deny them health or social care. I suppose you could basically pop all social care they receive as a charge against their capital but healthcare is free at the point of use for everyone.

I’m always slightly bewildered when people go into care homes and their families complain that they have had to sell their house. They are unlikely to go back to it and why should the taxpayer pick up the bill so someone else gets to keep their inheritance. Maybe we do need to have a more honest conversation about how we fund old age. More means testing etc.

My view tends to be that I would rather my DD pay less income tax while she’s young and trying to get on in life vs maybe receiving a lump sum when I’m dead.

I’m also unsure why working 16 hours means people are exempt from the benefit cap. I think it creates a ceiling rather than a floor when people are planning their working lives. As I said in a pp less than a third of the population are actually working full time. This really is unsustainable.

BIossomtoes · 30/09/2023 23:19

PickAChew · 30/09/2023 23:00

I'm in my early - mid 50s and can't access the bit of public sector pension I accrued before having the audacity to give birth to disabled children until I'm 60.

That’s the case for almost all public sector pensions.

jannier · 30/09/2023 23:13

Ylvamoon · 30/09/2023 13:33

Surely it depends on the disability?!

Rather than a blanket policy of can't work, it should be looked at case by case...

It is you go to a panel

PickAChew · 30/09/2023 23:00

Babyroobs · 30/09/2023 20:12

Most of my close circle of friends who are no longer working in their fifties are doing so because of their massive public sector pensions rather than ill health.

I'm in my early - mid 50s and can't access the bit of public sector pension I accrued before having the audacity to give birth to disabled children until I'm 60.

PickAChew · 30/09/2023 22:53

TheThinkingGoblin · 30/09/2023 19:45

The over 55s are responsible for 80% of NHS spending.

They are (by far) the most prodigious users of healthcare.

Hoefully you're not planning to be part of that statistic

DickJagger · 30/09/2023 22:35

My niece doesn’t want to work & never has. She admits this openly. She also doesn’t want to pay water as it falls from the sky for free🙄 she definitely has more disposable income than me. She’s just had a new bathroom & radiators. She also got registered with the only nhs dentist in the area & gets free scripts

Why don't you just do whatever she is doing then?

PickAChew · 30/09/2023 22:30

pointythings · 30/09/2023 15:09

It isn't wrong to want disabled people to work. The majority would love to work. Thing is, if we want to support people into work - I mean really support them - that will take investment. Some people will only ever be able to work part time - so employers will need incentives to offer job share. Some people will not be able to work unless it's from home - employers will need incentives to recognise and support that. Some people will always need a high level of supervision and teaching - that costs. Just pushing people into work by cutting their financial support will not work. And it's sadly the only thing the Tories will ever offer.

This.

Ds1(19, ASD, ADHD, highly anxious and electively mute) is doing supported internships, this year. Unpaid. Much of that support is through access to work. There is a £66k budget for that support. That is about 20 times what he receives in means tested benefits.

greengreengrass25 · 30/09/2023 22:18

Yes I don't agree with the 16 hr either.

WrongSwanson · 30/09/2023 22:05

BIossomtoes · 30/09/2023 22:03

Sorry! 😞

No it's not your fault, it's an interesting topic, it just could be displayed better

BIossomtoes · 30/09/2023 22:03

WrongSwanson · 30/09/2023 22:02

Yes, it's a terrible graph to be fair!

Sorry! 😞

WrongSwanson · 30/09/2023 22:02

Secondwindplease · 30/09/2023 21:30

Ok, I think I see now. So for 45 to 54, for example, ~67% turned out and of them ~44% voted remain.

It’s not my favourite graph ever but I see where I was going wrong!

Edited

Yes, it's a terrible graph to be fair!

WrongSwanson · 30/09/2023 22:01

StarDolphins · 30/09/2023 21:26

My niece doesn’t want to work & never has. She admits this openly. She also doesn’t want to pay water as it falls from the sky for free🙄 she definitely has more disposable income than me. She’s just had a new bathroom & radiators. She also got registered with the only nhs dentist in the area & gets free scripts.

I have saved ALL my life, done without, lived frugally. I know 9 mums that won’t do more than 16(?) hours as they then can’t get UC. Again, they live better than me.

imo, the system needs a massive overhaul.

Yes when mine were primary age I knew so many mums sticking rigidly to their 16 hours even when offered more/payrises and expecting the taxpayer to pick up the tab for their lifestyle

TheLongGloriesOfTheWinterMoon · 30/09/2023 21:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

The only "clear and present danger" in this country is sick evil fuckers who appear to be promoting eugenics.

You need fucking arresting for hate speech.

StarDolphins · 30/09/2023 21:38

Secondwindplease · 30/09/2023 21:33

I see a lot of discussion on here from people saying they might drop down to 16 hours for more time with their kids. Like, sorry what? Those sort of calculations shouldn’t even be an option.

In my view if you reduce your hours voluntarily you shouldn’t have access to additional benefits for at least a year.

The taxpayer is not your sugarmamma.

Yep, I agree. I didn’t even know it was a thing until I met school mums!

I have an 8 year old mini that it took 4.5yrz to save, 1 has a ‘21 puma & another has a brand new Nissan!

£13k I earn & they must get more than me with their wage & whatever else they get.

They’re nice people, I guess it’s not their fault - this is why it’s not working.

Secondwindplease · 30/09/2023 21:33

StarDolphins · 30/09/2023 21:26

My niece doesn’t want to work & never has. She admits this openly. She also doesn’t want to pay water as it falls from the sky for free🙄 she definitely has more disposable income than me. She’s just had a new bathroom & radiators. She also got registered with the only nhs dentist in the area & gets free scripts.

I have saved ALL my life, done without, lived frugally. I know 9 mums that won’t do more than 16(?) hours as they then can’t get UC. Again, they live better than me.

imo, the system needs a massive overhaul.

I see a lot of discussion on here from people saying they might drop down to 16 hours for more time with their kids. Like, sorry what? Those sort of calculations shouldn’t even be an option.

In my view if you reduce your hours voluntarily you shouldn’t have access to additional benefits for at least a year.

The taxpayer is not your sugarmamma.

BIossomtoes · 30/09/2023 21:33

Secondwindplease · 30/09/2023 21:30

Ok, I think I see now. So for 45 to 54, for example, ~67% turned out and of them ~44% voted remain.

It’s not my favourite graph ever but I see where I was going wrong!

Edited

I agree, it’s not great. It’s given my brain a workout though!

Secondwindplease · 30/09/2023 21:30

Ok, I think I see now. So for 45 to 54, for example, ~67% turned out and of them ~44% voted remain.

It’s not my favourite graph ever but I see where I was going wrong!

StarDolphins · 30/09/2023 21:26

My niece doesn’t want to work & never has. She admits this openly. She also doesn’t want to pay water as it falls from the sky for free🙄 she definitely has more disposable income than me. She’s just had a new bathroom & radiators. She also got registered with the only nhs dentist in the area & gets free scripts.

I have saved ALL my life, done without, lived frugally. I know 9 mums that won’t do more than 16(?) hours as they then can’t get UC. Again, they live better than me.

imo, the system needs a massive overhaul.

BIossomtoes · 30/09/2023 21:23

Secondwindplease · 30/09/2023 21:16

Sorry but I think your wrong @blossomtoes.

  • Age 45-54, approx 43% voted remain from a turnout of around 67%. More than half the turnout voted remain.
  • Age 55 to 64, approx 42% voted remain from a turnout of around 74%. Again, more than half the turnout voted remain.
  • 65% is the only category where more than half of the turnout did not vote remain (only 40% of a turnout of 90% voted remain).

I see exactly what you’re saying but is the Remain vote shown as a percentage of the turnout? This is the commentary that accompanied the diagram.

Blaming older generations for the outcome is prevalent in many analyses: if only the young had voted, the result would clearly have been ‘remain’. Two points are worth noting in the debate on young versus older voters. First, interpolating from the numbers in Figure 1, the ‘leave’ vote outstrips ‘remain’ already by the age of 41 or 42. Second, higher turnout among the young would have helped the ‘remain’ side, but would not have decisively swung the result. In fact, if the turnout of 18-34 year olds had been the same as that of the 65 year olds and older, it would have yielded a 50-50 outcome (see Figure 2). This is based on the assumption that abstaining young voters would have shown the same preferences as those who actually voted.

Here’s the link so you have the same information as me.

https://www.ceps.eu/ceps-publications/demographics-and-brexit-deeper-problem-eu/

Secondwindplease · 30/09/2023 21:23

WrongSwanson · 30/09/2023 21:18

You've misunderstood the graph.

(Either that or more than 100% of the youngest age group voted remain Wink )

What I interpreted from the youngest category is that approx 72% wanted remain but only approx 64% bothered to turnout. Which sounds about right really.

I don’t see any other way of interpreting the graph. Unless someone has the source and we can check.

WrongSwanson · 30/09/2023 21:18

Secondwindplease · 30/09/2023 21:16

Sorry but I think your wrong @blossomtoes.

  • Age 45-54, approx 43% voted remain from a turnout of around 67%. More than half the turnout voted remain.
  • Age 55 to 64, approx 42% voted remain from a turnout of around 74%. Again, more than half the turnout voted remain.
  • 65% is the only category where more than half of the turnout did not vote remain (only 40% of a turnout of 90% voted remain).

You've misunderstood the graph.

(Either that or more than 100% of the youngest age group voted remain Wink )

Secondwindplease · 30/09/2023 21:16

Sorry but I think your wrong @blossomtoes.

  • Age 45-54, approx 43% voted remain from a turnout of around 67%. More than half the turnout voted remain.
  • Age 55 to 64, approx 42% voted remain from a turnout of around 74%. Again, more than half the turnout voted remain.
  • 65% is the only category where more than half of the turnout did not vote remain (only 40% of a turnout of 90% voted remain).