Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think the disabled are the next target?

384 replies

Locutus2000 · 30/09/2023 13:14

The Guardian

Though Jeremy Hunt said the government was “not in a position” to contemplate a decrease in tax immediately, he said the welfare budget could be hit further down the line to foot the bill.

He told the Times that 100,000 people a year were “moving off work into benefits without any obligation to look for work” – a sign he said showed the system was not working.

The welfare system had to be a “mix of carrot and stick”, with more assistance required to help people find work, given there was “no shortage of jobs”, he added."

Funny how 'carrot and stick' always equates to 'more stick'.

UK welfare budget could be cut to pave way for tax cuts, says Jeremy Hunt

Chancellor says system has to be ‘mix of carrot and stick’ with more assistance to help people find jobs

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/sep/30/uk-welfare-budget-could-be-cut-to-pave-way-for-tax-cuts-says-jeremy-hunt

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Babyroobs · 30/09/2023 16:16

User183642 · 30/09/2023 16:12

Ironically the NHS would benefit hugely from a reduction in the welfare state. The number of nurses (and other healthcare workers) who work 16 hours per week in order to maximise their benefits is astonishing so if these people had to work full time we’d be seeing a massive reduction in the staffing issues as well as a reduction in the benefits bill.
Another major problem is the numbers of people reaching retirement age without any sort of pension or even qualifying for a full state pension based on contributions and it was about time that those opting out of work (who are not disabled or caring for a disabled family member) were forced to pay a surcharge to cover NI contributions for the time they are choosing not to work- if it benefits your household for you not to work it is only fair that you are taxed on that benefit.

I think many older nurses are working 16 hours because they have retired and then returned to the NHS rather than maximizing benefits ! As tax credits are being phased out there will be no more working 16 hours to maximise benefits unless you are a lone parent with very young kids, as Uc is tougher and earnings thresholds increasing.

Longcovider · 30/09/2023 16:16

User183642 · 30/09/2023 16:12

Ironically the NHS would benefit hugely from a reduction in the welfare state. The number of nurses (and other healthcare workers) who work 16 hours per week in order to maximise their benefits is astonishing so if these people had to work full time we’d be seeing a massive reduction in the staffing issues as well as a reduction in the benefits bill.
Another major problem is the numbers of people reaching retirement age without any sort of pension or even qualifying for a full state pension based on contributions and it was about time that those opting out of work (who are not disabled or caring for a disabled family member) were forced to pay a surcharge to cover NI contributions for the time they are choosing not to work- if it benefits your household for you not to work it is only fair that you are taxed on that benefit.

Yes, it is the rational choice for them, everyone is going to act according to their own economic interests.

I saw yesterday two jobs advertised at a local charity, both 16 hours a week. On the one hand I can see that it enables people to fulfil caring duties and also work. On the other hand I have friends who still only work 16 hours a week with teenagers and that's pretty wasteful in terms of state funding. It is a mess really.

RoseAndRose · 30/09/2023 16:16

Funny how the number having to reduce work or stop completely matches so closely with the arrival of covid - or rather more importantly with long covid.

The system might not be coping well with it, but it's wrong to blame the system, rather than examining properly the probable causes of rising ill heath and therefore spells out of the workforce

Universalsnail · 30/09/2023 16:14

Longcovider · 30/09/2023 16:13

Name changed for this.

I am a higher rate tax payer who has been off work for a year and is now being managed out of employment. I don't blame them, I had a failed return to work and am currently too fatigued to even work part time from home.

I am housebound and can't walk more than 100 yards without getting out of breath and resting, but I'm not entitled to PIP because I can shower, cook a basic meal etc.

There are lots of people in this situation and there will be more over this winter because covid is everywhere at the moment.

You are entitled to PIP. Did you apply and get rejected? If so did you appeal? You definitely meet the criteria for atleast mobility based on what you have said here.

Longcovider · 30/09/2023 16:13

Name changed for this.

I am a higher rate tax payer who has been off work for a year and is now being managed out of employment. I don't blame them, I had a failed return to work and am currently too fatigued to even work part time from home.

I am housebound and can't walk more than 100 yards without getting out of breath and resting, but I'm not entitled to PIP because I can shower, cook a basic meal etc.

There are lots of people in this situation and there will be more over this winter because covid is everywhere at the moment.

User183642 · 30/09/2023 16:12

Ironically the NHS would benefit hugely from a reduction in the welfare state. The number of nurses (and other healthcare workers) who work 16 hours per week in order to maximise their benefits is astonishing so if these people had to work full time we’d be seeing a massive reduction in the staffing issues as well as a reduction in the benefits bill.
Another major problem is the numbers of people reaching retirement age without any sort of pension or even qualifying for a full state pension based on contributions and it was about time that those opting out of work (who are not disabled or caring for a disabled family member) were forced to pay a surcharge to cover NI contributions for the time they are choosing not to work- if it benefits your household for you not to work it is only fair that you are taxed on that benefit.

loislovesstewie · 30/09/2023 16:12

SuVineer, what I am seeing though on this thread is a huge amount of generalisation, both about disabilities and the ability to work, and about how people vote . Most of my friends/acquaintances vote Labour for example and don't feel the way we are being portrayed. And we understand the differences in disabilities and why some cannot work.
FWIW, we have had rubbish government for far too long IMHO, none try to resolve the issues ,but faff around tinkering at edges, but with no understanding

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 16:11

agent765 · 30/09/2023 15:41

Not all of them.

You clearly have contempt for disabled people - and that comes from someone who personally knows several people who play the system.

It is a slippery slope to assume that. One day you may become ill or have an accident that disables you so you can no longer work. Karma's a bitch.

Why do you think saying disabled people can work shows contempt for them? I have a disability and it doesn’t stop me working. Many, probably most, disabled people can do some work.

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 16:07

Tiredalwaystired · 30/09/2023 16:04

Fund the nhs properly for starters. There are 7m people waiting for appointments. Many are now on long term sick who wouldn’t be if they could get their treatment.

Begin talks with the striking workers for starters so things don’t keep getting worse. And give nurses a decent payrise in April so it doesn’t all start again.

under investment in the NHS is a false economy.

We need more tax or to cut spending in other areas to increase spending like this. At the moment we are not even raising the amount of tax to pay for the spending we do - we are borrowing every year.

Universalsnail · 30/09/2023 16:06

Unfortunately a frank and honest conversation isn't going to cure my chronic illness and make me a capable and reliable worker. Perhaps medical treatment would, but unfortunately in the 3 years I have been ill I have received absolutely no treatment or help, just long wait lists for disappointing waste of time appointments. If the government really want to get sick people working perhaps they need to adequately fund health care and health research.

LolaSmiles · 30/09/2023 16:05

It's fine to want more people in the workforce. The current welfare situation is unsustainable. But, and it is a huge but, this needs to be with appropriate workplace practices, flexible working, proper adjustments for different needs, accepting part time work and getting rid of attendance policies that punish people for having a long term health condition.

It can't be all stick and cut finances until people are in desperate poverty so they have no choice to but to work until their health is dire to have a basic existence. What concerns me is that the Tories would love that because poor, unwell people who are barely surviving won't have much strength to push back.

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 16:05

loislovesstewie · 30/09/2023 16:02

I'm 67; I have NEVER, EVER voted Tory. I first voted in February 1974 and have always voted Labour. So please don't think we are all the same.

The current pensioner generation are much more likely than any other demographic to vote and to vote Tory. Of course that doesn’t mean absolutely every pensioner votes Tory. But the tories know this is their core vote so make sure to keep them happy.

Tiredalwaystired · 30/09/2023 16:04

Fund the nhs properly for starters. There are 7m people waiting for appointments. Many are now on long term sick who wouldn’t be if they could get their treatment.

Begin talks with the striking workers for starters so things don’t keep getting worse. And give nurses a decent payrise in April so it doesn’t all start again.

under investment in the NHS is a false economy.

loislovesstewie · 30/09/2023 16:02

I'm 67; I have NEVER, EVER voted Tory. I first voted in February 1974 and have always voted Labour. So please don't think we are all the same.

Princessandthepea0 · 30/09/2023 15:58

People can argue about what stops people from working and what doesn’t all they like. Can’t stop the facts. The chancellor was told by his own reports the excessive tax cliffs are harming tax take. Problem 1. We are now getting into colossal debt as our outgoings are much higher than tax take. Problem 2. A whopping 54.2% of adults are now state dependent as the ONS announced this year. The majority of adults are now state dependents. Problem 3.

That needs fixing and it needs the politicians of all colour to have a frank and honest conversation with everyone in the country before we get even poorer as a nation. The facts and figures are out there as a matter of public record.

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 15:56

FloweryName · 30/09/2023 13:27

YABU. The current rhetoric seems to be about convincing the public that pensioners don’t deserve what they receive despite many of them paying into the system for decades. I think they are being negatively targeted much more than disabled people right now.

Not sure where you get that from- state pensions cost over £120billion a year and at least 20% go to millionaires. Despite that pensioners are getting an increase way above any other benefit claimants. It’s the present generation of workers who are paying for this too.

despite this, and the fact that the triple lock increases alone cost £11 billion last year, no political party has even suggested moderating the increase in pensions never mind means testing. Of course this is partly paid for by continuing to increase the pension age for workers who are paying for these pensions.

The current generation of pensioners as a whole tend to vote and also tend to vote Tory. Hence why they are sitting pretty

Universalsnail · 30/09/2023 15:53

I have a chronic illness. I would love to work but what job would possibly accept me having to call in sick about 50 percent of the time as I never know which days will be a capable day and which won't? Also why should a business or work colleagues have to put up with me having 50% of the time off as my workload would fall to them. I considered self employment but what self employment could I get away with not being able to work half the time? Every body I know with their own business has to work double hard to get it off the ground?

People don't think the practicalities through of forcing sick people into the workplace.

Insommmmnia · 30/09/2023 15:50

What do you mean next, disabled people have been dying for years due to justifiable benefits claims being turned down and have been vilified by the press and the government for years, this is not a new thing

And if the government actually gave a shit about disabled people working they would stop whining about people working from home

agent765 · 30/09/2023 15:49

FloweryName · 30/09/2023 15:08

What’s wrong with that though? Pensioners should be provided with enough money to live on comfortably. No one wants to see their granny or grandad living in poverty, only just able to sustain themselves. These are people who will never be able to improve their income, unlike some carers or disabled people. And they have paid into the system that is now providing for them so it’s not like they have contributed nothing.

Old people being targeted is plain wrong. Most have paid their dues and a lot of retired on state pension provide childcare for grandchildren etc. No civilised society would treat their elderly like this, especially in a wealthy country.

I read a comment online a few days ago that said people over 70 should all be DNR because they use too many young people's resources. WTAF?

I wonder if those young people will be happy to be treated like that when they're older - especially as medical advances mean that many people will live longer, healthier lives.

Universalsnail · 30/09/2023 15:45

There are a lot of people here assuming other people's health or capabilities 😕

Princessandthepea0 · 30/09/2023 15:44

I am worried for the genuinely disabled. Equally - I can see a state dependency rate of 54.2% and not enough people paying in - isn’t sustainable.

loislovesstewie · 30/09/2023 15:43

Could you all remember that not all disabilities are visible? A person who uses a wheelchair might well be better able than a person with a severe and enduring mental health condition, a person with a learning disability might look OK but not be able to work, or find anyone who will give them a chance. People are individuals , some are more able/capable than others and should be assessed accordingly, and also given support and real, practical help. Are we going back to the 'deserving and undeserving poor', model of Victorian times?

agent765 · 30/09/2023 15:41

DoItAgainPlz · 30/09/2023 14:32

Disabled people can still work.

Not all of them.

You clearly have contempt for disabled people - and that comes from someone who personally knows several people who play the system.

It is a slippery slope to assume that. One day you may become ill or have an accident that disables you so you can no longer work. Karma's a bitch.

clothe · 30/09/2023 15:38

DoItAgainPlz · 30/09/2023 14:32

Disabled people can still work.

The problem with this statement is that all kinds of health conditions come under the disabled umbrella, including mental health conditions, learning difficulties, illnesses that are disabling in themselves as well as people with severe disabilities. I don’t know how you can make this kind of comment about a large and diverse group of people. There will always be people in society who are unable to work and are vulnerable. As a decent society we should be looking after them. Additionally, many people want to work but their conditions are unpredictable and variable. Show me an employer who would be happy to employ someone not knowing whether they were doing to be able to do the job on any given day.

Babyroobs · 30/09/2023 15:38

LadyMary50 · 30/09/2023 15:31

I do think think the benefits system needs a good hard look.I know a few genuinely disabled people who are wheelchair users and they all manage to work and enjoy it.But I have a family member who at the age of 42 has never had a job since leaving school,her parents supported her for years but now as pensioners they can no longer afford to.She suddenly developed ‘social anxiety’,and lo and behold is now in receipt if PIP and UC.She has no outgoings,still lives at home with her parents and has more disposable income than my son who works as a carer with autistic children.It’s a bloody sham and it will be the genuine disabled who will be targeted.

Yes she will likely be on over 1k a month on even lower rate PIP and the Limited capability for work element of UC. her parents need to take some of that off her for living there- hopefully they do. There are just so many people like this, but with the right help and support in the right job they could work. My brother has a nephew who has social anxiety - resulting in just sitting in his room playing playstation for years on end. It is sad and really can't be much of a life. These people need support to be integrated back into the workforce.

Swipe left for the next trending thread