Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think the disabled are the next target?

384 replies

Locutus2000 · 30/09/2023 13:14

The Guardian

Though Jeremy Hunt said the government was “not in a position” to contemplate a decrease in tax immediately, he said the welfare budget could be hit further down the line to foot the bill.

He told the Times that 100,000 people a year were “moving off work into benefits without any obligation to look for work” – a sign he said showed the system was not working.

The welfare system had to be a “mix of carrot and stick”, with more assistance required to help people find work, given there was “no shortage of jobs”, he added."

Funny how 'carrot and stick' always equates to 'more stick'.

UK welfare budget could be cut to pave way for tax cuts, says Jeremy Hunt

Chancellor says system has to be ‘mix of carrot and stick’ with more assistance to help people find jobs

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/sep/30/uk-welfare-budget-could-be-cut-to-pave-way-for-tax-cuts-says-jeremy-hunt

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Ponoka7 · 30/09/2023 17:00

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 16:36

Yes I agree 1 I think we have to get back to a situation where we realize we can’t just take. Of course some may be genuinely unable but most won’t be.

So what does your plan look like and we're do you get the stats from to say that most can do what you suggest?

Sirzy · 30/09/2023 17:00

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 16:58

I didn’t say anything of the sort about annual leave or pensions. I never mentioned them.

And community work can really be helpful to many disabled people who can end up quite isolated. Also we should all contribute to society as a general principle but also it’s really quite beneficial to people to do community work.

Equating it to slavery shows you have no understanding of how awful slavery is. You just add sound entitled

But if there is a need for that work then we should be properly supporting and paying people to do it. To say just because they are disabled they should be made to volunteer is wrong.

people may choose to volunteer but it should never be forced upon people as some sort of pay back for needing support

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 17:00

IClaudine · 30/09/2023 16:55

You know very well what I am saying. Go away.

You were just being ridiculous. Making silly comments doesn’t help your argument

Insommmmnia · 30/09/2023 16:58

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 16:47

We all should be contributing to society if we can. That’s not slavery and it’s really offensive to think that slavery is the same as community work.

Forced labour for no pay/less than minimum wage is not community work

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 16:58

pointythings · 30/09/2023 16:53

No, I stand by what I said. Work that needs doing should be properly paid. And that should include sick leave, annual leave, pensions. If you don't think so, I invite you to ask yourself, as a disabled person, why you think disabled people should not have these things.

I didn’t say anything of the sort about annual leave or pensions. I never mentioned them.

And community work can really be helpful to many disabled people who can end up quite isolated. Also we should all contribute to society as a general principle but also it’s really quite beneficial to people to do community work.

Equating it to slavery shows you have no understanding of how awful slavery is. You just add sound entitled

Ponoka7 · 30/09/2023 16:56

We should also be supporting community cafés etc who give people a chance to experience the world of work, but it should remain voluntary.

Duckingella · 30/09/2023 16:56

Mumofsend · 30/09/2023 14:40

I suspect soon enough it will be decided that carers on carers allowance will be assessed for their ability to work alongside their caring responsibilities. Or it shifts to high rate care/high Pip only.

Well I hope their going to pay for the childcare from someone who knows how to handle my children's disabilities then.

It's really unfair.

Soubriquet · 30/09/2023 16:55

I’m on disability but not a whole lot and it’s not enough to live on. If I could work, I would but I can see me having one or two good days, followed by a week of recovery and phoning in sick. Not an ideal employee really.

I can’t do any heavy lifting. I can’t stand for longer than 10 mins, and I can’t sit upright for long either. I have to be reclining.

I do wish there was something I could do though

IClaudine · 30/09/2023 16:55

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 16:53

Why do you plan to do that? Because someone suggested other disabled people could do community work if they are able?

so on that basis you’ve decided to tell your husband to clean graffiti? Is that right?

You know very well what I am saying. Go away.

Ponoka7 · 30/09/2023 16:55

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 16:47

We all should be contributing to society if we can. That’s not slavery and it’s really offensive to think that slavery is the same as community work.

It's making people work to be able to eat, regardless of how much pain, tiredness, distress, humiliation etc that causes, there always have been different forms of slavery. In practice this would cost more than the benefits being given. I can remember the deaths when the Youth Opportunity schemes were going because no-one had training or the right equipment.
What is needed are IT skills courses, but the Inbetween ones that employers are asking for. So Microsoft 350 etc.

Babyroobs · 30/09/2023 16:54

BIossomtoes · 30/09/2023 16:30

The point is that pensioners have much more generous benefits and get a greater share of government spending because they have high levels of voting and have high levels of voting Tory.

Do you have any statistics to support that? Because the most any pensioner can get from the state is £203.85 a week. Obviously it’s a high level of spending collectively because it’s a large cohort but individually it doesn’t seem overly generous.

Very few of them just get this. there are huge numbers getting Attendance Allowance ( one of the easiest disability beenfits to get ) and this can passport people to pension credit which passports them to full housing beenfit, council tax etc. i think unless you actually see the amounts first hand that people get it's very easy to think it's just £203 a week. The reality is far from this.

IClaudine · 30/09/2023 16:53

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 16:47

We all should be contributing to society if we can. That’s not slavery and it’s really offensive to think that slavery is the same as community work.

But you are not talking about voluntary work, are you? You are talking about forcing disabled people to do menial tasks to earn their benefits. That is fucking offensive.

And I really am coming off this thread now because it is genuinely making me feel sick.

pointythings · 30/09/2023 16:53

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 16:47

We all should be contributing to society if we can. That’s not slavery and it’s really offensive to think that slavery is the same as community work.

No, I stand by what I said. Work that needs doing should be properly paid. And that should include sick leave, annual leave, pensions. If you don't think so, I invite you to ask yourself, as a disabled person, why you think disabled people should not have these things.

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 16:53

IClaudine · 30/09/2023 16:50

I am going to let my husband know that he needs to start cleaning graffiti. A bit limited when only possible from a sitting position. Same with painting. I guess he could theoretically do someone's shopping, as long as the shopping list only includes goods from the lower shelves. And he'd need someone to help him in and out of the car and to carry the shopping etc.

Why do you plan to do that? Because someone suggested other disabled people could do community work if they are able?

so on that basis you’ve decided to tell your husband to clean graffiti? Is that right?

TheThinkingGoblin · 30/09/2023 16:52

Eleganz · 30/09/2023 14:44

It is affordable if we actually bite the bullet and harmonise capital gains tax with income taxation. Whilst we allow people to earn almost double in capital gains than through employment before they pay the same amount of tax we will always seem short of money for such a rich country.

We also need targeted infrastructure investment that will encourage growth and increase taxation revenues in that way.

In short we need a "New Deal" that rebalances our taxation system and encourages investment in infrastructure.

Nope. This is still nowhere near enough to compensate for the UKs deteriorating demographics and infrastructure.

There is no scenario where you fix this without less tax revenue being diverted to pensioners because you ignore the big 3:

Pensions
Healthcare
Social Care

You cannot raise £100bn+ in tax per year to fund those things as they stand.

Mathematically impossible.

Its the end of the line for the outsized perks that UK pensioners have been receiving due to the crumbling infrastructure, and the older and sicker population.

Even mass immigration on a Canada-like scale will not save you now. Too much damage has been done.

Spendonsend · 30/09/2023 16:52

hattie43 · 30/09/2023 16:33

Everyone should contribute something in return for benefits if they are able. . I'd advocate some voluntary work for those that may not be able to hold down a job due to LD , ND whatever but they could do a few hours in the community . Maybe cleaning off graffiti , gardening , helping disabled / pensioners with painting , collecting shopping , anything really .

Its not voluntary work if they have to do it in exchange for benefits.

DrCoconut · 30/09/2023 16:50

@hattie43 absolutely no. Community service cleaning graffiti and litter picking used to be for criminals. It is not a crime to be disabled or unemployed. If there is work to be done then pay people a fair wage to do it! Otherwise street sweepers, cleaners and other low paid workers will be laid off and then forced to go back to their job in exchange for a pathetic amount of universal credit. Because UC really is that. Look at all the "I only earn 80k however will I afford to live" threads and then think that that is around 13 years of bills and food money to a young single UC claimant.

IClaudine · 30/09/2023 16:50

I am going to let my husband know that he needs to start cleaning graffiti. A bit limited when only possible from a sitting position. Same with painting. I guess he could theoretically do someone's shopping, as long as the shopping list only includes goods from the lower shelves. And he'd need someone to help him in and out of the car and to carry the shopping etc.

User183642 · 30/09/2023 16:49

loislovesstewie · 30/09/2023 16:44

Actually I am coming off this thread because some of the comments are very close to the idea that only people who work are worth anything , and close to an ideology that is despicable.

It’s not so much that only those who work are worth anything but that the numbers of people not paying tax for whatever reason is unsustainably high.
Clearly in the case of a lot of disabled people and those that care for them work is not going to be an option whatever is done and the state needs to be able to provide for such people. At the same time people actively choosing to be a SaHP for example are financially benefiting their family at the expense of the state, both through lost tax revenue but more importantly through failing to contribute towards their pensions, and such choices should be subject to taxation to cover the additional costs to the state.

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 16:47

pointythings · 30/09/2023 16:42

We used to have this sort of thing. It was called 'slavery'.

If the work needs doing, pay someone a proper wage for it.

We all should be contributing to society if we can. That’s not slavery and it’s really offensive to think that slavery is the same as community work.

Insommmmnia · 30/09/2023 16:47

hattie43 · 30/09/2023 16:33

Everyone should contribute something in return for benefits if they are able. . I'd advocate some voluntary work for those that may not be able to hold down a job due to LD , ND whatever but they could do a few hours in the community . Maybe cleaning off graffiti , gardening , helping disabled / pensioners with painting , collecting shopping , anything really .

You appear to have a rose tinted view of both what it is to live as a disabled person, what it would take to run such a scheme and how painter, cleaners and gardeners would feel when they are struggling to make ends meet when a bunch of exhausted, in pain, distressed individuals are forced to take on their work for free.

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 16:45

BIossomtoes · 30/09/2023 16:30

The point is that pensioners have much more generous benefits and get a greater share of government spending because they have high levels of voting and have high levels of voting Tory.

Do you have any statistics to support that? Because the most any pensioner can get from the state is £203.85 a week. Obviously it’s a high level of spending collectively because it’s a large cohort but individually it doesn’t seem overly generous.

It is entirely untrue that that’s the maximum amount pensioners get from the state. It’s the minimum. This is the amount of pension credit- the equivalent amount for uc for working age people is about £67 for people under 25 and about £10 more for working age people under pension age. so pensioners on pension credit get over double working age people on benefits.

Then of course there’s housing benefit (no deductions for under occupation unlike working age people), free prescriptions, winter fuel allowance, etc. all of which pensioners on pension credit get automatically.

Not to forget of course that the state pension is one of the few universal benefits and certainly the highest. The cost of state pensions alone is greater than the whole education budget and at least 20% goes to millionaires.

loislovesstewie · 30/09/2023 16:44

Actually I am coming off this thread because some of the comments are very close to the idea that only people who work are worth anything , and close to an ideology that is despicable.

pointythings · 30/09/2023 16:42

hattie43 · 30/09/2023 16:33

Everyone should contribute something in return for benefits if they are able. . I'd advocate some voluntary work for those that may not be able to hold down a job due to LD , ND whatever but they could do a few hours in the community . Maybe cleaning off graffiti , gardening , helping disabled / pensioners with painting , collecting shopping , anything really .

We used to have this sort of thing. It was called 'slavery'.

If the work needs doing, pay someone a proper wage for it.

midgemadgemodge · 30/09/2023 16:42

Agreed

Fair pay for a days works - or a few hours if that's all they can do

There is something slightly off in society where disabled people who may have lower productivity than others find suitable jobs hard to come by , yet people can think of work they could do when the conversation is about benefits

Swipe left for the next trending thread