Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think the disabled are the next target?

384 replies

Locutus2000 · 30/09/2023 13:14

The Guardian

Though Jeremy Hunt said the government was “not in a position” to contemplate a decrease in tax immediately, he said the welfare budget could be hit further down the line to foot the bill.

He told the Times that 100,000 people a year were “moving off work into benefits without any obligation to look for work” – a sign he said showed the system was not working.

The welfare system had to be a “mix of carrot and stick”, with more assistance required to help people find work, given there was “no shortage of jobs”, he added."

Funny how 'carrot and stick' always equates to 'more stick'.

UK welfare budget could be cut to pave way for tax cuts, says Jeremy Hunt

Chancellor says system has to be ‘mix of carrot and stick’ with more assistance to help people find jobs

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/sep/30/uk-welfare-budget-could-be-cut-to-pave-way-for-tax-cuts-says-jeremy-hunt

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
pointythings · 30/09/2023 17:13

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 17:12

No, it still isn’t. And suitably voluntary community work would be beneficial for all.

So you're now rowing back and saying it would need to be voluntary...

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 17:12

Sirzy · 30/09/2023 17:09

It is if they are being forced into it purely as some sort of payback for daring to need benefits.

No, it still isn’t. And suitably voluntary community work would be beneficial for all.

Ponoka7 · 30/09/2023 17:10

Secondwindplease · 30/09/2023 17:05

I actually think it’s a reasonable expectation for single parents to return to work 15 hours a week when their child is 9 months, if the childcare is subsidised. It’s less hours than many other working parents do.

Edited

Those 15 hours can't be flexible. Most jobs want flexibility. If we made men pay towards child care or get the message across that if they can't pay, they do childcare on their days off. You need to be working 16 hours to still get topped up. You can end up worse off only working 16 hours, though. Personally I've always thought that when we have single, childless non disabled people not working, we shouldn't be forcing LPs of babies into work.

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 17:10

Ponoka7 · 30/09/2023 17:00

So what does your plan look like and we're do you get the stats from to say that most can do what you suggest?

It wasn’t my plan, I just agreed with someone who said that the principle of contributing to society is important. I still agree- it’s important for society and also generally beneficial to the people doing the volunteering.

DoItAgainPlz · 30/09/2023 17:09

agent765 · 30/09/2023 15:41

Not all of them.

You clearly have contempt for disabled people - and that comes from someone who personally knows several people who play the system.

It is a slippery slope to assume that. One day you may become ill or have an accident that disables you so you can no longer work. Karma's a bitch.

Wow.

No where did I say all disabled people can work.

No where did I give any suggestion that I have contempt for the disabled.

My comment stands. The disabled are often written off entirely when they needn't be.

Sirzy · 30/09/2023 17:09

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 17:07

Community work from those on benefits isn’t slavery.

It is if they are being forced into it purely as some sort of payback for daring to need benefits.

PerkingFaintly · 30/09/2023 17:08

Oh, and the DWP themselves are repeat offenders for illegally sacking their disabled staff.

DWP acted 'perversely' in sacking of disabled woman, judge findsThis article is more than 4 years old
Department discriminated against Isabella Valentine, employment tribunal rules
https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/jan/21/dwp-department-work-pensions-acted-perversely-sacking-disabled-woman

DWP acted 'perversely' in sacking of disabled woman, judge finds

Department discriminated against Isabella Valentine, employment tribunal rules

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/jan/21/dwp-department-work-pensions-acted-perversely-sacking-disabled-woman

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 17:07

Sirzy · 30/09/2023 17:05

So you do want slave Labour then.

Community work from those on benefits isn’t slavery.

FloweryName · 30/09/2023 17:07

Everyone's excited by the 15 hours free childcare for children aged 9 months - 4 years;I don't know how many people have worked out that the rule that they introduced that single parents have to find at least part time work from when their youngest child turns 3 will probably become from when their youngest child turns 9 months.

There would be nothing wrong with expecting single parents to work when their child gets to 9 months old. It would be in line with maternity leave that working mothers get. Even if it initially cost the state more in terms of childcare along with top up benefits, the long term financial gain for that family would be worth it.

Zebedee55 · 30/09/2023 17:07

A bulk of the benefits bill is going on those that can and do work limited hours - with UC, housing, and nursery fees top ups.

Perhaps best to concentrate on that before targeting the most vulnerable.🙄

PerkingFaintly · 30/09/2023 17:07

If the government gave a shit about disabled people, they'd come down like a ton of bricks on companies which them like this:

Home Bargains pays man £25k over disability discrimination claim
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-65770209

Disabled bloke working hard in a job which matched what his lifelong condition allowed him to do... and some manager decides to move him onto duties they knew he was incapable of. He had to have the Equality Commission help him take them to court. Don't know if they used an Employment Tribunal, but of course this Tory government have made Employment Tribunals harder to access.

A Home Bargains store

Home Bargains pays man £25k over disability discrimination claim

A Home Bargains employee who has cerebral palsy had his duties changed in the Armagh shop.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-65770209

Ponoka7 · 30/09/2023 17:06

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 17:02

We don’t have unlimited funds to pay people to do absolutely everything we might like done in the community. It’s just not feasible.

But you've just said that you didn't suggest people work for less than minimum wage, it's one or the other.

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 17:06

FloweryName · 30/09/2023 17:02

I get it from listening to the radio over the last few days where they’ve been talking about Kier Starmer’s ridiculous proposal to remove the triple lock.

All benefits went up in line with inflation, unlike wages, but no one ever seems to remember that fact.

No benefits have the triple lock except state pensions.

Keir starmer has also made no proposals whatsoever to drop the triple lock. However, some pensioner groups are already up in arms as he hasn’t recently pledged to keep it.

TheThinkingGoblin · 30/09/2023 17:05

Duckingella · 30/09/2023 17:02

Everyone's excited by the 15 hours free childcare for children aged 9 months - 4 years;I don't know how many people have worked out that the rule that they introduced that single parents have to find at least part time work from when their youngest child turns 3 will probably become from when their youngest child turns 9 months.

Their moving everyone who gets tax credits and child benefit onto UC and the letter thats arrived has duly informed people they may lose money they already get.

It's ridiculous;people are already massively struggling with COL and are merely existing and now the government want to kick Joe Public even harder.

As for the disabled thing;I honestly think if the government could it'd shove everyone claiming DLA/PIP on a one way flight to Switzerland.

Thats never going to work out.

Offering "free hours" when there are less nurseries and employees....

Yet another "lets govern by PR" action by the Tories.

What will happen is a massive level of congestion and problems, driving prices way up (we are seeing this now)

For this to work, you need proper long-term investment.

Like Sure Start centers. That takes time and money to build and develop.

Sirzy · 30/09/2023 17:05

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 17:02

We don’t have unlimited funds to pay people to do absolutely everything we might like done in the community. It’s just not feasible.

So you do want slave Labour then.

Secondwindplease · 30/09/2023 17:05

Duckingella · 30/09/2023 17:02

Everyone's excited by the 15 hours free childcare for children aged 9 months - 4 years;I don't know how many people have worked out that the rule that they introduced that single parents have to find at least part time work from when their youngest child turns 3 will probably become from when their youngest child turns 9 months.

Their moving everyone who gets tax credits and child benefit onto UC and the letter thats arrived has duly informed people they may lose money they already get.

It's ridiculous;people are already massively struggling with COL and are merely existing and now the government want to kick Joe Public even harder.

As for the disabled thing;I honestly think if the government could it'd shove everyone claiming DLA/PIP on a one way flight to Switzerland.

I actually think it’s a reasonable expectation for single parents to return to work 15 hours a week when their child is 9 months, if the childcare is subsidised. It’s less hours than many other working parents do.

pointythings · 30/09/2023 17:05

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 16:58

I didn’t say anything of the sort about annual leave or pensions. I never mentioned them.

And community work can really be helpful to many disabled people who can end up quite isolated. Also we should all contribute to society as a general principle but also it’s really quite beneficial to people to do community work.

Equating it to slavery shows you have no understanding of how awful slavery is. You just add sound entitled

Of course community work can be helpful. If it's voluntary. If it's forced, it's going to be useless. If it's at less than NMW, it's exploitative.

How am I entitled when I work full time and don't claim any benefits? I just feel that work should be paid and that it should not matter who is doing the work in terms of workers' rights. I do not understand how I'm the entitled one when you are the one who thinks disabled people should be forced to work without any of the rights that come with working.

Insommmmnia · 30/09/2023 17:03

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 16:58

I didn’t say anything of the sort about annual leave or pensions. I never mentioned them.

And community work can really be helpful to many disabled people who can end up quite isolated. Also we should all contribute to society as a general principle but also it’s really quite beneficial to people to do community work.

Equating it to slavery shows you have no understanding of how awful slavery is. You just add sound entitled

I didn’t say anything of the sort about annual leave or pensions. I never mentioned them.

Probably because you are expecting disabled people to be forced to work for no money with none of the protections than employment brings. That's really the point, that you never mentioned them

And community work can really be helpful to many disabled people who can end up quite isolated.

And those disabled people would absolutely benefit from the option to volunteer for something like this if it would help them. Not the expectation that they should have to and their benefits reply on it. That's forced labour.

Also we should all contribute to society as a general principle but also it’s really quite beneficial to people to do community work.

And yet no one is out here advocating for all able bodied people to be forced into doing voluntary work

Equating it to slavery shows you have no understanding of how awful slavery is.

Supporting an idea for forced labour for disabled people shows you have no idea how awful some disabilities can be

You just add sound entitled

You sound ableist

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 17:03

IClaudine · 30/09/2023 17:02

Not silly comments at all, just pointing out the impracticalities of your suggestions.

I didn’t make any suggestions that your husband should clean graffiti (or indeed anything else about your dh). Neither did anyone else

FloweryName · 30/09/2023 17:02

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 15:56

Not sure where you get that from- state pensions cost over £120billion a year and at least 20% go to millionaires. Despite that pensioners are getting an increase way above any other benefit claimants. It’s the present generation of workers who are paying for this too.

despite this, and the fact that the triple lock increases alone cost £11 billion last year, no political party has even suggested moderating the increase in pensions never mind means testing. Of course this is partly paid for by continuing to increase the pension age for workers who are paying for these pensions.

The current generation of pensioners as a whole tend to vote and also tend to vote Tory. Hence why they are sitting pretty

I get it from listening to the radio over the last few days where they’ve been talking about Kier Starmer’s ridiculous proposal to remove the triple lock.

All benefits went up in line with inflation, unlike wages, but no one ever seems to remember that fact.

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 17:02

Sirzy · 30/09/2023 17:00

But if there is a need for that work then we should be properly supporting and paying people to do it. To say just because they are disabled they should be made to volunteer is wrong.

people may choose to volunteer but it should never be forced upon people as some sort of pay back for needing support

We don’t have unlimited funds to pay people to do absolutely everything we might like done in the community. It’s just not feasible.

Duckingella · 30/09/2023 17:02

Everyone's excited by the 15 hours free childcare for children aged 9 months - 4 years;I don't know how many people have worked out that the rule that they introduced that single parents have to find at least part time work from when their youngest child turns 3 will probably become from when their youngest child turns 9 months.

Their moving everyone who gets tax credits and child benefit onto UC and the letter thats arrived has duly informed people they may lose money they already get.

It's ridiculous;people are already massively struggling with COL and are merely existing and now the government want to kick Joe Public even harder.

As for the disabled thing;I honestly think if the government could it'd shove everyone claiming DLA/PIP on a one way flight to Switzerland.

IClaudine · 30/09/2023 17:02

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 17:00

You were just being ridiculous. Making silly comments doesn’t help your argument

Not silly comments at all, just pointing out the impracticalities of your suggestions.

TheThinkingGoblin · 30/09/2023 17:02

Babyroobs · 30/09/2023 16:54

Very few of them just get this. there are huge numbers getting Attendance Allowance ( one of the easiest disability beenfits to get ) and this can passport people to pension credit which passports them to full housing beenfit, council tax etc. i think unless you actually see the amounts first hand that people get it's very easy to think it's just £203 a week. The reality is far from this.

I would ignore Blossomtoes.

She has no interest in having a conversation about "reality".

She trots out the £203/week every single time a thread brings up pensioners.

People like her are not interested in discussing the financial realities in an objective way. They want to use emotional arguments to sway people.

Thats how they get away with this.

Won't someone think of those "poor" pensioners?

Crocodile tears really with child poverty approaching 27%.

Money should be focused on the people most in need. And that is definitely not the pensioners now.

SueVineer · 30/09/2023 17:00

Insommmmnia · 30/09/2023 16:58

Forced labour for no pay/less than minimum wage is not community work

Again- no one said anything about forced labour at less than minimum wage.

Swipe left for the next trending thread