Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think the disabled are the next target?

384 replies

Locutus2000 · 30/09/2023 13:14

The Guardian

Though Jeremy Hunt said the government was “not in a position” to contemplate a decrease in tax immediately, he said the welfare budget could be hit further down the line to foot the bill.

He told the Times that 100,000 people a year were “moving off work into benefits without any obligation to look for work” – a sign he said showed the system was not working.

The welfare system had to be a “mix of carrot and stick”, with more assistance required to help people find work, given there was “no shortage of jobs”, he added."

Funny how 'carrot and stick' always equates to 'more stick'.

UK welfare budget could be cut to pave way for tax cuts, says Jeremy Hunt

Chancellor says system has to be ‘mix of carrot and stick’ with more assistance to help people find jobs

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/sep/30/uk-welfare-budget-could-be-cut-to-pave-way-for-tax-cuts-says-jeremy-hunt

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
8
BIossomtoes · 01/10/2023 17:53

Yes, politicians are short termists. Successive governments of both colours have had 60 years to plan for the biggest generation alive to grow old and have done nothing. It’s as if they managed not to register the high birth rates from 1945 to 1964 - amazing really, especially when you consider that they managed to educate all those kids.

You’re right @IClaudine, times have been hard before. Postwar Britain was pretty grim - yet managed to build houses and create the welfare state - the 1970s was an awful time and the medicine to cure it was dreadful. We’re currently going through a very tough time but nothing lasts for ever. The biggest challenge now is climate change and we’re currently stepping back, which feels like madness. I have high hopes of Gen Z, they seem to get it.

Princessandthepea0 · 01/10/2023 14:50

IClaudine · 01/10/2023 14:40

I don't know, princess. Thing were pretty awful when I was growing up. They got better. I think the UK will stumble on for a while and things will improve. Hopefully some fresh political talent will emerge. Young people with fire in their bellies and who have actual ideas rather than relying on populusm.

I really, really hope so.

Princessandthepea0 · 01/10/2023 14:49

Coveescapee · 01/10/2023 14:37

Yes I agree @Princessandthepea0 people including the politicians mainly think short term and have no idea how the economy works. And there is alot of entitlement (not everyone). This is not a labour v Tory issue as some on here seem to think, they all engender the same short term ism, maybe something about the political system?

100% and dare I say it - it’s all at the mercy of the media. I’m not conspiracy theorist at all. However this country has been bled dry. People hate those who do well - you see it on here. So shortsighted, you need those higher rate tax payers to pay the bills. They aren’t some evil entity. Aspiration has been crushed.

Something has to change and urgently. The trajectory from the ONS statistics is appalling. You can’t have a majority population not contributing and such a high state burden. It’s just impossible. It’s not Labour vs Tory. I wish they’d bang their heads together and sort it out for long term prospects. Labour’s school fees policy is another example of going down that rabbit hole. It’s so short sighted I don’t know where to start. However not for this thread. It’s not been costed and will lead to more inequality. It’s madness.

IClaudine · 01/10/2023 14:40

I don't know, princess. Thing were pretty awful when I was growing up. They got better. I think the UK will stumble on for a while and things will improve. Hopefully some fresh political talent will emerge. Young people with fire in their bellies and who have actual ideas rather than relying on populusm.

Coveescapee · 01/10/2023 14:37

Yes I agree @Princessandthepea0 people including the politicians mainly think short term and have no idea how the economy works. And there is alot of entitlement (not everyone). This is not a labour v Tory issue as some on here seem to think, they all engender the same short term ism, maybe something about the political system?

Princessandthepea0 · 01/10/2023 14:26

Things won’t improve. We are on a downward trajectory in the UK. For too many years we stupidly penalised success. Wanting to take more and more from those contributing to society. Throwing stones and trying to drag them down. We now have a society which is fiscally unproductive. More and more people going onto out of work benefits. Less children being born vs an increasing elderly population.

It’s not about electoral suicide. It’s about the crash of a whole country for future generations. Admittedly the selfishness and lack of education is the main problem of why we are in this position. All serious short sightedness.

We now have a minority working population that’s mad in a developed economy and completely unsustainable long term. The thing is, there isn’t much keeping the young or highly educated here. Painful truth and the statistics back it up. High tax, hatred if you do well, universal benefits are gone and a crumbling healthcare/education system. The economy is completely fucked and this has been a long time coming. Yes the politicians are to blame. However so are the selfish, shortsighted electorate. In general we don’t think of the long term issues in the country. “But boats!” “But passports” “But house prices” “We paid in all our lives.” “Tax the rich.” People get the country they deserve.

BIossomtoes · 01/10/2023 14:23

Babyroobs · 01/10/2023 14:10

How will things improve Blossom ? Do you mean just because of the sheer numbers of boomers ?

Of course. Boomers are the bulge in the snake. Once we’ve all gone - and the youngest are 60, so not too long to wait - the pressure will ease never to return.

Babyroobs · 01/10/2023 14:10

BIossomtoes · 01/10/2023 14:05

The political party that addresses them will commit electoral suicide. It was made crystal clear to May in 2017 so it will continue to be kicked into the long grass. Things will obviously improve dramatically in the next 20 years as the boomer generation dies.

How will things improve Blossom ? Do you mean just because of the sheer numbers of boomers ?

Babyroobs · 01/10/2023 14:07

SunL1ghter · 01/10/2023 14:04

But pensioners will be then on less than the cut off for other benefits which they’d then be eligible for so how is not paying them the measly pension they’ve paid into for years going to help?

I have no idea what will happen when there is no more money to pay for it all ? maybe the criteria for the other benefits will be cut, maybe old people will have to live with their families like they used to ? Who knows what will happen if / when the country goes bankrupt. I'm not sayin git will but the future doesn't look great.

BIossomtoes · 01/10/2023 14:05

The political party that addresses them will commit electoral suicide. It was made crystal clear to May in 2017 so it will continue to be kicked into the long grass. Things will obviously improve dramatically in the next 20 years as the boomer generation dies.

SunL1ghter · 01/10/2023 14:04

But pensioners will be then on less than the cut off for other benefits which they’d then be eligible for so how is not paying them the measly pension they’ve paid into for years going to help?

BrontëParsonage · 01/10/2023 14:04

I’m posting from the opposite end of the statistics to the majority here. My DD1 is registered blind and these are the employability statistics for blind people:

There is a significant employment gap between blind and partially sighted people and the general population. The employment rate is 76% in the general population, 51% amongst the disabled population excluding sight loss and 27% for people registered blind and partially sighted.

Babyroobs · 01/10/2023 14:04

It's actually a really scary situation. I really despair for my young adult kids. no prospect of owning a home, massive student debts and probably no chance of a state pension. The best hope is to strongly encourage starting paying into a private pension as early as possible and hope our home doesn't get all used up for care fees so we can leave them something.

Babyroobs · 01/10/2023 14:01

SunL1ghter · 01/10/2023 13:55

So those all saying pensioners shouldn’t have the state state pension they’ve spent their whole lives paying into can we see some figures please. What are you suggesting pensioners have? Currently in my late 50s so interested to know how much is deemed ok because the figures I’m looking at for state pensions don’t look in any way excessive and I’d love to know how you expect those of us near retirement to survive in our retirement years with less.

I think the point that has been made is that these pensioners haven't been paying in to anywhere - they have been paying for previous pensioners and the financial burden of paying for the current pensioners cannot now be met from the current working population because there are not enough tax revenues coming in. It is no-ones fault except politicians who have failed to plan adequately. But in the longer term everyone will suffer. Of course there would be uproar if pensioners suddenly couldn't get a state pension or it became means tested or disability benefits for older people are cut or pension credit cut, but these are the difficult decisions that are going to have to be addressed.

SunL1ghter · 01/10/2023 13:55

So those all saying pensioners shouldn’t have the state state pension they’ve spent their whole lives paying into can we see some figures please. What are you suggesting pensioners have? Currently in my late 50s so interested to know how much is deemed ok because the figures I’m looking at for state pensions don’t look in any way excessive and I’d love to know how you expect those of us near retirement to survive in our retirement years with less.

BIossomtoes · 01/10/2023 13:27

Babyroobs · 01/10/2023 13:04

It says right there in the Age Uk factsheet that income is taken into account.

OK, I’m wrong then, sorry. Neither of my parents had a financial assessment as they both exceeded the savings threshold.

Babyroobs · 01/10/2023 13:04

BIossomtoes · 01/10/2023 13:01

Income isn’t taken into account, just savings above £23,500 - which hasn’t gone up in over a decade.

It says right there in the Age Uk factsheet that income is taken into account.

BIossomtoes · 01/10/2023 13:01

Babyroobs · 01/10/2023 12:49

Yes I am aware of that. I was talking about value of a person's home being taken into account rather than just savings and income.

Income isn’t taken into account, just savings above £23,500 - which hasn’t gone up in over a decade.

Babyroobs · 01/10/2023 12:49

IClaudine · 01/10/2023 11:58

Just for future reference babyroobs, care in the home is not universally free.

www.ageuk.org.uk/information-advice/care/paying-for-care/paying-for-homecare/

Yes I am aware of that. I was talking about value of a person's home being taken into account rather than just savings and income.

Princessandthepea0 · 01/10/2023 12:12

EverySporkIsSacred · 01/10/2023 12:07

Yes I think the ongoing trend of "you can be whatever you want to be, just follow your dreeeeams" is just idiocy when what most teens seem to want to be is a Tick Tock star, a footballer, a professional gamer etc. We can't all be those things, realistically. We push our kids through the system in a one-size-fits-all education to decide at 15 or 16 what they want to do for potentially the rest of their life, with very little chance to try out possibilities they didn't have in school (like plumbing, construction, engineering, probably loads more I can't think of). Loads of teens drop out, loads will have taken a course they would enjoy only to find there is no employment using it and they can't afford to move anywhere that does.

The sad fact is that many that don't manage to choose a profession they have an aptitude for will end up in zero hours contracts or working 12 hour shifts that grind your mental health down and wear you out so they end up with depression from the hopelessness of it all, anxiety disorders from filling in the right forms and trying to keep the bills paid when you don't know what your income is going to be the next week, burnout from dealing with neurodiversity in a workplace designed for maximum productivity and speed from all employees, and that's just some of the mental health issues that can and do happen. There are also physical disabilities that can be exacerbated by being in the wrong job or for too many hours, hypermobility being one which my own family have issues with.

What happens when people break down because they're pushed too far? They end up relying on the state. And whose fault was it they ended up there?

This kind of goes full circle doesn’t it? Trapped in a cycle where aspiration is crushed (one look at all the reports on the tax system will tell you that). Bettering yourself is seen as bad in the country, let’s throw stones at those people who end up in well paid jobs - pull everyone down.

Those people say fuck it and stop, then we end up in a bitter cycle of state dependency where most people are net takers. The youth are ‘paying in’ at some of the highest rates ever. Knowing that probably in 10 years they will need private healthcare, probably education for their children. They will never get the state pension and probably can’t buy a house. They should shut up though because they need to keep working to pay tax.

The whole state system is completely top heavy now and I don’t know how it can be fixed. I feel so sorry for the young coming out of education.

EverySporkIsSacred · 01/10/2023 12:07

Yes I think the ongoing trend of "you can be whatever you want to be, just follow your dreeeeams" is just idiocy when what most teens seem to want to be is a Tick Tock star, a footballer, a professional gamer etc. We can't all be those things, realistically. We push our kids through the system in a one-size-fits-all education to decide at 15 or 16 what they want to do for potentially the rest of their life, with very little chance to try out possibilities they didn't have in school (like plumbing, construction, engineering, probably loads more I can't think of). Loads of teens drop out, loads will have taken a course they would enjoy only to find there is no employment using it and they can't afford to move anywhere that does.

The sad fact is that many that don't manage to choose a profession they have an aptitude for will end up in zero hours contracts or working 12 hour shifts that grind your mental health down and wear you out so they end up with depression from the hopelessness of it all, anxiety disorders from filling in the right forms and trying to keep the bills paid when you don't know what your income is going to be the next week, burnout from dealing with neurodiversity in a workplace designed for maximum productivity and speed from all employees, and that's just some of the mental health issues that can and do happen. There are also physical disabilities that can be exacerbated by being in the wrong job or for too many hours, hypermobility being one which my own family have issues with.

What happens when people break down because they're pushed too far? They end up relying on the state. And whose fault was it they ended up there?

Princessandthepea0 · 01/10/2023 12:06

IClaudine · 01/10/2023 11:41

I don't think it is tone deaf to point out that right now in some parts of the country people can be living in fairly modest homes that are worth an insane amount of money.

They may be millionaires on paper, but that is not the same as having millions in bank accounts. What do you want people to do, sell up and downsize to flats or smaller homes, thus making it even harder for first time buyers to get n the property ladder?

Edited

It isn’t really the thread for it to be honest. It’s not all about pensioners and defending their asset wealth. There is a background issue because of the state pension, sure. This is about how the disabled will have their benefits changed. The more pressing issue is how we make society more inclusive. That’s first, there aren’t enough people paying in to fund pensions. So cart before the horse.

loislovesstewie · 01/10/2023 12:06

Yep, I'm 67, never voted Tory, voted Remain, retired public sector worker, worked full time to ensure I got a pension, tried to provide for my retirement, ,still paying tax, husband died before he got 1 year of his state pension, thought that we had wasted opportunities for the various governments to actually fund pensions etc properly and apparently I am the cause of all ills.
BTW, the best thing we could do would be get rid of half the MP's , they cost us a fortune.

WrongSwanson · 01/10/2023 12:04

NeverDropYourMooncup · 01/10/2023 12:02

That is also to some extent an artefact of misogyny in medical care - women are held to a higher burden of proof for autoimmune, connective tissue diseases and associated injuries than men; it's only when I have repeated the 45 years of treatment for both, quoting medications, consultants and managed to get staff to actually look at my records that they shut the fuck up about fucking Fibro, as it's the default assumption (other than perimenopause) for a female describing pain - and there's no treatment other than 'live with it'. Unlike Autoimmune and Connective Tissues, where there are many medications and treatments that can help and even cause complete remission. And (ETA) uncontrolled inflammation also affects mood entirely independently of being as a response to pain or trauma/unhappiness - an informal diagnostic of that is where a steroid injection can resolve low mood and lability in a couple of hours. But you'd need to be able to access the hospital for a doctor or prescribing nurse specialist to find that one out.

I still get poked in the classic trigger points for Fibro pain first. I think the intention behind it (especially as it's often very aggressive poking) is to elicit a yelp of pain/surprise so they can immediately dismiss everything as the one diagnosis that has no particular treatment. However, because I'm expecting it, the conversation usually goes along the lines of

'Does that hurt?'

Not particularly because you're digging into a Fibro point. You need to go up to the hot and swollen bit where the ... tendon inserts into .... to find where it hurts'.

'What makes you think you've got anything wrong with you?'

45 years of DMARDs, Physio, Biologics, steroid pulses, significantly raised CRP and ESR, findings on X ray, ultrasound and MRI tend to contribute. And I do generally believe what Consultant Rheumatologists tell me. My current one is x at y hospital - perhaps they'd be happy to explain to you why they think I do?

(Yes, I know I'm being a dick to them at that point. But they're being a dick to me and deliberately inflicting pain with the intention of dismissing everything as the No Treatment Possible Fibro bucket at that point, so they've earned it).

Edited

So true about the misogyny in medicine

I was dismissed by GPs for 5 years before getting a diagnosis

The men in the group for my condition all tended to have been taken seriously far more quickly

NeverDropYourMooncup · 01/10/2023 12:02

Babyroobs · 01/10/2023 11:27

The sheer numbers suffering with MH issues and fibro are overwhelming though. I work in welfare rights and every other person seeking help with PIP forms has fibro or depression.

That is also to some extent an artefact of misogyny in medical care - women are held to a higher burden of proof for autoimmune, connective tissue diseases and associated injuries than men; it's only when I have repeated the 45 years of treatment for both, quoting medications, consultants and managed to get staff to actually look at my records that they shut the fuck up about fucking Fibro, as it's the default assumption (other than perimenopause) for a female describing pain - and there's no treatment other than 'live with it'. Unlike Autoimmune and Connective Tissues, where there are many medications and treatments that can help and even cause complete remission. And (ETA) uncontrolled inflammation also affects mood entirely independently of being as a response to pain or trauma/unhappiness - an informal diagnostic of that is where a steroid injection can resolve low mood and lability in a couple of hours. But you'd need to be able to access the hospital for a doctor or prescribing nurse specialist to find that one out.

I still get poked in the classic trigger points for Fibro pain first. I think the intention behind it (especially as it's often very aggressive poking) is to elicit a yelp of pain/surprise so they can immediately dismiss everything as the one diagnosis that has no particular treatment. However, because I'm expecting it, the conversation usually goes along the lines of

'Does that hurt?'

Not particularly because you're digging into a Fibro point. You need to go up to the hot and swollen bit where the ... tendon inserts into .... to find where it hurts'.

'What makes you think you've got anything wrong with you?'

45 years of DMARDs, Physio, Biologics, steroid pulses, significantly raised CRP and ESR, findings on X ray, ultrasound and MRI tend to contribute. And I do generally believe what Consultant Rheumatologists tell me. My current one is x at y hospital - perhaps they'd be happy to explain to you why they think I do?

(Yes, I know I'm being a dick to them at that point. But they're being a dick to me and deliberately inflicting pain with the intention of dismissing everything as the No Treatment Possible Fibro bucket at that point, so they've earned it).