Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why companies are mandating RTO during cost of living crisis

136 replies

Roxinabox · 30/09/2023 10:18

I don't understand the timing?

It's mor expensive than ever to live in cities. Rent and mortgage costs are way up, public transport prices are ridiculous, local places to eat lunch are more expensive, and salaries are down in real terms.

And now more companies are asking workers to spend more money returning to the office.

Why now? I half suspect it's a conspiracy to keep cities going as people are increasingly getting priced out of them!

OP posts:
CantHaveTooMuchChocolate · 30/09/2023 11:14

00100001 · 30/09/2023 10:32

Because people take the piss and aren't productive at work when at home.
They still have to heat the buildings whether it's 3 or 35 people in.

Its not the company's problem you applied for a job miles and miles away from home and choose to eat lunch out...

It will be the companies problem though when she leaves for one offering fully remote working! Replacing staff is expensive (as is keeping office space).

noticetomarry · 30/09/2023 11:14

I’m grateful we can home work. Makes a difference to my productivity. I log on earlier and finish later and typically they get way more out of me than on an office day because then I have to travel and usually walk around town to grab lunch in my lunch hour. At home I’m usually working fairly solidly 8:30am-5:30pm and usually work through lunch, if I take ten mins out that’s all it is.

Doubt there is space for us all to work in the office full time anymore. I’ve been there nearly two years now and can count on one hand the amount of times I’ve seen every at their desk in the office. It’s really rare to go in and in a small office of 8 see any more than one or two others there, sometimes nobody’s there!

midgemadgemodge · 30/09/2023 11:14

Certainly with larger companies there is some " you do this for the government if you want x/y/z"

Funny how change policies are announced days after bosses meet with government officials

Ginmonkeyagain · 30/09/2023 11:13

Indeed. You don't NEED to spend the money. I take a sandwich lunch and we are lucky enough to have free tea and coffee in the office.

I also find it strange people talking about "the economy" as it is a separate entity. We are all the economy.

There is a middle way between the obsessive presenteeism of some industries (which I never got - my work has always been flexible to some degree) and everyone sitting at home on their laptops.

I also wonder if people heard what they wanted to hear. I joined my current employer in late 2020 and I clearly remember a meeting and a follow up email where a question about remote (and even international) working was answered by the CEO saying they planned for a return to the office as soon as government rules allowed and that employees would be expected to be within a reasonable commute of an office (we have four in England and one in each of the other UK nations)

CruCru · 30/09/2023 11:10

I don’t think companies are doing this to prop up the cities they are based in. Companies care about themselves and their financials.

Realistically, head office (not in the UK) are saying things like “If no one is coming into the office, why are we paying a load of UK staff £30k / £40k / £80k when there are able people in India / Malaysia / the Philippines? Can we cut back our staff costs and move to a smaller UK premises?” The head of the UK company knows that if the UK is cut back to a skeleton staff, it’ll become a satellite office. There won’t be any need for an expensive head of XYZ Ltd.

gazpachosoupday · 30/09/2023 11:10

My work has always been working in the office, however they have recently moved offices, which has increased the majority of the people's travel expenses.

Added to this half the office is out sick with suspected covid and the rumour is they are now looking at the potential for more people to work at home at least through the winter.

However in my department, I cant see how that would work

MyCircumference · 30/09/2023 11:10

people dont always have the correct chair/seating arrangements at home
home working can feel isolating
torygraph and others have a bee in their bonnet

JimnJoyce · 30/09/2023 11:08

There is a local ish office to where I live but none of the people I support or work with are based there. They're all down South.

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 30/09/2023 11:06

My employer is happy for us to continue to work from home. Those who took the piss during lockdown and beyond are no longer working here. Productivity is higher than it was when we were in the office 5 days per week.

The one day per week I go into the office is my least productive day, but CEO has said he's happy for it to be used as a catch up/mental health type day if that's what people want to do. Some people choose to go into the office for more than the mandatory 1-day per week. And that's ok too.

I'm very lucky, I work at a place where we're treated well, give and take is the norm and everyone works hard.

I don't know why employers are insisting on making people RTO. It's very shortsighted. As are the comments about 'why apply for a job miles away and complain when you have to go in'. Being able to hire the best person for the job rather than the person who lives closest to the job benefits employers and employees alike.

I feel sorry for those being forced to RTO when WFH clearly works perfectly well for many jobs.

OnAFrolicOfMyOwn · 30/09/2023 11:06

While you might not spend your money like that, enough office workers spend money during their lunch break.

Do they, though, in this COL crisis? I take my food from home, including my preferred tea-bags because I certainly can't afford (and don't particularly like) Costa coffees and the like.

BoohooWoohoo · 30/09/2023 11:00

During the pandemic I saw a many people moaning about the loneliness and cost of wfh (space, utilities etc) as people loving the flexibility.

It depends where you are in your career too. I would guess that face to face training is much more effective than online and that people new in the careers achieve more faster in person.

The government wants people going to work spending money on work clothes,trains, parking, lunches, coffee, wandering around the shops during lunchtime etc I remember when Rishi was Chancellor, he was photographed buying his coffee at Pret and promoting EOTHO at Wagamamas. While you might not spend your money like that, enough office workers spend money during their lunch break.

Phos · 30/09/2023 10:59

Because WFH all the time was meant to be temporary during the pandemic - it just dragged on too long. I'm fed up of complaints from people in our department who chose to move to the arse end of nowhere and now have a long commute. Sorry you were never a contractual homeworker, you're not exempt, get to the office.

Photio · 30/09/2023 10:57

Ginmonkeyagain · 30/09/2023 10:36

It's not great conspiracy, a lot of workplaces simply prefer their staff it do some of their work face to face.

I suspect that part of it is the first cohort of post covid graduates and apprentices have passed through the system and results are ..... not great.

A lot of early careers staff struggle to develop the required soft skills when a lot of senior staff are WFH.

This^
This isn't about the current workforce, it's also about attracting the next generation in a labour shortage. New grads don't want to go to companies that are 100% remote as it's too difficult for them to learn the skills of the job by observing experienced workers and they feel they're "bothering" staff by having to call to ask things rather than just asking person next to them.
Companies are taking a long-term view about upskilling the next generation of workers and this is better done by some days in person absorbing everything going on around from experienced workers

CyberCritical · 30/09/2023 10:54

I think it depends on the company and their links to politicians or political views. The company I work for are closing offices globally or reducing the size of them because WFH works well for us and we only really need a few spaces for client facing meetings and the occasional team get together.
We aren't politically aligned so no pressure to support the 'get people commuting and spending money' agenda and bottom line for us is that it's cheaper and more efficient to not be paying the overheads on floor space and associated electric/lighting/maintenance fees when we don't need them.

MonkeyChiselTree · 30/09/2023 10:54

I got a well below cost of living pay rise and lots lower than the people in my team. We're being moved back to the office 2-3 days a week whilst at the same time reduced our travel to other offices. There's almost no point going into my local office (£13.20 return paid by me) because most of my team is in another office (£120 return paid by organisation). But I'm banned from going to that office more than once every 2 months (usually once a month for in person 1:1s with my team). So I have to go into my local office at cost to me to have virtual meetings I used to have in person. Nope. Doesn't work for me. I've ignored it. I agree during a cost of living crisis shifting costs to employees is plain wrong. Especially employees who you screwed over at appraisal time!

OnAFrolicOfMyOwn · 30/09/2023 10:53

Possibly a local issue, but in my area there is a significant shortage of parking since, following the pandemic housing boom, three large public carparks have now become blocks of flats.

Public transport is terrible here. The decision-makers for office working, are, of course, based in London and have no concept of areas where trains are one every two hours, assuming it is not cancelled. I'm not personally affected as I'm close enough to walk or cycle into work but it's causing enormous stress for those who live further out and can no longer find parking as they could pre-Covid.

midgemadgemodge · 30/09/2023 10:53

As a new recruit I worked alone in a lab or retreated to the library for peace and quiet

One of our recent recruits spends far more time at home than in the office but he is doing really well

I am not sure everyone learns loads from being in the office

Greengrassohla · 30/09/2023 10:53

Do people seriously think that individual employers are marking these decisions for the benefit of the economy? Don't be daft!

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 30/09/2023 10:52

Unless you were employed in work from home role o didn’t see why people are so upset about being asked to do what they were employed to do. Covid was exceptional circumstances, but things have returned to normal
people should expect their employers to want them in the office.

if you were employed to work from home and now they’re demanding you come in then that’s very different, but I suspect it’s not the case for most.

TGGreen · 30/09/2023 10:51

Presumably most took city jobs because of the higher wages.

Sensoria · 30/09/2023 10:49

00100001 · 30/09/2023 10:32

Because people take the piss and aren't productive at work when at home.
They still have to heat the buildings whether it's 3 or 35 people in.

Its not the company's problem you applied for a job miles and miles away from home and choose to eat lunch out...

Exactly this. To both of these points.

Unless it was advertised as a wfh role, I don’t understand people who applied for a job with a nightmare commute and then complain about it.

Plexie · 30/09/2023 10:48

Not everyone finds it expensive.

Travelling a few days a week on public transport is cheaper on pay as you go than an annual season ticket, which you would need if working full time in the office.

Lunches don't need to be expensive - some people used to take in lunch from home anyway, and supermarket meal deals haven't increased as much as the likes of Pret etc.

There are aspects of being together in person that you don't get from WFH.

And it depends what life/job stage people are at. People with years or decades of experience of work are more likely to be confidently established in their working practices. What about young people just starting out? Cast your mind back to your 18 or 21 year old self - how would you have settled into the world of work if you'd been working remotely and never experienced the wider culture of working actually in the workplace? Plus the social aspects.

Likewise people's living conditions. Older people can be more insulated from increasing housing costs because they have or have nearly paid off their mortgage. And at the other end, many young people are in house shares, which isn't necessarily comfortable to be WFH from.

Ginmonkeyagain · 30/09/2023 10:46

Well it is a bit of a chicken and egg thing really.

I really appreciate the flexibilty of hybrid working and want to keep that, but it would be foolish to say there is no benefit to people being in the office - both to staff and the organisation.

I think organisations do have to try harder to help people see the benefit of coming to the office. We have a monthly all department meeting that has to be attended in person. Our director mkes it an event with a free "social" sandwich lunch beforehand and then we usally organise after work drinks (no compulsion to attend) in the evening.

It has been really successful to help rebuild those social connections and the newer and younger staff really appreciate it.

RaisinsOfMildAnnoyance · 30/09/2023 10:38

Working in an office to hold meetings over Teams anyway is ridiculous.

Ginmonkeyagain · 30/09/2023 10:36

It's not great conspiracy, a lot of workplaces simply prefer their staff it do some of their work face to face.

I suspect that part of it is the first cohort of post covid graduates and apprentices have passed through the system and results are ..... not great.

A lot of early careers staff struggle to develop the required soft skills when a lot of senior staff are WFH.