Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why companies are mandating RTO during cost of living crisis

136 replies

Roxinabox · 30/09/2023 10:18

I don't understand the timing?

It's mor expensive than ever to live in cities. Rent and mortgage costs are way up, public transport prices are ridiculous, local places to eat lunch are more expensive, and salaries are down in real terms.

And now more companies are asking workers to spend more money returning to the office.

Why now? I half suspect it's a conspiracy to keep cities going as people are increasingly getting priced out of them!

OP posts:
frivlot · 30/09/2023 13:06

I wonder if some will be priced out of London especially entirely and look to work where the commute and housing isn't so expensive.

I think more FTBs then ever before left London to buy.

I do think more people will now look for a house a bit further out as opposed to a more central located flat.

frivlot · 30/09/2023 13:05

maybe the WFH has contributed to inflation/COL crisis as everyone had more money through reduced commuting fares, home made lunches etc

i'm pretty sure research found money spent on lunches in town were spent locally instead hence why Pret has opened up more local branches

MonkeyChiselTree · 30/09/2023 13:04

sweeneytoddsrazor · 30/09/2023 11:23

Maybe because some people take the piss. I had to ring a council dept last week and whilst talking to the person they suddenly said excuse me I need to put you on hold for a moment. A minute later they came back, apologised and said these parcel delivery men don't give you much time to answer the door. I wasn't bothered but it does show people do household stuff whilst being paid to work.

So you've never had a non work chat with a colleague whilst making a hot drink/getting some water? You've never sat at your desk having a non work related conversation with anyone, beit a phone call to book a dentist appointment, talk to a workman about a job they need to do in your home or a conversation with a colleague about last night's telly?

No one who works in an office every day spends every minute productively working. No one who works from home spends every minute taking in parcels and doing the washing.

But it is disingenuous to say being in the office per se increases productively. In my case it doesn't because my team (recruited both pre and post Covid) work in other parts of the UK.

PikachuChickenRice · 30/09/2023 13:03

Roxinabox · 30/09/2023 12:56

I wonder if some will be priced out of London especially entirely and look to work where the commute and housing isn't so expensive.

It's already happening... which is why rents and house prices in Manchester have gone up massively, with all the Londoners moving in.
Post-Brexit I have no idea how service staff, cleaners etc survive in London unless they've been there in social housing for at least a decade. It's become a playground for the rich.

I went to uni in London but having done the numbers realised I'd have nothing left over for life... of course more opportunity for promotion+higher salary etc but you can't rely on that.

I left, with respective salaries around the national median DH and I had decent lives, managed to save for a deposit and buy a house before having kids. I'd have been miserable if I had to spend my twenties eating beans on toast and 'hustling' every hour of the day solely to buy a grotty flat.

Truthlikeness · 30/09/2023 13:02

We do it because there's a noticeable difference in the quality of work and team working between those who come in more often and those who do so rarely. I'm sure all industries are different, but that's the case for our work.

7Worfs · 30/09/2023 13:02

Wanderingowl · 30/09/2023 12:56

The commercial property market is in big, big trouble and this is an attempt to stop it from crashing. Many companies, investments, pensions, etc are heavily tied up in commercial property, so when it does crash (as I suspect it will one way or the other) the knock on effects will be huge. Pushing people back into the office will shore it up for a while as Covid and remote working deflated the commercial market faster than it would have otherwise. It's not just the offices themselves but the shops and cafe's in areas that rely on office workers to stay afloat.

That’s exactly it - commercial real estate.

Within two weeks mine and two friends’ companies (all different industries) got official summons back to the office.

I’m going to do one day a week and ignore requests for more.

Wanderingowl · 30/09/2023 12:56

The commercial property market is in big, big trouble and this is an attempt to stop it from crashing. Many companies, investments, pensions, etc are heavily tied up in commercial property, so when it does crash (as I suspect it will one way or the other) the knock on effects will be huge. Pushing people back into the office will shore it up for a while as Covid and remote working deflated the commercial market faster than it would have otherwise. It's not just the offices themselves but the shops and cafe's in areas that rely on office workers to stay afloat.

Roxinabox · 30/09/2023 12:56

I wonder if some will be priced out of London especially entirely and look to work where the commute and housing isn't so expensive.

OP posts:
sunnyseed · 30/09/2023 12:56

OnAFrolicOfMyOwn · 30/09/2023 12:17

Although you might be saving on transport you're not saving on wear and tear in the home and heating costs

Depends - if you have someone else at home anyway, it makes no difference. My husband is retired, so the house still needs heating when I am at work.

Working from home has made it possible for my family to go from having 2 cars to one which is a massive saving. Add to that the cost of fuel and not having to pay for work attire and expensive lunches which I often ended up getting because I didn’t always have time to make a packed lunch. I am paid below the going rate for my profession so I think this is a fair trade off.

MinnieMouse0 · 30/09/2023 12:53

Good! I hate wfh and am dying to move to a job with mandatory office attendance.

sunnyseed · 30/09/2023 12:51

I regularly work way more than my contracted hours and don’t get paid for it because my organisation is too tight to pay for enough staff to do the work. I am not paid for the extra hours I work. Most weekends I end up doing extra hours and sometimes work until 11pm or into the early hours. If they started telling me to return to the office I would flat out refuse to do any additional work outside of the office because adding in the extra time commuting and having the faff of wearing stuffy office attire and making packed lunches would mean I am even more exhausted.

ilovesushi · 30/09/2023 12:47

I work hybrid and that suits me and the type of work I have to do, but I find it really annoying on the days when everyone is supposed to be in and only half the team turns up. In those situations my instinct his to crack on with the team in the room but I get flack from my line manager saying "You didn't consult X, Y feels sidelined, you have disrespected Z's position."

So what do I do? Waste the time of those who did turn up by not actually deciding anything and putting anything into action? Waste my time and delay everything by repeating everything at a convenient time for those who couldn't/ didn't make it in?

Hybrid works if people respect that some activities are done best alone and some in a team. I also hate coming in for a meeting which is essentially one person talking at us. Put it in an email, record a voice note, do it on teams. Everyone is too busy to come in just to be talked at.

GrapplingGoat · 30/09/2023 12:46

howshouldibehave · 30/09/2023 11:30

Were you employed on a WFH contract?

Yes, but I have been there for less than two years and am not convinced they think wfh is working out for them 😏 it's a minimum wage admin job though so hopefully would be able to find something local.

PikachuChickenRice · 30/09/2023 12:46

Photio · 30/09/2023 12:26

My DH was still WFH last winter. He saved money on his few miles of a commute but and we had to have our heating on until 11am and back on at 2pm every day in order for him not to freeze to death, even with a fleece on (Scotland). The rest of us were out for the day so the heating would have gone off at 8am and come back on at 3.30 if he hadn't been at home. How is that saving money in an energy cost crisis when households are doing this up and down the country instead of being in one office building?

The people upset with RTO aren't those who live nearby like your DH. It's those who used to, and spent a fortune doing so with high rents, and then moved away but are now facing spending fortune commuting on trains and whatnot. Also, wraparound childcare!

Personally for me (no DC yet) the difference is minimal. DH works from home FT, we used to live 20 mins away from the office but now live 40. Still doable.

BrawnWild · 30/09/2023 12:40

Imo its ridiculous that people are being priced out of cities when there are plenty of central office buildings that could be turned into flats which would be more likely to support a thriving high street. I'm sure o saw a study on it somewhere.

The real reason people are being forced back is because a lot of money and investments are tied up in office rentals and people responsible for those investments want to keep them going, hence they talk in the right ears to get the little people back back into the office so they can keep milking the cash cow.

Society doesnt benefit from central offices, wealthy people and investors do.

WhereYouLeftIt · 30/09/2023 12:35

midgemadgemodge · 30/09/2023 10:32

I our case the mangers are as put out as anyone - they don't care as long as the work gets done well

Sone people do work better in the office and if you have people like that who are also new then having more experienced people around really helps them

But blanket rules rather than situation appropriate seem daft to me and my boss and his boss

It's a good point about new employees, although I'd say it's helpful even if the new employee is happy to work from home. Every workplace has different ways of doing things, and being surrounded by the rest of your team means you'll get up to speed quicker.

I also think I would find it very lonely, working solely from home. I enjoy interacting with people, and face-to-face is better for me.

cuddlebear · 30/09/2023 12:32

Interesting. My employer has gone the other way entirely. They are selling off all our regional offices and just retaining the central London HQ.

So most staff, including myself now have our home address as our workplace. I anticipate going into London between 4 - 8 times a year. The train fare will be paid and travel time comes out of my working hours.

My job involves a lot of travel around the region seeing clients, so I won’t be stuck wfh every day. It suits me really well and is a very popular move with colleagues.

If they said everyone had to go back to the office, people would just leave in droves. Very low levels of unemployment in my region and in my sector, so getting a new job fairly simple.

00100001 · 30/09/2023 12:29

kirbykirby · 30/09/2023 12:22

It's probably the case that big business/commercial property owners have pushed for the return to office work as they are losing money on their investments.

Nothing is ever done for the wellbeing of workers these days, it is all about money and the rich ensuring they make a profit.

Which in turn keeps us all employed...

Winterday1991 · 30/09/2023 12:29

maybe the WFH has contributed to inflation/COL crisis as everyone had more money through reduced commuting fares, home made lunches etc

OnAFrolicOfMyOwn · 30/09/2023 12:29

Because like it or not, its not your workplaces problem that there's a COL crisis happening.

Most workplaces play a significant part in perpetuating wealth inequality, so it may not be their problem but it's partly their fault.

Photio · 30/09/2023 12:26

My DH was still WFH last winter. He saved money on his few miles of a commute but and we had to have our heating on until 11am and back on at 2pm every day in order for him not to freeze to death, even with a fleece on (Scotland). The rest of us were out for the day so the heating would have gone off at 8am and come back on at 3.30 if he hadn't been at home. How is that saving money in an energy cost crisis when households are doing this up and down the country instead of being in one office building?

Hufflemuff · 30/09/2023 12:26

Because like it or not, its not your workplaces problem that there's a COL crisis happening. If you worked in an office pre covid then of course workplaces have the right to expect you back. You have the right to say no and find another job.

I have about 70% less internal emails now I'm back in an office because in general you know about things happening around you and don't need to be cc into things. I can also be asked to do something and do it without needing an email to request this. Its faster in that sense for everyone. As a manager I can verbally discuss and train hands on rather than spending ages writing instructional emails to colleagues about which button to click next and what option to select after etc... So for me, the job is actually easier when I'm in the office - yes I might be travelling to work and back but I'm done a lot earlier than I would be if I'm WFH.

Wexone · 30/09/2023 12:22

I work from home and go into the office once every two weeks. I went in last week and actually cried it was so horrible. we were suppse to have training that required face to face which was then cancelled that morning. it was OK for people leving nearer to the office but I live 2.5 hours to the office. before people jump down my throat I did move further away during the past 2 years but it's due to rental not avaliable nearer. something beyond my control and a fact of life at mo. none of the people i deal with are not in my office anyway so ended up sitting on a teams call most of afternoon. I couldn't hear anything due to other people on their teams calls too. plus my desk was not comfortable. I was sitting beside someone I don't like and it was irrating me ( he is a cocky little shite) the noise of people walking in and out of office was annoying plus the printer nose and the noise of people coming in and out fo meeting rooms was also annoying. it's my least productive days too. tool me three hours to get home cost 60e in diesel as well. but what I hate most of office days is the rush yoi are rushing to get ready in morning get dogs sorted dress properly get out before traffic hits pray no crashes. then home rush walk dogs sort house get dinner on etc. that drives me mental. I am wrecked I feel like the house is out of synch and i spend the next few days at home catching up on work I have missed from being in the office. it you ar ebeing productive and work is being done what is tye harm in working from home.

kirbykirby · 30/09/2023 12:22

It's probably the case that big business/commercial property owners have pushed for the return to office work as they are losing money on their investments.

Nothing is ever done for the wellbeing of workers these days, it is all about money and the rich ensuring they make a profit.

OnAFrolicOfMyOwn · 30/09/2023 12:17

Although you might be saving on transport you're not saving on wear and tear in the home and heating costs

Depends - if you have someone else at home anyway, it makes no difference. My husband is retired, so the house still needs heating when I am at work.