Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why companies are mandating RTO during cost of living crisis

136 replies

Roxinabox · 30/09/2023 10:18

I don't understand the timing?

It's mor expensive than ever to live in cities. Rent and mortgage costs are way up, public transport prices are ridiculous, local places to eat lunch are more expensive, and salaries are down in real terms.

And now more companies are asking workers to spend more money returning to the office.

Why now? I half suspect it's a conspiracy to keep cities going as people are increasingly getting priced out of them!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ginmonkeyagain · 30/09/2023 19:26

To WFH successfully in my industry you have to be "always on" and practice a certain amount of managing up.

We often have to turn around drafting in an hour or less or make changes to papers against the clock. Previously I would have sit with the team and gone though it together but now I often rely in team members picking stuff up in a shared document. If you get the Sharepoint notification you have to jump on it.

Experienced team members understand this but by god it had been hard with some younger and newer people.

PikachuChickenRice · 30/09/2023 19:03

Avenueofcherryblossom · 30/09/2023 13:41

And it's part of the reason why I shot up the career ladder. I wasnt being a martyr

It’s a real shame that doing 10 - 20 hours a week unpaid overtime is the way to make career progression.

There must be so many talented people with interests or responsibilities outside of work who are overlooked for promotion on this basis.

@Avenueofcherryblossom people don't have to do overtime to get promoted. However, logically speaking, if a promotion requires X, Y and Z experience that on average requires 3 years of working normal hours. Working overtime gets you that experience in 1.5 years, so you can get promoted quicker.

Of course this is simplistic, some people work many years without getting the level of responsibility (and hence skills) for the next step up, others do but never get adequately compensated. But it's so complex.

Crapsummer2023 · 30/09/2023 17:56

However the government fiddles the figures to make it look like the economy has grown 0.2% for the last few months, we’re pretty much not growing or are in a recession.

The jobs market isn’t good and employers know this. Despite most on here claiming they are more productive from home, service levels have noticeably dropped in many areas.

I have an acquaintance who moved miles away during Covid, and when her employer went from their ‘promised’ fully remote to 1 then 2 days a week in office, she complained bitterly, insisting she wouldn’t come into the office. She was made redundant 3 months ago and still hasn’t found another job.

LadyGrinningSoul85 · 30/09/2023 17:48

00100001 · 30/09/2023 10:32

Because people take the piss and aren't productive at work when at home.
They still have to heat the buildings whether it's 3 or 35 people in.

Its not the company's problem you applied for a job miles and miles away from home and choose to eat lunch out...

SOME people take the piss.

Don't generalise.
You sound like a 'delightful' human being 🙄

Badbadbunny · 30/09/2023 17:45

Photio · 30/09/2023 17:19

*"Badbadbunny
I agree about the point re graduates. WFH is fine for people who are settled, experienced, etc., but new starters, trainees, etc really struggle without having people around them to train/support them. Having to email/team call constantly is not alternative to real face to face support."

Yes, and it's notable that our junior staff all seem to know this as they all choose to come into the office more often than they have to - so I have made sure I and my team leaders are all in more too*

Yes @WrongSwanson and in a labour shortage market like we have at the moment the Boss's know that graduates and trainees will go for the jobs which are office-based or hybrid. These companies where everyone is WFH are going to find it hard to compete in the job market for the next generation coming up.

Exactly, at my son's employer (he's just finished his first month), they offer pretty complete flexibility - whether WFH, office or hybrid. DS was excited and thought he'd probably WFH for 3/4 days and only go into the office 1/2 days.

First three weeks, son and his graduate/intern colleagues were all in the office as they had all kinds of induction jobs to do. This last week, they were allowed to WFH. DS did just one day and absolutely hated it, he says the other interns/graduates in his team felt the same, so they've all agreed to go fully into the office next week and beyond, and maybe only WFH for good reasons, i.e. bad weather or waiting at home for deliveries/workmen etc.

I think WFH "works" for older/experienced/settled workers, but for younger/new staff, being in the office is far better, in terms of gaining experience, meeting people, settling into their first workplace, etc. Of course, you need the experienced staff in the office, too, to train and support the newbies, so that puts a lot of pressure on them if most WFH as the burden falls on the shoulders of only a small number of experienced staff in the office.

Photio · 30/09/2023 17:19

*"Badbadbunny
I agree about the point re graduates. WFH is fine for people who are settled, experienced, etc., but new starters, trainees, etc really struggle without having people around them to train/support them. Having to email/team call constantly is not alternative to real face to face support."

Yes, and it's notable that our junior staff all seem to know this as they all choose to come into the office more often than they have to - so I have made sure I and my team leaders are all in more too*

Yes @WrongSwanson and in a labour shortage market like we have at the moment the Boss's know that graduates and trainees will go for the jobs which are office-based or hybrid. These companies where everyone is WFH are going to find it hard to compete in the job market for the next generation coming up.

AtmosAtmos · 30/09/2023 16:31

I’m now hybrid, from this thread unusually would prefer fully in the office but due to shifts it needs to be wfh 2 days a week. I need work interaction with people in the same building. My productivity might be better at home my MH only works with hybrid.

OnAFrolicOfMyOwn · 30/09/2023 16:19

We do it because there's a noticeable difference in the quality of work and team working between those who come in more often and those who do so rarely.

If you have been told to come into the office, and some are diligently doing so and others are not (or are coming in as seldom as they can get away with), it's not surprising you'd see better work from those coming into the office - that doesn't mean the diligent ones wouldn't work just as well from home, or the slack ones would work any better in the office.

madamreign · 30/09/2023 16:15

Truthlikeness · 30/09/2023 13:02

We do it because there's a noticeable difference in the quality of work and team working between those who come in more often and those who do so rarely. I'm sure all industries are different, but that's the case for our work.

How are you measuring this?

madamreign · 30/09/2023 16:14

AfraidToRun · 30/09/2023 13:42

I Work in a "team" but because of WFH training is dire and as more experienced colleague more work falls on me and our service is declining as a result. And if I hear one more person say "oh I don't know if I can get doggy daycare" I will scream!

Train your colleagues then- make a workstream out of it and get a promotion out of it.

WrongSwanson · 30/09/2023 16:09

Badbadbunny · 30/09/2023 15:44

I agree about the point re graduates. WFH is fine for people who are settled, experienced, etc., but new starters, trainees, etc really struggle without having people around them to train/support them. Having to email/team call constantly is not alternative to real face to face support.

Yes, and it's notable that our junior staff all seem to know this as they all choose to come into the office more often than they have to - so I have made sure I and my team leaders are all in more too

Itsnamechange · 30/09/2023 16:03

I'm with the same employer since pre pandemic but in a different role and hybrid is in my contract now.
Hybrid has really worked for me tbh. Its allowed me to move to a head office based role which is further away and wouldn't have worked with wrap around care and has allowed me to advance my career which previously wouldn't have worked as a lone parent. It allows me to do the school run a couple of days a week (my manager and her manager are totally fine with this) and walk my dog at lunchtime.
My employer has had a big shift towards a better work life balance since covid and lots of people are feeling the benefit. I'm actually less productive on my office days as we all tend to enjoy a blether too much.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 30/09/2023 15:45

*Because people take the piss and aren't productive at work when at home.
They still have to heat the buildings whether it's 3 or 35 people in.

Its not the company's problem you applied for a job miles and miles away from home and choose to eat lunch out...*

The evidence does not bear this out. People are able to be perfectly productive at home and you dont waste as much time over coffee etc like in offices.

Badbadbunny · 30/09/2023 15:44

Ginmonkeyagain · 30/09/2023 10:36

It's not great conspiracy, a lot of workplaces simply prefer their staff it do some of their work face to face.

I suspect that part of it is the first cohort of post covid graduates and apprentices have passed through the system and results are ..... not great.

A lot of early careers staff struggle to develop the required soft skills when a lot of senior staff are WFH.

I agree about the point re graduates. WFH is fine for people who are settled, experienced, etc., but new starters, trainees, etc really struggle without having people around them to train/support them. Having to email/team call constantly is not alternative to real face to face support.

OhmygodDont · 30/09/2023 15:23

My employer wants more work from home.

Sounds more like a staff issue than company shit staff wasting time and taking the piss means offices want staff in.

WrongSwanson · 30/09/2023 15:13

Avenueofcherryblossom · 30/09/2023 15:10

What can I say WrongSwanson? You’re obviously a super woman managing 12 hour work days 5 days a week and fitting child care, self care and ‘heaps of other responsibilities & interests’ on top of managing a complex health condition.

What can I say. I don't like watching TV and I do a lot of my hours when the children are in bed. So yeah, I cram in a lot.

The key is outsourcing the housework and having a husband that does 50%.

I think plenty of people manage the same juggle as me, I don't think it's that exceptional

Avenueofcherryblossom · 30/09/2023 15:10

What can I say WrongSwanson? You’re obviously a super woman managing 12 hour work days 5 days a week and fitting child care, self care and ‘heaps of other responsibilities & interests’ on top of managing a complex health condition.

WrongSwanson · 30/09/2023 14:05

Avenueofcherryblossom · 30/09/2023 13:41

And it's part of the reason why I shot up the career ladder. I wasnt being a martyr

It’s a real shame that doing 10 - 20 hours a week unpaid overtime is the way to make career progression.

There must be so many talented people with interests or responsibilities outside of work who are overlooked for promotion on this basis.

I have heaps of interests and responsibilities outside of work. And a complex health condition.

I do outsource housework though and have a husband who does half the childcare

TheBeef · 30/09/2023 13:51

People are productive WFH. The same people arsing about in the office, will arse about at home too.

Public transport is not up to the task. My pre-covid commute was 90 mins each way. It took me 2.5 hours to get into work one day last week. Two buses didn't arrive and there were delays on the train. My wah day is usually at least 9 hours. I did 7 in the office and was out of the house for 13.5 hours.

I used to buy sandwiches and drinks from nearby shops. I take everything with me now.

OnAFrolicOfMyOwn · 30/09/2023 13:44

There must be so many talented people with interests or responsibilities outside of work who are overlooked for promotion on this basis.

That's their choice!

AfraidToRun · 30/09/2023 13:42

I Work in a "team" but because of WFH training is dire and as more experienced colleague more work falls on me and our service is declining as a result. And if I hear one more person say "oh I don't know if I can get doggy daycare" I will scream!

Avenueofcherryblossom · 30/09/2023 13:41

And it's part of the reason why I shot up the career ladder. I wasnt being a martyr

It’s a real shame that doing 10 - 20 hours a week unpaid overtime is the way to make career progression.

There must be so many talented people with interests or responsibilities outside of work who are overlooked for promotion on this basis.

Boysnme · 30/09/2023 13:28

Outwiththenorm · 30/09/2023 10:28

It’s panicking managers having to justify their relevance.

I doubt there are that many mangers who would have the influence to make that decision. Most will be told and are just pushing it down the way.

PikachuChickenRice · 30/09/2023 13:15

MonkeyChiselTree · 30/09/2023 13:04

So you've never had a non work chat with a colleague whilst making a hot drink/getting some water? You've never sat at your desk having a non work related conversation with anyone, beit a phone call to book a dentist appointment, talk to a workman about a job they need to do in your home or a conversation with a colleague about last night's telly?

No one who works in an office every day spends every minute productively working. No one who works from home spends every minute taking in parcels and doing the washing.

But it is disingenuous to say being in the office per se increases productively. In my case it doesn't because my team (recruited both pre and post Covid) work in other parts of the UK.

My immediate team is also scattered - not just around the UK, but across the globe. We sit with a wider UK team in the office though.
Conversations with colleagues about unrelated things builds relationship and usually we end up talking about work anyway. My (and my boss') ability to keep our fingers on the pulse and get a general sense of things happening across the org is a major contributor to keeping our team employed... and identifying new opportunities. For example, we heard rumours that a new technology was going to be brought in, offered to help test and are now known as the SME's.. which means more visibility for our team and more high profile projects.

That aside taking a parcel etc is fine it's just rude to do it during a call! Using your examples would be calling the dentist, workman etc in the middle of a F2F conversation?

Phos · 30/09/2023 13:11

Although I’m for the RTO, I don’t mind people answering the door for a parcel. It’s not different from pre pandemic sometimes people would ask to WFH on one specific day as they were expecting a delivery. It’s a much shorter interruption than Pamela coming over to show your her new nails/holiday photos/moan about her stakeholders.