Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is my MIL rude with her food serving habit?

292 replies

Kindlemagic · 30/09/2023 10:10

Ok I’ll be honest I don’t like my MIL for so many reasons. However I do my best to be warm and kind when we see them. It’s a long drive to get to them (around 7 hours) which is hard with little ones and always stressful and exhausting. Invariably due to the length of the drive we turn up around dinner time or just before and we are always informed beforehand that they’ll organise dinner for all of us - which is obviously welcome and appreciated. Almost always we find that they have eaten before we have arrived and we get served heated up leftovers. This even happened one Christmas when we left very early in the morning to make Christmas lunch - raced to get there and found they had decided to just go ahead and eat Christmas dinner 25 mins before we arrived (despite us keeping them updated on our journey as to the time we would be arriving). Last time we arrived at 5pm thinking surely we had got there in time, but no, they ate at 4.30 so we ate dinner on our own just after 5pm, picked through the cold leftovers, and they wandered off to serve themselves pudding separately. I was so annoyed I couldn’t help myself asking why they ate so early and why they hadn’t waited on us and was informed they made a point of eating particularly early and before we arrived as they thought it was best if the dinner table wasn’t so crowded. Am I being unreasonable in thinking this is really weird and the height of rudeness? Whenever they come to us we ensure we sit down together to eat together and the meal is served hot to everyone.

OP posts:
10HailMarys · 30/09/2023 11:21

It is definitely rude.

Maybe not deliberately so - perhaps your PILs are just utterly ignorant of basic manners - but it certainly rude. The Christmas example in particular is just insane.

MyCircumference · 30/09/2023 11:20

order a pizza delivery when you get there

Kindlemagic · 30/09/2023 11:19

Parentalalienation · 30/09/2023 10:56

It's a way of protesting that they aren't happy that you live so far away. I'd be spending Christmas at home and going to see them at a different time of year.
When we were taken to see grandparents, all I really remember is hours in the car and then comments from grandparents about 'well if you hadn't moved so far away...'. Meals were always a ham salad with eggs 'because we didn't know what time you would be getting here.' Even when we had gone early and were there for lunch and dinner, it was two cold meals. Almost as though they didn't want to make the effort for their adult children who had dared to move away.
I wouldn't want your children's memories of going to see grandparents being like mine. Especially as your husband's relationship with them is 'tortured'. Put your family first.

I think this is exactly right. I hadn’t thought about it this way but yes, it is exactly this. We do get a LOT of comments and pressure about how far away we live. The issues between my MIL and DH are all based on this.

OP posts:
Tryingmybestadhd · 30/09/2023 11:19

Are they one of those grandparents who actually don’t like spending time with the grandchild? Maybe they don’t like children at the table? Either way in my opinion it’s as rude as it gets and I would be upset over this . I would stop updating them on when you are going to arrive or lie qnd say an hour after qnd then surprise them or better stop going to eat with them all together

TiredMamOfTwo · 30/09/2023 11:18

Very rude, I'd tell them they need to travel to you and that 7 hours in a car is to much for the little ones.

Kindlemagic · 30/09/2023 11:17

lottiegarbanzo · 30/09/2023 11:10

Sounds like they're trying to be accommodating and helpful, in their own way. Just that their way is different from yours.

Also that they may not enjoy eating at a table with very young children. Few people do. It isn't an enjoyable family dining experience anyway, as all attention is so often on the LOs that adults can't converse anyhow.

Christmas Dinner is odd, as even families who never eat together do so then - unless there's more you're not telling us; like they'd invited you for a particular time when dinner would be served and you were late. (Your 'racing to get there' and 'updates' do imply this).

The 'mirror' post from your MIL, about how she'd planned Christmas Dinner so carefully, invited people for the right time but her son's family turned up late - after bombarding her with messages just as she was trying to manage the final stages of preparing multiple dishes at once - forcing her to choose between serving dinner while the food was 'right' and waiting half an hour while it wilted and cooled, would gain a LOT of sympathy here. (More so if she was a DIL rather than a MIL of course).

Just imagine that post... what utter inconsiderate bastards the PIL would be portrayed as, for turning up late and ruining the DIL's carefully planned Christmas Dinner.

No it really wasn’t like this - family meals aren’t really a thing for them. They knew when we left the house and when we would arrive and my MIL is not precious about her food in the slightest. There was no censure on us when we arrived and no suggestion we were late - it was, if anything, just thoughtless. As if it really didn’t matter that we were coming at all.

OP posts:
MyCircumference · 30/09/2023 11:17

is there no space at the table?
are they embarrassed?

MyCircumference · 30/09/2023 11:15

very inhospitable
can you lie and say you will be there later and catch them out!

PurpleWisteria1 · 30/09/2023 11:15

They don’t like eating with you OP. It’s as simple as that. They would rather not. Yes it’s rude.
I suspect it’s the kids and the noise and everything that goes with young kids.
As we age many people (not all before I get jumped on) can’t tolerate loud noise. Life slows down and is quiet, so young kids just seem too frantic / hectic.
When I was a child, me and my siblings had to sit in a completely different room to eat, away from my grandparents who sat in the main dining room with the other adults.
They prioritised eating in peace to having the grandkids up at the table.

Anewest · 30/09/2023 11:15

lottiegarbanzo · 30/09/2023 11:10

Sounds like they're trying to be accommodating and helpful, in their own way. Just that their way is different from yours.

Also that they may not enjoy eating at a table with very young children. Few people do. It isn't an enjoyable family dining experience anyway, as all attention is so often on the LOs that adults can't converse anyhow.

Christmas Dinner is odd, as even families who never eat together do so then - unless there's more you're not telling us; like they'd invited you for a particular time when dinner would be served and you were late. (Your 'racing to get there' and 'updates' do imply this).

The 'mirror' post from your MIL, about how she'd planned Christmas Dinner so carefully, invited people for the right time but her son's family turned up late - after bombarding her with messages just as she was trying to manage the final stages of preparing multiple dishes at once - forcing her to choose between serving dinner while the food was 'right' and waiting half an hour while it wilted and cooled, would gain a LOT of sympathy here. (More so if she was a DIL rather than a MIL of course).

Just imagine that post... what utter inconsiderate bastards the PIL would be portrayed as, for turning up late and ruining the DIL's carefully planned Christmas Dinner.

Although OP hasn't said if they were late, it sounds like what happened was OP tried to keep them updated as to their arrival time due to not being given a specific time. I imagine that whatever happened, the PIL would have made sure to eat prior to their arrival anyway since it sounds like the updates were a desperate attempt to avoid yet more cold leftovers.

There are a lot of posts saying maybe the PIL don't want to eat with young kids, but I can't help but wonder - what's stopping them using their words and saying this?

DisquietintheRanks · 30/09/2023 11:14

I think it's odd and yes, rude but it doesn't sound as though they intend to be. What happens for the rest of your visit - do you continue to eat separately?

It sounds very much as though this is about their issues and not personal to you (though I appreciate that might be cold comfort).

Ketty72 · 30/09/2023 11:13

I would find that quite odd (and a bit rude - especially the Christmas one!) too.

Assuming they are fit and well enough to travel to you I would let their 'don't like to be away from home' fall on deaf ears. It is their turn to visit you next (where you can make a point of eating a lovely hot dinner all together when they arrive).

I would completely stop mentioning them at all to your DH. When he next suggests going to see them say 'no, it's their turn to come here' 'that's fine if you want to go up but I'll wait until they come here to see them next'. When/if it is your turn to go up to them decline their offer of dinner and stop off and have something on the way instead. Don't engage with much discussion about it at all and just be matter of fact about your boundaries and preferences.

inamarina · 30/09/2023 11:13

Mintearo7 · 30/09/2023 10:25

People on here are a bit OTT, it’s her in laws and yes this is rude in some eyes but wouldn’t say you should stop going. Are they just regimented in terms of not snacking then got really hungry waiting? Or they can’t time the cooking properly but want to eat as soon as it’s done? Tbh, my in laws do the same. We don’t see them that often as they live 5 hours away but they almost always eat separately to us. But FIL has health condition that restricts his eating times. . Anyway, I wouldn’t waste your time getting annoyed at it.

I agree.
It could be for a number of reasons that they chose to eat earlier. Maybe they‘re hungry, maybe they don’t enjoy eating at a crowded table.
OP, you say you don’t like your MIL for various reasons - maybe she senses that and is trying to stay out of your way? Tbh, I wouldn’t insist on eating together with someone I don’t like/ feel uncomfortable around.
The Christmas lunch situation was weird though, they definitely should have waited on that occasion.

ErinAoife · 30/09/2023 11:12

My ex sil is like that she will invite you for dinner but she will always have her dinner before our arrival. She won't sit at the table with us. Very weird

lottiegarbanzo · 30/09/2023 11:10

Sounds like they're trying to be accommodating and helpful, in their own way. Just that their way is different from yours.

Also that they may not enjoy eating at a table with very young children. Few people do. It isn't an enjoyable family dining experience anyway, as all attention is so often on the LOs that adults can't converse anyhow.

Christmas Dinner is odd, as even families who never eat together do so then - unless there's more you're not telling us; like they'd invited you for a particular time when dinner would be served and you were late. (Your 'racing to get there' and 'updates' do imply this).

The 'mirror' post from your MIL, about how she'd planned Christmas Dinner so carefully, invited people for the right time but her son's family turned up late - after bombarding her with messages just as she was trying to manage the final stages of preparing multiple dishes at once - forcing her to choose between serving dinner while the food was 'right' and waiting half an hour while it wilted and cooled, would gain a LOT of sympathy here. (More so if she was a DIL rather than a MIL of course).

Just imagine that post... what utter inconsiderate bastards the PIL would be portrayed as, for turning up late and ruining the DIL's carefully planned Christmas Dinner.

Kindlemagic · 30/09/2023 11:10

Yes this is it exactly. Gosh. Nail on the head

OP posts:
itsalongwaybackfromsorry · 30/09/2023 11:10

I wouldn't be busting my arse to get up there for any holiday meals going forward as they clearly don't want to share them with your family. Their actions speak volumes.

Save your important holidays for people who treat you like you're loved and wanted there.

Anewest · 30/09/2023 11:10

I would stop making an effort to be "warm and kind", especially if MIL creates other issues on top of this.
I honestly think that if 2 adults need to be told this sort of behaviour is rude, then it isn't worth having to spell it out as it'll likely keep happening. It's clearly unkind to feed visitors, especially little children, cold leftovers after they travelled hours to see you and gave you updates as to their whereabouts. Very spiteful IMO.

Dillane · 30/09/2023 11:09

Hardly ‘the height of rudeness’ OP, get a grip 🙄

TigerJoy · 30/09/2023 11:09

You say DH won't hear a bad word against them but also it's a tortuous relationship.

Can you have a non-confrontational talk with him some time about this? Say that you find it confusing that they always eat before you. Is there a way he could talk to his parents and find out what's going on?

You could frame it as concern - as they always eat before you, are you inconveniencing them? Would it be better for you all to stop on the way there and eat before arrival? Or offer as others have suggested to have a shop delivered that you can have a simple meal from e.g. fresh pasta and sauce, oven pizza, roasted chicken, bread and salad etc.

HowIsItSeptemberAlready · 30/09/2023 11:09

What happens about other mealtimes while you're there? Do they also eat separately from you then, as this dining room table is apparently so small?

CurlewKate · 30/09/2023 11:07

Yes. But why is your FIL not rude too?

JustAMinutePleass · 30/09/2023 11:06

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn due to privacy concerns.

This is my sister in law. She gave me lectures on how to cook, viewed herself as some kind of masterchef, and not only does she cooks things that look and small like a blocked toilet she also can’t get the portions right. At least I can cook for 10/20/30 people with my simple foods.

LookItsMeAgain · 30/09/2023 11:06

Kindlemagic · 30/09/2023 10:53

I didn’t say but should have done - after the last awful Christmas we had with them we don’t go to them for Christmas any more and haven’t been for a few years now. I figured out pretty quickly that it was destroying our own christmases to do so. So this is now more about when we go to them outside of Christmas. I should also add that they don’t really have friends and never entertain outside of family. My DH, despite having issues with them, won’t hear a bad word said about them so I do have to be careful with what I say.

You see, I don't get the mentality where a DH in a situation like this will not hear anything that reflects badly on their parents. The parents though, don't have any issues behaving like this and getting their children and grandchildren to travel 7 hrs and feed them cold leftovers on Christmas day (which is ALL about families). That just doesn't work in my head.

Is there a way that you could describe a similar situation but make it about some friends and their inlaws and get DH to give his advice on the situation. See if he'd offer anything as a solution. See if you could then explain that his parents are doing similar to him and you and your kids.

I am pleased to learn that you're not travelling to them for Christmas any more. I'm sure your kids prefer having Christmas in their own home too.

UnbeatenMum · 30/09/2023 11:06

It sounds like either they think they're being considerate, or one or both of them finds a crowded/noisy dinner table difficult for whatever reason. With your update about them not liking to travel and not having friends I'm wondering if there's something else going on there rather than rudeness that means they're not conforming to social norms. My autistic child doesn't usually eat at the table with us for sensory reasons and doesn't always realise when people perceive her as rude.