Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it would actually be better for ds to be in nursery?

39 replies

tlja · 30/09/2023 08:29

Ds is 11 months. I didn’t plan to go back to work until he was 2.5 ish.

But… he is clearly bored with me! In the last month or so he needs to be out of the house or entertained in some way that doesn’t involve sitting him watching me cook or clean. Obviously I have to do these things so wonder if actually nursery would be better for him, at least some of the week? I end up feeling totally stretched getting through the day and entertaining him non stop or dealing with crying when I’m simply trying to put a wash on!

AIBU to think nursery would actually be good for him? (I’m aware it would probably be good for me 😂 but I’m specifically asking for him..)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BertieBotts · 30/09/2023 11:47

I find playgroups quite stressful as parenting styles are so different and the kids can get mixed messages. Some ok to let their kids hit others and not be addressed, some micromanaging every move and over apologising for taking a toy and other totally normal things that kids do.

Surely, this is the same at nursery? The nursery staff/behaviour policy is never going to align 100% with your exact wishes and ideas as a parent. So kids get the same mixed messages that home and nursery have different rules, which I think is fine BTW - they seem to adapt to this just fine, the same as they do with seeing children being subject to different rulesets when out in public.

Gifgirl · 30/09/2023 09:20

Morning!

Nursery absolutely can be beneficial for both parent and child, and that's definitely an option. Lots to think about though.

However, nurseries are expensive; for the price of putting him in 2 days a week, you could hire a cleaner/housekeeper.

  • Mornings spent at playgroups/playground/library/swimming

  • Home for lunch

  • Nap

  • Play at home in the afternoon

If you hire a cleaner/housekeeper/Parents help 2 mornings a week, they can clean and do the washing while you are out. Then when baby is napping, you have time to refresh/do any jobs that you need to do.

Babyboomtastic · 30/09/2023 09:15

tlja · 30/09/2023 09:10

@Babyboomtastic we do, everyday, but there’s still periods of being in the house and it’s clear within 15 mins they’ve had enough 🤦‍♀️

Is it being in the house that he's objecting to, or you doing chores?

If it's the latter then frankly 15m is pretty good at this age. You may find it easier to go and out a wash on or something with a 5 minute interval, or leave it mostly to nap and evening (or when he's eating).

newhere24 · 30/09/2023 09:14

@tlja mine were the same, absolutely loved their childminder with other kids, a big garden and long walks every day (youngest walked really early). Not happy at home doing “pottering around” stuff. Still hate that, can entertain themselves in a field for hours though and no behavioural issues as long as they get enough exercise.

acquiescence · 30/09/2023 09:14

At this age I returned to work with all of my children, part time with one day at nursery and one half day when I was at home. I use this to do housework so that I can focus more on play and activities. It has done wonders for my mental health (Baby DS4 will be doing the same shortly) and has been great for their socialisation.

I find playgroups quite stressful as parenting styles are so different and the kids can get mixed messages. Some ok to let their kids hit others and not be addressed, some micromanaging every move and over apologising for taking a toy and other totally normal things that kids do.

If you have the money for a few days nursery when you’re not working then another option could be a cleaner for a fair few hours per week instead. Cooking and laundry doesn’t take too much time with just one child.

JC89 · 30/09/2023 09:12

Mine went to nursery at 1 year for a couple of days a week, had a day with DH, a day with me and a day with grandparents. I think the mixture was good for him - different people tended to do different things with him! He wouldn't play with other children that young but did like watching them, and watching older kids too. So yes I think it can be good for them and gives you a break so you have more energy for them when they are with you (which is also good for them). You might be able to do a couple of half days if it just for a break/getting all the jobs done.

Lana12345 · 30/09/2023 09:11

Also I forgot to add my main point. YANBU. I think you should just do what works for you.

occasionally I have the day of work and I still put LO to nursery because it’s already paid for anyway, he loves it so much, and then I have a little break myself!

newhere24 · 30/09/2023 09:11

@KateyCuckoo he’s 11 months, well on his way to be a toddler! Other kids are fascinating at that age, and they entertain each other just by existing. Kids are mobile at 11 months, and insatiably curious. For a high energy child, other kids and space are essential at this age, just like a mellow child would still be happy at home. There is no one size fits all for children

Jk987 · 30/09/2023 09:11

If you've got the choice, I'd go back to work for 3 days and put him in nursery. You still get 4 days quality time with him and you'll enjoy it as life will be more balanced.

tlja · 30/09/2023 09:10

@Babyboomtastic we do, everyday, but there’s still periods of being in the house and it’s clear within 15 mins they’ve had enough 🤦‍♀️

OP posts:
Babyboomtastic · 30/09/2023 09:09

No, I don't think he'd be better off in nursery. This is very much an age where you need to be out and about with them a lot, and then just slot housework into any free moments, rather than it being the priority.

They aren't like a tiny baby where they will sit and watch you, you need to go and do things with them, go out places etc.

Ange1233556 · 30/09/2023 09:06

So many judgy posts on here that YOU should be doing more!! All my 3 kids started nursery when they were 1 for couple of days a week. They bloody love it. They do stuff at nursery that I wouldn’t think to do with them and love socialising with other children and honestly I love having bit of time to myself to get the boring jobs done so when I am with them we are doing fun stuff. Do what is right for you!

PS from experience those starting nursery at 2.5 struggle to settle so much more than those who started earlier. I’m biased as our nursery is absolutely amazing!

Thanksforreading · 30/09/2023 09:05

Hey! If your little one is high energy and at 11 months is moving around already, two half days at nursery would be great for you and him. It’s obviously playing on your mind atm, so why not try it. I do have to say depending on where you are there can be a waiting list, so if you are thinking of it, why not visit a few around your area and pop him onto a waiting list if there is one. I mean sometimes you can visit the nursery and decide it might not be for you and him. We took little one in for a viewing at 9months old, and decided it wasn’t time yet and back at 12months and I was all for it then.
Establishing some sort of routine with him would be great for you and him. There are a lot of classes or free playgroups around, calling up your children centre and asking for a timetable you can see everything available in that centre. If not there’s always farm, swimming, music classes, baby massages around too.
i personally can’t stay at home for more than a day, so from six weeks old my DD has always had a routine, but it was more for my mental health than her At that point, but from around ten months on (she’s two now) the sing and sign really paid off as she could tell me when she was tired, wants milk or snacks.
But like I said if nursery is playing on your mind, go for a couple of visits to a few different nurseries, and it will become more clear with what you would like for your son.

Khvdrt · 30/09/2023 09:04

I would try to fill your week up with groups and classes then that’s the morning filled up, home for a sleep and some afternoon things at home or see people or go out doing whatever else you need to do.

Parker231 · 30/09/2023 09:03

Nurseries are brilliant. DT’s went full time from six months old as I wanted to return to my career. Nurseries are interesting to babies and toddlers - lots of different activities and other children. Opportunities to do messy play which I hated.

PerfectMatch · 30/09/2023 09:03

How much time are you spending cooking and cleaning? Of course some chores need to be done, but your main focus during the day should be your DS, whether you're taking him out or playing with him at home. I don't think your DS "needs" nursery but I do think it's absolutely fine for you to go down that route if you're finding it hard to juggle everything. Could you consider getting a cleaner for a couple of hours a week? That would be cheaper than nursery fees, and have the same effect of you being able to spend more time with DS.

InTheRainOnATrain · 30/09/2023 09:01

At his age it’s purely for your benefit not his. He’ll get very little out of before the age of 2 but if you feel like you’d be a better parent for having a break 2 mornings a week then no judgement, go ahead and do it. However, if it’s just about the housework then get a cleaner once a week. It’ll be cheaper and you can use the time you get back to take him out to groups, playgrounds etc.

Halfemptyhalfling · 30/09/2023 09:01

The nursery had the option of 9 until 3ish rather than 9 until 5:30.

Lana12345 · 30/09/2023 09:00

My toddler likes to follow the hoover around lol. And thinks he’s helping with laundry (he’s really undoing the help lol). Chores sometimes take longer when he’s around but that’s ok because he’s showing interest. Sometimes he gets bored and cranky when I’m doing chores. That’s also ok because they need done. I also take him to groups and days out etc. get creative with him etc. always let him join in and help if he wants - one day he will be good at it haha.

soemtines he is good at entertaining himself when o do chores. He gets impatient while I’m prepping dinner :/
he goes to nursery when I work which I admit was only because I went back to work and we had no other options but he has benefited from it so much and it’s such a wonderful nursery. He gets so excited going in. He also gets so excited to see me at the end of the day. He just loves everything. The days I don’t work I take him swimming, library, galleries, parks, music class, play dates, garden, art etc etc.

but Now that he has been going to nursery a few months and loves it and gets so much from I’d probably still send him a couple days even if I didn’t need anymore.

EpitomeofEpiphany · 30/09/2023 08:59

I think it helps them socially and gives them some structure and routine. They do so many activities that I couldn't possibly do aswell as all the cleaning, cooking etc.

KateyCuckoo · 30/09/2023 08:59

newhere24 · 30/09/2023 08:51

@dearcleo @KateyCuckoo there is a world of a difference between a child alone inside, and a group of children together, in a spacious environment. leaving a high energy child at home with only an adult is damaging for these children. having them in a group with other kids and plenty of space to create their own fun is very different.

He is a baby! Babies don't need other children to play with. They need adult company, stimulation, guidance, care and love. Childcare is useful and necessary when a primary caregiver needs to work or is otherwise not able to care for the baby but ultimately being at home with a parent learning about the world, self regulation etc. is perfect.

BertieBotts · 30/09/2023 08:59

If you'd prefer to put him into nursery then do that, there's nothing wrong with nursery.

But you can get the same things that you describe at home, which suits some people better.

I tend to try and think of the day in "blocks", so roughly there's something outside of the house, some tasks I'm doing at home with DC self occupying, some time I'm spending doing an activity with them and some downtime for us both (TV basically).

That sounds like a lot but the proportions vary, so going out might be a walk around the block, play at the local park while I listen to a podcast, we might go into town and do some errands or it might be a whole activity that lasts a couple of hours.

Likewise doing some tasks might just be putting some washing on or I might (rarely) do something like a decluttering project.

And doing stuff with them could be playing Lego together for a while, or reading together or doing some colouring or showing them a new toy. It could be 15 mins or an hour. Just depends on what else is going on that day.

What I do think really really helps is having other mum contacts locally so you can meet up at each others houses rather than constantly paying for activities. You make friends and build a support network this way too.

tlja · 30/09/2023 08:57

@Halfemptyhalfling what is a short day? I haven’t looked into it yet.

OP posts:
Halfemptyhalfling · 30/09/2023 08:56

My DC were ready for 2 short days at nursery once they were walking at about the age of 12 months. It helped alot with social skills. If I'd had a whirlwind social life with lots of contact with small kids then would be less benefit

tlja · 30/09/2023 08:55

@MarySmit I was genuinely wondering if nursery would be better for him for part of the week so I have more time to focus on him when we are together.

OP posts: