Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Temperature not freaking everyone out?

312 replies

JKDcot · 30/09/2023 07:34

Meant to be 23/24 degrees in London next week? Not usual for early October… anyone else think it’s bonkers that climate change so obvious and still nothing being done my government and corporates

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
Fallenangelofthenorth · 01/10/2023 15:54

I think it's reasonable to ask questions given the nett zero targets that will affect us all. I'm happy to listen to all voices on this subject. And even happier to waste my Sunday afternoon eating a giant galaxy laying on my sofa.

Andnowtowhatcomesnext · 01/10/2023 15:51

Curry has become known for hosting a blog which is part of the climate change denial blogosphere, despite having published research confirming anthropogenic effects on climate.[3]

Blogosphere - Wikipedia

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blogosphere

Andnowtowhatcomesnext · 01/10/2023 15:48

Interests

Andnowtowhatcomesnext · 01/10/2023 15:48

Just like anyone suggesting UPF isn’t bad for us seems to be linked to producers of said products, do too do climate change deniers seem to always be linked somehow to the oil industry. Oil industry has spent millions on undermining the science.

Im going to believe the scientific consensus, rather than a random on a forum and a couple of outliers in the scientific community who have dubious credentials and links to the industries with the most to lose if we reduce fossil fuel consumption. These people don’t have our best I tetsts at heart.

Andnowtowhatcomesnext · 01/10/2023 15:45

Mark Mills is associated with the Manhattan Institute, a free-market think tank with a long history of rejecting any government involvement in markets. This has left the group with a reflexive loathing of any attempts to address global warming.

Bogwood · 01/10/2023 14:21

@Fallenangelofthenorth How refreshing to have an open minded response! I come from an environmentalist background (before 'green' was fashionable). I had major questions about aspects of the science and the feedback loops when I was at university back in the early 1990s. I remain an absolutely passionate environmentalist - but I think the anthropogenic global warming agenda is controlling the green narrative to an unhelpful degree. Take the quest for 'net zero' - it simply cannot happen on the current trajectory - given issues such as the inadequate electricity distribution infrastructure for low density renewable energy production. Another major obstacle will be the lack of supply of raw materials such as copper, graphite, lithium, cobalt and rare earth metals. These are simply not being mined (and there are not the plans to mine them) in the necessary quantities to meet stated ambitions for electric vehicles and their associated batteries. Where they are being mined and processed, there is a great risk of environmental damage and poor labour conditions (most of the mining takes place in Africa and Asia - most of the refining in China). Ironically, EVs are not 'carbon neutral' when the carbon footprint of their production is taken into account - indeed, some larger vehicles may actually never 'pay back' their carbon footprint. So, even if you buy into the current climate alarmist narrative, the goals of 'net zero' simply cannot be fulfilled by the stated policy aims - we will just impoverish ourselves in our panic (and make society less resilient to the sort of extreme weather events that always have and will continue to be an issue!).
WIth respect to the unintelligent way that society is pursuing 'net zero', Mark P. Mills has carried out a great deal of detailed work, scrutinising how realistic such policies are - for example, he examines the shortcomings of the ostensible energy transition in this interview...

Mark Mills on The Energy Transition Delusion

Mark Mills on "The Energy Transition Delusion". Mark P. Mills is a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute and a faculty fellow at Northwestern University’s...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q7Gi0vObVSo

Fallenangelofthenorth · 01/10/2023 11:53

@Bogwood I'm interested in your posts. I'm going to listen to the interviews you linked as really can't find the motivation for cleaning and I feel this would be a better use of my time.

Bogwood · 01/10/2023 11:18

MedSchoolRat · 01/10/2023 10:18

In the covid pandemic we had a lot of eminent accomplished scientists (and data analysts) stepping out of their lane, billing themselves as experts in another science area, and then coming up with crazy conclusions about epidemic control because they completely didn't understand infectious disease epidemiology at all.

Would you trust your car mechanic to do orthopaedic surgery? They are both disciplines that require great expertise on mechanical repair. How different could they be? Is how they operate.

Is how I look at people like Koonin (and plenty others).

I am afraid that you cannot view climate as a standalone discipline in the same way - it is simply far too complex. Understanding the climate requires a multidisciplinary approach that incorporates physics, astrophysics, chemistry, biology, geology and importantly computer science (projections are completely dependent on hugely inadequate computer modelling). Koonin is definitely worth listening to as a scientist who has spent a lot of time getting to grips with the published material that feeds into the IPCC material - probably very few individual climate scientists have this level of understanding...the scientific research is necessarily atomised - dealing with a huge number of individual areas that connect to the overall oceanic-atmospheric system (which in turn is not a closed system, but rather operates within and interacts with the wider solar/cosmic environment).
Dr Judith Curry is a climate scientist and provides a good overview of these complexities....and the lack of meaningful consensus in the principal areas of scientific understanding. She has given plenty of detailed online interviews (eg ) - some more detailed than others. It is probably best, if you are genuinely interested in gaining a level of knowledge (beyond the inaccurate, simplistic screaming climate emergency headlines) to read her recent publication - it is excellent - called 'Climate Uncertainty and Risk' - published this year.

Judith Curry Part 1: Presentation about her new book | Tom Nelson Podcast #77

Dr. Judith Curry is President and co-founder of CFAN. Following an influential career in academic research and administration, Curry founded CFAN to support...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pQvo0Id_4Tw

MedSchoolRat · 01/10/2023 10:18

In the covid pandemic we had a lot of eminent accomplished scientists (and data analysts) stepping out of their lane, billing themselves as experts in another science area, and then coming up with crazy conclusions about epidemic control because they completely didn't understand infectious disease epidemiology at all.

Would you trust your car mechanic to do orthopaedic surgery? They are both disciplines that require great expertise on mechanical repair. How different could they be? Is how they operate.

Is how I look at people like Koonin (and plenty others).

Bogwood · 01/10/2023 09:16

Andnowtowhatcomesnext · 01/10/2023 08:50

Bogwood

A quick check of Koonin. He’s not a climate expert, was employed by (and may still earn money from) the oil industry. See quote below for one extract from Wikipedia;

“Critics of Koonin's book Unsettled accused him of cherry picking data, muddying the waters surrounding the science of climate change, and having no experience in climate science.”

There is an overwhelming majority of actual climate experts and so much data that shows, beyond a doubt, the the rapid and extreme climate change we are experiencing is caused by our actions. Using h many different models and based on the work of hundreds of scientist over decades, we know this. We ignore them at our own peril.

Quick checks are really not the way to do due diligence! Define a climate scientist! Koonin's scientific credentials are fantastic! Steve Koonin served as Undersecretary for Science in the US Department of Energy under the Obama administration. He has more than 200 peer-reviewed papers in the fields of physics and astrophysics, scientific computation, energy technology & policy and climate science. He was the professor of theoretical physics at Caltech, where he was also vice president. He is currently a professor at New York University. He clearly ticks the boxes of eminent scientist and academic - he does not dispute the underlying physics of anthropogenic global warming (most climate sceptics don't) - however, he does dispute the way that the science that feeds into the IPCC reports is subsequently misrepresented by mainstream media and politicians. He disputes that we are in a climate emergency - he sees a huge disparity between the actual data and the way that the data is misrepresented in subsequent summary documents and media headlines (I have read his book, and most of the material is drawn directly from IPCC published material - https://www.amazon.co.uk/Unsettled-Climate-Science-Doesnt-Matters/dp/B0948CBSY6/ref=sr_1_1?keywords=unsettled&qid=1690956367&sr=8-1
The negative review that you reference has been thoroughly debunked - yet it strangely still appears at the top of the Google searches on Koonin! You clearly haven't even had time to watch the video I posted. I have taken the time to read his recent book - he takes all of his evidence directly from the 'settled science' of IPCC data.

As for the negative criticism of his book, he challenges one of the listed authors (Andrew Dessler) directly at the end of a recorded debate with him -  - this fellow academic initially denies having contributed to the piece that was published in Scientific American, until he is shown a slide with his name on it as a contributing author! Koonin is clearly, and understandably, very angry - he says:
"Inexplicably, the criticisms were based upon a review of the book, not what I’d actually written. They criticised 3 points I was alleged to have made. For example, they said I portrayed sea level rises as steady over time, when the entirety of ‘Unsettled;’ Chapter 8, if you've read it, is devoted to variations over the past century. Since Scientific American refused to publish a detailed rebuttal, I posted one on my 'Medium' page and it is worth checking out. But the great bulk of the 1000 words from those dozen ‘distinguished’ scientists were devoted to ad hominem attacks - for example, I was called a crank who is taken seriously only by far right disinformation peddlers, hungry for anything they can use to score some political points…really, Andy…you really think I am a crank, you really believe that? It is unfortunately typical of public discussions of climate and energy, when senior academics engage in name-calling they debase themselves and deny the public any real expertise that they have. It is the kind of thing people do when the facts aren't on their side…”
And that conveys a microcosm of the reality of what has been happening with the manipulation of the scientific debate - despite that negative review being challenged and clearly discredited by Koonin, it remains very easy for the public to find (as you did), who then take it at face value, believing it to be a credible source - unlikely to scratch beneath the surface!

Anyway, as Koonin explains in another interview, he is aware of the individual scientific criticisms and believes that he has effectively countered each of them - he has his own webpage called 'Medium', which I eventually managed to find, where he does publish rebuttals of criticisms, including the Scientific American one - https://steven-koonin.medium.com/  It is notable that when you Google 'Steven Koonin', the top result is that Scientific American negative review...but you have to hunt hard to find Steven Koonin actual page, in which he clearly discredits the Scientific American piece...funny that, almost as though Google is deliberately manipulating the information that you get to read!

Steven Koonin – Medium

Read writing from Steven Koonin on Medium. Every day, Steven Koonin and thousands of other voices read, write, and share important stories on Medium.

https://steven-koonin.medium.com/

Andnowtowhatcomesnext · 01/10/2023 09:05

itsmyp4rty

Why compare us to China? Why not compare us to the hundreds of countries with much lower emissions that are getting the first and worst effects of climate change. Pakistan as one example.

And, If we are setting out to compare ourselves to China, and take their lead, then why just in this respect? Let’s lower our human rights. Let’s treat our workers worse than we do. Why are we not looking to them for our lead in those areas? It shouldn’t be a race to the bottom if we have any self respect as a nation. we should aim high.

China are also investing heavily in renewables and we are falling behind in that race where we could be global leaders. Its a massive and growing industry.

Saying ‘what about’ is illogical. ‘ Bert down the road beats his wife with a massive stick and I only beat mine with a wooden spoon. Why should I stop, when he’s still doing that?’ Answer: because what you are doing is wrong. - We should do the right thing, even when it’s hard. Climate chaos will disproportionately affect brown skinned people, already living in comparative poverty. By saying we don’t need to do anything because we only contribute x amount to the problem is akin to several people stabbing someone to death, and one of the defendants saying ‘but they all used massive knives, I only used this pen knife’. Doesn’t make sense.

We are contributing to the problem. We have the means to stop contributing to the problem. And that’s the right (but harder) thing to do.

Many of us could make massive reductions in our personal carbon footprint. All of us can write to our MPs and sign petitions. Lots of us can get out there and protest. There is stuff we can do.

The UK will be effected dramatically too, so it’s in our best interests. It’s way past the time for debate.

Andnowtowhatcomesnext · 01/10/2023 08:50

Bogwood

A quick check of Koonin. He’s not a climate expert, was employed by (and may still earn money from) the oil industry. See quote below for one extract from Wikipedia;

“Critics of Koonin's book Unsettled accused him of cherry picking data, muddying the waters surrounding the science of climate change, and having no experience in climate science.”

There is an overwhelming majority of actual climate experts and so much data that shows, beyond a doubt, the the rapid and extreme climate change we are experiencing is caused by our actions. Using h many different models and based on the work of hundreds of scientist over decades, we know this. We ignore them at our own peril.

Scientific consensus on climate change - Wikipedia

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_consensus_on_climate_change

TheThingIsYeah · 01/10/2023 08:40

Echobelly · 30/09/2023 14:16

I'm surprised at how many people are being blasé about this weather. Yes, maybe you get the odd mild low 20s day in October but 5 days in London of 24-27 is rather different. And yes it's nice in itself, but it's also not a good sign.

For example, at this rate I'm thinking of giving up on summer holidays in Southern Europe in July/August as the heat is getting consistently unbearable. Imagine what it must be like for people who live there!

You say others have a blasé attitude to the weather and that you are thinking of not jetting off to Southern Europe for your summer hols. But will you really?

itsmyp4rty · 01/10/2023 08:24

Andnowtowhatcomesnext · 30/09/2023 14:15

One hot day in one place in the UK might not be something to panic about but it’s still yet another example of what is happening all across the world. It will still impact on biodiversity and put things out of kilter. I’ll get out and thoroughly enjoy the sunshine but I’d be stupid not to worry about climate breakdown.

Yet people are just accepting it like it’s inevitable. We all should be taking action. In whatever way we can. It’s just pure madness to roll our eyes and bemoan the ‘eco zealots’ or ‘net zero zealots’. We should be out in the streets in response to the stupidity of the current government allowing new oil to be extracted - and NO it won’t effected our energy hills. And NO it won’t help our economy. The oil will be sold on the open Market. The profits will go to a Norwegian company. We the tax payer will subsidise it heavily. It will create a few local jobs at best but will contribute to further destabilising the climate and sends a dangerous message to the world.

But it is inevitable. China has over 1000 coal powered power stations and are building more at a rate of knots. We wring our hand over using the 3 we have. As a country we could be completely carbon neutral and we'd still see climate change happening at a rate of knots.

China produces over 10 billion tonnes of CO2 a year, the UK is at around 300 million - not even in the top 10 of producers. China is not going to stop because the west says it's a problem, it is choosing to adapt to climate change rather than reduce green house gases.

Cabdiraxman · 01/10/2023 08:14

October London 2008, it was 30 plus degrees for 3 days.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 01/10/2023 08:07

12 years ago we had a U.K. holiday end of September and first week in October. It was 35 degrees some days. So this week doesn’t seem like anything special tbh.

Timeforchangeithink · 30/09/2023 17:37

13 and pissing down in Scotland- nae climate change here unless you count it not being windy........

ohsuzannah · 30/09/2023 16:40

The last time I was in London in October there was a heavy frost, it was freezing!
23 degrees is insane!

JKDcot · 30/09/2023 16:21

@tpxqi what a kind comment. Hope you are nicer to others than you are on here

OP posts:
UniversalAunt · 30/09/2023 14:37

Warm Octobers are not unusual.& the onset of seasonal leaf drop tantalises as the days may be balmy & warm but the rapidly shortening hours of daylight tip the balance.

In my adult years I have known settled snowfall in October in London, so there is distinct variation around the seasonal average.

Echobelly · 30/09/2023 14:16

I'm surprised at how many people are being blasé about this weather. Yes, maybe you get the odd mild low 20s day in October but 5 days in London of 24-27 is rather different. And yes it's nice in itself, but it's also not a good sign.

For example, at this rate I'm thinking of giving up on summer holidays in Southern Europe in July/August as the heat is getting consistently unbearable. Imagine what it must be like for people who live there!

Andnowtowhatcomesnext · 30/09/2023 14:15

One hot day in one place in the UK might not be something to panic about but it’s still yet another example of what is happening all across the world. It will still impact on biodiversity and put things out of kilter. I’ll get out and thoroughly enjoy the sunshine but I’d be stupid not to worry about climate breakdown.

Yet people are just accepting it like it’s inevitable. We all should be taking action. In whatever way we can. It’s just pure madness to roll our eyes and bemoan the ‘eco zealots’ or ‘net zero zealots’. We should be out in the streets in response to the stupidity of the current government allowing new oil to be extracted - and NO it won’t effected our energy hills. And NO it won’t help our economy. The oil will be sold on the open Market. The profits will go to a Norwegian company. We the tax payer will subsidise it heavily. It will create a few local jobs at best but will contribute to further destabilising the climate and sends a dangerous message to the world.

Daftasabroom · 30/09/2023 14:14

Moonmelodies · 30/09/2023 14:12

That temperatures are currently in the upward curve part of the interglacial cycle?

Sadly not, if interglacial cycles were the main factor the earth should be cooling not warming.

Daftasabroom · 30/09/2023 14:12

Justifiedcheese · 30/09/2023 14:00

No, but they will have a hell of a lot more impact than you and I pretending that separating our rubbish will singlehandedly save the planet.

Butter fingers, sorry.

Swipe left for the next trending thread