Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Temperature not freaking everyone out?

312 replies

JKDcot · 30/09/2023 07:34

Meant to be 23/24 degrees in London next week? Not usual for early October… anyone else think it’s bonkers that climate change so obvious and still nothing being done my government and corporates

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
Daftasabroom · 01/10/2023 18:08

IslaWinds · 01/10/2023 17:50

Unfortunately, the global temperature averages often published usually start their graph circa 1850 to when we were coming out of the Little Ice Age.

Humans and human history goes back hundreds of thousands of years further back than 1850 or even 1650 (during little Ice Age), so you do have to look for graphs that go back a lot longer.

Here you go! Oops, it doesn't really support your implication does it?

nomadmummy · 01/10/2023 18:05

Research

Temperature not freaking everyone out?
Bellavida99 · 01/10/2023 18:05

We had rotten pumpkins and hot Halloween a few years ago. And my son’s birthday is end of October and he’ll be 18. The year he was born is was so lovely and warm the end of October I got told off by midwife for being out walking too much and not laying round indoors enough. So I think it’s not particularly unusual unless this weather is settled for the whole of October instead of being mixed spells of cold/ nice/ wet

OP posts:
IslaWinds · 01/10/2023 17:53

To suggest that the modeling and experts don't agree, is either incredibly ignorant of how science gets done, or, willfully disingenuous.

But they don’t all agree? You get ten scientists on anything as complex as this in a room and there will always be a dissenting opinion also based on science.
Also, there are multiple models projecting the future of our climate, they are all different and so far, none of them have been right as they have been modelling for decades now. What was predicted for today- not one model done in say the 1990s or 2000s was correct.

Karen398 · 01/10/2023 17:52

Cast your mind back to 2012 and early October was the same, nothing new here! Its very early in October, give it a few weeks and will be decidedly chillier

IslaWinds · 01/10/2023 17:50

littleblackcat27 · 01/10/2023 16:52

Completely agree and also with the OP.

People don’t want to know, because it’s an unpleasant fact staring them in the face.

Unfortunately, the global temperature averages often published usually start their graph circa 1850 to when we were coming out of the Little Ice Age.

Humans and human history goes back hundreds of thousands of years further back than 1850 or even 1650 (during little Ice Age), so you do have to look for graphs that go back a lot longer.

Spendonsend · 01/10/2023 17:40

Boomboom22 · 01/10/2023 17:32

I've noticed in recent years it gets very warm 3 to 5 pm rather than 12 to 2 or 3, which is great for the park afterschool though a bit odd.

Yes! I distictly remember the hottest part of the day was 12-3 and its definitely shifted later in the summer now.

Boomboom22 · 01/10/2023 17:32

I've noticed in recent years it gets very warm 3 to 5 pm rather than 12 to 2 or 3, which is great for the park afterschool though a bit odd.

Daftasabroom · 01/10/2023 17:27

@Bogwood The world's leading experts don't agree. You need to dig behind the headlines! Where are you getting your information from about scientific consensus? Even the computer modelled projections don't agree.

To suggest that the modeling and experts don't agree, is either incredibly ignorant of how science gets done, or, willfully disingenuous.

There are certainly differences in quite how bad it's will be, and what the best mitigations may be. But they do all agree that climate change is an unfolding catastrophe that we need to address with utmost urgency. You clearly have no scientific training or experience.

P.s. there's plenty of lithium that's been found in good safe jurisdictions.

Bogwood · 01/10/2023 17:20

@Andnowtowhatcomesnext If you re-read my earlier replies, you will see that the scientists that I reference are not challenging the scientific consensus - they are challenging the alarmist 'climate boiling' rhetoric that is not actually based in scientific consensus! The actual science contained in the IPCC reports is not adequately summarised and this results in it being misrepresented to the public. I have deliberately referenced scientific positions that reflect the current scientific understanding. This understanding does not point to the level of anthropogenic climate change indicated by the media headlines or the political propaganda. We should all be very concerned about this - but I understand it will probably be impossible to increase general awareness of the key issues. Most people will probably respond just as you have. However, as Mills has made clear, regardless of the science underpinning the race to 'net zero', the economic reality is that it simply will not be achievable - we do not have the resources currently to meet the logistical demands of the energy transition, whether people want it politically or not!

Sunnydays41 · 01/10/2023 17:17

YANBU...

It's been warm right up until the end of October for the last few years. My (young) DC were in the sea on 29 October last year!!

Tbh though, I much prefer a warm Autumn to a hot summer... I love sitting in the lower sun.

Bogwood · 01/10/2023 17:09

@littleblackcat27 and @Knnniggets How do you think they work out global average temperatures? It is actually not an exact science! And all this nonsense about the hottest temperatures in human history. I thought the last interglacial (the Eemian) was supposed to have reached higher temperatures - and modern Homo sapiens were certainly in existence then. It is silly headlines like this that start to discredit our perception of 'the science'.

Andnowtowhatcomesnext · 01/10/2023 17:07

Bogwood

As I’ve said, the arguments are of no interest to me. I’m not an expert in that field so can’t even begin to unpick it all and get my head around it. Of course there is not an absolute consensus. Science is always evolving. There is always debate. This is not an area I have a hope in hell of even partially understanding. So I don’t need to dig behind the headlines. Equally, I’m not going pay attention to three, likely biased, lone voices as it makes no difference to my understanding.

What I do know is that tax payers money HEAVILY subsidies the oil industry. The oil industry is a billion pound industry and has heavily invested, over the years in funding climate change sceptics to undermine the scientific consensus. Anyone with financial links to the oil industry loses any credibility in my eyes. I work in a different scientific area and I’ve seen first hand the bias caused by various funding streams.

I also know experts in climate science personally, who understand a lot more than I, who have sleepless nights worrying about the future for their kids. I trust them and know their expertise, so again, I’ll trust them rather than a random on a forum: no offence.

As I said, my view is that I’ll believe the consensus rather than the outliers.

littleblackcat27 · 01/10/2023 16:52

Knnniggets · 30/09/2023 10:43

The data really doesn’t lie: 2023 has been beating global average temperatures by a long shot and it’s not even over. We need a lot more resources thrown at this problem, sustained over many years for finding ways to mitigate it/adapt.

Completely agree and also with the OP.

People don’t want to know, because it’s an unpleasant fact staring them in the face.

Bogwood · 01/10/2023 16:40

@Andnowtowhatcomesnext
How about addressing the millions (if not billions) of pounds that are being made available in pursuit of net zero - both through industrial subsidies, the provision of renewable energy infrstructure and, crucially (in terms of the type of scientific analysis encouraged) in the form of academic grants for the right sort of research projects! Legislative frameworks are being created that are forcing industrial changes - ultimately this is going to be massively inflationary. this is not a zero sum game.

The world's leading experts don't agree. You need to dig behind the headlines! Where are you getting your information from about scientific consensus? Even the computer modelled projections don't agree. The only agreement is that CO2 is a greenhouse gas and that its increase will produce some warming - there is no consensus with respect to the amount of warming that it produces, relative to other causes of warming. I don't believe that you have taken the time to listen to the positions of any of the scientists that I have linked to. Fair enough! But that doesn't put you in a strong position when it comes to criticising their positions. They are not challenging the scientific consensus per se - they are saying that the public is not being given an accurate representation of the objective scientific understanding of climate change.

With respect to Mills, his position is only to question - quite reasonably - the logistics of pursuing net zero within the current political, social and economic constraints. Do you have any sources that would counter his systematic assessment of how unrealistic the supposed energy transition is? Do you disagree with the evidence that he presents that demonstrates that the carbon footprint and environmental damage associated with mining the raw materials for EVs makes the end products far from the clean, carbon neutral panacea they are marketed as?

For context, I have no skin in the game - I walk everywhere, don't go on foreign holidays, grow my own veg, make do and mend etc...I hate the noise of combustion engines. I hate the throw away consumer culture of fast capitalism (crapitalism). I hate the pollution of rivers, pesticides that impact on pollinators and the general reduction of biodiversity. However, I am sick of the overly simplistic propaganda that leads the public to think that CO2 (a natural plant fertilizer) is the most pressing problem currently facing humanity - ironically, it may be our rush to achieve 'net zero' that constitutes far more of an existential threat than the 'problem' it purports to solve!

mrsbyers · 01/10/2023 16:23

It’s not unusual we always have a weeks holiday late sept when the kids are back at home and the weather is often beautiful

Divinespark · 01/10/2023 16:20

I'm heading towards being 50, and remember being in my early 20's and it being at least 25c in a dress.

I remember as it's my mums birthday on the 23rd October. Also, we've had a bad summer so milder autumns tend it follow. It's not even 22c today. They say it is on the weather, it's probably 19c at most and im in the south. The mornings and evenings are cold.

Andnowtowhatcomesnext · 01/10/2023 16:15

Bogwood

Not attacking on ideological grounds. Climate breakdown is an humanitarian issue. I don’t see it as left versus right. I’d vote outside of my usual political leanings if a party had strong climate policy.

My point is that I’m not an expert so I can’t challenge the minutiae. None of us can understand the whole picture. Even someone who has studied climate science for decades won’t have the full picture as one person, with one brain. Therefore, I am going to listen to the consensus of the majority of experts globally, the massive reviews, rather than the minority who won’t have the full picture and will be biased by their links to the industry. It’s just good sense.

Given the risk assessment mentioned above, it seems sensible and wise to err on the side of caution to me - rather than cling to the narrative of a minority with poor credentials- even if it gives some comfort.

Andnowtowhatcomesnext · 01/10/2023 16:07

Bogwood you are cherry picking data that confirms your view. That’s unscientific. understandable, given the enormity of the problem, but not helpful.

There have been so many MASSIVE reviews of the data, over decades, using multiple models in different countries. Peer reviewed, solid science. You are only linking to outliers. The tiny proportion of scientists, often with industry links. It’s so arrogant to think that you know better than the global scientific community.

I’m sure there are some nuggets of truth or wisdom in what you say and the people you quote, but with a risk assessment you ask two main questions:

  • how likely is it?
  • how bad would the consequences be

The current scientific consensus is that climate catastrophe is highly likely without significant change (and is happening more quickly and with more severity than at first modelled) and that the outcomes are catastrophic (as is already happening across the world - drought, crop failures, wild fires, floods, apocalyptic storms. Leading to food shortages, mass migration, social instability and war).

I say if the worlds leading experts all agree the above - based on decades of work, better safe than sorry. It’s too late to avoid it, but we can still mitigate the worst of it.

Bogwood · 01/10/2023 16:05

@Andnowtowhatcomesnext You should listen to the substance of what is being said...the trouble is that you are confusing science with politics. I am left-leaning politically, but hold a position on some aspects of climate science that means I risk being labelled as right wing. That is dangerous, silly nonsense! We should be free to scrutinise the science - political affiliations should be irrelevant. Professor Koonin served under the Obama administration and so doesn't fit into the standard socio-political narrative...but this really should not be a factor when discussing the actual science.
I would be interested if you had a position that challenged the actual objective information being presented by any of the eminent scientists that I have referenced (Mills, Koonin, Curry) - but I am not interested in you trying to discredit through attacking them on ideological grounds.
You talk about the scientific consensus - both Koonin and Curry detail what that consensus consists of. Koonin draws his information precisely from the 'scientific consensus' in the form of evidence published by the IPCC. Curry makes it clear exactly what the areas of scientific agreement are - and there are absolutely fundamental differences of opinion on key areas of understanding with respect to the climate system. There are also huge variations in computer generated modelling - giving greater levels of variation in output than the temperature changes that they have attempted to describe over the past hundred years!

Thegoodbadandugly · 01/10/2023 16:02

Its has been known that we get a hot well or two in October I remember a good few years ago Oct half term was warm so no not freaked out.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 01/10/2023 16:00

Autumnunmasks · 30/09/2023 09:23

I'm with you OP totally.

The irony of people on here saying that it was warm in London 10 years ago does my head in, they don't seem to understand that global warming didn't start up last August, it's been accelerating since the industrial revolution

A period of warm weather in mid October used to be called St Luke's Little Summer because the saint's feast day falls on October 18 - and it's been called that for centuries. Not just the last 10 years.

Andnowtowhatcomesnext · 01/10/2023 15:54

Curry’s own site states her funding has partially come from energy companies;

“CFAN contracts with private sector and other non-governmental organizations include energy and power companies,”