Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that 'looks don't matter ' is a complete lie

106 replies

Petunia90 · 30/09/2023 01:41

It's just something people say, alongside 'money isn't everything '. However they absolutely do matter. They might not be #1 priority, but I'd be very surprised if anyone chose their partner without any consideration for how they looked. We're judged on looks all the time, rightly or wrongly, whether that be in relationships, job interviews and so on.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CosmicSoup · 03/10/2023 12:55

I don't want anyone to PM me, that's your perspective but it certainly isn't mine, I'm merely contributing to the thread as anyone else.

What I've said in my posts isn't any more "anti pc" than what the average mumsnetter writes, I feel like I'm being attacked unreasonably just because I've identified myself as a guy. I'm entitled to write my thoughts and you have no right to self appoint as thought police.

Please do not communicate with me again if you can't engage in constructive debate and can only attack.
Just do not reply, do not respond to me I don't want to hear from you.

roseyposies · 03/10/2023 12:06

Call me cynical but when some men pop up on these threads using the weird, IMO, language to describe women then talk about the difficulty they have in finding someone, and how sensitive and lovely they are, I often think that they're looking for someone to PM them.

5128gap · 03/10/2023 11:36

CosmicSoup · 03/10/2023 11:08

No mate, no particular individual was mentioned, noone is being singled out and lots of women on here do far worse in the form of man bashing. This is just you being overly sensitive and choosing to take offence where there's really none to take, but it's your right I suppose.

If you mean me, maybe think that through a little? I don't know you from a hole in the ground, and I'm not the person on here struggling to find a partner, so your opinion on women and how you express it is entirely irrelevant to me personally. Therefore, it doesn't make much sense that I would be overly sensitive to or offended by your comments, does it? The comments of a random woman with no skin in the game are about as close as you'll get to an objective view point. Take it or leave it mate.

CosmicSoup · 03/10/2023 11:08

No mate, no particular individual was mentioned, noone is being singled out and lots of women on here do far worse in the form of man bashing. This is just you being overly sensitive and choosing to take offence where there's really none to take, but it's your right I suppose.

5128gap · 03/10/2023 06:38

There have always been women who go for your type of look, so I really doubt that's your problem. I'll bet my house it's your attitude.
Your self awareness is not strong.
Coming onto this forum and talking about women as Barbies, 'caked' in make up like porn stars, being explicit about how 'chunky' you like them, implying some choose to be ambitious due to societal manipulation that seemingly unlike you they can't see through...that is not a sign of emotional intelligence.
Its fine to have preferences, but an EI person would know that to use loaded and disparaging language to describe them to a thread full of women is not going to go well.
EI involves empathy. Thinking about the person you're engaging with and what they might warm to and what might be off putting or offensive. Focus less on the looks you think women want and more on the attitudes.

CosmicSoup · 03/10/2023 01:27

Perhaps I come across wrong, or you're perceiving me wrong, I'm open to either.

Fortunately for me, I am not at all into Barbie type women, in fact I prefer women who wear very little or no makeup... I want to see the REAL woman not some cakes up version of what the porn industry would like me to believe I want.

I want a woman with emotional intelligence not grade A tits, because that's what I value... you know what I value in a woman?

Emotional Intelligence
Curiosity (doesn't need to be mega smart)
A strong sense of right and wrong
Cares about herself and others
Loyalty
Some ambition (picked by her not society)

Those are but a few, I don't think those are shallow?

I don't care if she has a few extra pounds, I couldn't date someone who was obese, but I'm sure some people would! Just being "fat" isn't a problem though, I love chunky gals.

I'll be honest with you, it's not my looks I worry about so much as my stature and my very soft, warm and emotionally expressive personality, might sound like a great thing but I've always felt insecure in that it's not what I perceived women to want, I felt like women would think I was gay (I am bi, but cheating is cheating!) Because I have a bit of a feminine personality and a VERY expressive face. But I love these things about myself even though males try to bully me for it occasionally, and I'm now embracing my feminine side.

I ride motorbikes too and lift weights and laid slabs for my granny last week, I also fix cars....so it's not like I'm not masculine at all 🤨

DdraigGoch · 02/10/2023 14:03

StoatofDisarray · 01/10/2023 19:04

Obviously you know nothing about the high personal beauty standards of South Korea or Brazil.

What are you suggesting that he does, emigrate?

roseyposies · 02/10/2023 13:33

When men say this, 9 times out of 10 they mean that they want a specific type of woman. A woman who is herself very physically attractive and so can have her pick. The give away is when they continue to complain that they lose out to 6 foot, good looking men in great shape. Because in reality, the average woman is not dating a man like that. The average looking woman typically dates an average looking man.

I agree with your whole post but just wanted to highlight this part!

CoffeeCantata · 02/10/2023 12:26

I'll get flamed for this, but I agree with the tone of this thread - wishing doesn't make things so! I'm all for dealing with reality, not some Utopian ideal.

I remember what 2 brilliant comedians/actors said. Jennifer Saunders says she decided to lose weight fairly early in her career because the difference in how seriously she was taken by BBC commissioning editors etc was immense. Sad but true.

Also, the wonderful Maxine Peake, whose first TV appearance was in Dinnerladies (when she was bigger than she is now) told her that Victoria Wood advised her to lose weight to further her career. Not because of the male gaze/patriarchy, but as above, because you get taken more seriously by both sexes.

It's definitely a thing as PPs have suggested. Anyone perceived to be overweight is open to judgement about 'letting themselves go' or 'not being in control'. It's unfair and unkind, but I have to say it's a fact in the real world. I've heard many people (women actually) express a similar view. Yes, I call them out - but it's a prevalent attitude - that's all I'm saying.

5128gap · 02/10/2023 10:38

@CosmicSoup There is no 'good looking in the way women want' at most there is 'good looking in the way many women want' or 'good looking enough that most women would find you attractive'.
Very few men fall into this category. Just as very few men are so physically repulsive (or so quirky strange special good looking!) no woman would ever want them.
When men say this, 9 times out of 10 they mean that they want a specific type of woman. A woman who is herself very physically attractive and so can have her pick. The give away is when they continue to complain that they lose out to 6 foot, good looking men in great shape. Because in reality, the average woman is not dating a man like that. The average looking woman typically dates an average looking man.
My point, if you are not a stunningly hot man, unless you are rich or powerful, you may not be able to attract a woman with the sort of looks you would prefer. So rather than moan about how shallow women are, be less shallow yourself and consider other aspects of women beyond how they look.

HelloItsMeHowAreYou · 02/10/2023 09:32

I consider myself very good looking but just not in the way women want

I think this is one of the biggest differences between men and women. I doubt 95%of women would EVER write that sentence. We just don't talk about ourselves that way.

It makes me realise even more that the differences between the sexes will never be bridged, however many bits on a person's body are cut off or added.

There's a transexual on Married at First Sight UK that is acting in their mind like a woman does, and is physically how one would think a woman wants to look. And says they can't understand why their partner doesn't fancy them.

And that attitude is EXACTLY why their partner doesn't fancy them. That entitled male attitude can't ever be expunged

CosmicSoup · 01/10/2023 19:20

@StoatofDisarray

I'll ignore the provocative tone.
I'm quite familiar with the K-pop look, I'm just not quite sure if you're implying that I should embrace and accept my resemblance to that OR... well I'm really not sure what you are getting at here to be honest.

StoatofDisarray · 01/10/2023 19:04

CosmicSoup · 01/10/2023 12:34

Of course they matter

In our western culture there is definitely a demand for aesthetic symmetry and generally accepted standards of beauty can be observed.

Women: perky boobs, nice hair, nice ass, curves in right places, not too tall, make up etc.

Men: 6 foot tall plus, muscles, v-shape, good jawline etc.

I'm a guy with none of the above features, dating for me has always been dire, in fact in high school girls showed so little interest in me that I ended up discovering my bisexuality in order to get what I needed, I couldn't get it from the girls so I got it from the boys instead, where such standards didn't matter - they were so horny I only needed to be alive! This suited me as apart from the fact I didn't meet the visual criteria I also could not be arsed with the mind fuckery and drama of the girls. You have to play the game, right?

I'm in my 30s now and most women would still not care to look at me in a romantic way, I'm 5'6, skinny and I look very boyish. My personality is also quite feminine - I have good emotional intelligence but that doesn't matter a fuck it seems :/

It's really annoying to me, I consider myself very good looking but just not in the way women want, they just think I'm cute and want to mother me.

Can't win.

Obviously you know nothing about the high personal beauty standards of South Korea or Brazil.

CosmicSoup · 01/10/2023 17:59

I can and I do sometimes but it's not just that

I'm a very small guy too and I'm neurodivergent, when your cards are stacked against you all you can do is hope the right person will come along or just be glad there's animals for company.

I'm generally quite happy in my own company and even in a relationship I'd need my own time and space to a degree, but it would be nice to share life with someone.

AllTheChaos · 01/10/2023 13:49

CoffeeCantata · 30/09/2023 08:44

HelloItsMeHowAreYou · Today 02:11

I was thinking the other day that I must be so shallow because I always notice other people's sizes on a beach/swimming pool.

So many people say "no one is looking at you OP in your swim costume" if someone posts how big they feel. I defy anyone not to notice others, unless you live in a vaccum.

Yes - I agree.

There was a pp on a thread a while ago who stated the exact opposite view to this (that you shouldn't worry because NO-ONE is even looking, never mind judging you). I thought then 'What planet is this person on??' but didn't want to spoil their very optimistic world-view by disagreeing!!

Absolutely agree with this. The way I approached it with DD (nearing 10, and starting to become aware of such things), was to ask if she noticed, then when she said ‘yes’, and ask ‘and then what?’ Because for me, I notice, but unless I (a) fancy the person; or (b) find something singularly noticeable about what they’re wearing - usually good, sometimes bad (looking at you, nude leggings/crop top combo, and the first time I thought one of the school mums was nekkid on the school run!) then I Just Don’t Care. I explained that most people are the same, they’ll notice but won’t give a toss. We’ll get to discussing how the way women are treated varies according to their looks when she’s older. I’m already angry that we will have to have that conversation.

GreyCarpet · 01/10/2023 13:38

But good looking people do get away with a lot of bad behaviour.

For some people, yes.

I've read a few threads I've eye rolled at recently on here - women who've posted about flakey men treating them badly - where the only good things they've had to say about him are that he is tall and good looking. And when people have pointed out he's a dick, have replied "but he's good looking."

Whereas I tend to find these to be the least interesting and important aspects of a person.

KandieKaine · 01/10/2023 13:08

CosmicSoup · 01/10/2023 12:34

Of course they matter

In our western culture there is definitely a demand for aesthetic symmetry and generally accepted standards of beauty can be observed.

Women: perky boobs, nice hair, nice ass, curves in right places, not too tall, make up etc.

Men: 6 foot tall plus, muscles, v-shape, good jawline etc.

I'm a guy with none of the above features, dating for me has always been dire, in fact in high school girls showed so little interest in me that I ended up discovering my bisexuality in order to get what I needed, I couldn't get it from the girls so I got it from the boys instead, where such standards didn't matter - they were so horny I only needed to be alive! This suited me as apart from the fact I didn't meet the visual criteria I also could not be arsed with the mind fuckery and drama of the girls. You have to play the game, right?

I'm in my 30s now and most women would still not care to look at me in a romantic way, I'm 5'6, skinny and I look very boyish. My personality is also quite feminine - I have good emotional intelligence but that doesn't matter a fuck it seems :/

It's really annoying to me, I consider myself very good looking but just not in the way women want, they just think I'm cute and want to mother me.

Can't win.

Grow some facial hair ?

JamSandle · 01/10/2023 12:42

Of course they matter. But so do many other things.

Dustpantsandbush · 01/10/2023 12:41

As a seasoned ugly povvo I can tell you from lived experience that both things matter a very great deal to the vast majority of people.

CosmicSoup · 01/10/2023 12:34

Of course they matter

In our western culture there is definitely a demand for aesthetic symmetry and generally accepted standards of beauty can be observed.

Women: perky boobs, nice hair, nice ass, curves in right places, not too tall, make up etc.

Men: 6 foot tall plus, muscles, v-shape, good jawline etc.

I'm a guy with none of the above features, dating for me has always been dire, in fact in high school girls showed so little interest in me that I ended up discovering my bisexuality in order to get what I needed, I couldn't get it from the girls so I got it from the boys instead, where such standards didn't matter - they were so horny I only needed to be alive! This suited me as apart from the fact I didn't meet the visual criteria I also could not be arsed with the mind fuckery and drama of the girls. You have to play the game, right?

I'm in my 30s now and most women would still not care to look at me in a romantic way, I'm 5'6, skinny and I look very boyish. My personality is also quite feminine - I have good emotional intelligence but that doesn't matter a fuck it seems :/

It's really annoying to me, I consider myself very good looking but just not in the way women want, they just think I'm cute and want to mother me.

Can't win.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 01/10/2023 12:23

NameAU1 · 30/09/2023 08:58

I really don’t think this is true.
A lot of people put up with lot of crap to keep a partner.
Of course partly it could be just so that they don’t have to be alone.
But good looking people do get away with a lot of bad behaviour.

Also, I don’t really understand this, at first looks are important, but once in a relaotionship it’s bot that big of a deal: doesn’t that just translate that looks matter very much and if you don’t got it, you won’t get a relationship.

Also just MN, there’s a lot if threads of people complaining about their partners ’losing their looks’.

I'm not so sure. It's not as if the only people who are in relationships are people who are beautiful or good-looking, or even conventionally attractive at all. You're right that people put up with lots of crap in relationships, but I don't think that's directly related to looks. Many people are crap partners without being attractive!

roseyposies · 01/10/2023 11:49

Agree @Disturbia81 It's all about the cheater and their personality and moral code. Nothing to do with how attractive their partner is.

Disturbia81 · 01/10/2023 10:47

Knitgoodwoman · 30/09/2023 14:15

@Petunia90 it’s not that at all, re: abbey Clancy. Some people think people cheat because someone more attractive came along, my point was that often isn’t actually the case.

Yeah it's not about looks, look at all the actors/actresses or singers who are stunning/handsome and get cheated on still.
It's about the cheater. They feel entitled and are that way inclined that they get bored and want different. Even the people who are with the supermodels.
Where I live the women look like Kathy Burke and are in the most loyal loving relationships and the men adore them.
It's always about the cheater.

5128gap · 30/09/2023 14:24

I've met very few men who consider themselves unattractive. Even the worst of them tend to describe themselves as 'average'. If they feel restricted at all in the dating department they tend to think its due lack of height or wealth rather than their facial features.
Women on the other tend to have a very high bar set for them. Name any woman generally regarded as beautiful and they'll be a rush of people telling you they don't think she's anything special. I've seen it recently with Margot Robbie, who is 'just pretty' apparantly!
So back to Crouch and Clancy, there's a good chance as a tall wealthy man who no doubt thinks himself at least 'average' looking, in a world where its hard to know how beautiful a woman needs to be to be considered exceptional, he probably doesn't think he's punching above his weight at all.

Knitgoodwoman · 30/09/2023 14:15

@Petunia90 it’s not that at all, re: abbey Clancy. Some people think people cheat because someone more attractive came along, my point was that often isn’t actually the case.