Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this is harsh

33 replies

Aglassaday · 29/09/2023 19:11

DD15 y11 struggles with generalised anxiety, is currently on medication and has recently had Cbt which has helped but wasn’t necessarily for her. She struggles a lot in school mentally, although has a nice small friendship group and friends in every class, her anxiety ruins it completely. She has self harmed for many years and continues to do so and is being supported through Ed psychologist in school, form tutor (who is amazing) and by myself and DH and her friends.

In school however, she can be a bit naughty, nothing awful and behaviour at her school is particularly bad, chairs being thrown at teachers that sort of thing, whereas DD is just a bit chatty and sometimes unfocused and the usual rolled up skirt, jewellery etc.

Despite outstanding school attendance, she does struggle attending and staying in lessons due to her frequent anxiety and panic attacks and walks out of lessons etc hyperventiling and crying and being under general distress. This is expected of her anxiety and Is currently under ADHD and ASD testing too. Some issues have been made with teaching staff and subsequently brought to her year team.

Her year leader however, despite being happy for the naughty chair throwing kids to come to her and deal with them all the time, making jokes with them and sharing sweets, I feel is being a bit harsh on DD. She had told DD to sort it out and has asked “have you tried staying in lesson?” When it is clear DD only left because she was having an intense panic attack.

Today, after going to year leader unable to stay in her English lesson due to a servere panic attack, DD went to her year leader, following the advice she was told by YL to come to her if she can’t stay in a lesson due to anxiety.

YL then decided she has had enough and even though DD followed what she was told to do, started lashing out at DD saying it’s not fair every other student has to go to lesson but DD doesn’t go (due to her high functioning anxiety). Bear in mind a group of popular naughty kids who had been kicked out their classroom were sat in YL’s classroom laughing and sat on their phones eating sweets. YL then proceeded to say INFRONT of the other kids, I don’t think schools for you, you need to consider dropping out!

DD, already upset burst into another round of tears and cried again when she came home. She has strong plans for college, university and career and is predicted to get all 11 GCSEs at grades 7-9

AIBU to think her year leader is being too harsh and to be upset by this?

Please comment your thoughts and be kind with your comments

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MargaretThursday · 30/09/2023 10:26

I think you need to talk to the teacher and find out what is going on.

It may be that she does need to get out. It may be that she thinks the only option is getting out and they are trying to help her find ways round it.

Sometimes you can give too much leeway which can be ultimately unhelpful.
One of my dc's friends had an exit pass. It started so he could get out when he needed to, and he stayed in most lessons, and came out occasionally. He was using the pass well.
Then he started using it to leave any lessons he didn't like-and he was quite open about it.
Then he started leaving pretty much every lesson. My dc tried to help him. They said to him that they'd ask if the seating plan could be changed so they sat next to him and would help him. The chap in question replied "why should I bother staying in lessons if I don't have to? They're boring".
Shortly afterwards he dropped out of school and didn't go back.

You need to talk to the school and try and help her get strategies to manage it too.

Aglassaday · 30/09/2023 09:59

@Boomboom22 in DD’s school they don’t have heads of key stage, only year leaders, deputy year leaders etc

OP posts:
Boomboom22 · 29/09/2023 23:53

Is there a head of ks4 above the hoy? If not their slt, ask for a meeting.

AtomicBlondeRose · 29/09/2023 23:48

It would be good to know what the year leader actually said as no teacher would ever even use the phrase “dropping out” to a student as it’s not a thing! I would also hope that no non-teaching pastoral staff would ever say that but honestly I couldn’t rule it out. But it’s wildly inappropriate. I teach in a college and it would only be in the very direst of circumstances that I would even suggest that college might not be the best place for a student. Really we want them to stay and do their best for as long as they can.

namestevalian · 29/09/2023 23:43

Everything anyone needs to know about tret basically

simpleskincarescience.com/tretinoin/

This is my go to resource

Aglassaday · 29/09/2023 21:38

@TeenLifeMum i love the book idea will definitely be using that, thank you so much and for your kind advice, it is so appreciated.

OP posts:
TeenLifeMum · 29/09/2023 21:03

@Aglassaday my personal approach re team leader would be to talk honestly with your dd (helpful to build trust at this age) and say you’re not happy with the teacher’s approach but it’s useful life skill to manage working with people who are annoying/approach things differently/have different views and it’s important to still be kind and respectful. Maybe chose a safe person dd can get support from?

i have a 15 yo who is an introvert, worrier and gets anxious. We’ve managed to get her in a good place but honestly it could have gone either way and there’s lots of gentle nudging along the way. I’m a confident extrovert who loves being surrounded by people and noise but dd gets sensory overload. It’s been a massive learning curve for me because she’s very different to me but the main thing we have is fantastic open dialogue so keep talking.

one thing dd did was write her worries in a book and leave it outside her bedroom door at night for me to read (what she wanted to share with me not like a diary) and we’d talk about it the next day. I don’t tell her how to fix things but ask her questions to think about the bigger picture. I am wishing this year away and hoping her results reflect her hard work.

Daffodil18 · 29/09/2023 20:40

Ive worked in a school which sounds similar. The kids throwing chairs probably have terrible lives and no prospect for a career. That’ll be why they are in that office as a safety precaution for other children. Also in the school there were some who keep coming out of class for anxiety. It’s very disruptive for others and the child.

Aglassaday · 29/09/2023 20:38

@user1846385927482658 she only walks out of lessons as she has been given an exit card to do so by her yearleader, which I am starting to feel has become a bit of a crutch she relies on though I think we currently have bigger issues to deal with

OP posts:
Aglassaday · 29/09/2023 20:37

@Findyourneutralspace shes not the sort of person to struggle from anxiety, although can be sensitive she is very outgoing and chatty. It isn’t just school where her anxiety is bad but I imagine it’s heightened at school as she doesn’t view it as a “safe” environment anxiety wise

OP posts:
KnowledgeableMomma · 29/09/2023 20:35

Just to throw another homeschool hat in the ring-at her age, her learning would be more under her control then and might even have a positive benefit with her anxiety

user1846385927482658 · 29/09/2023 20:33

It goes without saying that she knows if she was to make an allegation as such and it was not true

It's not so much about her "making it up" but the more likely possibility that in a state of heightened emotions she misunderstood or intuited meaning that wasn't there and is now misremembering based on that perception. It's common and happens to us all.

It is valid to question what happens if she instead stays in class and lets the anxiety peak and fall. The body can only physically sustain a state of extreme anxiety for a limited period - it would end even if she stayed in the lesson. Part of living with anxiety disorders is learning that you can survive and ride out that wave while it burns out.

Walking out of class every time she feels overwhelmed is not necessarily helpful in the long run as it becomes self-reinforcing and keeps the anxiety going.

I realise that's a difficult point to listen to and perhaps it was not made as sensitively as you might have liked, but that doesn't make it less valid.

Findyourneutralspace · 29/09/2023 20:33

It sounds a really stressful environment with chairs being thrown around etc. If that was going on at home there would be concerns about safeguarding.
Is her anxiety around school? Or more general? If she is a sensitive sort thats’s bound to put her on edge and into a state of high alert - or anxiety.
It’s difficult at this point in year 11 because moving is going to impact her too much but I wonder whether it is the right environment for her.
Is she moving to a better environment post 16? That level of behaviour isn’t ok in school.

Aglassaday · 29/09/2023 20:25

@TeenLifeMum thank you for your kind words and advice, I really appreciate it. In addition to finding out what has gone wrong with the year leader, I do in general want to meet with the school about how we can support DD together (something I have requested numerous times but year leader has refused to)

OP posts:
Almostautumn2023 · 29/09/2023 20:23

It’s probably worth looking on the SEN boards for accommodations for your DD - maybe a reduced timetable or some kind of 1-1 tuition.

Aglassaday · 29/09/2023 20:22

@Dramatic completely understand this and of course will be investigating further with the school.
However, as DD’s mum and legal guardian it is my duty to help her however she needs and to give her love, trust and support through everything and so I will always believe her, and be there for her no matter what and she knows she can come to me about anything. It goes without saying that she knows if she was to make an allegation as such and it was not true what she came home crying to me about, then there would be serious consequences and she is aware of this but for now I am going to do my absolute best in loving and supporting her

OP posts:
TeenLifeMum · 29/09/2023 20:22

Current advice is to manage anxiety by not shying away from triggers and instead finding techniques to stay in class. Sounds like teacher is trying a bit of tough love which may not be helpful but sometimes a habit forms and it’s really really hard to break that cycle. We all have to do things we don’t want to do and yes, it’s incredibly disruptive to the whole class when your dd ups and leaves so there’s a wider impact than just on dd.

i would be trying to support dd in techniques to build her resilience at this point and acknowledge her feelings by focusing on how she can manage them.

I’m sorry there’s not more support from the school. Try and find out what they would like to happen to get through the next few months. Good luck.

Dramatic · 29/09/2023 20:16

I wouldn't take your DD's word for exactly how this conversation went down

Aglassaday · 29/09/2023 20:15

@Chickenkeev thank you, that is correct. We thought about home school but sadly we don’t have the time with both myself and DP working full time

OP posts:
Almostautumn2023 · 29/09/2023 20:14

Could you homeschool for the last year? If she’s bright then I’m sure she would be able to pass her GCSEs

Aglassaday · 29/09/2023 20:14

Thanks @AuntMarch , I will be speaking to DD’s form tutor on Monday about this. We’ve had repeated issues with this year leader, with her refusing to pass on vital information about DD to teachers (understandable, as I know teachers have a lot on their plates, in addition to losing several doctors notes of DDs and DDs friends) and in general she hasn’t been nice to DD so I’m upset but not surprised that she said that to DD though of course will ask for statements from the other children in the room and be speaking to SLT

OP posts:
Chickenkeev · 29/09/2023 20:13

Sorry for the spelling 🙁

Chickenkeev · 29/09/2023 20:12

Aglassaday · 29/09/2023 20:08

@Chickenkeev sadly not. We didn’t want her to go there in the first place due to its reputation, despite having OFSTED “good” but we weren’t in the catchment for any others. DD is year 11 now so moving to a different school would not help her anxiety at all and also would be inconvenient with different schools offering different exam boards etc

Soŕry, am not fully au fait with the lingo as am not UK but basically you can't move her then? That is tough, am trying to think of a third way but nothing popping up rn. Apart from home school. And that's nit suitable for moat people.

MidnightOnceMore · 29/09/2023 20:09

I agree the YL seems not to be helping your DD. I'd ask for a meeting with someone more senior to ask for help with this.

YL then proceeded to say INFRONT of the other kids, I don’t think schools for you, you need to consider dropping out! If this is true, it's very serious and needs escalating.

AuntMarch · 29/09/2023 20:08

You should probably ask the senior member of about it before you commit to it being harsh, as you should in any scenario you only hear one side of.
It isn't impossible that someone in the middle of a panic attack might not remember a conversation in exactly the same way as the other party. Especially a teenager (even without a panic attack).

Swipe left for the next trending thread