Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that people should use their manners when I'm out walking my dog

215 replies

politenesspooch · 29/09/2023 18:25

I've changed name for this due to the dog haters on here.

I walk my dog on lead of an early evening (he has a long off lead walk in the morning). I'm training him to walk properly by my side on a loose leash, but it's a work in progress and will take some time. He's a spaniel and very high energy, so I use lots of treats and encouragement. I've used and paid for a trainer to be able to do this correctly and I'm following her instruction and technique.

So why then do I have to contend with joggers, people on bikes and walkers coming up right behind me and my dog, spooking us both? Why don't they say "Excuse me!" because I would quite happily move to one side and make room for them?

Tonight it was a woman who exclaimed as she walked right up behind me and surprised both me and my dog and so my dog jumped towards her because he was taken by surprise?

AIBU to think people should just use some basic manners?

OP posts:
MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 30/09/2023 09:26

Spanne · 30/09/2023 09:15

The excuse me gives the owner time to move her dog to the side or put him in a middle or down etc if that’s what they do.

You all keep doing what you want though. Don’t take 5 seconds of your time to make someone’s life easier. Why should you?

That's not it though, is it? I would be perfectly happy to say "excuse me" if I thought it was going to make someone's life easier, but it wouldn't necessarily occur to me that this would be needed if there is enough space for me to walk past without any physical contact. Like I say, I know nothing about dogs, why would I?

There are so many lone walkers with earphones in now anyway, I wouldn't assume that they would even hear an "excuse me" from behind in any case. If I'm walking alone, I am typically listening to something and have to stop it and take my earphones out to talk to someone.

GivetheCataBone · 30/09/2023 09:22

I'm a dog owner, I trained my dog on a lead, they need to get used to people coming up behind them and traffic, other dogs etc. I wouldn't have minded joggers etc going by, that's what the dog needs to show him it's all normal behaviour. No good walking him and not seeing anyone else, that will teach him nothing.

Dwappy · 30/09/2023 09:17

I understand its different on small paths as really you should say excuse me rather than just barging past someone. And I guess in smaller villages you come across less people.
However in London it amazes me how unaware some people are that other people might exist and be walking on the same road. Only yesterday I was walking along a pavement and I was walking about 10 meters behind a woman and 2 children. Our pace was very similar so i wasn't getting closer while walking. They then stopped to get something out of a bag. All fine. It was a wide pavement so huge amounts of room to get past. I carried on at my normal pace and went to overtake. As I was level with them they started walking again. So now we're all walking at the same pace next to each other. The woman looked at me and pulled the child nearest to me away and said "EXCUSE ME!" It was so weird. I was simply walking down the road and overtook other stopped pedestrians. The woman just seemed shocked and annoyed that another person was on the road. What should I have done? Stopped behind them and waited? Said excuse me when passing them despite there being about 5ft of passing room? Waited to cross the busy road to the other side to get round them?
I find this happens with dog walkers a lot as well in London. You're walking at a normal pace way behind a dog walker. But they obviously keep stopping so eventually you catch up with them. And they always start walking again just as you're right next to them. So you're now walking down the road next to them like you're with them. And they always seem to look at me like I'm the weird one. I just these people should be aware others might be walking along as well and wait 2 seconds for them to pass.
(This is kind of lighthearted because in my part of London you certainly do not talk to strangers so walking next to a stranger is the height of awkwardness!)

Spanne · 30/09/2023 09:15

The excuse me gives the owner time to move her dog to the side or put him in a middle or down etc if that’s what they do.

You all keep doing what you want though. Don’t take 5 seconds of your time to make someone’s life easier. Why should you?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 30/09/2023 09:10

Are they having to physically push past you, OP? If so, then of course they are being rude and they should say "excuse me". If they're simply walking past without actually making any contact with you or your dog, then you are being a bit unreasonable in my view.

I know nothing about dogs personally but I don't hate them. It just wouldn't ever occur to me that someone would take an untrained dog for a walk on such a narrow path.

I also don't really understand how someone saying "excuse me" when they pass would help your dog. Surely your dog would still be surprised by someone coming up behind him and having to pass by?

elderflowerandpomelo · 30/09/2023 08:59

Well this is interesting. Unless I could see a good reason why I shouldn’t, I’d definitely squeeze past, rather than speak to someone.

this reminds me of a time when the kids were small and we were out on bikes on a quiet road and totally inadvertently spooked a horse - I didn’t think we were being particularly quiet, and (not being a horse person) had no idea a horse wd be scared by people on bikes. Rider was FURIOUS w me - and accused me of putting her, horse and kids in real danger. But I genuinely had no idea that what we were doing - passing fairly quietly - would cause any problem.

maybe it’s a similar situation? Pple think what they are doing is just fine/polite.

notanothernana · 30/09/2023 08:49

Cyclists should ring a bell or announce they're coming past IMO as one nearly knocked my dog over the other day.

If I'm overtaking someone I always say "excuse me", basic manners n

cheezncrackers · 30/09/2023 08:45

YABU I'm a jogger and I'm sick to death of all the fucking dogs blocking pavements! Go and train your dog elsewhere or choose a quieter time of day to do it. Early evening is peak time for people to be out taking exercise before it gets dark. Your sense of entitlement in a public space is irritating, but not unexpected, since I frequently have to run in the road to get round people like you who are taking up all the pavement with their fucking dogs.

Nannyfannybanny · 30/09/2023 08:40

But, no, I don't expect anyone to get out of my way.

Nannyfannybanny · 30/09/2023 08:39

A lot of people in general are rude and selfish. Am just starting latest puppy training, socialising. It's the previous mentioned plus a lot of very fast electric scooters, mobility scooters, they don't say excuse me. Those ridiculous long extending leads get my goat. There's one neighbour who walks her 2 dogs,fully extended, one often goes into the road. When the sun is very low in winter, after the clock change in October,dogs on leads on the prom (local beach) you can't see those cord ones stretched across the path

Oliotya · 30/09/2023 08:30

I suspect you're taking up more space than think. On a shared pavement you need to be ready for someone to pass at any moment. Just like I have taught my dc to go in single file ahead of the pushchair, your dog needs to be on a short lead and right next to you. It's on you to be aware of other people imo.

MontyDonsBlueScarf · 30/09/2023 08:22

This thread is making me feel very grateful that I live where I do, even though it normally feels like the land that time forgot. Round here the normal etiquette is to be aware of everyone else's use of the paths, to overtake or pass with consideration, to smile and nod or (brace yourselves) even say 'good morning' when it goes well, 'thank you' when someone steps aside or waits for you, and 'sorry' if you misjudge it.

OP the only practical suggestion I can make (apart from moving here) is maybe break the training into smaller steps if possible. So wider paths with no-one else around, narrower paths with no-one else around, go back to wider paths with a few people around, narrower paths with a few people, wider paths with lots of people, and finally narrow paths with lots of people. You mentioned traffic noise, you might have to add that in as another variable too. It takes more thought and organization on your part, but it makes it so much easier for the dog to learn that overall it doesn't take any more time.

LikeARainstorm · 30/09/2023 08:03

There have been a few threads recently where people have argued that they need to train their dogs using other (unwilling!) people - most notably the ones who decide to 'socialise' their dog by taking it to primary school gates at hometime so it can get used to children. And when it chases, jumps at, barks at and frightens children then it's the kid's fault for being nervous or 'surprising' the dog that they never asked to be near in the first place.

I do understand the logic of having to train your dog to behave around strangers and having to do that in the real world but there are just so many dogs now and they are everywhere. You talk with scorn about 'dog-haters' OP but some people have been attacked by dogs, some are allergic, some people have health and mobility issues that mean someone's 'playful, friendly, just saying hello' dog can knock them over or hurt them badly. There are so many lovely walks around me where I can't take my kids because of the amount of unpredictable dogs. Maybe they're all in the process of being trained but for those of us who don't choose to have dogs, it can get very wearying to constantly be a training tool for other people's every time you step outside.

Passepartoute · 30/09/2023 07:43

politenesspooch · 29/09/2023 20:15

It's interesting you say "I know nothing about dogs" because maybe that's it? I do find other dog walkers don't walk right up behind other dog walkers. Perhaps we've all picked up the subtle clues that you just don't do that? You either hold back a bit and give some space or you cross or even change your route. What you don't do id get right up behind another dog walker and squeeze past.

You're imposing your dog's needs on others. If you are training your dog in walking on paths like this, you need to train him to deal with how people actually behave, not how you would like them to behave.

margotrose · 30/09/2023 07:28

OP - speaking as a dog owner and dog walker, people generally don't give a shit that you're training your dog when you're out in public.

People just want to get on with their lives - they're not interested in the fact that you're loose-lead training - they just want to carry on with their bike ride or get to work on time.

Their thoughts won't be "oh, that lady looks like she's training, I'd better go into the road/stop/wait/go around her" - they just think "she's blocking the path and I need to get home".

MintJulia · 30/09/2023 07:14

In the end, OP, your dog should be under control at all times. If you think it might jump up at someone, keep it on a lead on narrow paths.

It is your job to keep it under control in a public space, not other people's job to avoid you both.

temperedolive · 30/09/2023 07:01

You paid for a trainer to work with your dog. You did not pay for exclusive use of the outdoors.

echt · 30/09/2023 06:51

If an animal has a temperament so unreliable that it can’t cope with someone coming up behind it, you shouldn’t be walking it in public

I knew someone would trot out this ineffable shite out at some point.

By this argument, a human, who is far more intelligent than a dog, able to analyse and calculate dangers should also be able to cope with someone coming up behind. If they can't handle this they shouldn't be out in public.

nevynevster · 30/09/2023 06:44

Prescottdanni123 · 29/09/2023 20:56

@CakeInAJar

There has been plenty of the bargy type of joggers lately. They are definitely on the increase.

I run a lot. In London where there are a lot of people on the pavements and towpaths and parks.
These days most people have their phones out and I don't think they realise how much they weave/meander across the pavement! I am very alert whilst running, planning how I will overtake, often running into the road and I try to pick a line holding to the left especially on towpaths to follow normal traffic conventions. But honestly sometimes it's bloody difficult to get past people who aren't paying attention to anything other than their phone and not holding a straight line.
It's not practical for me to say excuse me to everyone as I run past. 80pc of people have earphones in anyway. So if I can't see a space to get past, I'll slow down and jog behind until it's practical to overtake or I'll say something like "runner on your right" if it's a tight squeeze. I don't think I can be expected to know that your dog needs notice of my arrival and I can't be saying excuse me to everyone as I'd literally be talking non stop some mornings.

BitOutOfPractice · 30/09/2023 06:25

How much was your permit to own the ruddy pavement op? I’d like to get one too 🙄

DinoDaddy · 30/09/2023 06:22

Dog owners are all so entitled these days.

thelonemommabear · 30/09/2023 06:13

Well you are the one breaking the law having a dog off the lead in a public place not the jogger

HappiestSleeping · 30/09/2023 03:21

user1477391263 · 30/09/2023 03:13

If an animal has a temperament so unreliable that it can’t cope with someone coming up behind it, you shouldn’t be walking it in public.

This is absolutely true, but the reality is that they do get walked in public. Besides, we are talking about animals, so nothing is ever 100% reliable, especially if they are startled. I know of dogs who have never shown aggression who reacted unfavourably when surprised by a cyclist.

user1477391263 · 30/09/2023 03:13

HappiestSleeping · 29/09/2023 18:53

I think this is unreasonable but not for the reasons you might think. I have experienced this while walking my dog and it startles me and the dog. In an ideal world, there would be a little bit of warning. After all, they are essentially creeping up on an animal (2 animals if you include me). These are the same people who would complain about being growled at / bitten (and I know they shouldnt have to worry about this while going about their business, but it is an animal). They wouldn't creep up on a horse in a field, or any other animal, so why it's OK to do it to a dog is beyond me.

However, people are stupid, self absorbed, and don't think about what they are doing. Do they need to give notice / warning? No. Would it be sensible to do so? Yes. So my unreasonable verdict is because you are expecting people to be sensible when they are inherently not so.

I have my flame proof helmet on now, so bring on the debate MN 🤪

Edited

If an animal has a temperament so unreliable that it can’t cope with someone coming up behind it, you shouldn’t be walking it in public.

echt · 30/09/2023 02:32

Unless one is on a very crowded pavement, there's no reason at all to come up closely behind anyone, with or without a dog.

Swipe left for the next trending thread