Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH and I can’t agree on whether we should move house

87 replies

sunlightinthetrees · 29/09/2023 15:48

We live in a nice house in a nice village. Objectively it’s a good place to live.

However, both our DC go to primary school in the nearby town 10-15 mins away. All of their friends live near the school and most of their activities are in the town too.

I’m SO fed up of driving to and from the town. On a “normal” day it’s twice but some days it can be three or even four return journeys.

Generally the traffic is ok but every now and again it’s not, yesterday there was a bad accident and I ended up being really really late for an important meeting at the school and it was really embarrassing and frustrating. I’ve been saying for ages that I’d prefer to live in the town but this was the last straw for me.

I’ve said I want to move house but DH doesn’t get it. He just doesn’t think it’s enough of an inconvenience to warrant the hassle and cost of moving. I think it is. We would only be able to afford a smaller house in the other town (but still big enough for our needs), again I think it’s worth it and he doesn’t.

It may be relevant that he grew up in a rural location and is used to being driven everywhere but I did not. It’s starting to become an issue and I don’t know how we resolve it.

AIBU to want to move closer or is he right that it’s not worth the hassle?

OP posts:
Diddleflop · 30/09/2023 08:08

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

sunlightinthetrees · 29/09/2023 23:03

ZiriForEver · 29/09/2023 20:02

I read that you moved from London - it is a huge change and a totally different lifestyle.

I would hate spending the whole day off work by driving, waiting to drive and trying to be on time.
It would be strong enough reason for me.

You've said that he gets stressed by other things, could you use some of them to explain how you feel about driving?

Edited

Yes it is a real change from London, and interesting to me that I miss it and he doesn’t. I think it just shows that we’re wired differently on stuff like this.

I think this thread has helped me see that neither of us is right or wrong but it is really affecting me and we need to have a chat about what might be possible.

OP posts:
ZiriForEver · 29/09/2023 20:02

I read that you moved from London - it is a huge change and a totally different lifestyle.

I would hate spending the whole day off work by driving, waiting to drive and trying to be on time.
It would be strong enough reason for me.

You've said that he gets stressed by other things, could you use some of them to explain how you feel about driving?

sunlightinthetrees · 29/09/2023 19:46

jeaux90 · 29/09/2023 18:37

You have to look at what's next. Your eldest is a couple of years away from it but at 10ish they start to want more independence, walking to the park, meeting friends to play sports, going into town together etc.

I live in a small country town.

It's really helpful that my now DD14 can go into town on her own with he friends etc

Yes and I feel it’s a shame that she won’t be able to walk to school with her friends etc.

I guess it’s just a question of whether it’s enough of a shame for us to spend several thousand pounds on stamp duty and moving costs 🙃

OP posts:
RandomMess · 29/09/2023 19:18

I think you need to explain how miserable it makes you already and that's only going to build and build over time.

Perhaps you can agree a time frame before moving?

You had never lived rurally before and you've now tried it and don't like it.

jeaux90 · 29/09/2023 18:37

You have to look at what's next. Your eldest is a couple of years away from it but at 10ish they start to want more independence, walking to the park, meeting friends to play sports, going into town together etc.

I live in a small country town.

It's really helpful that my now DD14 can go into town on her own with he friends etc

sunlightinthetrees · 29/09/2023 18:30

Eleganz · 29/09/2023 18:05

I think a proper discussion is needed about this and then having an agreement and sticking to it even if it isn't what you want - that is marriage and kids I'm afraid. I can't see that your DH is being unreasonable here he just has a difference of opinion. Decisions have been made by you both and this is the situation that has resulted.

Throwing your toys out of the pram and refusing to do any of the school run as some have suggested is not reasonable behaviour.

Yes I think this is fair! I won’t be stopping school runs as I agree that would be a nuclear option 😂

This has all become more of an issue recently as up until a few months ago my youngest DC was at a pre school in the village. It’s only now that they’re BOTH at the school in the town that living here feels increasingly pointless (to me).

OP posts:
Eleganz · 29/09/2023 18:05

I think a proper discussion is needed about this and then having an agreement and sticking to it even if it isn't what you want - that is marriage and kids I'm afraid. I can't see that your DH is being unreasonable here he just has a difference of opinion. Decisions have been made by you both and this is the situation that has resulted.

Throwing your toys out of the pram and refusing to do any of the school run as some have suggested is not reasonable behaviour.

Talipesmum · 29/09/2023 17:56

If the secondary school is also in the same town as the primary school, I think you’ve got a better case. It’ll be far harder once your kids want more independence.

HelpIcantfindaname · 29/09/2023 17:19

In KS1 my DDs primary school was very close to us. Playdates were easy & we often saw school friends in the park.

In KS2 she had to move to the school I taught in, 3 miles away. It's not that far but made playdates more tricky. Friends in her class lived very close to each other & saw each other outside of school a lot.

Now she's in KS4 her school is over 3 miles away in the other direction. There is no direct bus route. We drive her to school & collect her. Again, her friends live closer to each other & it's easier for them to socialise. I have to do a lot of driving to take her to see them & collect them, & if they come here I often end up running them home to save them getting on 2 buses.

I also have grown up DCs, when they were younger they went to local schools, their friends all lived close by & they saw them lots independently.

If I was you I'd definitely move closer to the school.

Londonscallingme · 29/09/2023 17:14

Arightoldcarryabag · 29/09/2023 17:09

Pretty key bit of info this.

I think you overstepped when you made the initial move, your DH is used to it but you made too large a compromise.
I'd say that really you need to suck this up but given the move from London this could drive you round the bend.

I don't like driving, but it's a sacrifice I can make to uphold the maxim of "Happy wife, happy life". With you being the wife I think you'll have to put your foot down. I think if something is making either party miserable to a point that might spiral, a decision needs to be made for the good of the family, especially if it is only a preference for your DH but is feeling more vital for you.

I agree that perhaps it's a case of establishing 'who's happiness is being affected most by not having their preferred choice". Then decide on that basis.

That's where me and my DP are on our living arrangements, he has a preference but he recognises he feels less strongly than me so he is prepared to be the one to compromise.

tenterden · 29/09/2023 17:13

I think you need to have a proper heart to heart and explain how unhappy it's making you living there.

sunlightinthetrees · 29/09/2023 17:12

tenterden · 29/09/2023 17:04

If he doesn't mind the driving and you hate it, why are you doing it (aside from when it's on your way to work obvs)

My best mates parents moved to a very rural area when we were at school and she hated it so much. She really missed out until she was old enough to drive.

Two days a week I don’t work, so it wouldn’t make sense for my DH to do lifts on those days. Those are also the days when the kids tend to have activities.

Also I just tend to have more reason to go to the school/local activities than he does, I’m more likely to volunteer at the school etc and am involved in a couple of groups (outside of the kids) which are in the local town.

OP posts:
Arightoldcarryabag · 29/09/2023 17:09

sunlightinthetrees · 29/09/2023 16:44

Yes we moved from London too, about 5 years ago. I miss it a lot. DH doesn’t miss it at all!

is the countryside move temporary for you?

Pretty key bit of info this.

I think you overstepped when you made the initial move, your DH is used to it but you made too large a compromise.
I'd say that really you need to suck this up but given the move from London this could drive you round the bend.

I don't like driving, but it's a sacrifice I can make to uphold the maxim of "Happy wife, happy life". With you being the wife I think you'll have to put your foot down. I think if something is making either party miserable to a point that might spiral, a decision needs to be made for the good of the family, especially if it is only a preference for your DH but is feeling more vital for you.

Heronwatcher · 29/09/2023 17:04

I think I’d definitely be trying to move, especially if their secondary school will be there.

If you’re reasonably certain how much money you’ll get for your house, what about looking around a few places in your price range in the town and seeing if either it puts you off, or your DH realises they’re not dreadful?

In the meantime I agree with trying to combine the lifts with your work.

tenterden · 29/09/2023 17:04

If he doesn't mind the driving and you hate it, why are you doing it (aside from when it's on your way to work obvs)

My best mates parents moved to a very rural area when we were at school and she hated it so much. She really missed out until she was old enough to drive.

sunlightinthetrees · 29/09/2023 17:01

Good luck with your dilemma - it's so hard when two people just fundamentally take a different view. Neither is objectively right and neither is objectively wrong, just different priorities. It's tough to find a way to keep everyone happy.

@Londonscallingme this sums it up perfectly. We just seemed to be wired differently on this one, he doesn’t understand why it bothers me so much.

OP posts:
Newestname002 · 29/09/2023 16:58

@sunlightinthetrees

Haha yes this! I meant when he was growing up it was normal for his parents to drive him to school/activities and he doesn’t get why I don’t like it.

You are not his parents, but yourself with your own mind, needs, stresses and strains. I wonder - did both his parents work full time when they were ferrying him around? Was there the same amount of traffic then as there seems to be now? 🌹

Londonscallingme · 29/09/2023 16:58

sunlightinthetrees · 29/09/2023 16:44

Yes we moved from London too, about 5 years ago. I miss it a lot. DH doesn’t miss it at all!

is the countryside move temporary for you?

I hope so 😂

I am currently 31 weeks pregnant so we will stay here (close to family) until I go back to work then I am pushing for a move back to London, at least for the short / medium term. It's just so bloody expensive and we won't have the same level of support but I think we should take the hit. I do love the countryside but I almost feel suffocated by the remoteness of where we live. I miss walking to a coffee shop, popping out to get a loaf of fresh bread. I miss decent coffee! It's all shit here. There are few pavements where we live to the outside feels so inaccessible, especially with a baby / small child (we have a 2 year old) so although we are in the countryside I feel like it's much harder to be active.

I shouldn't complain because we are very lucky to have choices. My DP is also very reasonable and if I am insistent, I know he will support a move back but I also know he would favour staying where we are. He likes London too but doesn't feel it's 'worth it' (financially) in the same way I do. He grew up where we are currently living and recalls a wonderful childhood with loads of space to roam around and ride his mountain bike in the woods. I think we will end up here because I value those things for our kids when they are older too, I am just hoping to get another stint in London before I have to throw in the towel, hahaha!

Good luck with your dilemma - it's so hard when two people just fundamentally take a different view. Neither is objectively right and neither is objectively wrong, just different priorities. It's tough to find a way to keep everyone happy.

Diddleflop · 29/09/2023 16:51

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Diddleflop · 29/09/2023 16:50

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

DivingForLove · 29/09/2023 16:50

Move. Living in a rural area with teens is shit. I grew up in a city and wish I’d put my foot down on bringing our kids up in a town or city. Soooooo fucking dull for them otherwise 😬

sunlightinthetrees · 29/09/2023 16:44

Londonscallingme · 29/09/2023 16:35

We are currently living in the countryside and I HATE having to drive everywhere (having come from London where obviously we never drove anywhere). I totally feel your pain.

Yes we moved from London too, about 5 years ago. I miss it a lot. DH doesn’t miss it at all!

is the countryside move temporary for you?

OP posts:
parietal · 29/09/2023 16:43

plan to move to whatever town your kids will go to secondary school in. by secondary, they will want to be able to get around on their own on buses a bit and rural living is a trap.

so no need to move right now in a great hurry, but do keep looking at what you can afford in a location with better transport.

43ontherocksporfavor · 29/09/2023 16:43

Rock and a hard place then op.

Swipe left for the next trending thread